D J Deka1, B Choudhury2, P Talukdar1, T Q Lo3, B Das4, S A Nair1, P K Moonan3, A M V Kumar5. 1. World Health Organization Country Office for India, New Delhi, India. 2. Department of Health, Government of Assam, Guwahati, Assam, India. 3. Division of Global HIV and Tuberculosis, Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, Atlanta, Georgia, USA. 4. Department of Health, Government of Tripura, Agartala, Tripura, India. 5. International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease (The Union), Paris, France ; The Union, South-East Asia Office, New Delhi, India.
Abstract
Setting: Nine district-level microscopy centres in Assam and Tripura, India. Objective: Same-day sputum microscopy is now recommended for tuberculosis (TB) diagnosis. We compared this method against the conventional 2-day approach in routine programmatic settings. Methods: During October-December 2012, all adult presumptive TB patients were requested to provide three sputum samples (one at the initial visit, the second 1 h after the first sample, and the third the next morning) for examination by Ziehl-Neelsen smear microscopy. Detection of acid-fast bacilli with any sample was diagnostic. The first and second spot sample comprised the same-day approach, and the first spot sample and next-day sample comprised the 2-day approach. Results: Of 2168 presumptive TB patients, 403 (18.6%) were smear-positive according to the same-day method compared to 427 (19.7%) by the 2-day method (McNemar's test, P < 0.001). Of the total 429 TB patients, 26 (6.1%) were missed by the same-day method and 2 (0.5%) by the 2-day method. Conclusion: Same-day specimen collection for microscopy missed more TB than 2-day collection. In India, missing cases by using same-day microscopy would translate into a considerable absolute number, hindering TB control efforts. We question the indiscriminate switch to same-day diagnosis in settings where patients reliably return for testing the next day.
Setting: Nine district-level microscopy centres in Assam and Tripura, India. Objective: Same-day sputum microscopy is now recommended for tuberculosis (TB) diagnosis. We compared this method against the conventional 2-day approach in routine programmatic settings. Methods: During October-December 2012, all adult presumptive TB patients were requested to provide three sputum samples (one at the initial visit, the second 1 h after the first sample, and the third the next morning) for examination by Ziehl-Neelsen smear microscopy. Detection of acid-fast bacilli with any sample was diagnostic. The first and second spot sample comprised the same-day approach, and the first spot sample and next-day sample comprised the 2-day approach. Results: Of 2168 presumptive TB patients, 403 (18.6%) were smear-positive according to the same-day method compared to 427 (19.7%) by the 2-day method (McNemar's test, P < 0.001). Of the total 429 TB patients, 26 (6.1%) were missed by the same-day method and 2 (0.5%) by the 2-day method. Conclusion: Same-day specimen collection for microscopy missed more TB than 2-day collection. In India, missing cases by using same-day microscopy would translate into a considerable absolute number, hindering TB control efforts. We question the indiscriminate switch to same-day diagnosis in settings where patients reliably return for testing the next day.
Authors: S B Squire; A K Belaye; A Kashoti; F M L Salaniponi; C J F Mundy; S Theobald; J Kemp Journal: Int J Tuberc Lung Dis Date: 2005-01 Impact factor: 2.373
Authors: J Lucian Davis; Adithya Cattamanchi; Luis E Cuevas; Philip C Hopewell; Karen R Steingart Journal: Lancet Infect Dis Date: 2012-10-23 Impact factor: 25.071
Authors: E Botha; S den Boon; K-A Lawrence; H Reuter; S Verver; C J Lombard; C Dye; D A Enarson; N Beyers Journal: Int J Tuberc Lung Dis Date: 2008-08 Impact factor: 2.373
Authors: Luis Eduardo Cuevas; Najla Al-Sonboli; Lovett Lawson; Mohammed Ahmed Yassin; Isabel Arbide; Nasher Al-Aghbari; Jeevan Bahadur Sherchand; Amin Al-Absi; Emmanuel Nnamdi Emenyonu; Yared Merid; Mosis Ifenyi Okobi; Juliana Olubunmi Onuoha; Melkamsew Aschalew; Abraham Aseffa; Greg Harper; Rachel Mary Anderson de Cuevas; Sally Jane Theobald; Carl-Michael Nathanson; Jean Joly; Brian Faragher; Stephen Bertel Squire; Andrew Ramsay Journal: PLoS Med Date: 2011-07-12 Impact factor: 11.069
Authors: Luis Eduardo Cuevas; Mohammed Ahmed Yassin; Najla Al-Sonboli; Lovett Lawson; Isabel Arbide; Nasher Al-Aghbari; Jeevan Bahadur Sherchand; Amin Al-Absi; Emmanuel Nnamdi Emenyonu; Yared Merid; Mosis Ifenyi Okobi; Juliana Olubunmi Onuoha; Melkamsew Aschalew; Abraham Aseffa; Greg Harper; Rachel Mary Anderson de Cuevas; Kristin Kremer; Dick van Soolingen; Carl-Michael Nathanson; Jean Joly; Brian Faragher; Stephen Bertel Squire; Andrew Ramsay Journal: PLoS Med Date: 2011-07-12 Impact factor: 11.069