Ayelet Kuper1,2,3, Paula Veinot3, Jennifer Leavitt4, Sarah Levitt5, Amanda Li3, Jeannette Goguen3,6, Martin Schreiber3,6, Lisa Richardson1,3,7, Cynthia R Whitehead1,8,9. 1. Wilson Centre, University Health Network/University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada. 2. Department of Medicine, Sunnybrook Health Sciences Centre, Toronto, ON, Canada. 3. Department of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada. 4. Department of Family Practice, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada. 5. Department of Psychiatry, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada. 6. Department of Medicine, St Michael's Hospital, Toronto, ON, Canada. 7. Department of Medicine, University Health Network, Toronto, ON, Canada. 8. Department of Family & Community Medicine, Women's College Hospital, Toronto, ON, Canada. 9. Department of Family & Community Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON, Canada.
Abstract
CONTEXT: While medical curricula were traditionally almost entirely comprised of bioscientific knowledge, widely accepted competency frameworks now make clear that physicians must be competent in far more than biomedical knowledge and technical skills. For example, of the influential CanMEDS roles, six are conceptually based in the social sciences and humanities (SSH). Educators frequently express uncertainty about what to teach in this area. This study concretely identifies the knowledge beyond bioscience needed to support the training of physicians competent in the six non-Medical Expert CanMEDS roles. METHODS: We interviewed 58 non-clinician university faculty members with doctorates in over 20 SSH disciplines. We abstracted our transcripts (meaning condensation, direct quotations) resulting in approximately 300 pages of data which we coded using top-down (by CanMEDS role) and bottom-up (thematically) approaches and analysed within a critical constructivist framework. Participants and clinicians with SSH PhDs member-checked and refined our results. RESULTS: Twelve interrelated themes were evident in the data. An understanding of epistemology, including the constructed nature of social knowledge, was seen as the foundational theme without which the others could not be taught or understood. Our findings highlighted three anchoring themes (Justice, Power, Culture), all of which link to eight more specific themes concerning future physicians' relationships to the world and the self. All 12 themes were cross-cutting, in that each related to all six non-Medical Expert CanMEDS roles. The data also provided many concrete examples of potential curricular content. CONCLUSIONS: There is a definable body of SSH knowledge that forms the academic underpinning for important physician competencies and is outside the experience of most medical educators. Curricular change incorporating such content is necessary if we are to strengthen the non-Medical Expert physician competencies. Our findings, particularly our cross-cutting themes, also provide a pedagogically useful mechanism for holistically teaching the underpinnings of physician competence. We are now implementing our findings into medical curricula.
CONTEXT: While medical curricula were traditionally almost entirely comprised of bioscientific knowledge, widely accepted competency frameworks now make clear that physicians must be competent in far more than biomedical knowledge and technical skills. For example, of the influential CanMEDS roles, six are conceptually based in the social sciences and humanities (SSH). Educators frequently express uncertainty about what to teach in this area. This study concretely identifies the knowledge beyond bioscience needed to support the training of physicians competent in the six non-Medical Expert CanMEDS roles. METHODS: We interviewed 58 non-clinician university faculty members with doctorates in over 20 SSH disciplines. We abstracted our transcripts (meaning condensation, direct quotations) resulting in approximately 300 pages of data which we coded using top-down (by CanMEDS role) and bottom-up (thematically) approaches and analysed within a critical constructivist framework. Participants and clinicians with SSH PhDs member-checked and refined our results. RESULTS: Twelve interrelated themes were evident in the data. An understanding of epistemology, including the constructed nature of social knowledge, was seen as the foundational theme without which the others could not be taught or understood. Our findings highlighted three anchoring themes (Justice, Power, Culture), all of which link to eight more specific themes concerning future physicians' relationships to the world and the self. All 12 themes were cross-cutting, in that each related to all six non-Medical Expert CanMEDS roles. The data also provided many concrete examples of potential curricular content. CONCLUSIONS: There is a definable body of SSH knowledge that forms the academic underpinning for important physician competencies and is outside the experience of most medical educators. Curricular change incorporating such content is necessary if we are to strengthen the non-Medical Expert physician competencies. Our findings, particularly our cross-cutting themes, also provide a pedagogically useful mechanism for holistically teaching the underpinnings of physician competence. We are now implementing our findings into medical curricula.
Authors: Ayelet Kuper; Victoria A Boyd; Paula Veinot; Tarek Abdelhalim; Mary Jane Bell; Zac Feilchenfeld; Umberin Najeeb; Dominique Piquette; Shail Rawal; Rene Wong; Sarah R Wright; Cynthia R Whitehead; Arno K Kumagai; Lisa Richardson Journal: J Grad Med Educ Date: 2019-08
Authors: Stella L Ng; Jeff Crukley; Ryan Brydges; Victoria Boyd; Adam Gavarkovs; Emilia Kangasjarvi; Sarah Wright; Kulamakan Kulasegaram; Farah Friesen; Nicole N Woods Journal: Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract Date: 2022-01-01 Impact factor: 3.629
Authors: Elisabeth Assing Hvidt; Anne Ulsø; Cecilie Valentin Thorngreen; Jens Søndergaard; Christina Maar Andersen Journal: BMC Med Educ Date: 2022-09-05 Impact factor: 3.263