Laith Yakob1, Sebastian Funk2, Anton Camacho2, Oliver Brady2, W John Edmunds2. 1. Department of Disease Control, The London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, United Kingdom. 2. Department of Infectious Disease Epidemiology, The London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, United Kingdom.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: In the context of the ongoing, unprecedented Zika virus outbreak in the Americas, the World Health Organization has expressed its support for developing and up-scaling three novel approaches to controlling the Aedes aegypti mosquito: the Sterile Insect Technique (SIT), the Release of Insects carrying Dominant Lethal genes (RIDL) and the release of Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes. Whereas the former two approaches are temporary insect population suppression strategies, Wolbachia infection is a self-sustaining, invasive strategy that uses inherited endosymbiotic bacteria to render natural mosquito populations arbovirus resistant. METHODS: A mathematical model is parameterised with new, Brazilian field data informing the mating competitiveness of mass-reared, released insects; and simulations compare and contrast projections of vector control achieved with the alternative approaches. RESULTS: Important disadvantages of Wolbachia and SIT are identified: both strategies result in mosquitoes ovipositing non-viable eggs and, by alleviating intense larval competition, can cause an overall increase in survival to the adult stage. However, it is demonstrated that strategically combining the suppression methods with Wolbachia can generate a sustained control while mitigating the risks of inadvertent exacerbation of the wild mosquito population. DISCUSSION: This initial analysis demonstrates potential for good synergy when combining novel mosquito approaches in a modernized, integrated vector control programme.
INTRODUCTION: In the context of the ongoing, unprecedented Zika virus outbreak in the Americas, the World Health Organization has expressed its support for developing and up-scaling three novel approaches to controlling the Aedes aegypti mosquito: the Sterile Insect Technique (SIT), the Release of Insects carrying Dominant Lethal genes (RIDL) and the release of Wolbachia-infected mosquitoes. Whereas the former two approaches are temporary insect population suppression strategies, Wolbachia infection is a self-sustaining, invasive strategy that uses inherited endosymbiotic bacteria to render natural mosquito populations arbovirus resistant. METHODS: A mathematical model is parameterised with new, Brazilian field data informing the mating competitiveness of mass-reared, released insects; and simulations compare and contrast projections of vector control achieved with the alternative approaches. RESULTS: Important disadvantages of Wolbachia and SIT are identified: both strategies result in mosquitoes ovipositing non-viable eggs and, by alleviating intense larval competition, can cause an overall increase in survival to the adult stage. However, it is demonstrated that strategically combining the suppression methods with Wolbachia can generate a sustained control while mitigating the risks of inadvertent exacerbation of the wild mosquito population. DISCUSSION: This initial analysis demonstrates potential for good synergy when combining novel mosquito approaches in a modernized, integrated vector control programme.
Authors: A A Hoffmann; B L Montgomery; J Popovici; I Iturbe-Ormaetxe; P H Johnson; F Muzzi; M Greenfield; M Durkan; Y S Leong; Y Dong; H Cook; J Axford; A G Callahan; N Kenny; C Omodei; E A McGraw; P A Ryan; S A Ritchie; M Turelli; S L O'Neill Journal: Nature Date: 2011-08-24 Impact factor: 49.962
Authors: Danilo O Carvalho; Andrew R McKemey; Luiza Garziera; Renaud Lacroix; Christl A Donnelly; Luke Alphey; Aldo Malavasi; Margareth L Capurro Journal: PLoS Negl Trop Dis Date: 2015-07-02
Authors: Moritz U G Kraemer; Marianne E Sinka; Kirsten A Duda; Adrian Mylne; Freya M Shearer; Oliver J Brady; Jane P Messina; Christopher M Barker; Chester G Moore; Roberta G Carvalho; Giovanini E Coelho; Wim Van Bortel; Guy Hendrickx; Francis Schaffner; G R William Wint; Iqbal R F Elyazar; Hwa-Jen Teng; Simon I Hay Journal: Sci Data Date: 2015-07-07 Impact factor: 6.444
Authors: Krisztian Magori; Mathieu Legros; Molly E Puente; Dana A Focks; Thomas W Scott; Alun L Lloyd; Fred Gould Journal: PLoS Negl Trop Dis Date: 2009-09-01
Authors: Andrew F van den Hurk; Sonja Hall-Mendelin; Alyssa T Pyke; Francesca D Frentiu; Kate McElroy; Andrew Day; Stephen Higgs; Scott L O'Neill Journal: PLoS Negl Trop Dis Date: 2012-11-01
Authors: Ary A Hoffmann; Inaki Iturbe-Ormaetxe; Ashley G Callahan; Ben L Phillips; Katrina Billington; Jason K Axford; Brian Montgomery; Andrew P Turley; Scott L O'Neill Journal: PLoS Negl Trop Dis Date: 2014-09-11
Authors: Oliver J Brady; Nick Golding; David M Pigott; Moritz U G Kraemer; Jane P Messina; Robert C Reiner; Thomas W Scott; David L Smith; Peter W Gething; Simon I Hay Journal: Parasit Vectors Date: 2014-07-22 Impact factor: 3.876
Authors: Irfan A Rather; Hilal A Parray; Jameel B Lone; Woon K Paek; Jeongheui Lim; Vivek K Bajpai; Yong-Ha Park Journal: Front Cell Infect Microbiol Date: 2017-07-25 Impact factor: 5.293
Authors: Gisele da S Botas; Rodrigo A S Cruz; Fernanda B de Almeida; Jonatas L Duarte; Raquel S Araújo; Raimundo Nonato P Souto; Ricardo Ferreira; José Carlos T Carvalho; Marcelo G Santos; Leandro Rocha; Vera Lúcia P Pereira; Caio P Fernandes Journal: Molecules Date: 2017-11-17 Impact factor: 4.411
Authors: Annelies Wilder-Smith; Raman Preet; Elizabeth B Brickley; Ricardo Arraes de Alencar Ximenes; Demócrito de Barros Miranda-Filho; Celina Maria Turchi Martelli; Thália Velho Barreto de Araújo; Ulisses Ramos Montarroyos; Maria Elisabeth Moreira; Marília Dalva Turchi; Tom Solomon; Bart C Jacobs; Carlos Pardo Villamizar; Lyda Osorio; Ana Maria Bispo de Filipps; Johan Neyts; Suzanne Kaptein; Ralph Huits; Kevin K Ariën; Hugh J Willison; Julia M Edgar; Susan C Barnett; Rosanna Peeling; Debi Boeras; Maria G Guzman; Aravinda M de Silva; Andrew K Falconar; Claudia Romero-Vivas; Michael W Gaunt; Alessandro Sette; Daniela Weiskopf; Louis Lambrechts; Helen Dolk; Joan K Morris; Ieda M Orioli; Kathleen M O'Reilly; Laith Yakob; Joacim Rocklöv; Cristiane Soares; Maria Lúcia Brito Ferreira; Rafael Freitas de Oliveira Franca; Alexander R Precioso; James Logan; Trudie Lang; Nina Jamieson; Eduardo Massad Journal: Glob Health Action Date: 2019 Impact factor: 2.640
Authors: Jannelle Couret; Marco Notarangelo; Sarashwathy Veera; Noah LeClaire-Conway; Howard S Ginsberg; Roger L LeBrun Journal: Parasit Vectors Date: 2020-04-21 Impact factor: 3.876
Authors: Adriano R Paula; Leila E I Silva; Anderson Ribeiro; Tariq M Butt; Carlos P Silva; Richard I Samuels Journal: Parasit Vectors Date: 2018-05-04 Impact factor: 3.876
Authors: Oliver J Brady; Dinar D Kharisma; Nandyan N Wilastonegoro; Kathleen M O'Reilly; Emilie Hendrickx; Leonardo S Bastos; Laith Yakob; Donald S Shepard Journal: BMC Med Date: 2020-07-09 Impact factor: 8.775