Effect of peritoneal dialysis versus hemodialysis on renal anemia in renal in end-stage disease patients: a meta-analysis.

The aim of this meta-analysis was to evaluate the effect of peritoneal dialysis (PD) and hemodialysis (HD) on renal anemia (RA) in renal disease patients by a meta-analysis. Relevant studies published before June 2015 were searched. Pooled odds ratio (OR) with 95% confidence interval (CI) was used to evaluate the effect of HD and PD on RA based on five indexes: hemoglobin, ferritin, transferrin saturation index, serum albumin, and parathyroid hormone. Sensitivity analysis and publication bias assessment were conducted to evaluate the stability and reliability of our results. A total of fourteen eligible studies with 1103 cases underwent HD and 625 cases underwent PD were used for this meta-analysis. There were no significant difference for levels of hemoglobin (SMD = -0.23, 95% CI: -0.74 to 0.28), ferritin (SMD = 0.01, 95% CI: -0.59 to 0.62), parathyroid hormone (SMD = 0.11, 95% CI: -1.53 to 1.75) and transferrin saturation index (SMD = -0.06, 95% CI: -0.67 to 0.56) between HD and PD group. However, the content of serum albumin in HD group was much more than that in PD group (SMD = 1.58, 95% CI: 0.35 to 2.81). Neither of the included studies could reverse the pooled side effect and Egger's test demonstrated no publication bias. Both of the two dialysis strategies have a similar effect on RA in renal disease patients.

Introduction

Anemia is a clinical manifestation that commonly happened in patients with renal disease. Untreated anemia is associated with several physiological abnormalities which will significantly reduce patients’ life quality., The management of anemia with erythropoiesis-stimulating agents (ESAs) is an important treatment for chronic kidney disease (CKD) patients with anemia (namely renal anemia [RA]) who receiving dialysis programs.

Recently, a number of factors were recognized to be associated with dialysis modes, such as the iron deficiency, severe hyperparathyroidism, vitamin deficiency, aluminum toxicity, inflammation, as well as inadequate dialysis., However, little evidence has been made with regard to the contribution of inflammation to RA observed in different dialysis patients. Inflammatory stimuli will cause the release of several cytokines and results in a series of systemic changes. The serum albumin, hemoglobin, ferritin, and transferrin saturation index were reported to be involved in the presence of inflammation. In secondary hyperparathyroidism of CKD patients, the high level of parathyroid hormone is suggested to be of multiple biological effects, including a negative influence on the RA patients.,

The most common treatment modalities for CKD are HD (hemodialysis) and PD (peritoneal dialysis). However, the function and outcomes between these two dialysis techniques are controversial. A recent clinical study has demonstrated that the serum albumin could predict the mortality of both PD and HD patients while the mortality was different in different dialysis modalities., However, the most recent cohort studies suggested that patients treated with either PD or HD in end-stage renal disease showed remarkably similar outcomes.,

Therefore, in the present work, we performed a meta-analysis to compare the effect of PD and HD on RA in patients with renal disease. The data of hemoglobin, ferritin, transferrin saturation index, serum albumin, and parathyroid hormone indexes between HD and PD groups were pooled respectively. Our study aimed at finding the effect of dialysis modalities on RA and provide a basis for clinical application.

Materials and methods

Search strategy

Related clinical studies about the effect of PD and HD on RA were systematically searched from Pubmed (http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed) and Embase (http://www.embase.com) databases, with the retrieval deadline of June 2015. Keywords for all searches were (“renal anemia” or “renal anemia” or “anemia of renal failure”) in combination with (“hemodialysis” or “hemodialysis”) and (“peritoneal dialysis”).

Inclusion and exclusion criteria

Studies included in this meta-analysis should meet the following criteria: (1) they reported clinical research about the effects of PD and HD on RA; (2) the number of patients in both PD and HD groups should be provided; (3) at least one of the following indexes should be provided, including hemoglobin (g/dL), ferritin (ng/mL), transferrin saturation index (%), serum albumin (g/dL), and parathyroid hormone.

Studies should be excluded if they (1) were reviews, reports, letters, and comments; (2) had not available data to be extracted.

Data extraction and quality evaluation

Wan-ning Wang and Wen-long Zhang reviewed and screened the articles, respectively based on the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Afterward, information about the publications and the patients from the included studies were extracted, including the first author’s name, year of publication, country, demographic information of patients in both PD and HD groups (age, gender, weight/BMI, time on dialysis, and the levels of hemoglobin, ferritin, transferrin saturation index, serum albumin, and parathyroid hormone). Any discrepancies during data extraction were resolved by discussion with Tao Sun.

The quality assessment of included trials was conducted by Wan-ning Wang and Wen-long Zhang independently according to the evaluation criterion tool proposed by AHRQ (Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality). Any disagreement was resolved by inviting Zhong-gao Xu for discussion. The tool evaluates the study quality through eleven items, each of which was responded with “yes” or “no” or “not clear”.

Statistical analysis

Meta-analysis was conducted by the R 3.12 software (R Foundation for Statistical Computing, Vienna, Austria). The effect size was assessed by standardized mean difference (SMD) and 95% confidence interval (CI). A random-effects model was used for heterogeneous outcomes (p < .05 and I2 > 50%), and a fixed-effect model was used for the homogeneous outcomes (p > .05 and I2 < 50%). Publication bias was evaluated by Egger’s test. Finally, the sensitivity analysis was also conducted to calculate the results by omitting one study at one time to measure its effect on the pooled SMD.

Results

Trail flow

The flow chart of the literature search and study selection was presented in Figure 1. A total of 1636 potentially relevant studies were searched from PubMed (n = 1020) and Embase (n = 616). Afterward, 528 duplicates and 987 obvious irrelevant articles were removed. After title and abstract evaluation, 41 were excluded because they were letters (n = 8), case series (n = 7), and literature reviews (n = 26). The left 80 publications underwent further review while 66 of them (23 were unable to be data-extracted and 43 were not reported RA disease) were removed. Finally, a total of fourteen studies were included in this meta-analysis.

Figure 1.

Literature search and study selection.

Characteristics of included studies

The characteristics of the fourteen studies and basic information of the subjects were listed in Table 1. These studies distributed from Europe (Spain, UK, Portugal, Ireland, and Germany), Africa (South Africa), America (Canada and USA) and Asia (Turkey and Kuwait) were published from 1991 to 2014. Among them, 11 studies reported the comparison of hemoglobin between HD and PD, ten reported the comparison of ferritin between HD and PD, eight reported the transferrin saturation index in both HD and PD groups, nine reported the serum albumin in both HD and PD groups, and six studies reported the parathyroid hormone in both HD and PD groups. A total of 1103 cases underwent HD and 625 cases underwent PD were used for this meta-analysis. There were more males than females in these patients. There was no significant difference in weight or BMI between the patients who underwent HD and PD.

Table 1.

Characteristics of 14 included studies in this meta-analysis.

Author	Year	Study location	Type	N	Gender (M/F)	Age (years)	Weight (kg)/BMI	Time on dialysis	Hemoglobin (g/dL)	Ferritin (ng/mL)	Transferrin saturation index (%)	Serum albumin (g/dL)	Parathyroid hormone	Study types
F. Coronel	2003	Spain	HD	69	40/29	65 ± 15	NA	64 ± 69 m	11.6 ± 1.3	338 ± 167	23.1 ± 7.7	4.1 ± 0.3	412 ± 438 pg/mL	A comparative multicenter study
			PD	63	32/31	56 ± 15	NA	26 ± 26 m	11.4 ± 1.4	218 ± 214	26.2 ± 10.8	3.7 ± 0.4	272 ± 290 pg/mL
G.K. Sakkas	2004	UK	HD	12	10/2	62 (35–76)	75 (60–90)	47 (6–192) m	11.3 ± 0.9	NA	NA	3.9 ± 0.4	8.4 ± 10 pmol/L	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD*	12	7/5	55 (37–70)	79 (51–105)	47 (7–196) m	12.6 ± 1.3	NA	NA	3.9 ± 0.5	22 ± 20 pmol/L
M.R. Fructuoso	2011	Portugal	HD	37	21/16	67.3 ± 14.9	NA	6.1 ± 6.5 y	11.9 ± 1.2	NA	NA	3.36 ± 0.44	NA	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD	14	8/6	38.9 ± 13.3	NA	1.9 ± 1.3 y	11.5 ± 1.8	NA	NA	3.35 ± 0.33	NA
A. Vega	2014	Ireland	HD	176	NA	66 ± 15	26.3 ± 5.5	NA	NA	165.0 ± 55.2	34 ± 9.8	4.0 ± 0.5	NA	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD	42	NA	58 ± 17	26.1 ± 3.9	NA	NA	204.2 ± 78.9	36 ± 10.1	3.8 ± 0.4	NA
I.G. Okpechi	2013	South Africa	HD	56	26/30	38.6 ± 1.4	NA	49.8 ± 71.5m	8.5 ± 0.3	549.4 ± 54.3	24.7 ± 1.4	3.97 ± 0.09	52.1 ± 7.3 pmol/L	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD	26	17/9	36.0 ± 2.2	NA	14.5 ± 11.6m	8.2 ± 0.4	457.8 ± 81.6	21.2 ± 1.2	3.87 ± 0.10	80.6 ± 18.1 pmol/L
A. Yavuz	2004	Turkey	HD	38	21/17	50 ± 19	63 ± 19	27 ± 32 m	9.9 ± 1.4	404 ± 243	30 ± 11	NA	170.8 ± 180.1 pg/mL	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD*	40	19/21	50 ± 13	70 ± 13	34.6 ± 30.5m	10.8 ± 1.6	376.0 ± 336.7	40.8 ± 18.7	NA	275.9 ± 183.0 pg/mL
A.A. House	1998	Canada	HD	157	93/64	57.22 ± 1.46	NA	14.21 ± 0.68 m	10.47 ± 0.12	258.7 ± 42.66	28.5 ± 1.12	3.92 ± 0.04	282.8 ± 29.2 pg/mL	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD	126	72/54	57.46 ± 1.51	NA	15.27 ± 0.69 m	10.71 ± 0.14	253.8 ± 56.75	28.1 ± 1.02	3.44 ± 0.06	187.4 ± 19.3 pg/mL
J. Gunnell	1999	USA	HD	92	54/38	53 ± 18	NA	3.7 ± 3.0 y	NA	78 (44–149)	22.4 (17.1–28.2)	3.8 (3.5–4.0)	NA	Case-control study
			PD	36	20/16	51 ± 17	NA	4.4 ± 4.1 y	NA	173 (88–334)	25.6 (21.0–34.2	3.8 (3.5–4.2)	NA
M.A. Góes	2010	USA	HD	29	19/10	47 ± 14	23.5 ± 3.20	NA	NA	406 ± 209	32 ± 12	NA	NA	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD	29	12/17	54 ± 14	27.7 ± 7.40	NA	NA	364 ± 214	37 ± 17	NA	NA
Z. Aydin	2014	Turkey	HD	20	8/12	49.8 ± 12.0	23.6 ± 4.1	NA	11.7 ± 1.2	769 ± 389	24.7 ± 9.7	4.1 ± 0.4	NA	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD	21	14/7	47.7 ± 12.1	28.4 ± 7.7	NA	10.7 ± 1.7	269 ± 135	29.4 ± 14.8	3.6 ± 0.3	NA
J.J. Fadrowski	2004	USA	HD	33	17/16	16.5 ± 1.7	NA	NA	11.1 ± 1.4	NA	NA	NA	NA	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD	66	37/29	10.7 ± 5.6	NA	NA	11.3 ± 1.4	NA	NA	NA	NA
N. Al-Hilali	2005	Kuwait	HD	83	30/53	51.5 ± 15.2	NA	32.1 ± 2.4	11 (10.30–11.8)	130 (71–236)	NA	3.2 (3.0–3.4)	33 (17.9–64.0) pg/mL	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD*	35	20/15	55.8 ± 13.3	NA	19.2 ± 2.1	11 (10.1–12.0)	194 (123– 279)	NA	2.8 (2.3–3.3)	24 (8.5–53.4) pg/mL
U. Frei	2009	Germany	HD	288	175/113	60.7 ± 15.6	NA	12-24 w	11.2 ± 1.1	NA	NA	NA	NA	Multicentre, open-label uncontrolled study
			PD	91	45/46	52.4 ± 14.0	NA	12-24 w	11.6 ± 1.1	NA	NA	NA	NA
A. Férnandez	1991	Spain	HD	13	NA	44.23 ± 15.36	NA	52.46 ± 42.32m	8.76 ± 1.99	436.59 ± 528.53	NA	NA	NA	Cross-sectional observational study
			PD*	24	NA	51.81 ± 13.87	NA	36.63 ± 25.73m	9.61 ± 1.84	459.32 ± 557.75	NA	NA	NA

HD: hemodialysis; PD: peritoneal dialysis; m: months; *: continuous ambulatory peritoneal dialysis; BMI: body mass index; PTH: parathyroid hormone; M: male; F: female; y: years; w: weeks; NA: not applicable.

Quality evaluation

As shown in Supplementary Table 1, the quality of all the studies was relatively high. Almost all the included studies described more than four items according to AHRQ.

Meta-analysis

Comparison of hemoglobin, ferritin, transferrin saturation index, serum albumin, and parathyroid hormone indexes between HD and PD groups were shown in Figure 2(a)–(e).

Figure 2.

Forest plot. (a) Forest plot for the comparison of hemoglobin between HD and PD groups. (b) Forest plot for the comparison of ferritin between HD and PD groups. (c) Forest plot for the comparison of transferrin saturation index between HD and PD groups. (d) Forest plot for the comparison of serum albumin between HD and PD groups. (e) Forest plot for the comparison of parathyroid hormone between HD and PD groups.

There were eleven studies reported the content of hemoglobin between the HD and PD groups (Figure 2(a)). The random-effect model was used to evaluate the effect because a significant heterogeneity existed among these studies (I2 = 93.9%, p < .0001). Meta-analysis showed no significant difference in the hemoglobin content between patients suffered from HD and PD (SMD = −0.23, 95% CI: −0.74 to 0.28).

Totally ten studies reported the comparison of ferritin between HD and PD (Figure 2(b)). There was significant heterogeneity among these studies (I2 = 95.2%, p < .0001), therefore, the random-effect model was used to evaluate the effect size. No significant difference of ferritin was found between the HD and PD groups (SMD = 0.01, 95% CI: −0.59 to 0.62).

Eight publications reported the transferrin saturation index in both HD and PD groups (Figure 2(c)). As well, significant heterogeneity was detected (I2 = 94.7%, p < .0001) and the random-effect model was used for meta-analysis. As a result, the transferrin saturation index in both HD and PD groups showed no significant difference (SMD = −0.06, 95% CI: −0.67 to 0.56).

With regard to the serum albumin, nine studies were included in the meta-analysis (Figure 2(d)). The random-effect model was chosen because of the high heterogeneity (I2 = 98.3%, p < .0001). The content of serum albumin in HD group was much more than that in PD group (SMD = 1.58, 95% CI: 0.35 to 2.81), indicating that the HD dialysis may be superior to PD dialysis.

There were six studies reported the compassion of parathyroid hormone in HD and PD groups (Figure 2(e)). High heterogeneity was found among these studies (I2 = 98.7%, p < .0001). Therefore, the random-effect model was used to evaluate the effect. However, no significant difference was found for parathyroid hormone between the two dialysis strategies (SMD = 0.11, 95% CI: −1.53 to 1.75).

Sensitivity analysis and publication bias

In order to evaluate the effect of each study on the pooled SMD value, the sensitivity analysis was performed (Figure 3). Neither of the included studies could reverse the pooled side effect in each meta-analysis of the five indexes, indicating the stable results of our meta-analysis.

Figure 3.

Sensitivity analysis of the included studies. (a) hemoglobin; (b) ferritin; (c) transferrin saturation index; (d) serum albumin; (e) parathyroid hormone.

The results of the Egger’s test were presented in Supplementary Table 2. The studies included in all the meta-analyses demonstrated no publication bias, suggesting that our results were reliable.

Discussion

Recently, both PD and HD are the most comment methods for clinical treatment of nephropathy. RA is one of the most common complications of CKD that mainly caused by nephropathy. In the present study, we evaluated the effect of PD and HD on RA, and the results demonstrated that there was no significant difference in hemoglobin, ferritin, transferrin saturation index, and parathyroid hormone between HD and PD groups. However, the content of serum albumin in HD group was much more than that in PD group.

During dialysis, several factors were recognized to be associated with postoperative outcomes of RA patients, such as hemoglobin, ferritin, transferrin saturation index, and parathyroid hormone. ESAs are recommended to correct RA, as maintenance of hemoglobin within a suitable range can play an important role in patients outcomes. However, the issue remains controversial, because recent prospective randomized trials have suggested that maintaining hemoglobin to normal or near normal levels in CKD patients dose not confer any survival benefit., In our study, the hemoglobin levels showed no significant difference in both PD and HD groups, indicating that the impact of hemoglobin variability may produce a similar clinical outcome between patients treated with PD and HD. One of the factors involved in dialysis is the blood loss, which makes patients prone to develop iron deficiency. However, there was no statically significant difference for ferritin and transferrin saturation index between PD and HD groups, which suggested that these two dialysis methods might present similar results for iron supply in patients with RA. The role of parathyroid hormone as a uremic toxin on erythropoiesis has been discussed in several studies. It was reported that high levels of serum parathyroid hormone are involved in decreasing survival of red blood cells and their progenitor number. Middle-molecular-weight solutes were suggested to be responsible for the toxic effect of red blood cells. Previous evidence has proved that ambulatory PD is more efficient in eliminating middle-molecular-weight substances and results in less anemia than HD. However, a recent study indicated that no significant difference was found in red blood cell survival between HD and PD. In our study, there was no significant difference in parathyroid hormone levels between HD and PD dialysis strategies, thus, the beneficial effect of PD and HD on anemia may be related to elevated erythropoiesis other than improved red blood cells survival.

Severe RA tended to be associated with manifestations of fluid overload and other risk factors. In our study, the content of serum albumin in HD group was much more than that in PD group, which may in part be explained by fluid overload resulting in dilution of albumin in PD group. Besides, the PD itself, using peritoneum as the semipermeable membrane, can lead to albumin loss. The serum proteins in PD patients averages 5 g per 24 h, of which, 4 g is albumin. However, we cannot get the conclusion from the serum albumin level in the two-dialysis ways that HD was more efficient than PD in the treatment of RA. For one thing, we did not know if the difference in serum albumin level causes by ESAs treatment or dialysis strategies. For the other, it is unclear that if the reduced serum albumin level in PD group leads to anemia-related inflammatory conditions. Therefore, the association between albumin and dialysis strategies needs further clinical studies to clarify.

In our meta-analysis, high levels of heterogeneity were detected in hemoglobin, ferritin, transferrin saturation index, parathyroid hormone, and albumin between HD and PD groups, thus, the random-effected model was used for effect size. The reason for the high heterogeneity may be explained by different detection methods of these indexes, ethnic and lifestyle differences. Other confounding factors such as gender and age may also contribute to the heterogeneity. In order to detect if the time span or changing guidelines the hemoglobin targets, we performed a cumulative meta-analysis, and the results showed that during 1991 and 2014, the results were not changed significantly. Therefore, neither the time span nor the changing guidelines attributed to the heterogeneity of this study.

Our meta-analysis is the first one to evaluate the effect of PD and HD on RA. Both the sensitivity analysis and the publication bias analysis suggested that our results were stable and reliable. However, several limitations should be pointed out in this study. Firstly, there were significant heterogeneities across the included studies in the meta-analysis of the five indexes. As discussed above, the heterogeneities may associate with many factors. We did not perform the subgroup meta-analysis because of the inconsistency caused by unavailable or incomplete data of some studies. For instance, the treatment of ESAs should be considered as an important factor that is associated with the five indexes analyzed in our study. However, some of the included patients received ESAs before dialysis, and others were not., So the effects ESAs were not analyzed in our study. Besides, we did not correct the concomitant variables such as age, gender and other confounding factors that may affect the results of this analysis. Therefore, it is necessary to develop more studies with larger sample size to assess the commonality of our results.

In conclusion, in our study, though the albumin in HD group was much more than in PD group, the hemoglobin, ferritin, transferrin saturation index, and parathyroid hormone were similar in the two groups. These results suggest that both of the two-dialysis strategies have a similar effect on RA in patients with renal diseases.