Michelle P Lin1, Thomas Nguyen1, Marc A Probst1, Lynne D Richardson1,2, Jeremiah D Schuur3. 1. Department of Emergency Medicine, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, NY. 2. Department of Population Health Science and Policy, Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, NY. 3. Department of Emergency Medicine, Brigham and Women's Hospital, and Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: In 2013, the American College of Emergency Physicians joined the Choosing Wisely campaign; however, its impact on emergency physician behavior is unknown. We assessed knowledge, attitudes, and self-reported behaviors regarding the Choosing Wisely recommendations. METHODS: We performed a cross-sectional survey of emergency physicians at a national meeting. We approached 819 physicians; 765 (93.4%) completed the survey. RESULTS: As a result of the Choosing Wisely campaign, most respondents (64.5%) felt more comfortable discussing low-value services with patients, 54.5% reported reducing utilization, and 52.5% were aware of local efforts to promote the campaign. A majority (62.97%) of respondents were able to identify at least four of five recommendations. The most prevalent low-value practices were computed tomography (CT) brain for minor head injury (29.9%) and antibiotics for acute sinusitis (26.9%). Few respondents reported performing lumbar radiograph for nontraumatic low back pain (7.8%) and Foley catheter for patients who can void (5.6%). Respondents reported patient/family expectations as the most important reason for ordering antibiotics for sinusitis (68%) and imaging for low back pain (56.8%). However, concern for serious diagnosis was the most important reason for performing CT chest for patients with normal D-dimer (49.7%) and CT abdomen for recurrent uncomplicated renal colic (42.5%). A minority (3.8% to 26.7%) of respondents identified malpractice risk as the primary reason for performing low-value services. CONCLUSIONS: Despite familiarity with Choosing Wisely, many emergency physicians report performing low-value services. Primary reasons for low-value services differ: antibiotic prescribing was driven by patient/family expectations, while concern for serious diagnosis influenced advanced diagnostic imaging. Greater efforts are needed to promote effective dissemination and implementation; such efforts may be targeted based on differing reasons for low-value services.
OBJECTIVE: In 2013, the American College of Emergency Physicians joined the Choosing Wisely campaign; however, its impact on emergency physician behavior is unknown. We assessed knowledge, attitudes, and self-reported behaviors regarding the Choosing Wisely recommendations. METHODS: We performed a cross-sectional survey of emergency physicians at a national meeting. We approached 819 physicians; 765 (93.4%) completed the survey. RESULTS: As a result of the Choosing Wisely campaign, most respondents (64.5%) felt more comfortable discussing low-value services with patients, 54.5% reported reducing utilization, and 52.5% were aware of local efforts to promote the campaign. A majority (62.97%) of respondents were able to identify at least four of five recommendations. The most prevalent low-value practices were computed tomography (CT) brain for minor head injury (29.9%) and antibiotics for acute sinusitis (26.9%). Few respondents reported performing lumbar radiograph for nontraumatic low back pain (7.8%) and Foley catheter for patients who can void (5.6%). Respondents reported patient/family expectations as the most important reason for ordering antibiotics for sinusitis (68%) and imaging for low back pain (56.8%). However, concern for serious diagnosis was the most important reason for performing CT chest for patients with normal D-dimer (49.7%) and CT abdomen for recurrent uncomplicated renal colic (42.5%). A minority (3.8% to 26.7%) of respondents identified malpractice risk as the primary reason for performing low-value services. CONCLUSIONS: Despite familiarity with Choosing Wisely, many emergency physicians report performing low-value services. Primary reasons for low-value services differ: antibiotic prescribing was driven by patient/family expectations, while concern for serious diagnosis influenced advanced diagnostic imaging. Greater efforts are needed to promote effective dissemination and implementation; such efforts may be targeted based on differing reasons for low-value services.
Authors: Emma Simon; Isomi M Miake-Lye; Silas W Smith; Jordan L Swartz; Leora I Horwitz; Danil V Makarov; Soterios Gyftopoulos Journal: J Am Coll Radiol Date: 2019-04-29 Impact factor: 5.532
Authors: Andrew I Geller; Maribeth C Lovegrove; Nadine Shehab; Lauri A Hicks; Mathew R P Sapiano; Daniel S Budnitz Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2018-04-20 Impact factor: 5.128
Authors: Arjun K Venkatesh; Jean Elizabeth Scofi; Craig Rothenberg; Carl T Berdahl; Nalani Tarrant; Dhruv Sharma; Pawan Goyal; Randy Pilgrim; Kevin Klauer; Jeremiah D Schuur Journal: Am J Emerg Med Date: 2020-01-17 Impact factor: 2.469