Jasmeet Kaur1, Alan M Rice2, Elizabeth O'Connor3, Anil Piya4, Bradley Buckler5, Himangshu S Bose1. 1. Laboratory of Biochemistry, Biomedical Sciences, Mercer University School of Medicine, Savannah, Georgia, USA; Anderson Cancer Institute, Memorial University Medical Center, Savannah, Georgia, USA. 2. Division of Pediatric Endocrinology, Memorial University Medical Center, Savannah, Georgia, USA; Augusta University School of Medicine, Augusta, Georgia, USA; Neonatology Intensive Care Unit, Memorial University Medical Center, Georgia, USA. 3. Laboratory of Biochemistry , Biomedical Sciences, Mercer University School of Medicine, Savannah, Georgia , USA. 4. Division of Pediatric Endocrinology, Memorial University Medical Center, Savannah, Georgia, USA; Neonatology Intensive Care Unit, Memorial University Medical Center, Georgia, USA. 5. Neonatology Intensive Care Unit , Memorial University Medical Center, Georgia , USA.
Abstract
Congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) is caused by mutations in cytochrome P450 side chain cleavage enzyme (CYP11A1 and old name, SCC). Errors in cholesterol side chain cleavage by the mitochondrial resident CYP11A1 results in an inadequate amount of pregnenolone production. This study was performed to evaluate the cause of salt-losing crisis and possible adrenal failure in a pediatric patient whose mother had a history of two previous stillbirths and loss of another baby within a week of birth. CAH can appear in any population in any region of the world. The study was conducted at Memorial University Medical Center and Mercer University School of Medicine. The patient was admitted to Pediatric Endocrinology Clinic due to salt-losing crisis and possible adrenal failure. The patient had CAH, an autosomal recessive disease, due to a novel mutation in exon 5 of the CYP11A1 gene, which generated a truncated protein of 286 amino acids compared with wild-type protein that has 521 amino acids (W286X). Although unrelated, both parents are carriers. Mitochondrial protein import analysis of the mutant CYP11A1 in steroidogenic MA-10 cells showed that the protein is imported in a similar fashion as observed for the wild-type protein and was cleaved to a shorter fragment. However, mutant's activity was 10% of that obtained for the wild-type protein in non-steroidogenic COS-1 cells. In a patient of Mexican descent, a homozygous CYP11A1 mutation caused CAH, suggesting that this disease is not geographically restricted even in a homogeneous population. LEARNING POINTS: Novel mutation in CYP11A1 causes CAH;This is a pure population from Central Mexico;Novel mutation created early truncated protein.
Congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH) is caused by mutations in cytochrome P450 side chain cleavage enzyme (CYP11A1 and old name, SCC). Errors in cholesterol side chain cleavage by the mitochondrial resident CYP11A1 results in an inadequate amount of pregnenolone production. This study was performed to evaluate the cause of salt-losing crisis and possible adrenal failure in a pediatric patient whose mother had a history of two previous stillbirths and loss of another baby within a week of birth. CAH can appear in any population in any region of the world. The study was conducted at Memorial University Medical Center and Mercer University School of Medicine. The patient was admitted to Pediatric Endocrinology Clinic due to salt-losing crisis and possible adrenal failure. The patient had CAH, an autosomal recessive disease, due to a novel mutation in exon 5 of the CYP11A1 gene, which generated a truncated protein of 286 amino acids compared with wild-type protein that has 521 amino acids (W286X). Although unrelated, both parents are carriers. Mitochondrial protein import analysis of the mutant CYP11A1 in steroidogenic MA-10 cells showed that the protein is imported in a similar fashion as observed for the wild-type protein and was cleaved to a shorter fragment. However, mutant's activity was 10% of that obtained for the wild-type protein in non-steroidogenic COS-1 cells. In a patient of Mexican descent, a homozygous CYP11A1 mutation caused CAH, suggesting that this disease is not geographically restricted even in a homogeneous population. LEARNING POINTS: Novel mutation in CYP11A1 causes CAH;This is a pure population from Central Mexico;Novel mutation created early truncated protein.
Protein targeting to a specific cellular compartment depends on two principal criteria:
(1) the signal sequence and (2) maintenance of protein folding. Incorrect
folding of metabolic enzymes present in the steroidogenic pathway leads to the reduced
production of steroids necessary for mammalian development (1). There are many genes involved in the steroidogenic pathway, and
a mutation in one has the potential to negatively impact the production of cortisol and
induce adrenal enlargement, a condition known as congenital adrenal hyperplasia (CAH). A
common feature in these mutations is the development of salt-losing crisis and ambiguous
genitalia. Although it may be challenging to identify the gene responsible for reduced
or low baseline steroid synthesis and subsequently ambiguous genitalia (2), the problem often starts with the availability
of first steroid synthesized, pregnenolone, because the synthesis of all steroids
depends on (i) cholesterol flow into the mitochondria and (ii) cleavage of the side
chain of cholesterol to generate pregnenolone.The steroidogenic acute regulatory protein (StAR) fosters cholesterol from the outer to
inner mitochondrial membrane; thus, StAR mutations that impact this activity result in
low levels of pregnenolone (2, 3). Although some mutations are more common in some
specific ethnicities, StAR mutations are present in any ethnicity independent of the
country of origin. In addition, mutations in the cytochrome P450 side chain
cleavage enzyme (CYP11A1) gene may render the protein inactive and result in
low pregnenolone synthesis (3, 4). Thus, a full-term pregnancy is likely not to
have any disorder in progesterone synthesis due to mutant CYP11A1. In contrast, low
levels of progesterone and miscarriage may be due to CYP11A1 mutations that impact
pregnenolone to progesterone conversion.In addition to the correct folding, the activity of CYP11A1 depends on ferrodoxin,
ferrodoxin reductase and NADPH, which are associated with several mitochondrial-resident
proteins, generating a large molecular weight complex (5, 6). Here, we report for the first
time a de novo mutation in CYP11A1 that causes CAH identified in an
infant of Mexican descent. The point mutation in exon 5 resulted in a truncated protein
that is processed into the mitochondria in a fashion similar to that observed for
wild-type CYP11A1. Both parents are carriers of this mutation, which is likely
responsible for two previous abortions and the death of a previous newborn. Thus,
although CAH is considered autosomal, it may also appear independent of genetic origin
and as a result of the founder effect. We overexpressed this mutant CYP11A1 and
determined its activity, folding and expression and compared it with the wild-type
protein.
Case presentation
The proband was born by emergency C-section due to an approximately 10% placental
abruption at 36 weeks and 1 day gestational age with a birth weight of 2416 g
(26–50th percentile-for-gestational age), birth length of 46.8 cm
(26–50th percentile-for-gestational age) and a head circumference of
34.5 cm (76–90th percentile-for-age). APGARS were 5 at 1 min and 7
at 5 min and 9 at 10 min. Prenatal ultrasound revealed a nuchal fold.
Amniocentesis was refused by the mother.The parents were originally from Central Mexico. A pedigree analysis is presented in
Fig. 1A. At the time of proband’s
birth, the mother was G4, P4 A2. The prior live-born infant, reportedly appeared female,
was born at 23 weeks and 5 days gestational age with a weight of 600 g
(51–75th percentile-for-gestational age) vaginally as a result of preterm labor,
had multiple extreme prematurity-related problems, including anemia, hypotension, grade
IV intraventricular hemorrhage, renal dysfunction, patent ductus arteriosis, pulmonary
intersititial emphysema of the newborn, thrombocytopenia, neonatal hypocalcemia followed
by hypercalcemia, hyperbilirubinemia of prematurity, hypo- and hyperglycemia and
electrolyte abnormalities – initially hypernatremia accompanied by eukalemia,
followed by hyponatremia and hyperkalemia during the last 24 h of life. Newborn
screening 17-OH progesterone level on the second day of life was reported to be
‘within normal limits’, and a total T4 was reported as
<3.0 µg/dL, whereas the TSH was reported to be
2.3 μIU/mL. The infant died on the 10th day of life of the complications
of extreme prematurity and, in accordance with parental request, an autopsy was not
done. The other two pregnancies concluded with spontaneous abortions. Because of the
prior spontaneous abortions, and the extremely premature birth of the sibling, the
mother of the proband received weekly injections of 17-hydroxyprogesterone caproate from
16 to 35 weeks of gestation. The last injection of 17-hydroxyprogesterone caproate
(7) was received 1 week before the proband
was born.
Figure 1
Pedigree and imaging analysis of a newborn patient presenting with salt-losing
crisis and possible adrenal failure. (A) Pedigree analysis of the family: Black
symbol represents affected individual and white symbols show unaffected
individuals. The symbol () represents female, () male, preterm delivery of male
() and () female who died prematurely. (B) A close view of ambiguous
genitalia.
Pedigree and imaging analysis of a newborn patient presenting with salt-losing
crisis and possible adrenal failure. (A) Pedigree analysis of the family: Black
symbol represents affected individual and white symbols show unaffected
individuals. The symbol () represents female, () male, preterm delivery of male
() and () female who died prematurely. (B) A close view of ambiguous
genitalia.The proband infant had a prolapse of the upper vaginal region into the vaginal introitus
with no visible secretions, partial labial-scrotal fusion, a 5 mm wide phallic
structure with the urethral opening at the base, and no palpable gonads in the
labial-scrotal folds (Fig. 1B). A chromosome
analysis was ordered because of ambiguity of the genitalia (Fig. 1B). The infant was noted to have generalized
hyperpigmentation, even when considering the Mexican ethnicity of the parents. The
chromosome analysis revealed a 46, XY karyotype. On the sixth day of life,
adrenocorticotropic hormone (ACTH) level was 3975 pg/mL
(5–46 pg/mL), cortisol level was undetectable at less than
0.4 µg/dL, plasma renin activity was 141.6 ng/mL/h (normal,
2.0–35.0 ng/mL/h), progesterone was <0.10 ng/mL,
17-hydroxyprogesterone was <10 ng/dL (29–35 weeks gestational age
normal range 26–568 ng/dL), dihydroepiandrosterone (DHEA) was
<0.050 ng/mL (premature normal range <40 ng/mL) and androstenedione
was <0.030 ng/mL (31–35 weeks gestational age normal range
0.80–4.46 ng/mL). The chromosome analysis, ACTH, plasma renin activity,
steroids, with the exception of the cortisol, and their reference ranges are from ARUP
LABORATORIES (Way, Salt Lake City, UT, USA). The serum glucose level was
58 mg/dL, sodium was 130 mmol/L and the potassium was 5.7 mmol/L,
and the infant was noted to be tachypneic and to have subcostal retractions. Stress
doses of hydrocortisone sodium succinate were started.When the tachypnea and retractions resolved, the serum sodium, potassium and glucose
levels were stably within the normal ranges for age, the hydrocortisone sodium succinate
was replaced with physiologic replacement doses of prednisone, as well as
9-alpha-fludrocortisone and sodium chloride supplementation. Since then, the
infant’s linear growth and rate of weight gain have been normal, and the upper
portion of the vagina is no longer protruding from the vaginal introitus. The adrenal
gland was observed to be enlarged. The parents have opted to raise the child as a female
unless the child opts for a male gender at an older age.
Investigation
Study participants: Informed consent was obtained from each participating family member
as well as the parents of the patient with putative CAH.Sequence analysis: Blood samples collected in ethylenediaminetetraacetate were used to
prepare genomic DNA using a genomic DNA isolation kit (DNeasy Blood and Tissue Kit,
Qiagen). Because the patient was considered to have lipoid CAH, seven exons of
StAR gene were analyzed following a standard procedure (3). Analysis of the CYP11A1 gene was also
undertaken by first amplifying the genomic DNA using a variety of primer combinations
(8), where we first amplified exons 1 and 2,
which was similar to wild-type CYP11A1. We then amplified the rest of the exons using
identical PCR conditions as previously described (8). PCR products were sequenced directly using commercial resources (MC Lab,
South San Francisco, CA, USA).Restriction fragment length polymorphism (RFLP) analysis: After the amplification of
exon 5 using genomic DNA with primers SCC5S and SCC5AS as previously described (8), the resultant 282 bp product was
incubated with BfaI at 37°C for 45 min. The bands were resolved in a
non-denaturing 8% TBE acrylamide gel after electrophoresis at 60 V for 2 h
and were visualized after staining with ethidium bromide.Cell culture, transfection and activity analysis: COS-1 cells were grown in DMEM medium
supplemented with 5% fetal bovine serum, 10% horse serum and 1× gentamycin at
37°C in a humidified incubator under 5% CO2. For CYP11A1 expression
and activity, the mutant or wild-type CYP11A1 subcloned in pCMV vector and the purified
plasmid cDNA was transfected with Lipofectamine as previously described (3). The cells were washed with serum-free media
12 h after transfection and supplemented with media containing the appropriate
antibiotics and 10% serum. In all cases, 100 ng/mL of trilostane (Steraloids, Los
Angeles, CA, USA) was added as an inhibitor of 3βHSD2.Metabolic conversion of cholesterol to pregnenolone was performed with reactions
initiated with NADPH and 14C-cholesterol for pregnenolone synthesis. For
complete conversion, we used five-fold excess of cold water-soluble cholesterol carrier
to reach the saturation point. Trilostane was added in all the reactions to inhibit
3βHSD2 activity. Equal amounts of cold cholesterol-pregnenolone in ethanol were
added as a carrier; the steroids were extracted with ether/acetone (9:1 v/v), and the
solvent was evaporated under N2. It was completed with the addition of
five-fold excess of cold pregnenolone. The extract was brought up in
100 μL of methanol, and radioactive counts were determined. The extracts
were concentrated under a stream of nitrogen or air and then separated by TLC (Whatman,
MA, USA) using a chloroform/ethyl acetate (3:1) mobile phase.Mitochondrial translocation assay: A cell-free transcription/translation kit (Promega),
which contains rabbit reticulocyte lysate (RRL) for protein expression after our
modified procedure (6), was used to express
wild-type and W286X CYP11A1-mutant proteins for in vitro experiments.
Briefly, a mixture of 19 amino acids without cold methionine was incubated with
35S-methionine, (MP Biomedicals, Santa Ana, CA, USA) and SP6 polymerase at
26°C for 2 h. Expression was verified using SDS-PAGE. For mitochondrial
import analysis, mitochondria isolated from MA-10 cells were suspended in 20 mM
HEPES, pH 7.5, following a previously described procedure (3, 4, 5, 6). After addition of
the freshly prepared cell-free synthesized (CFS) protein of interest, mitochondria were
incubated at 26°C. To inhibit the mitochondrial proton pump,
1.0 µg/mL valinomycin (Sigma) was added.
Outcome and follow-up
We have performed a pedigree analysis of the patient’s family, which shows that
all the grandparents were from the same village and of the same ethnic origin (Fig. 1A). The grandparents lived a very long life
with the paternal side living close to 100 years or more and the maternal side living
more than 95 years. The parent’s cousins were all living, and no major genetic
defect, physical disability or abnormality was known to the parents of the patient.We first considered that the ambiguous female genitalia and adrenal insufficiency were
possibly due to a mutation in the 7.5 kb StAR gene, which has
seven exons with exon 5–7 comprising 40% of the protein. Although mutations have
been identified in other exons, most StAR mutations causing lipoid CAH
have been found in exons 5–7 of the StAR gene (3). Because we did not find any mutation in exons
4–7, we sequenced the complete gene but found no nucleotide changes in the
StAR coding sequence even in the exon and intron boundary.After revisiting the phenotypic data and finding that the mother had a problem retaining
pregnancy, suggesting an inadequate supply of progesterone, we next analyzed all nine
exons of the CYP11A1 gene using a combination of primers used previously (8). We identified a change in nucleotide 857, which
changed from guanine to adenine, mutating tryptophan 286 to a stop codon (Fig. 2A). To confirm the presence of the mutation,
we next amplified exon 5, including its intron–exon boundaries with the
appropriate primers and performed RFLP analysis with BfaI because a TGG-to-TAG
nucleotide change would destroy a BsrI restriction site at position 286 and
simultaneously create a new BfaI restriction site (Fig.
2B and C). As shown in Fig. 3A, RFLP analysis using PCR-amplified product
of exon 5 (282 bp) from the patient, mother and father confirmed the presence of
the mutation, resulting in two bands of 202 and 80 bp in the patient. The
wild-type product was not digested at all because of the absence of the BfaI restriction
site. However, both of the parents showed a similar, partial digestion with the
intensities of the digested bands being 50% less as compared with the patient’s
sample, showing that both parents were carriers. The RFLP analysis is presented
schematically (Fig. 3A), including the position
of the exon with its intronic boundaries (Fig.
3B).
Figure 2
Sequencing analysis of the CYP11A1 gene. (A) Sequencing of the genomic DNA
isolated from the patient, patient’s parents and a control, unaffected
individual with SCC5S and SCC5AS primers. A change in nucleotide 857 was found,
which changed guanine to adenine, resulted in a mutation of tryptophan 286 to a
stop codon. The father and mother were both heterozygous carriers of the
mutation. (B) The G to A mutation created a BfaI restriction site but destroyed
a BsrI site, shown by the indicated arrow. (C) Restriction enzyme nucleotide
recognition sites of the BfaI and BsrI.
Figure 3
Analysis of the CYP11A1 mutation by RFLP and its effect on pregnenolone
synthesis. (A) RFLP analysis of the 282 bp-amplified exon 5 of CYP11A1
followed by incubation with BfaI. Although the wild-type product is not
digested, the product amplified from the patient was digested into two bands
(202 and 80 bp). The mother and father are both carriers, resulting in
partial digestion. (B) Schematic analysis of the digestion pattern of the
restriction analysis by BfaI. The hatched bar represents the exon–intron
boundary. Digestion at the BfaI site results in two smaller fragments of 80 and
202 bp. (C) Measurement of pregnenolone synthesis by the W286X mutant
and wild-type CYP11A1 after their expression in nonsteroidogenic COS-1 cells.
(D) Quantitative analysis of the amount of steroid synthesized through
phosphorimaging. The Y-axis is presented in arbitrary units (AU) developed by
phosphoimager program. Data represent the
mean ± s.e.m. of three independent experiments
performed at three different times.
Sequencing analysis of the CYP11A1 gene. (A) Sequencing of the genomic DNA
isolated from the patient, patient’s parents and a control, unaffected
individual with SCC5S and SCC5AS primers. A change in nucleotide 857 was found,
which changed guanine to adenine, resulted in a mutation of tryptophan 286 to a
stop codon. The father and mother were both heterozygous carriers of the
mutation. (B) The G to A mutation created a BfaI restriction site but destroyed
a BsrI site, shown by the indicated arrow. (C) Restriction enzyme nucleotide
recognition sites of the BfaI and BsrI.Analysis of the CYP11A1 mutation by RFLP and its effect on pregnenolone
synthesis. (A) RFLP analysis of the 282 bp-amplified exon 5 of CYP11A1
followed by incubation with BfaI. Although the wild-type product is not
digested, the product amplified from the patient was digested into two bands
(202 and 80 bp). The mother and father are both carriers, resulting in
partial digestion. (B) Schematic analysis of the digestion pattern of the
restriction analysis by BfaI. The hatched bar represents the exon–intron
boundary. Digestion at the BfaI site results in two smaller fragments of 80 and
202 bp. (C) Measurement of pregnenolone synthesis by the W286X mutant
and wild-type CYP11A1 after their expression in nonsteroidogenic COS-1 cells.
(D) Quantitative analysis of the amount of steroid synthesized through
phosphorimaging. The Y-axis is presented in arbitrary units (AU) developed by
phosphoimager program. Data represent the
mean ± s.e.m. of three independent experiments
performed at three different times.After overexpression of the wild-type and mutant CYP11A1 in non-steroidogenic COS-1
cells that were also transfected with ferrodoxin, ferrodoxin reductase and P450scc as a
single fusion protein, F2 (3), analysis of
pregnenolone synthesis revealed that the wild-type vector synthesized 8-fold more
pregnenolone compared with the mutant CYP11A1 (Fig.
3C and D), suggesting that W286X
truncated CYP11A1 reduced progesterone synthesis but not to that level of complete
inactivity.To understand whether the inactivity of the mutant was due to the shorter protein
sequence and/or whether it was incapable of interaction with mitochondrial translocases
and, therefore, mitochondrial translocation, we compared the mitochondrial import of the
W286X CYP11A1 mutant with wild-type CYP11A1 using radiolabeled CYP11A1 obtained via
cell-free rabbit reticulocyte system (CFS) and mitochondria isolated from the
steroidogenic mouse Leydig (MA-10) cells. As shown in Fig. 4A, the 61 kDa protein is imported into the mitochondria in two
successive steps, resulting in 57 and 54 kDa proteins. The 61 and 57 kDa
proteins were quickly proteolyzed by proteinase K (PK) in the presence of Triton X-100;
however, the 54-kDa protein was resistant, suggesting that it was protected by the inner
mitochondrial environment (Fig. 4A, last lane).
Triton X-100 forms elliptical micelles on the membrane and makes an easy entry of the
protease resulting in faster proteolysis. CYP11A1 was imported into the mitochondrial
matrix as a 54 kDa protein, so a shorter incubation of PK and Triton X-100
together protected mostly the protein fragment imported into the matrix (Fig. 4A, Right hand Panel). Interestingly, the
31-kDa W286X mutant was also imported into the mitochondria and processed into a shorter
27-kDa band (Fig. 4B), suggesting that the
CYP11A1 signal sequence is sufficient for mitochondrial transport. However, the regions
required for interaction with the cofactors necessary for performing the enzymatic
action may be lost in the truncated protein. To confirm the accuracy of the
mitochondrial import and processing assay, we confirmed the quality of the mitochondria
by importing cell-free synthesized CYP11A1 into the isolated mitochondria with the
inhibition of the mitochondrial proton pump after incubation with
1.0 μg/mL valinomycin (Fig. 4C).
CYP11A1 import was inhibited by valinomycin as indicated by the presence of only the 61
and 57 kDa proteins, thus validating our mitochondrial import and processing
analysis.
Figure 4
Mitochondrial import of the wild-type and W286X-mutant CYP11A1. (A) Left panel
– 35S-Methionine-labeled wild-type CYP11A1 was synthesized in
a linked cell-free rabbit reticulocyte lysate system (CFS) and then the newly
synthesized protein was imported into mitochondria (mito) isolated from MA-10
cells. The import analysis was performed with proteinase K (PK) proteolysis in
the presence and absence of Triton X-100 (Triton) and was visualized by
autoradiography. The full-length protein is unimported (unimport) and
mitochondrial resident fraction is imported (import). Right panel –
Quantitative analysis of imported CYP11A1 in isolated mitochondria
(54 kDa band), protected after PK and triton treatment. Data presented
in this panel are a mean ± s.e.m. of at least
three independent experiments performed at three different times. (B)
Comparison of wild-type (WT) and W286X mutant (patient) CYP11A1 into the
isolated mitochondria (mito). The 31-kDa mutant protein was also imported and
processed in the mitochondria into a shorter 27-kDa protein. (C)
35S-Methionine-labeled wild-type CYP11A1 was synthesized in a linked
cell-free transcription translation system (CFS) and imported into mitochondria
isolated from MA-10 cells (mito). The mitochondrial imported and unimported
fractions were separated by washing (Wash) followed by centrifugation, where
the unimported fraction remained in the supernatant (S), and the imported
fraction remained in the pellet (P). Sodium carbonate (Carb) determines the
lipid integrated from the unintegrated protein. Addition of
1.0 μg/mL mitochondrial uncoupler, valinomycin (Val) inhibited
the proton pump from the matrix to the inner mitochondria space and thus only
two bands were observed. The positive (+) and negative (−) symbols
indicate the presence and absence of the indicated reagents.
Mitochondrial import of the wild-type and W286X-mutant CYP11A1. (A) Left panel
– 35S-Methionine-labeled wild-type CYP11A1 was synthesized in
a linked cell-free rabbit reticulocyte lysate system (CFS) and then the newly
synthesized protein was imported into mitochondria (mito) isolated from MA-10
cells. The import analysis was performed with proteinase K (PK) proteolysis in
the presence and absence of Triton X-100 (Triton) and was visualized by
autoradiography. The full-length protein is unimported (unimport) and
mitochondrial resident fraction is imported (import). Right panel –
Quantitative analysis of imported CYP11A1 in isolated mitochondria
(54 kDa band), protected after PK and triton treatment. Data presented
in this panel are a mean ± s.e.m. of at least
three independent experiments performed at three different times. (B)
Comparison of wild-type (WT) and W286X mutant (patient) CYP11A1 into the
isolated mitochondria (mito). The 31-kDa mutant protein was also imported and
processed in the mitochondria into a shorter 27-kDa protein. (C)
35S-Methionine-labeled wild-type CYP11A1 was synthesized in a linked
cell-free transcription translation system (CFS) and imported into mitochondria
isolated from MA-10 cells (mito). The mitochondrial imported and unimported
fractions were separated by washing (Wash) followed by centrifugation, where
the unimported fraction remained in the supernatant (S), and the imported
fraction remained in the pellet (P). Sodium carbonate (Carb) determines the
lipid integrated from the unintegrated protein. Addition of
1.0 μg/mL mitochondrial uncoupler, valinomycin (Val) inhibited
the proton pump from the matrix to the inner mitochondria space and thus only
two bands were observed. The positive (+) and negative (−) symbols
indicate the presence and absence of the indicated reagents.
Discussion
Progesterone synthesis by mitochondrial 3βHSD2 (2, 3, 4) is required for the maintenance of human pregnancies as it
suppresses uterine contractility, and interruption in the maintenance of progesterone
level induces abortion. As Miller’s group has considered, no mutation of the
placental ferrodoxin, ferrodoxin reductase and 3βHSD2 was reported and none of
the START domain proteins can compensate for the loss of CYP11A1 activity by cleaving
cholesterol to pregnenolone. Thus, we analyzed whether a mutation in the CYP11A1 gene
was the reason for the extremely high ACTH levels and PRA activity in the newborn and
why the patient’s mother experienced difficulty in retaining pregnancies. Our
report demonstrates that the presence of homozygous disruptive CYP11A1 mutations may
represent a preemptive indication for multiple spontaneous abortion. The mutation
identified in this study was isolated from a Mexican newborn whose maternal and paternal
families were from the same village and whose families had long and healthy
lifespans.To date, CYP11A1 gene mutations that induce CAH have been described in only 15 patients
(Table 1), which is likely due to the fact
that it is the sole enzyme maintaining adrenal activity required for the production of
all steroids. Most CYP11A1 gene mutations have been heterozygous and some have appeared
at the late onset of puberty. In contrast, we have identified a single nucleotide change
at position 857 of the CYP11A1 gene, which results in a nonsense mutation (W286X) and,
therefore, a truncated protein (from a 61 to a 31 kDa protein). The patient had
very high ACTH levels and PRA activity, and the ACTH level remained higher than normal
levels possibly because the mineralocorticoid receptor is not acting at the same level
as the glucocorticoid receptor. As the ACTH level remained above the normal range,
increased cortisol should then be maintained by the adrenal gland. However, inactivity
of the metabolizing enzymes of the adrenal gland resulted in an imbalance in the
electrolyte transport from the adrenal gland.
Table 1
Mutations in the side chain cleavage enzyme (CYP11A1) causing ambiguous
genitalia, sex reversal, past miscarriages and spontaneous abortions.
Mutations
Ref
Homozygous/heterozygous
(patient)
Onset of adrenal failure
Karyotype
Genitalia
Maternal
miscarriage/abortion
Gestation
L222P
(3)
Homozygous
9 years
46, XY
Normal male
0
Full term
R360W/R405X
(3)
Heterozygous
15 days
46, XY
Micropenis
1
Full term
L141W/V415E
(3)
Heterozygous
1–9 days
46, XY
Normal female
0
Full term
c835delA
(3)
Homozygous
9 days
46, XY
Normal female
Low E3, 2
31 weeks
Frameshift; c835delA stop/slice
(3)
Heterozygous
8 days
46, XY
Normal female
Low E3, 1
Full term
R353W
(3)
Heterozygous
7–9 months
46, XY
Normal female
0
Full term
A189V
(3)
Heterozygous
7–9 months
46, XY
Normal female
0
Full term
A359V
(3)
Homozygous
21 months
46, XY
Normal female
2
Full term
R232X
(10)
Homozygous
Neonate
46, XX
Normal female
2
Post-term
R232X
(10)
Homozygous
Neonate
46, XX
Normal female
0
Full term
R232X/F215S
(10)
Heterozygous
1.2 years
46, XY
Small penis
0
Twin at full term
R232X/F215S
(10)
Heterozygous
4.75 years
46, XY
Normal male
0
Full term
R232X/F215S
(10)
Heterozygous
1.5 years
46, XX
Normal female
0
Full term
R120X
(10)
Homozygous
Neonate
46, XX
Normal female
1
Full term
A269V
(3)
Heterozygous
8 years
46, XY
Normal male
0
Full term
A269V
(3)
Heterozygous
12 months
46, XX
Normal female
0
Full term
R451W
(3)
2 year 10 months
46, XY
Normal male
0
Full term
R451W
(3)
1 year 3 months
46, XY
Normal male
0
Full term
Insertion of G and N between D271 and
V272
(3)
Heterozygous
4 years
46, XY
Normal female
0
Full term
W286X
This study
Homozygous
1 day after birth
46, XY
Normal female
3
Full term
Mutations in the side chain cleavage enzyme (CYP11A1) causing ambiguous
genitalia, sex reversal, past miscarriages and spontaneous abortions.Many of the patients with previously identified CYP11A1 mutations had mothers with a
history of miscarriages, and some experienced the very early stage of salt wasting
crisis and high ACTH secretion (9). In some
cases, the onset of adrenal failure was later, and many were either heterozygotes or had
undergone gene conversion, likely resulting in a minimum level of
pregnenolone-to-progesterone conversion catalyzed by 3βHSD2 (4, 10).Our recent finding shows that steroidogenic protein 3βHSD2 activity requires an
association with mitochondrial translocases, including Tim50 or Tim23 of the inner
mitochondrial translocase and Tom22 translocase facing the IMS side of the mitochondria,
after entering to the mitochondria (10). In the
absence of these mitochondrial translocases, 3βHSD2 and StAR activities were
reduced. In the absence of the mitochondrial import receptor, Tom22, the alternate
OMM-associated protein, Tom20, can facilitate protein import; however, it cannot
translocate to the appropriate protein environment and thus becomes inactive. CYP11A1 is
a 521 amino acid protein and its N-terminal 39 amino acids are essential for import into
the mitochondria (3). In this study, the 286
amino acid CYP11A1 is a truncated protein, which is imported into the mitochondria where
its 39 amino acid N-terminal signal sequence is cleaved in a fashion similar to the
wild-type protein. Because of the absence of full-length sequence, the CYP11A1 passenger
protein sequence could not interact with the electron donating partner of ferrodoxin
– ferrodoxin reductase. Thus, the short CYP11A1 is imported into the mitochondria
and processed in a similar fashion like wild type, which was not observed for another
mitochondrial enzyme 3βHSD2, which ignored the N-terminal sequence when fused
with its N-terminus (10). Thus, CYP11A1
activity requires the passenger protein sequence, which explains why carriers of the
CYP11A1 mutation had retained activity.
Declaration of interest
The authors declare that there is no conflict of interest that could be perceived as
prejudicing the impartiality of the research reported.
Funding
The work was initially supported by a grant from National Institutes of Health
(HD057876), an intramural research grant from Anderson Cancer Institute and a Seed Grant
from the Mercer University School of Medicine (all to H S B).
Patient consent
Informed consent has been obtained for this study.
Author contribution statement
J Kaur did the lab/scientific experiments and analyzed the data. H Bose analyzed and
interpreted the data and wrote the manuscript. Patient was seen by A Rice, E
O’Connor, A Piya, B Buckler.
Authors: Maheshinie Rajapaksha; Jasmeet Kaur; Manoj Prasad; Kevin J Pawlak; Brendan Marshall; Elizabeth W Perry; Randy M Whittal; Himangshu S Bose Journal: Mol Cell Biol Date: 2016-01-19 Impact factor: 4.272
Authors: Meng Kian Tee; Michal Abramsohn; Neta Loewenthal; Mark Harris; Sudeep Siwach; Ana Kaplinsky; Barak Markus; Ohad Birk; Val C Sheffield; Ruti Parvari; Ruti Pavari; Eli Hershkovitz; Walter L Miller Journal: J Clin Endocrinol Metab Date: 2013-01-21 Impact factor: 5.958
Authors: Paul J Meis; Mark Klebanoff; Elizabeth Thom; Mitchell P Dombrowski; Baha Sibai; Atef H Moawad; Catherine Y Spong; John C Hauth; Menachem Miodovnik; Michael W Varner; Kenneth J Leveno; Steve N Caritis; Jay D Iams; Ronald J Wapner; Deborah Conway; Mary J O'Sullivan; Marshall Carpenter; Brian Mercer; Susan M Ramin; John M Thorp; Alan M Peaceman; Steven Gabbe Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2003-06-12 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: Himangshu S Bose; Fadi Gebrail; Brendan Marshall; Elizabeth W Perry; Randy M Whittal Journal: Mol Cell Biol Date: 2018-12-11 Impact factor: 4.272
Authors: Himangshu S Bose; Alan M Rice; Brendan Marshall; Fadi Gebrail; David Kupshik; Elizabeth W Perry Journal: Endocrinol Diabetes Metab Case Rep Date: 2019-05-03