Roman Maduz1, Patrick Kugelmeier1, Severin Meili1, Robert Döring1, Christoph Meier2, Peter Wahl1. 1. Division for Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery, Cantonal Hospital, Winterthur, Switzerland. 2. Division for Orthopaedic and Trauma Surgery, Cantonal Hospital, Winterthur, Switzerland. Electronic address: christoph.meier@ksw.ch.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: The Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS) and the Injury Severity Score (ISS) find increasingly widespread use to assess trauma burden and to perform interhospital benchmarking through trauma registries. Since 2015, public resource allocation in Switzerland shall even be derived from such data. As every trauma centre is responsible for its own coding and data input, this study aims at evaluating interobserver reliability of AIS and ISS coding. METHODS: Interobserver reliability of the AIS and ISS is analysed from a cohort of 50 consecutive severely injured patients treated in 2012 at our institution, coded retrospectively by 3 independent and specifically trained observers. RESULTS: Considering a cutoff ISS≥16, only 38/50 patients (76%) were uniformly identified as polytraumatised or not. Increasing the cut off to ≥20, this increased to 41/50 patients (82%). A difference in the AIS of ≥ 1 was present in 261 (16%) of possible codes. Excluding the vast majority of uninjured body regions, uniformly identical AIS severity values were attributed in 67/193 (35%) body regions, or 318/579 (55%) possible observer pairings. CONCLUSION: Injury severity all too often is neither identified correctly nor consistently when using the AIS. This leads to wrong identification of severely injured patients using the ISS. Improving consistency of coding through centralisation is recommended before scores based on the AIS are to be used for interhospital benchmarking and resource allocation in the treatment of severely injured patients.
OBJECTIVE: The Abbreviated Injury Scale (AIS) and the Injury Severity Score (ISS) find increasingly widespread use to assess trauma burden and to perform interhospital benchmarking through trauma registries. Since 2015, public resource allocation in Switzerland shall even be derived from such data. As every trauma centre is responsible for its own coding and data input, this study aims at evaluating interobserver reliability of AIS and ISS coding. METHODS: Interobserver reliability of the AIS and ISS is analysed from a cohort of 50 consecutive severely injured patients treated in 2012 at our institution, coded retrospectively by 3 independent and specifically trained observers. RESULTS: Considering a cutoff ISS≥16, only 38/50 patients (76%) were uniformly identified as polytraumatised or not. Increasing the cut off to ≥20, this increased to 41/50 patients (82%). A difference in the AIS of ≥ 1 was present in 261 (16%) of possible codes. Excluding the vast majority of uninjured body regions, uniformly identical AIS severity values were attributed in 67/193 (35%) body regions, or 318/579 (55%) possible observer pairings. CONCLUSION: Injury severity all too often is neither identified correctly nor consistently when using the AIS. This leads to wrong identification of severely injured patients using the ISS. Improving consistency of coding through centralisation is recommended before scores based on the AIS are to be used for interhospital benchmarking and resource allocation in the treatment of severely injured patients.
Authors: Roman Pfeifer; Sascha Halvachizadeh; Sylvia Schick; Kai Sprengel; Kai Oliver Jensen; Michel Teuben; Ladislav Mica; Valentin Neuhaus; Hans-Christoph Pape Journal: World J Surg Date: 2019-10 Impact factor: 3.352
Authors: Amy C Gunning; Menco J S Niemeyer; Mark van Heijl; Karlijn J P van Wessem; Ronald V Maier; Zsolt J Balogh; Luke P H Leenen Journal: Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg Date: 2022-08-16 Impact factor: 2.374
Authors: Eftychios Bolierakis; Sylvia Schick; Kai Sprengel; Kai Oliver Jensen; Frank Hildebrand; Hans-Christoph Pape; Roman Pfeifer Journal: Eur J Med Res Date: 2021-04-15 Impact factor: 2.175
Authors: Suzan Dijkink; Erik W van Zwet; Pieta Krijnen; Luke P H Leenen; Frank W Bloemers; Michael J R Edwards; Dennis Den Hartog; Peter A Leenhouts; Martijn Poeze; W Richard Spanjersberg; Klaus W Wendt; Ralph J De Wit; Stefan W A M Van Zuthpen; Inger B Schipper Journal: Eur J Trauma Emerg Surg Date: 2021-03-12 Impact factor: 3.693