Robert W Westermann1, Cameron Schick1, Christopher M Graves1, Kyle R Duchman2, Stuart L Weinstein1. 1. Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation, University of Iowa, 200 Hawkins Dr., 01008 JPP, Iowa City, IA, 52242, USA. 2. Department of Orthopaedics and Rehabilitation, University of Iowa, 200 Hawkins Dr., 01008 JPP, Iowa City, IA, 52242, USA. kyle-duchman@uiowa.edu.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: More than 100 MRIs per 1000 inhabitants are performed in the United States annually, more than almost every other country. Little is known regarding the cost of obtaining an MRI and factors associated with differences in cost. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: By surveying all hospital-owned and independent imaging centers in Iowa, we wished to determine (1) the cost to the consumer of obtaining a noncontrast shoulder MRI, (2) the frequency and magnitude of discounts provided, and (3) factors associated with differences in cost including location (hospital-owned or independent) and Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services designation (rural, urban, and critical access). METHODS: There were 71 hospitals and 26 independent imaging centers that offered MRI services in Iowa. Each site was contacted via telephone and posed a scripted request for the cost of the technical component of a noncontrast shoulder MRI. Radiologists' reading fees were not considered. Statistical analysis was performed using standard methods and significance was defined as a probability less than 0.05. RESULTS: The mean technical component cost to consumers for an MRI was USD 1874 ± USD 694 (range, USD 500-USD 4000). Discounts were offered by 49% of imaging centers, with a mean savings of 21%. Factors associated with increased cost include hospital-owned imaging centers (USD 2062 ± USD 664 versus USD 1400 ± USD 441 at independent imaging centers; p < 0.001; mean difference, USD 662; 95% CI, USD 351-USD 893) and rural imaging centers, unless designated as a critical access hospital (USD 2213 ± USD 668 versus USD 1794 ± USD 680; p = 0.0202; mean difference, USD 419; 95% CI, USD 66-USD 772). CONCLUSIONS: In Iowa, the cost to the consumer of a shoulder MRI is significantly less at independent imaging centers compared with hospital-owned centers. Referring physicians and healthcare consumers should be aware that there may be substantial price discrepancies between centers that provide advanced imaging services. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, Economic and decision analysis.
BACKGROUND: More than 100 MRIs per 1000 inhabitants are performed in the United States annually, more than almost every other country. Little is known regarding the cost of obtaining an MRI and factors associated with differences in cost. QUESTIONS/PURPOSES: By surveying all hospital-owned and independent imaging centers in Iowa, we wished to determine (1) the cost to the consumer of obtaining a noncontrast shoulder MRI, (2) the frequency and magnitude of discounts provided, and (3) factors associated with differences in cost including location (hospital-owned or independent) and Centers for Medicare & Medicaid Services designation (rural, urban, and critical access). METHODS: There were 71 hospitals and 26 independent imaging centers that offered MRI services in Iowa. Each site was contacted via telephone and posed a scripted request for the cost of the technical component of a noncontrast shoulder MRI. Radiologists' reading fees were not considered. Statistical analysis was performed using standard methods and significance was defined as a probability less than 0.05. RESULTS: The mean technical component cost to consumers for an MRI was USD 1874 ± USD 694 (range, USD 500-USD 4000). Discounts were offered by 49% of imaging centers, with a mean savings of 21%. Factors associated with increased cost include hospital-owned imaging centers (USD 2062 ± USD 664 versus USD 1400 ± USD 441 at independent imaging centers; p < 0.001; mean difference, USD 662; 95% CI, USD 351-USD 893) and rural imaging centers, unless designated as a critical access hospital (USD 2213 ± USD 668 versus USD 1794 ± USD 680; p = 0.0202; mean difference, USD 419; 95% CI, USD 66-USD 772). CONCLUSIONS: In Iowa, the cost to the consumer of a shoulder MRI is significantly less at independent imaging centers compared with hospital-owned centers. Referring physicians and healthcare consumers should be aware that there may be substantial price discrepancies between centers that provide advanced imaging services. LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: Level IV, Economic and decision analysis.
Authors: Ezekiel Emanuel; Neera Tanden; Stuart Altman; Scott Armstrong; Donald Berwick; François de Brantes; Maura Calsyn; Michael Chernew; John Colmers; David Cutler; Tom Daschle; Paul Egerman; Bob Kocher; Arnold Milstein; Emily Oshima Lee; John D Podesta; Uwe Reinhardt; Meredith Rosenthal; Joshua Sharfstein; Stephen Shortell; Andrew Stern; Peter R Orszag; Topher Spiro Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2012-08-01 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Benjamin D Sommers; Thomas Musco; Kenneth Finegold; Munira Z Gunja; Amy Burke; Audrey M McDowell Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2014-07-23 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Tracy Onega; Rebecca Hubbard; Deirdre Hill; Christoph I Lee; Jennifer S Haas; Heather A Carlos; Jennifer Alford-Teaster; Andy Bogart; Wendy B DeMartini; Karla Kerlikowske; Beth A Virnig; Diana S M Buist; Louise Henderson; Anna N A Tosteson Journal: J Am Coll Radiol Date: 2014-06-02 Impact factor: 5.532
Authors: Jordan W Paynter; B Gage Griswold; Pearce W Lane; Daniel W Paré; Rahil A Patel; Michael J Steflik; K Aaron Shaw Journal: J Orthop Date: 2021-11-09
Authors: Madeleine A Salesky; Alan L Zhang; C Benjamin Ma; Brian T Feeley; Valentina Pedoia; Drew A Lansdown Journal: Arthrosc Sports Med Rehabil Date: 2022-02-13