Sheila F O'brien1,2, Wenli Fan1, Qi-Long Yi1,2, Samra Uzicanin1, Lori Osmond1, Mindy Goldman1,3. 1. Canadian Blood Services, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON, Canada. 2. School of Epidemiology, Public Health and Preventive Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON, Canada. 3. Department of Pathology and Laboratory Medicine, University of Ottawa, Ottawa, ON, Canada.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: To reduce the risk of variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (vCJD) transmission via blood transfusion in Canada, potential donors who spent a cumulative time in the United Kingdom, Western Europe or Saudi Arabia are deferred. "Stop dates" for accumulated time were later implemented for 3 months spent in the United Kingdom or France (1980-1996) and for 5 years elsewhere in Western Europe (1980-2007); Saudi Arabia deferral was implemented with the "stop date" (1980-1996). We evaluated the long-term impact of these deferrals and "stop dates", as well as the consistency of donors' answers to post-implementation screening questions. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The monthly deferral rate was monitored from 2003-2015. Time series methods (ARIMA) were used with interruption when "stop dates" were implemented. A telephone survey of 1,000 donors (250 first-time, 500 repeat deferred donors, 250 non-deferred control donors) assessed travel history (response rate 62%). An anonymous mail survey of 40,000 donors assessed compliance with deferral (response rate 45.3%). RESULTS: When the "stop date" for UK/France travel was implemented, the deferral rate decreased for first-time (2.1% to 1.1%, p<0.0001) and repeat (0.2% to 0.03%, p<0.0001) donors. The deferral rate increased after Saudi Arabia was included (mean increase of 0.4% first-time, 0.02% repeat, p<0.0001). After the Western Europe "stop date" the deferral rate was unchanged in first-time donors (1.0% to 1.1%, p=0.5) but decreased in repeat donors (0.03% to 0.02%, p<0.002). In the telephone survey, 94% of deferred donors confirmed deferrable travel history. In the anonymous survey 0.3% of donors were non-compliant with the UK/France deferral. DISCUSSION: Donors, particularly first-time ones, continue to be lost due to vCJD travel deferral, but most deferrals are correctly applied and non-compliance is rare. The application of a "stop date" reduced deferrals for UK/France travel, but it may be too early to see the full impact of the "stop date" for Western Europe.
BACKGROUND: To reduce the risk of variant Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease (vCJD) transmission via blood transfusion in Canada, potential donors who spent a cumulative time in the United Kingdom, Western Europe or Saudi Arabia are deferred. "Stop dates" for accumulated time were later implemented for 3 months spent in the United Kingdom or France (1980-1996) and for 5 years elsewhere in Western Europe (1980-2007); Saudi Arabia deferral was implemented with the "stop date" (1980-1996). We evaluated the long-term impact of these deferrals and "stop dates", as well as the consistency of donors' answers to post-implementation screening questions. MATERIALS AND METHODS: The monthly deferral rate was monitored from 2003-2015. Time series methods (ARIMA) were used with interruption when "stop dates" were implemented. A telephone survey of 1,000 donors (250 first-time, 500 repeat deferred donors, 250 non-deferred control donors) assessed travel history (response rate 62%). An anonymous mail survey of 40,000 donors assessed compliance with deferral (response rate 45.3%). RESULTS: When the "stop date" for UK/France travel was implemented, the deferral rate decreased for first-time (2.1% to 1.1%, p<0.0001) and repeat (0.2% to 0.03%, p<0.0001) donors. The deferral rate increased after Saudi Arabia was included (mean increase of 0.4% first-time, 0.02% repeat, p<0.0001). After the Western Europe "stop date" the deferral rate was unchanged in first-time donors (1.0% to 1.1%, p=0.5) but decreased in repeat donors (0.03% to 0.02%, p<0.002). In the telephone survey, 94% of deferred donors confirmed deferrable travel history. In the anonymous survey 0.3% of donors were non-compliant with the UK/France deferral. DISCUSSION: Donors, particularly first-time ones, continue to be lost due to vCJD travel deferral, but most deferrals are correctly applied and non-compliance is rare. The application of a "stop date" reduced deferrals for UK/France travel, but it may be too early to see the full impact of the "stop date" for Western Europe.
Authors: Sheila F O'brien; Jo Anne Chiavetta; Mindy Goldman; Wenli Fan; Rama C Nair; Graham D Sher; Eleftherios C Vamvakas Journal: Transfusion Date: 2006-03 Impact factor: 3.157
Authors: Abigail B Diack; Mark W Head; Sandra McCutcheon; Aileen Boyle; Richard Knight; James W Ironside; Jean C Manson; Robert G Will Journal: Prion Date: 2014-11-01 Impact factor: 3.931