Q Yang1, S L Lin1, S L Au Yeung1, M K Kwok1, L Xu1, G M Leung1, C M Schooling1,2. 1. School of Public Health, Li Ka Shing Faculty of Medicine, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China. 2. School of Public Health and Health Policy, City University of New York, New York, NY, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND/ OBJECTIVES: Milk provides protein and micronutrients, and is recommended by some dietary guidelines, particularly for bone health. Meta-analysis of small randomized controlled trials suggests that milk may increase bone mineral density, but they are very heterogeneous. No randomized controlled trial has assessed the effects of milk on major chronic diseases. Previous Mendelian randomization studies of milk did not consider bone health, found no effects on ischemic heart disease (IHD) or type 2 diabetes (T2D) but higher body mass index. Using larger genetic studies, we estimated the effects of milk on osteoporosis, IHD, T2D, adiposity, lipids and glycemic traits. SUBJECTS/ METHODS: Instrumental variable analysis based on a genetic variant endowing lactase persistence (rs4988235 (MCM6)) was used to obtain estimates for osteoporosis (GEFOS), IHD (CARDIoGRAMplusC4D), T2D (DIAGRAM), adiposity (GIANT), lipids (GLGC) and glycaemic traits (MAGIC). Eye color was a negative control for IHD, as it mirrors the distribution of lactase persistence and IHD in Western Europe. RESULTS: Genetically predicted adult milk consumption was not clearly associated with bone mineral density, IHD (odds ratio (OR): 1.03 per s.d., 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.95-1.12) and or T2D (OR: 0.92, 95% CI: 0.83-1.02) but was associated with higher log-transformed fasting insulin (0.05, 95% CI: 0.02-0.07) and body mass index (0.06, 95% CI: 0.03-0.09). Genetically predicted eye color was not associated with IHD. CONCLUSIONS: The lack of association of genetically predicted milk consumption with bone health, IHD or T2D suggests few beneficial effects but is more consistent with milk promoting adiposity.
BACKGROUND/ OBJECTIVES: Milk provides protein and micronutrients, and is recommended by some dietary guidelines, particularly for bone health. Meta-analysis of small randomized controlled trials suggests that milk may increase bone mineral density, but they are very heterogeneous. No randomized controlled trial has assessed the effects of milk on major chronic diseases. Previous Mendelian randomization studies of milk did not consider bone health, found no effects on ischemic heart disease (IHD) or type 2 diabetes (T2D) but higher body mass index. Using larger genetic studies, we estimated the effects of milk on osteoporosis, IHD, T2D, adiposity, lipids and glycemic traits. SUBJECTS/ METHODS: Instrumental variable analysis based on a genetic variant endowing lactase persistence (rs4988235 (MCM6)) was used to obtain estimates for osteoporosis (GEFOS), IHD (CARDIoGRAMplusC4D), T2D (DIAGRAM), adiposity (GIANT), lipids (GLGC) and glycaemic traits (MAGIC). Eye color was a negative control for IHD, as it mirrors the distribution of lactase persistence and IHD in Western Europe. RESULTS: Genetically predicted adult milk consumption was not clearly associated with bone mineral density, IHD (odds ratio (OR): 1.03 per s.d., 95% confidence interval (CI): 0.95-1.12) and or T2D (OR: 0.92, 95% CI: 0.83-1.02) but was associated with higher log-transformed fasting insulin (0.05, 95% CI: 0.02-0.07) and body mass index (0.06, 95% CI: 0.03-0.09). Genetically predicted eye color was not associated with IHD. CONCLUSIONS: The lack of association of genetically predicted milk consumption with bone health, IHD or T2D suggests few beneficial effects but is more consistent with milk promoting adiposity.
Authors: Marc Jan Bonder; Alexander Kurilshikov; Ettje F Tigchelaar; Zlatan Mujagic; Floris Imhann; Arnau Vich Vila; Patrick Deelen; Tommi Vatanen; Melanie Schirmer; Sanne P Smeekens; Daria V Zhernakova; Soesma A Jankipersadsing; Martin Jaeger; Marije Oosting; Maria Carmen Cenit; Ad A M Masclee; Morris A Swertz; Yang Li; Vinod Kumar; Leo Joosten; Hermie Harmsen; Rinse K Weersma; Lude Franke; Marten H Hofker; Ramnik J Xavier; Daisy Jonkers; Mihai G Netea; Cisca Wijmenga; Jingyuan Fu; Alexandra Zhernakova Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2016-10-03 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Lieke Gijsbers; Eric L Ding; Vasanti S Malik; Janette de Goede; Johanna M Geleijnse; Sabita S Soedamah-Muthu Journal: Am J Clin Nutr Date: 2016-02-24 Impact factor: 7.045
Authors: Elisabeth Lerchbaum; Albrecht Giuliani; Hans-Jürgen Gruber; Thomas R Pieber; Barbara Obermayer-Pietsch Journal: Clin Endocrinol (Oxf) Date: 2012-12 Impact factor: 3.478
Authors: Terho Lehtimäki; Nina Hutri-Kähönen; Mika Kähönen; Jukka Hemminki; Vera Mikkilä; Marika Laaksonen; Leena Räsänen; Nina Mononen; Markus Juonala; Jukka Marniemi; Jorma Viikari; Olli Raitakari Journal: Clin Sci (Lond) Date: 2008-11 Impact factor: 6.124
Authors: Heribert Schunkert; Inke R König; Sekar Kathiresan; Muredach P Reilly; Themistocles L Assimes; Hilma Holm; Michael Preuss; Alexandre F R Stewart; Maja Barbalic; Christian Gieger; Devin Absher; Zouhair Aherrahrou; Hooman Allayee; David Altshuler; Sonia S Anand; Karl Andersen; Jeffrey L Anderson; Diego Ardissino; Stephen G Ball; Anthony J Balmforth; Timothy A Barnes; Diane M Becker; Lewis C Becker; Klaus Berger; Joshua C Bis; S Matthijs Boekholdt; Eric Boerwinkle; Peter S Braund; Morris J Brown; Mary Susan Burnett; Ian Buysschaert; John F Carlquist; Li Chen; Sven Cichon; Veryan Codd; Robert W Davies; George Dedoussis; Abbas Dehghan; Serkalem Demissie; Joseph M Devaney; Patrick Diemert; Ron Do; Angela Doering; Sandra Eifert; Nour Eddine El Mokhtari; Stephen G Ellis; Roberto Elosua; James C Engert; Stephen E Epstein; Ulf de Faire; Marcus Fischer; Aaron R Folsom; Jennifer Freyer; Bruna Gigante; Domenico Girelli; Solveig Gretarsdottir; Vilmundur Gudnason; Jeffrey R Gulcher; Eran Halperin; Naomi Hammond; Stanley L Hazen; Albert Hofman; Benjamin D Horne; Thomas Illig; Carlos Iribarren; Gregory T Jones; J Wouter Jukema; Michael A Kaiser; Lee M Kaplan; John J P Kastelein; Kay-Tee Khaw; Joshua W Knowles; Genovefa Kolovou; Augustine Kong; Reijo Laaksonen; Diether Lambrechts; Karin Leander; Guillaume Lettre; Mingyao Li; Wolfgang Lieb; Christina Loley; Andrew J Lotery; Pier M Mannucci; Seraya Maouche; Nicola Martinelli; Pascal P McKeown; Christa Meisinger; Thomas Meitinger; Olle Melander; Pier Angelica Merlini; Vincent Mooser; Thomas Morgan; Thomas W Mühleisen; Joseph B Muhlestein; Thomas Münzel; Kiran Musunuru; Janja Nahrstaedt; Christopher P Nelson; Markus M Nöthen; Oliviero Olivieri; Riyaz S Patel; Chris C Patterson; Annette Peters; Flora Peyvandi; Liming Qu; Arshed A Quyyumi; Daniel J Rader; Loukianos S Rallidis; Catherine Rice; Frits R Rosendaal; Diana Rubin; Veikko Salomaa; M Lourdes Sampietro; Manj S Sandhu; Eric Schadt; Arne Schäfer; Arne Schillert; Stefan Schreiber; Jürgen Schrezenmeir; Stephen M Schwartz; David S Siscovick; Mohan Sivananthan; Suthesh Sivapalaratnam; Albert Smith; Tamara B Smith; Jaapjan D Snoep; Nicole Soranzo; John A Spertus; Klaus Stark; Kathy Stirrups; Monika Stoll; W H Wilson Tang; Stephanie Tennstedt; Gudmundur Thorgeirsson; Gudmar Thorleifsson; Maciej Tomaszewski; Andre G Uitterlinden; Andre M van Rij; Benjamin F Voight; Nick J Wareham; George A Wells; H-Erich Wichmann; Philipp S Wild; Christina Willenborg; Jaqueline C M Witteman; Benjamin J Wright; Shu Ye; Tanja Zeller; Andreas Ziegler; Francois Cambien; Alison H Goodall; L Adrienne Cupples; Thomas Quertermous; Winfried März; Christian Hengstenberg; Stefan Blankenberg; Willem H Ouwehand; Alistair S Hall; Panos Deloukas; John R Thompson; Kari Stefansson; Robert Roberts; Unnur Thorsteinsdottir; Christopher J O'Donnell; Ruth McPherson; Jeanette Erdmann; Nilesh J Samani Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2011-03-06 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Nicole Soranzo; Serena Sanna; Eleanor Wheeler; Christian Gieger; Dörte Radke; Josée Dupuis; Nabila Bouatia-Naji; Claudia Langenberg; Inga Prokopenko; Elliot Stolerman; Manjinder S Sandhu; Matthew M Heeney; Joseph M Devaney; Muredach P Reilly; Sally L Ricketts; Alexandre F R Stewart; Benjamin F Voight; Christina Willenborg; Benjamin Wright; David Altshuler; Dan Arking; Beverley Balkau; Daniel Barnes; Eric Boerwinkle; Bernhard Böhm; Amélie Bonnefond; Lori L Bonnycastle; Dorret I Boomsma; Stefan R Bornstein; Yvonne Böttcher; Suzannah Bumpstead; Mary Susan Burnett-Miller; Harry Campbell; Antonio Cao; John Chambers; Robert Clark; Francis S Collins; Josef Coresh; Eco J C de Geus; Mariano Dei; Panos Deloukas; Angela Döring; Josephine M Egan; Roberto Elosua; Luigi Ferrucci; Nita Forouhi; Caroline S Fox; Christopher Franklin; Maria Grazia Franzosi; Sophie Gallina; Anuj Goel; Jürgen Graessler; Harald Grallert; Andreas Greinacher; David Hadley; Alistair Hall; Anders Hamsten; Caroline Hayward; Simon Heath; Christian Herder; Georg Homuth; Jouke-Jan Hottenga; Rachel Hunter-Merrill; Thomas Illig; Anne U Jackson; Antti Jula; Marcus Kleber; Christopher W Knouff; Augustine Kong; Jaspal Kooner; Anna Köttgen; Peter Kovacs; Knut Krohn; Brigitte Kühnel; Johanna Kuusisto; Markku Laakso; Mark Lathrop; Cécile Lecoeur; Man Li; Mingyao Li; Ruth J F Loos; Jian'an Luan; Valeriya Lyssenko; Reedik Mägi; Patrik K E Magnusson; Anders Mälarstig; Massimo Mangino; María Teresa Martínez-Larrad; Winfried März; Wendy L McArdle; Ruth McPherson; Christa Meisinger; Thomas Meitinger; Olle Melander; Karen L Mohlke; Vincent E Mooser; Mario A Morken; Narisu Narisu; David M Nathan; Matthias Nauck; Chris O'Donnell; Konrad Oexle; Nazario Olla; James S Pankow; Felicity Payne; John F Peden; Nancy L Pedersen; Leena Peltonen; Markus Perola; Ozren Polasek; Eleonora Porcu; Daniel J Rader; Wolfgang Rathmann; Samuli Ripatti; Ghislain Rocheleau; Michael Roden; Igor Rudan; Veikko Salomaa; Richa Saxena; David Schlessinger; Heribert Schunkert; Peter Schwarz; Udo Seedorf; Elizabeth Selvin; Manuel Serrano-Ríos; Peter Shrader; Angela Silveira; David Siscovick; Kjioung Song; Timothy D Spector; Kari Stefansson; Valgerdur Steinthorsdottir; David P Strachan; Rona Strawbridge; Michael Stumvoll; Ida Surakka; Amy J Swift; Toshiko Tanaka; Alexander Teumer; Gudmar Thorleifsson; Unnur Thorsteinsdottir; Anke Tönjes; Gianluca Usala; Veronique Vitart; Henry Völzke; Henri Wallaschofski; Dawn M Waterworth; Hugh Watkins; H-Erich Wichmann; Sarah H Wild; Gonneke Willemsen; Gordon H Williams; James F Wilson; Juliane Winkelmann; Alan F Wright; Carina Zabena; Jing Hua Zhao; Stephen E Epstein; Jeanette Erdmann; Hakon H Hakonarson; Sekar Kathiresan; Kay-Tee Khaw; Robert Roberts; Nilesh J Samani; Mark D Fleming; Robert Sladek; Gonçalo Abecasis; Michael Boehnke; Philippe Froguel; Leif Groop; Mark I McCarthy; W H Linda Kao; Jose C Florez; Manuela Uda; Nicholas J Wareham; Inês Barroso; James B Meigs Journal: Diabetes Date: 2010-09-21 Impact factor: 9.461
Authors: Jean-Philippe Drouin-Chartier; Yanping Li; Andres Victor Ardisson Korat; Ming Ding; Benoît Lamarche; JoAnn E Manson; Eric B Rimm; Walter C Willett; Frank B Hu Journal: Am J Clin Nutr Date: 2019-11-01 Impact factor: 7.045
Authors: Linda E T Vissers; Ivonne Sluijs; Yvonne T van der Schouw; Nita G Forouhi; Fumiaki Imamura; Stephen Burgess; Aurelio Barricarte; Heiner Boeing; Catalina Bonet; Maria-Dolores Chirlaque; Guy Fagherazzi; Paul W Franks; Heinz Freisling; Marc J Gunter; J Ramón Quirós; Daniel B Ibsen; Rudolf Kaaks; Timothy Key; Kay T Khaw; Tilman Kühn; Olatz Mokoroa; Peter M Nilsson; Kim Overvad; Valeria Pala; Domenico Palli; Salvatore Panico; Carlotta Sacerdote; Annemieke M W Spijkerman; Anne Tjonneland; Rosario Tumino; Miguel Rodríguez-Barranco; Olov Rolandsson; Elio Riboli; Stephen J Sharp; Claudia Langenberg; Nicholas J Wareham Journal: Diabetes Care Date: 2019-02-06 Impact factor: 19.112