| Literature DB >> 28044116 |
Stéphane Mathis1, Laurent Magy2, Philippe Corcia3, Karima Ghorab2, Laurence Richard2, Jonathan Ciron4, Mathilde Duchesne2, Jean-Michel Vallat2.
Abstract
Immune-mediated neuromuscular disorders include pathologies of the peripheral nervous system, neuromuscular junction, and muscles. If overlap syndromes (or the association of almost two autoimmune disorders) are recognized, the simultaneous occurrence of several autoimmune neuromuscular disorders is rare. We describe two patients presenting the simultaneous occurrence of inflammatory neuropathy, myositis, and myasthenia gravis (with positive acetylcholine receptor antibodies). For each patient, we carried out a pathological analysis (nerve and muscle) and an electrophysiological study (and follow-up). To our knowledge, this is the first description of such a triple immune-mediated neuromuscular syndrome. We compared our observations with a few other cases of simultaneous diagnosis of two inflammatory neuromuscular disorders.Entities:
Year: 2016 PMID: 28044116 PMCID: PMC5156794 DOI: 10.1155/2016/6108234
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Case Rep Neurol Med ISSN: 2090-6676
Motor and sensory nerve conduction studies: follow-up of our two patients.
| Nerve | DA | DL | NCV | F | CB | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
| ||||||
| ENMG1 (year 0) | ||||||
| Motor nerves | ||||||
| Right | Median | 1.46 mV | 4.74 ms | 56.3 m/s | 30 ms | No |
| Ulnar | 4 mV | 4.34 ms | 65.8 m/s | 31.4 ms | No | |
| Peroneal | 5.2 mV | 4.1 ms | 46.9 m/s | 51.9 ms | No | |
| Tibial | 15 mV | 4.58 ms | ND | 52.7 ms | ND | |
| Left | Median | 2.6 mV | 3.4 ms | 55 m/s | 31.8 ms | No |
| Ulnar | 3.9 mV | 3.87 ms | 60 m/s | 31 ms | No | |
| Peroneal | 5.2 mV | 4.03 ms | 41.3 m/s | 50.4 ms | No | |
| Tibial | 9.9 mV | 4.58 ms | ND | 54.8 ms | ND | |
| Sensory nerves | ||||||
| Right | Median | 8.5 | — | 45.5 m/s | — | — |
| Ulnar | 5.8 | — | 57.1 m/s | — | — | |
| Peroneal | 0 | — | — | — | — | |
| Sural | 0 | — | — | — | — | |
| Left | Median | 6.5 | — | 42.7 m/s | — | — |
| Ulnar | 8 | — | 51.6 m/s | — | — | |
| Peroneal | 0 | — | — | — | — | |
| Sural | 4 | — | 36.8 m/s | — | — | |
| ENMG2 (year 1) | ||||||
| Motor nerves | ||||||
| Right | Median | 2.9 mV | 3.55 ms | 46.3 m/s | ND | No |
| Ulnar | 7.5 mV | 2.13 ms | 57.5 m/s | 30.5 ms | No | |
| Peroneal | 7.4 mV | 13.2 ms | 43.3 m/s | 54.1 ms | No | |
| Tibial | 19.4 mV | 3.32 ms | ND | 51.4 ms | ND | |
| Left | Median | 5.8 mV | 2.76 ms | 55.1 m/s | 27 ms | No |
| Ulnar | 6.5 mV | 2.92 ms | 71.8 m/s | 27.3 ms | No | |
| Peroneal | 4 mV | 10.7 ms | 42.5 m/s | 50.7 ms | No | |
| Tibial | 8.4 mV | 3.32 ms | ND | 56.1 ms | ND | |
| Sensory nerves | ||||||
| Right | Median | 9 | — | 49.8 m/s | — | — |
| Ulnar | 4.9 | — | 46 m/s | — | — | |
| Peroneal | 0 | — | — | — | — | |
| Sural | 2.8 | — | 44.2 m/s | — | — | |
| Left | Median | 9.2 | — | 33.7 m/s | — | — |
| Ulnar | 10.6 | — | 47.9 m/s | — | — | |
| Peroneal | 0 | — | — | — | — | |
| Sural | 0 | — | — | — | — | |
| ENMG3 (year 2) | ||||||
| Motor nerves | ||||||
| Right | Median | 4.1 mV | 3.24 ms | 41.4 m/s | 27.2 ms | No |
| Ulnar | ND | ND | ND | ND | No | |
| Peroneal | 6.3 mV | 3.16 ms | 42.6 m/s | 48.3 ms | No | |
| Tibial | 15 mV | 3.57 ms | 35.6 m/s | 51.4 ms | ND | |
| Left | Median | 8.2 mV | 2.92 ms | 53.5 m/s | 29.4 ms | No |
| Ulnar | ND | ND | ND | ND | No | |
| Peroneal | 2.6 mV | 3.79 ms | 42.8 m/s | 40.6 ms | No | |
| Tibial | 10.8 mV | 3.9 ms | 33.6 m/s | 56.3 ms | ND | |
| Sensory nerves | ||||||
| Right | Median | 6.3 | — | 48.8 m/s | — | — |
| Ulnar | ND | — | ND | — | — | |
| Peroneal | 0 | — | — | — | — | |
| Sural | 4 | — | 54 m/s | — | — | |
| Left | Median | 7.9 | — | 47.2 m/s | — | — |
| Ulnar | ND | — | ND | — | — | |
| Peroneal | 0 | — | — | — | — | |
| Sural | 0 | — | — | — | — | |
|
| ||||||
| ENMG1 (year 0) | ||||||
| Motor nerves | ||||||
| Right | Median | 7.5 mV | 4.2 ms | 46.9 m/s | 33.2 ms | No |
| Ulnar | 6.4 mV | 2.5 ms | 60 m/s | 32.4 ms | No | |
| Peroneal | 2.3 mV | 5.2 ms | 42.3 m/s | 60.3 ms | No | |
| Tibial | 2 mV | 5 ms | 42.4 m/s | 63.3 ms | ND | |
| Left | Median | 8.2 mV | 4.4 ms | 45 m/s | 32.5 ms | No |
| Ulnar | 7.8 mV | 3.1 ms | 62.2 m/s | 33.1 ms | No | |
| Peroneal | 2.3 mV | 5.2 ms | 42.7 m/s | 60.8 ms | No | |
| Tibial | 1.3 mV | 4.5 ms | 44.9 m/s | 63 ms | ND | |
| Sensory nerves | ||||||
| Right | Median | 6.5 | — | 46.3 m/s | — | — |
| Ulnar | 3.5 | — | 32 m/s | — | — | |
| Peroneal | ND | — | ND | — | — | |
| Sural | 4.6 | — | 40 m/s | — | — | |
| Left | Median | 3 | — | 43.1 m/s | — | — |
| Ulnar | 3.3 | — | 40 m/s | — | — | |
| Peroneal | ND | — | ND | — | — | |
| Sural | ND | — | ND | — | — | |
| ENMG2 (year 4) | ||||||
| Motor nerves | ||||||
| Right | Median | 6.3 mV | 6.14 ms | 45.2 m/s | 38.5 ms | No |
| Ulnar | 7.1 mV | 2.65 ms | 59.5 m/s | 35.5 ms | No | |
| Peroneal | ND | ND | ND | ND | ND | |
| Tibial | 1.18 mV | 5.02 ms | ND | 61.6 ms | ND | |
| Left | Median | ND | ND | ND | ND | No |
| Ulnar | ND | ND | ND | ND | No | |
| Peroneal | ND | ND | ND | ND | ND | |
| Tibial | ND | ND | ND | ND | ND | |
| Sensory nerves | ||||||
| Right | Median | 0 | — | — | — | — |
| Ulnar | 4.1 | — | 42 m/s | — | — | |
| Peroneal | ND | — | ND | — | — | |
| Sural | 2.1 | — | 38.9 m/s | — | — | |
| Left | Median | ND | — | ND | — | — |
| Ulnar | ND | — | ND | — | — | |
| Peroneal | ND | — | ND | — | — | |
| Sural | ND | — | ND | — | — |
CB: conduction block; DA: distal amplitude; DL: distal latency; F: F wave; µV: microVolt; ms: millisecond; m/s: meter/second; mV: millivolt; NCV: nerve conduction velocity.
Figure 1Pathological findings in patient 1. (a) Transverse semithin section of sural nerve stained with Toluidine Blue: there is a moderate loss of myelinated fibers. Only a few fibers have a too thin myelin sheath compared to their axonal diameter. (b) Frozen section of deltoid muscle stained with hematein-eosin showing important infiltrates of mononuclear cells; the immunostaining confirmed that these cells were mostly T cells and macrophages. (c) Electron micrograph of a sural nerve section showing two fibers surrounded by onion bulb formation and a fiber with a thin myelin sheath. (d) Electron micrograph of a sural nerve section showing an axon that has been completely demyelinated.
Figure 2Pathological findings in patient 2. (a) Transverse semithin section of a sural nerve stained with Toluidine Blue: there is a moderate loss of myelinated fibers; several fibers have a too thin sheath compared to their axonal diameter. (b) Frozen section of a deltoid muscle stained with anti-CD45 antibody showing the presence of T cell infiltrates. (c) Electron micrograph of a sural nerve section showing a myelinated fiber which is surrounded by an onion bulb formation. (d) Same field as in (c) but at higher magnification.
Main characteristics of the patients with concurrent acute/subacute autoimmune neuromuscular disorders diagnosed at the same time (ranked in descending chronological order).
| References | Type of NMD | Age | Sex | Description of NMD | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| N | M | MG | ||||
| Our observations [ | ||||||
| Patient 1 | • | • | • | 67 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of MG (no thymus abnormality), subacute inflammatory neuropathy, and myositis |
| Patient 2 | • | • | • | 79 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of MG (no thymus abnormality), subacute inflammatory neuropathy, and myositis |
| Tanaka & Satomi, 2016 [ | • | • | 69 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of MFS (positivity of anti-GQ1b antibodies) and MG | |
| Seton et al., 2013 [ | • | • | 46 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG (with thymoma) | |
| Paik et al., 2014 [ | ||||||
| Patient 1 | • | • | 75 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and MG | |
| Patient 2 | • | • | 44 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG (with thymic mass and lymphoid follicular hyperplasia) | |
| Patient 3 | • | • | 54 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG | |
| Patient 4 | • | • | 38 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and MG (with thymic mass and lymphoid follicular hyperplasia) | |
| Patient 5 | • | • | 61 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG | |
| Patient 6 | • | • | 24 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG | |
| Belin et al., 2013 [ | • | • | 58 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of GBS and MG | |
| Reimann et al., 2011 [ | • | • | 57 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of myositis and neuropathy with pipestem capillaries and vascular activated complement deposition | |
| Hill et al., 2011 [ | • | • | 67 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and MG | |
| Kung et al., 2009 [ | • | • | 36 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of GBS and MG | |
| Nomura et al., 2010 [ | • | • | 52 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and severe axonal neuropathy (nerve biopsy: axonal atrophy, ovoids, no demyelinating feature, no vasculitis) | |
| Kizilay et al., 2008 [ | • | • | 52 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of GBS and MG | |
| Kraus et al., 2007 [ | • | • | 65 | M | Development of MG 10 weeks after GBS | |
| Yoshidome et al., 2007 [ | • | • | 62 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG | |
| Avni et al., 2006 [ | • | • | 66 | M | MG (with thymoma) diagnosed 2 weeks after treatment for PM (with high level of blood eosinophils) | |
| Shichijo et al., 2005 [ | • | • | 57 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and MG | |
| Farah et al., 2005 [ | • | • | 71 | F | Diagnosis of AMSAN two years after a diagnosis of MG | |
| Diaco et al., 2004 [ | • | • | 47 | F | Myositis (antisynthetase syndrome) developed in a context of MG | |
| Matsui et al., 2003 [ | ||||||
| Case 1 | • | • | 68 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and inflammatory neuropathy | |
| Case 2 | • | • | 48 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and inflammatory neuropathy | |
| Van de Warrenburg et al., 2002 [ | • | • | 28 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and MG | |
| Otton et al., 2000 [ | • | • | • | 71 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of MG (with thymoma) sensorimotor neuropathy (no nerve biopsy), and PM |
| Kornizky et al., 2000 [ | • | • | 69 | M | PM in a context of MG | |
| Raschilas et al., 1999 [ | • | • | 66 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG (with malignant thymoma) | |
| Kobayashi et al., 1997 [ | • | • | 14 | F | PM developed 29 years after MG (in a context of Grave's syndrome) | |
| Ko et al., 1995 [ | • | • | 25 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG (with thymoma), with also autoimmune active chronic hepatitis | |
| Vogelgesang et al., 1995 [ | • | • | 9 | M | Simultaneous DM and sensorimotor neuropathy (no biopsy) | |
| • | • | 7 | F | Simultaneous DM and sensorimotor neuropathy (nerve biopsy: vasculitis) | ||
| Hausmanowa-Petrusewicz et al., 1995 [ | • | • | 58 | F | DM developed 9 years after MG | |
| Hassel et al., 1992 [ | • | • | 37 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG two days after thymectomy (for thymoma) | |
| Carlander et al., 1991 [ | • | • | 45 | M | MG with recurrent episodes of GBS | |
| García-Merino et al., 1991 [ | • | • | 68 | M | Inflammatory neuropathy (and continuous muscle fiber activity) developed 12 years after a diagnosis of MG (with thymoma) | |
| Behan et al., 1982 [ | • | • | 56 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG, with also Hashimoto's thyroiditis, pemphigoid, carcinoma of the bladder, and Norwegian scabies | |
| Boudouresques et al., 1981 [ | • | • | MG developed 7 months prior to GBS | |||
| Davis & Gallai, 1979 [ | • | • | 71 | F | MG developed after PM | |
| Vasilescu et al., 1978 [ | ||||||
| Case 1 | • | • | 24 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and MG | |
| Case 2 | • | • | 46 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and MG | |
| Case 3 | • | • | 18 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and MG | |
| Case 4 | • | • | 42 | F | Simultaneous diagnosis of DM and MG | |
| De Reuck et al., 1976 [ | • | • | 23 | M | Simultaneous diagnosis of PM and MG | |
AMSAN: acute motor sensory axonal neuropathy; DM: = dermatomyositis; GBS: Guillain-Barré syndrome; M: myositis; MFS: Miller Fisher syndrome; MG: myasthenia gravis; N: acute/subacute neuropathy; NMD: neuromuscular disorder; PM: polymyositis.