Frédérique Vallières1, Eilish McAuliffe2, Bianca van Bavel3, Patrick J Wall4, Augustine Trye5. 1. Centre for Global Health, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland; School of Psychology, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland. Electronic address: vallierf@tcd.ie. 2. School of Nursing, Midwifery & Health Systems, University College Dublin, Ireland. 3. Centre for Global Health, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland. 4. School of Computer Science and Statistics, Trinity College Dublin, Ireland. 5. World Vision Sierra Leone, Freetown, Sierra Leone.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The unprecedented access to mobile phones in resource-poor settings has seen the emergence of mobile-health (mHealth) applications specific for low- and middle-income contexts. One such application is the Mobile Technology for Community Health Suite (MOTECH Suite). Given the importance of community health worker (CHW) perceptions of a health program toward its successful implementation, this study explores whether the introduction of an mHealth application, as a human resource management tool, is associated with changes in CHW perceived supervision, motivation, work engagement, and job satisfaction over time. METHODS: We employed a 3-arm randomized longitudinal cohort design in Bonthe District, Sierra Leone. Three hundred twenty-seven CHWs were assessed over an 18-month period, with 3 different rounds of data collection. CHWs were assigned to 3 different intervention groups and given either a mobile phone with access to both the application and to a closed user group; a phone set up on a closed user group but with no application; or no mobile phone but the same level of training as the previous 2 groups. RESULTS: Findings indicated that there were no initial or sustained differences in perceived supervision and motivation across the 3 experimental groups over time with the introduction of the MOTECH Suite as a human resource management tool. Furthermore, there was no significant change in the self-reported measures of work engagement and job satisfaction across each of the intervention groups over time. DISCUSSION/ CONCLUSION: Findings suggest that there are no systematic changes in perceived supervision, work engagement, job satisfaction, or motivation between CHWs who received a mobile phone set up on a closed user group with the MOTECH Suite application and those who either only received a phone with the closed user group or no phone at all. Therefore, the results of this study do not provide sufficient evidence to support the use of mobile technology or mHealth applications to strengthen these organizational factors within CHW programs and interventions. We argue that strengthening the organizational factors within CHW programs must therefore extend beyond the introduction of a technological solution.
RCT Entities:
BACKGROUND: The unprecedented access to mobile phones in resource-poor settings has seen the emergence of mobile-health (mHealth) applications specific for low- and middle-income contexts. One such application is the Mobile Technology for Community Health Suite (MOTECH Suite). Given the importance of community health worker (CHW) perceptions of a health program toward its successful implementation, this study explores whether the introduction of an mHealth application, as a human resource management tool, is associated with changes in CHW perceived supervision, motivation, work engagement, and job satisfaction over time. METHODS: We employed a 3-arm randomized longitudinal cohort design in Bonthe District, Sierra Leone. Three hundred twenty-seven CHWs were assessed over an 18-month period, with 3 different rounds of data collection. CHWs were assigned to 3 different intervention groups and given either a mobile phone with access to both the application and to a closed user group; a phone set up on a closed user group but with no application; or no mobile phone but the same level of training as the previous 2 groups. RESULTS: Findings indicated that there were no initial or sustained differences in perceived supervision and motivation across the 3 experimental groups over time with the introduction of the MOTECH Suite as a human resource management tool. Furthermore, there was no significant change in the self-reported measures of work engagement and job satisfaction across each of the intervention groups over time. DISCUSSION/ CONCLUSION: Findings suggest that there are no systematic changes in perceived supervision, work engagement, job satisfaction, or motivation between CHWs who received a mobile phone set up on a closed user group with the MOTECH Suite application and those who either only received a phone with the closed user group or no phone at all. Therefore, the results of this study do not provide sufficient evidence to support the use of mobile technology or mHealth applications to strengthen these organizational factors within CHW programs and interventions. We argue that strengthening the organizational factors within CHW programs must therefore extend beyond the introduction of a technological solution.
Authors: Ayomide Owoyemi; Joanne I Osuchukwu; Clark Azubuike; Ronald Kelechi Ikpe; Blessing C Nwachukwu; Cassandra B Akinde; Grace W Biokoro; Abisoye B Ajose; Ezechukwu Ikenna Nwokoma; Nehemiah E Mfon; Temitope O Benson; Anthony Ehimare; Daniel Irowa-Omoregie; Seun Olaniran Journal: Front Digit Health Date: 2022-06-03
Authors: Sydney Chauwa Phiri; Margaret Lippitt Prust; Caroline Phiri Chibawe; Ronald Misapa; Jan Willem van den Broek; Nikhil Wilmink Journal: Hum Resour Health Date: 2017-06-24
Authors: James O'Donovan; Kenneth Kabali; Celia Taylor; Margarita Chukhina; Jacqueline C Kading; Jonathan Fuld; Edward O'Neil Journal: Hum Resour Health Date: 2018-09-19
Authors: Meagan M Hanbury; Banafsheh Sadeghi; Iraklis Erik Tseregounis; Rosa Gomez-Camacho; Rosa D Manzo; Maria Isabel Rangel; Bogdan Alexandrescu; Adela de la Torre Journal: J Med Internet Res Date: 2019-01-16 Impact factor: 5.428