| Literature DB >> 28203571 |
Braulio Martinez-Burbano1, Edgar Patricio Correa Diaz1, Carolina Jácome Sánchez1.
Abstract
Intracranial dural arteriovenous fistulas (DAVFs) are abnormal communications between arteries and veins or dural venous sinuses, which sit between the sheets of the dura. They represent 10% to 15% of intracranial vascular malformations. Clinical manifestations and prognosis depend on the pattern of venous drainage and location. The clinical presentation of DAVF may be mistaken for vascular or nonvascular brain pathologies. For that reason, within the differential diagnosis come a wide range of conditions, such as secondary headaches, encephalopathies, dementias including those with rapid progression, neurodegenerative diseases, inflammatory processes, or tumors typically at the orbital level or in the cavernous sinus. Diagnosis requires a high degree of suspicion because of the multiplicity of symptoms and presentations, making this pathology an entity that provides a major challenge for clinicians, yet early and multidisciplinary treatment of high-grade fistulas improve the possibility of avoiding poor or unfavorable outcomes for the patient.Entities:
Keywords: dementia; headache; intracranial hypertension; multiple dural fistula
Year: 2016 PMID: 28203571 PMCID: PMC5298414 DOI: 10.1177/2324709616683722
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Investig Med High Impact Case Rep ISSN: 2324-7096
Borden Classification of Dural Arteriovenous Fistula[2].
| 1. Venous sinus drainage anterograde flow |
| 2. Venous sinus drainage retrograde flow into leptomeningeal veins |
| 3. Drainage into leptomeningeal veins |
Cognard Classification of Dural Arteriovenous Fistula[2].
| I. Main sinus drainage, anterograde flow |
| IIa. Main sinus drainage into a sinus |
| IIb. Main sinus drainage into leptomeningeal veins |
| IIa+b. Main sinus drainage into sinus and leptomeningeal veins |
| III. Direct leptomeningeal venous drainage without venous ectasia[ |
| IV. Direct leptomeningeal venous drainage with venous ectasia |
| V. Spinal venous drainage |
Venous ectasia = venous dilatation >5 mm in diameter or 3 times larger than the diameter of the draining vein.
Figure 1.Cerebral angiography. (a) Left occipital artery (black arrow). (b) Branches of the left vertebral artery (black arrows) with embolization material (white arrow). (c) Branches of the superficial temporal artery (black arrows). (d) Drainage to the superior sagittal sinus (black arrows).
Figure 2.Cerebral angiography. Recanalization of left occipital artery (white arrows). Embolization of branches of occipital artery with onyx (black arrows).
Figure 3.MRI of cervical spinal. (a) Sagittal T1-weighted demonstrate perimedullary venous plexus dilatation (white arrows) and venous pouch at the infratentorial level (head of white arrow). (b) Axial T1-weighted showed perimedullary dilated venous plexus. MRI of brain. (c) Axial T2-weighted reveal multiple foci of leukoaraiosis (black arrows), edema of white matter (white arrows), and venous ischemia (head of white arrow). (d) Axial with Gd showed vascular enhancement (black arrows). (e) MRI venography demonstrate presence of venous pouch at the supratentorial level (white arrows). (f) MRI brain without changes of white matter (before evolution of dural fistula).
Figure 4.Cerebral angiography. (a and b) Dilated arterial branches of the external carotid artery (black arrows) and transverse sinus (white arrow). (c) Drainage from branches of the external carotid artery to superior sagittal (black arrow) and transverse sinus (white arrow). (d) Arterial feeders of the internal carotid artery (black arrows) with superior sagittal sinus drainage (head of white arrow).
Figure 5.MRI and computed axial tomography (CT) of brain. (a, b, and c) Hemorrhage in the left putamen and internal capsule and intraventricular hemorrhage. (d) Hemorrhage at the medial pontine level.
Figure 6.Evolutionary history of dural fistula. This patient had different clinical manifestations both in their presentation and in their evolution.
Baseline Demographics, Clinical Characteristics, and Image Assessments of DAVF.
| Reference | Number of Patients/Analyzed Patients | Demographics/Follow-up (years) and Main Objective of Study | Initial Clinical Presentation and Signs or Symptoms (%) | Classification: Borden or Cognard (%) | CVD (%) | MR Images (%) | Outcome (%) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Söderman et al[ | 163/85 | Males 58% | Borden II (37.6) | CVD 100 | Not reported | Second hemorrhage (9.3) | |
| Mean age at diagnosis 58 | 1. Subarachnoid (15.3) | Borden III (62.4) | First hemorrhage (1.8) | ||||
| Mean follow-up 25 | 2. Cerebral or cerebellar (20) | Death (1) | |||||
| Natural course of untreated DAVFs with CVD | 3. Subarachnoid and intracerebral (1.2) | ||||||
| 4. Intraventricular bleed (1.2) | |||||||
| 1. Bruit (25.9) | |||||||
| 2. Asymptomatic (14.1) | |||||||
| 3. Another symptoms (21.1) | |||||||
| 4. Progressive dementia (1.2) | |||||||
| van Rooij et al[ | 91/29 | Males 24 | 1. Intraparenchymal or subarachnoid hemorrhage (62) | Borden III (100) | 1. CVD (69) | 1. Dilated peripheral cortical veins (13.8) | 1. Obliteration spontaneously (7) |
| Mean age 53.9 | 2. Seizures (14) | 2. Cortical cerebellar veins (17.2) | 2. Occlusion of the transverse/sigmoid sinus (13.8) | 2. Complete occlusion with embolization alone (48.1) | |||
| Mean follow-up 12 | 3. Visual symptoms (7) | 3. Perimesencephalic or peripontine veins (13.8) | 3. Complete occlusion with embolization + surgery (24.2) | ||||
| 4. Pulsatile bruit (3) | 4. Complete occlusion with surgery (17.2) | ||||||
| 5. Asymptomatic (14) | 5. Unknown (3.5) | ||||||
| van Dijk et al[ | 118/20 | Males 11 | 1. Intracranial hemorrhage (25) | Borden II (75) | CVD (100) | Not reported | 1. Severely disabled (5) |
| Mean age 56.7 (one child 3 years old) | 2. NHND (45) | Borden III (25) | 2. Remained stable with moderate disabilities (25) | ||||
| Mean follow-up 4.3 | 3. Generalized seizures (10) | 3. Resolution of the preexisting symptoms (25) | |||||
| Persistence of CVD | 4. Cranial bruit (10) | 4. Death (45) | |||||
| 5. Orbital phenomena (5) | 5. Second hemorrhage (15) | ||||||
| 6. Asymptomatic (5) | 6. Progressive dementia syndrome (20) | ||||||
| 7. NHND (10) | |||||||
| Brunereau et al[ | 258/12 | Males 7 | Cognard V (100) | 1. Spinal venous drainage + venous drainage (41.7) |
| Not reported | |
| Mean age 52.5 | 1. Progressive sensorimotor deficit with urinary dysfunction | 2. Spinal venous drainage (58.3) | 1. T1-weighted MR images of the spinal cord perimedullary flow voids (25) | ||||
| Retrospective | 2. T2-weighted images perimedullary flow voids and a central hyperintense signal of the cervical spinal cord (8.3) | ||||||
| DAVF with spinal venous drainage | 1. Subarachnoid hemorrhage + meningeal syndrome (25) | ||||||
| 2. Subarachnoid hemorrhage + coma (16.7) | |||||||
| 3. Transient aphasia (8.3) | |||||||
| Hurst et al[ | 40/5 | Males 5 | 1. Memory loss, encephalopathy + chronic headaches + bruit (20) | Cognard IIa+b (60) | 1. Retrograde into adjacent dural sinuses + CVD (60) | Enlarged vessels over hemispheric | Partial occlusion with one embolization: clinical improvement in mental status (40) |
| Mean age 66 | 2. Dementia + chronic headaches + bruit (80) | Cognard III (20) | 2. Retrograde into cortical veins (20) | Surface + increased T2-weighted signal (60) | Partial occlusion with second embolization: remission of cognitive symptoms (60) | ||
| Follow-up >1 | Cognard IV (20) | 3. Retrograde into cortical veins + venous dilatation (20) | MR angiogram: high flow veins (40) | ||||
| Diffuse encephalopathy or a chronic dementing process | |||||||
| Cognard et al[ | 120/13 | Males 7 | Isolated symptoms of intracranial hypertension (53.8) | Cognard I (15.4) | Dural venous sinus with antegrade flow (15.4) | Chronic tonsillar herniation + syringomyelia (7.7) | Chronic tonsillar herniation asymptomatic (15.4) |
| Mean age 50 | Associated intracranial hypertension with tinnitus (15.4) | Cognard IIa (38.5) | Dural venous sinus with retrograde flow (38.5) | Chronic tonsillar herniation (7.7) | Acute tonsilar herniation (coma) after lumboperitoneal shunting (7.7) | ||
| Mean follow-up 7.5 | Tinnitus (15.4) | Cognard IIb (7.7) | Dural venous sinus with antegrade flow and CVD (7.7) | Not reported (84.6) | Acute tonsilar herniation (death) after lumboperitoneal shunting (7.7) | ||
| Isolated or associated signs of intracranial hypertension | Seizure (7.7) | Cognard IIa+b (30.7) | Dural venous sinus with retrograde flow and CVD (30.7) | Acute confusion after lumbar puncture regressive after embolization (7.7) | |||
| Frontal superficial veins dilatation (7.7) | Cognard IIa, IIa, IIb (DAVF multiple) (7.7) | DAVF multiple (7.7) | Not reported (61.5) | ||||
| Kwon et al[ | 27/27 | Male 12 | Ocular symptoms + hemorrhage (3.7) | Borden I (29.7) | Dural venous sinus (29.7) | Flow void clusters (82) | Not reported |
| Mean age 52 | Ocular symptoms + tinnitus (7.4) | Borden II (44.4) | CVD (70.3) | Engorged ophthalmic vein (30) | |||
| Retrospective | Ocular symptoms (29.7) | Borden III (22.2) | White matter hyperintensity (15) | ||||
| Identify MR imaging finding differences between DAVF types classified on the basis of venous drainage patterns | Hemorrhage (14.8) | DAVF multiple (3.7) | Intracranial hemorrhage (30) | ||||
| Tinnitus (11.1) | Dilated leptomeningeal or medullary vessels (44) | ||||||
| Seizure (7.4) | Venous pouch (7) | ||||||
| Focal neurologic deficit + hemorrhage (7.4) | Leptomeningeal or medullary vascular enhancements (41) | ||||||
| Focal neurologic deficit (3.7) | MR angiograpic fistula and venous flow-related enhancement (91) | ||||||
| Altered mentality + hemorrhage (3.7) | Prominent extracranial vessels (36) | ||||||
| Altered mentality (3.7) | |||||||
| Intracranial hypertension (3.7) | |||||||
| Asymptomatic (3.7) |
Abbreviations: CVD, cortical venous drainage; DAVF, dural arteriovenous fistulas; MR, magnetic resonance; NHND, nonhemorrhagic neurologic deficit.