| Literature DB >> 27930356 |
Laura N Medford-Davis1, Gregg C Fonarow2, Deepak L Bhatt3, Haolin Xu4, Eric E Smith5, Robert Suter6, Eric D Peterson4,7, Ying Xian4,8, Roland A Matsouaka4,9, Lee H Schwamm10.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Insurance status affects access to care, which may affect health outcomes. The objective was to determine whether patients without insurance or with government-sponsored insurance had worse quality of care or in-hospital outcomes in acute ischemic stroke. METHODS ANDEntities:
Keywords: health outcomes; health policy; health services research; insurance; stroke, ischemic
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2016 PMID: 27930356 PMCID: PMC5210352 DOI: 10.1161/JAHA.116.004282
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Am Heart Assoc ISSN: 2047-9980 Impact factor: 5.501
Figure 1Patient inclusion algorithm.
Patient and Hospital Characteristics for Acute Ischemic Stroke in Patients Younger Than 65 Years Old, Overall and by Insurance Statusa
| Variable | Overall (N=197 474) | Uninsured (N=31 437) | Private (N=104 623) | Medicare (N=23 759) | Medicaid (N=37 655) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patient demographics | |||||
| Age, y | 56 (50–61) | 54 (48–59) | 56 (50–61) | 58 (53–62) | 55 (49–60) |
| Sex | |||||
| Female | 82 084 (41.57) | 11 471 (36.49) | 42 868 (40.97) | 9961 (41.93) | 17 784 (47.23) |
| Male | 115 390 (58.43) | 19 966 (63.51) | 61 755 (59.03) | 13 798 (58.07) | 19 871 (52.77) |
| Race/Ethnicity | |||||
| White | 116 248 (58.89) | 15 483 (49.27) | 69 111 (66.08) | 14 119 (59.46) | 17 535 (46.58) |
| Black | 51 332 (26) | 9629 (30.64) | 21 358 (20.42) | 7027 (29.59) | 13 318 (35.38) |
| Hispanic (any race) | 16 288 (8.25) | 4185 (13.32) | 6565 (6.28) | 1597 (6.73) | 3941 (10.47) |
| Asian | 5116 (2.59) | 852 (2.71) | 3010 (2.88) | 283 (1.19) | 971 (2.58) |
| Other | 8419 (4.26) | 1276 (4.06) | 4540 (4.34) | 721 (3.04) | 1882 (5) |
| Medications prior to admission in those with a medical history | |||||
| Antihypertensives with prior hypertension | 92 565 (74.51) | 11 747 (60.52) | 47 881 (76.31) | 13 452 (81.38) | 19 485 (76.26) |
| Cholesterol reducers with prior dyslipidemia | 48 014 (65.27) | 4534 (52.96) | 26 336 (65.55) | 7661 (71.6) | 9483 (67.15) |
| Diabetic medications with prior diabetes mellitus | 47 570 (74.67) | 5835 (65.97) | 23 355 (76.36) | 7724 (76.87) | 10 656 (74.89) |
| Arrival information | |||||
| Arrival mode: EMS (excluding transfer‐in) | 68 502 (37.94) | 10 528 (35.71) | 33 569 (34.85) | 9225 (43.87) | 15 180 (44.99) |
| Onset to arrival time, minutes | 266 (82‐700) | 306 (90‐791) | 247 (77‐655) | 271 (85‐697) | 292 (88‐747.5) |
| Initial NIH Stroke Scale (0‐42) | 3 (1–7) | 3 (1–7) | 3 (1–6) | 4 (2–9) | 4 (2–9) |
| Ambulate independently on admission | 67 270 (41.73) | 11 203 (42.39) | 38 828 (45.89) | 6381 (33.67) | 10 858 (34.8) |
| Hospital characteristics | |||||
| TJC primary stroke center | 93 669 (47.43) | 14 546 (46.27) | 51 288 (49.02) | 11 144 (46.9) | 16 691 (44.33) |
| Academic/teaching hospital | 121 135 (63.64) | 18 574 (61.67) | 64 042 (63.34) | 14 044 (61.48) | 24 475 (67.49) |
| Rural location | 7975 (4.04) | 1324 (4.21) | 3785 (3.62) | 1423 (5.99) | 1443 (3.83) |
| Annual volume of ischemic stroke admissions | 234.49 (155.61–367.92) | 225.67 (155.24–352.83) | 235.56 (157.9–368.86) | 235.07 (154.59–361.7) | 229.86 (152.24–369.4) |
MI indicates myocardial Infarction; NIH, National Institutes of Health; TIA, transient ischemic attack; TJC, The Joint Commission.
Due to large sample size, all P‐values are statistically significant to <0.0001.
Continuous/ordinal row variables designated by * are presented as Median (IQR). All other values are presented as Patient Count (%).
Process of Care Measures and Other Outcomes of Interest in Acute Ischemic Stroke Patients Younger Than 65 Years Old, Overall and by Insurance Statusa
| Variable | Overall (N=197 474) | Uninsured (N=31 437) | Private (N=104 623) | Medicare (N=23 759) | Medicaid (N=37 655) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Achievement measures | |||||
| Stroke defect‐free care (GWTG) | 174 946 (93.11) | 28 069 (93.37) | 93 405 (93.6) | 20 732 (92.24) | 32 740 (92.08) |
| Quality measures | |||||
| IV t‐PA arrive by 3.5 and treated by 4.5 hours | 16 774 (76.38) | 2642 (78.05) | 9550 (76.17) | 1721 (74.12) | 2861 (77.01) |
| Rehabilitation considered | 172 777 (97.62) | 27 601 (97.71) | 92 149 (97.35) | 20 576 (97.92) | 32 451 (98.12) |
| Reporting measures | |||||
| In‐hospital mortality (excluding transfer‐out, AMA, missing) | 5706 (3.01) | 989 (3.29) | 2634 (2.62) | 839 (3.67) | 1244 (3.46) |
| Discharge destination (excluding death) | |||||
| Home | 123 036 (64.16) | 22 301 (73.24) | 67 970 (66.64) | 12 081 (52.71) | 20 684 (56.81) |
| Hospice | 2199 (1.15) | 285 (0.94) | 1008 (0.99) | 399 (1.74) | 507 (1.39) |
| Inpatient rehab facility | 40 465 (21.1) | 4755 (15.62) | 21 910 (21.48) | 5685 (24.8) | 8115 (22.29) |
| Skilled nursing facility | 15 006 (7.83) | 1459 (4.79) | 5663 (5.55) | 3301 (14.4) | 4583 (12.59) |
| Other outcomes | |||||
| Ambulate independently (excluding death) | 113 976 (59.43) | 19 078 (62.66) | 64 001 (62.75) | 11 367 (49.59) | 19 530 (53.64) |
| Ambulatory status returned to independent during admission, excluding death | 46 706 (24.35) | 7825 (25.70) | 25 173 (24.68) | 4986 (21.75) | 8672 (23.82) |
| Modified Rankin Scale at discharge (total) | 2 (1–4) | 2 (1–4) | 2 (1–4) | 3 (1–4) | 3 (1–4) |
| New diagnosis of diabetes mellitus | 3461 (3.82) | 982 (6.07) | 1744 (3.47) | 201 (2.41) | 534 (3.36) |
| Stroke rehab services | |||||
| Received rehabilitation services during hospitalization | 146 666 (92.51) | 23 831 (92.97) | 77 217 (91.69) | 17 362 (94.13) | 28 256 (93.45) |
| Transferred to rehabilitation facility | 40 863 (25.78) | 4811 (18.77) | 21 170 (25.14) | 6033 (32.71) | 8849 (29.27) |
| Referred to rehabilitation services following discharge | 30 047 (18.95) | 4925 (19.21) | 15 023 (17.84) | 3614 (19.59) | 6485 (21.45) |
| Ineligible to receive rehabilitation services because symptoms resolved | 13 271 (8.37) | 2266 (8.84) | 8060 (9.57) | 1075 (5.83) | 1870 (6.18) |
| Ineligible to receive rehabilitation services due to impairment (ie, poor prognosis, unable to tolerate rehabilitation therapeutic regimen) | 487 (0.31) | 72 (0.28) | 202 (0.24) | 76 (0.41) | 137 (0.45) |
AMA indicates against medical advice; GWTG, Get With the Guidelines.
Due to large sample size, all P‐value are significant to <0.001 with the exception of IV t‐PA, arrive by 3.5 hours, and treated by 4.5 hours, P=0.0047.
Continuous/ordinal row variables designated by † are presented as Median (IQR). All other values are presented as Patient Count (%).
Figure 2Forest plot for unadjusted and adjusted ORs (95% CI) among patients with age <65 years. Private insurance is the reference group for all ORs. The first P‐value within each outcome tests if OR differs by at least 2 insurance categories; all other P‐values test if OR differs significantly from 1. Covariates in adjusted model include patient age, sex, and race; patient medical history of atrial fibrillation or flutter, stroke/TIA, CAD/MI, carotid stenosis, diabetes mellitus, PVD, hypertension, dyslipidemia, or smoking; arrival off‐hours, NIHSS score; and hospital region, teaching status, number of beds, annual ischemic stroke volume, annual IV t‐PA volume, rurality, primary stroke center.