| Literature DB >> 28265458 |
Russell P Sawyer1, Federico Rodriguez-Porcel1,2,3, Matthew Hagen4, Rhonna Shatz1,2, Alberto J Espay1,3.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Disruption of the frontal lobes and its associated networks are a common consequence of neurodegenerative disorders. Given the wide range of cognitive, behavioral and motor processes in which the frontal lobes are involved, there can be a great variety of manifestations depending on the pathology distribution. The most common are the behavioral variant of frontotemporal dementia (bvFTD) and the frontal variant of Alzheimer's disease (fvAD), which are particularly challenging to disentangle. Recognizing fvAD from bvFTD-related pathologies is a diagnostic challenge and a critical need in the management and counseling of these patients. CASEEntities:
Keywords: Behavioral disorder; Frontal variant of Alzheimer’s disease; Frontotemporal Dementia; Movement disorders; Parkinsonism
Year: 2017 PMID: 28265458 PMCID: PMC5333400 DOI: 10.1186/s40734-017-0052-4
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Clin Mov Disord ISSN: 2054-7072
Fig. 1Brain MRI of Case #1–3. Sagittal T2-weighted (upper row) and axial FLAIR (lower row) brain MRIs. Patient 1 (a and d) showed mild to moderate atrophy in the frontotemporal regions, minimally asymmetric, with right frontal encephalomalacia. Patient 2 (b and e) showed similar findings with somewhat lower burden of associated periventricular and spotty subcortical white matter increased signal. Patient 3 (c and f) showed mild diffuse atrophy with minimal periventricular and subcortical white matter disease
Fig. 2fvAD and bvFTD in the Wizard of Oz. a fvAD Scarecrow was searching for a brain because he had none, and without a brain he had no memory or object knowledge. While his phonemic fluency was preserved, fvAD Scarecrow had difficulty with semantics and was irritable and paranoid, believing the crows were gearing to bothering and stealing from him. Furthermore, fvAD Scarecrow was very tremulous (myoclonus). The wind could suddenly jolt him (stimulus-sensitive myoclonus). b bvFTD Tin Man had no heart, so his behavior and emotions were affected from the outset. The “heartless” bvFTD Tin Man lacked empathy and was very ritualistic, only going out to chop wood. His rituals included hyperphagia, making him heavier than the straw-filled fvAD Scarecrow. Furthermore, bvFTD Tin Man was insufficiently lubricated, making him appear parkinsonian. This particular bvFTD Tin Man was missing progranulin, rendering his frontotemporal region asymmetric, as judged by a crooked hat. Both images are from 1900; US Copyright law on public domain
Fig. 3Chronology of symptoms. The diagram illustrates the severity and timing of cognitive impairments, motor manifestations, and behavioral changes as they may appear across disease stages in bvFTD
Fig. 4Chronology of symptoms. The diagram illustrates the severity and timing onset of cognitive impairments, motor manifestations, and behavioral changes as they may appear across disease stages in fvAD
Clinical features distinguishing fvAD from bvFTD
| Clinical Features supporting fvAD | Clinical Features supporting bvFTD | |
|---|---|---|
| Memory | Early memory complaints | Late memory complaints |
| Language | Phonemic and semantic paraphasias | Loss of socioemotional aspects of speech |
| Fluency | Semantic > phonemic fluency impairment | Phonemic > semantic fluency impairment |
| Behavioral | Compulsive or perseverative behaviors are uncommon | Collection or hoarding, and ritualistic and disinhibited behaviors (particularly involving food) |
| Personality Change | Agitation and irritability | Early apathy, disinhibition, loss of empathy |
| Thought Content | Delusions (theft, infidelity, and paranoid) | Mental rigidity |
| Body Habitus | Weight loss associated with depression | Weight gain associated with hyperphagia |
| Movement Disorder | Myoclonus (often mischaracterized as tremor), late parkinsonism | Early parkinsonism |
| Brain MRI pattern | Symmetric atrophy (temporal > frontal, posterior corpus callosum, and perisylvian) | Symmetric (~ |
| CSF findings | CSF p-Tau/Aβ42 ratio (>0.21 ng/mL) | CSF progranulin levels (<60 ng/mL)- not validated in clinical practice |
| Biomarkers | APOE ε4 allele positive | No relation to APOE allele |