| Literature DB >> 28265432 |
Nahoko Harada1,2, Jun Shigemura3, Masaaki Tanichi3, Kyoko Kawaida1, Satomi Takahashi1, Fumiko Yasukata1.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: On March 11, 2011, Japan experienced an unprecedented combination of earthquake/tsunami/nuclear accidents (the Great East Japan Earthquake; GEJE). We sought to identify mental health and psychosocial consequences of this compound disaster.Entities:
Keywords: Disaster; Earthquake; Fukushima Daiichi nuclear accident; Great East Japan Earthquake; Mental health; Posttraumatic stress disorder; Psychological service; Radiation fear; Tsunami
Year: 2015 PMID: 28265432 PMCID: PMC5330089 DOI: 10.1186/s40696-015-0008-x
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Disaster Mil Med ISSN: 2054-314X
Fig. 1Locations of earthquake epicenter of the 2011 Great East Japan Earthquake and major cities
Fig. 2Three severely affected prefectures of the Tohoku region, Japan; Iwate, Miyagi, and Fukushima
Mental health outcomes among individuals affected by the GEJE (excluding Fukushima)
| Citation (reference no.) | Sample type (location) | N | Data collectiona | Findings (subject proportions, measurements) | Risk factors of outcome(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Yokoyama et al. [ | Residents (Iwate) | 10,025 | 6 and 11 months | 42.6 %, K6 ≥ 5 | Severe financial problems, displacement, lack of network |
| Niitsu et al. [ | Residents (Iwate) | 902 | 11 months | 48 %, K6 ≥ 5 | Female, middle-to-low educational status, unemployment |
| Koyama et al. [ | Residents (Miyagi) | 281 | 11 and 12 months | 35.9 %, K6 ≥ 13 | No social support, lower annual income, cohabitating with ≥6 people |
| Nagata et al. [ | Residents of temporary housings (Iwate) | 200 | 10–12 and 19–21 months | No significance in K6 ≥5 between two time points (37.5 %, 10–12 months vs. 43.5 %, 19–21 months). Sense of isolation higher at 19–21 months | |
| Sugimoto et al. [ | National sample | 8777 | 12 months | No significance in K6 ≥13 between certified vs. non-certified groups for house damage (8.4 vs. 9 %) | Lack of support from family, friends and neighbors |
| Fujihara et al. [ | Diabetic patients (Ibaraki) | 320 | 3 months pre- and post-disaster | Worsening of glycemic control was associated with total GHQ scores, interruption of drug regimen, somatic symptoms, and sleep disturbances/anxiety | |
| Inoue et al. [ | Household of tsunami-affected houses (Miyagi) | 4176 | 7–12 months | Social isolation | Men <65 years and living alone, low income |
| Funayama et al. [ | Psychiatric outpatients (Tochigi) | 294 | 2 months | 4.1 % worsened and 1.2 % improved in GAF score | GAF score >50 |
| Saito et al. [ | Psychiatric in/outpatients (Tokyo) | 155 | 1 week | 3.5 % worsening of psychiatric symptoms (increase in epileptic seizure or GAF score) | |
| Aoki et al. [ | Psychiatric patients on mandatory admission (Tokyo) | 224 | 6 months pre- and post-disaster | Increased admission cases post-disaster (n = 127) compared to pre-disaster (n = 97) | Schizophrenia |
| Kato et al. | Psychiatric inpatients with suicide attempt (Kanagawa) | 592 | 6–1 months before and 1–6 months post-disaster | The number of admitted patients on ventilator was higher after the earthquake (Pre, n = 87 vs. post, n = 123) | Jobless, family psychiatric history, precipitating attempt, and alcohol intake |
| Orui et al. [ | National government statistics report (Iwate, Miyagi and Fukushima) | 24 months pre- and post-disaster | Suicide rates in men decreased during the post-disaster period; rates in women increased in the first 7 months | ||
| Momma et al. [ | Small and medium enterprise employees (Miyagi) | 522 | 7 months pre- and 5 months post-disaster | 14.3 % (men), IES-R ≥ 25 (5 months post-disaster) | Male: weak bilateral leg extension power, daily drinking habits, and depressive symptoms |
| Takeda et al. [ | Female high school students (Miyagi) | 1180 | 9 months | 10 %, IES-R ≥25 | |
| Iwadare et al. [ | Junior high school student (Miyagi) | 1919 | 8 and 20 months | Shorter sleep duration and later bedtime at 20 months | Bereavement experience |
| Usami et al. [ | Children, 4–15 years (Miyagi) | 11,639 | 8 and 20 months | 42.6 %, PTSSC-15 ≥ 23 at 8 months | Evacuation, house damage and/or separation from family, female, and not having breakfast |
| Kuwabara et al. [ | Children, 6–15 years (Miyagi) | 2259 | 6 months | Students from junior high schools with mortality rate ≥4 % had higher PTSSC-15 scores | |
| Numata et al. [ | PTSD outpatients (Miyagi) | 43 | Unspecified | 2.5 g of | |
| Tuerk et al. [ | Residents (Ibaraki) | 41 | 40 days post-event | 27 %, self-reported PTSD symptoms | Subjective health and loss of sense of community |
| Niitsu et al. [ | College students (USA) | 30 | 12–14 months | Japanese students (n = 17) reported higher hyper-arousal than did non-Japanese students (n = 13) | Media exposure |
| Sekiguchi et al. [ | Non-PTSD residents (Miyagi) | 42 | Pre-disaster, 3–4 months post-disaster | Regional volume changes in the brain observed after the disaster | Smaller GMV in the ACC before the earthquake, decreased GMV in the OFC through the earthquake |
| Sekiguchi et al. [ | Non-PTSD residents (Miyagi) | 30 | Pre-disaster and 3–4 months post-disaster | Post-disaster anxiety level associated with cerebral structure changes | Lower FA in the right anterior cingulum, increased FA in the left anterior cingulum and uncinated fasciculus |
| Matsubara et al. [ | Survivors remained at damaged residences (Miyagi) | 5454 | 1–4 months | 8.1 %, depressive reaction (PHQ-2) | House flooding below or above the ground floor, unavailability of gas supply, female, middle aged or elderly, regular intake of psychotropic medicine(s) since before the tsunami, no cohabitant |
| Nishigori et al. [ | Postpartum women (Miyagi) | 677 | 1 month pre- and 7 months post-disaster | 20 %, Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale ≥9 | Maternal age of under 25 years, child’s birth weight under 2.5 kg |
| Matsumoto et al. [ | Residents (Miyagi) | 4176 | 7–12 months | 15 %, Sleep disturbance measured by an original scale | Lack of pleasure in life, lack of interaction with neighbors |
| Sugiura et al. [ | Food delivery users (Tokyo and Osaka) | 5053 | 2 months pre- and 1 months post-disaster | Insomnia (original scale), post- vs. pre-disaster odds ratio; Tokyo, 2.0, Osaka, 1.6 |
GEJE Great East Japan Earthquake, K6 Kessler Psychological Distress Scale, GHQ General Health Questionnaires, GAF global assessment of functioning, IES-R impact of event scale-revised, PTSCC-15 posttraumatic stress symptoms for children 15 items, GMV grey matter volume, ACC anterior cingulate cortex, OFC orbitofrontal cortex, FA fractional anisotropy, PHQ-2 Patient Health Questionnaire-2
aCross-sectional studies unless otherwise noted
Mental health outcomes of Fukushima residents following the GEJE
| Citation (reference no.) | Sample type (location) | n | Data collectiona | Findings | Risk factors of outcome(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Matsumoto et al. [ | Psychiatric outpatient (Fukushima) | 1273 | 1 month | Bipolar I showed worst exacerbation among psychiatric diseases and manic change was prominent | |
| Wada et al. 2013 [ | Psychiatric inpatient (Fukushima) | 28 | 7 days | Two-thirds showed no change | |
| Yabe et al. [ | Residents (Fukushima) | 73,433 (2011), 39495 (2012) | 10 and 22 months | 14.6 vs. 11.9 %, K6 ≥13, | |
| Tsubokura et al. [ | Residents (Fukushima) | 155 | 1 year pre- and post-disaster | 12 %, PHQ-9 ≥ 10 | |
| Kukihara et al. [ | Evacuees (Fukushima) | 241 | 9 months | 33.2 %, IES-R ≥ 25 | |
| Sawa et al. [ | Internally displaced people from Fukushima (Chiba) | 73 | 5 and 10 months | Compared to a reference group (Chiba residents), the study sample was more likely to have GHQ-12 ≥ 3, adverse social dysfunction at both time points and psychological distress at 10 months | |
| Sugimoto et al. [ | National sample | 5809 | 1 year | Women were more concerned than men about radiation. | |
| Rubin et al. [ | British nationals living in Japan | 284 | 9 mo. | 16 %, GHQ-12 ≥ 4 | |
| Goto et al. [ | Parenting counseling records (Fukushima) | 150 | 1 year pre-, 1 and 13 months post-disaster (qualitative analysis) | Lowered maternal confidence and potential role of public health nurses in risk communication process post-disaster were reported | |
| Yoshii et al. [ | Post-partum women (Miyagi) | 259 | 16 months (qualitative analysis) | Seven themes of maternal anxiety for radioactivity from the Fukushima emerged: food safety, outdoor safety, radiation effects on embryos during pregnancy, effects on children, radiation exposures, economic issues and distrust towards disclosing information | |
| Ben-Ezra et al. [ | Residents (Hiroshima/Nagasaki, Tokyo and Fukushima) | 750 | 3 years post-disaster | 10.6 %, Fukushima, endorsed PTSD symptoms |
GEJE Great East Japan Earthquake, K6 Kessler Psychological Distress Scale, PCL PTSD checklist, SDQ Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire, PHQ-9 Patient Health Questionnaire-9, IES-R impact of events-revised, GHQ-12 General Health Questionnaires 12
aCross-sectional studies unless otherwise noted
Studies of the GEJE disaster and support workers
| Citation (reference no.) | Sample type (location) | n | Data collectiona | Findings | Risk factors of outcome(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Shigemura et al. [ | Nuclear plant workers (Fukushima) | 1495 | 2–3 months | 42.7 %, K6 ≥ 13 | Preexisting illness(es), discrimination/slurs, near-death experience, tsunami evacuation, major property loss, home evacuation |
| Dobashi et al. [ | Defense personnel (Miyagi) | 606 | 1 month post deployment | 6.2 (±8.1), IES-R | No identified factors |
| Matsuoka et al. [ | Disaster Medical Assistant Team | 426 | 1 month | 4.0 %, K6 ≥ 13 | Concern over radiation exposure |
| Nishi et al. [ | Disaster Medical Assistant Team | 173 | 4 months | 6.8 (±8.4), IES-R | PDI score and watching earthquake TV news reports ≥4 h/day |
| Nishi et al. [ | Disaster Medical Assistant Team | 172 | Baseline and 12-week post-intervention | Fish oil attenuated posttraumatic stress symptoms among female | |
| Fukasawa et al. [ | Government workers (Miyagi) | 4331 | 2 months | 3.0 %, K6 ≥13 (group with less property damages) | Less damaged: working overtime (>100 h/mo. overtime), poor workplace communication |
| Suzuki et al. [ | Government workers (Miyagi) | 3743 | 7 months | 9.6 %, K6 ≥ 10 | Not taking a non-work day each week |
GEJE Great East Japan Earthquake, K6 (K10) Kessler Psychological Distress Scale, IES-R impact of events-revised, CES-D Center for Epidemiologic Studies Depression Scale, PDI peritraumatic distress inventory
aCross-sectional studies unless otherwise noted
Grief study following the GEJE
| Citation (reference no.) | Sample type (location) | N | Data collectiona | Findings | Risk factors of outcome(s) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tsutsui et al. [ | Hospital workers (tsunami-affected area) | 82 | 8 months | 9.8 %, ICG ≥ 25 |
GEJE Great East Japan Earthquake, ICG Inventory of Complicated Grief, IES-R impact of events-revised, CES-D Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale
aCross-sectional studies unless otherwise noted