INTRODUCTION AND HYPOTHESIS: The Goh Vesico-Vaginal Fistula (VVF) classification has prognostic value in VVF in the developing world (predominantly obstetric), with chances of successful closure decreasing from type 1 to type 4. We evaluated the prognostic value of the Goh classification for VVF of the developed world (predominantly iatrogenic). METHODS: A retrospective review was performed of 63 consecutive patients with a mean age of 53 years (range 21-88) undergoing VVF repair under a single surgeon between 2006 and 2014. Demographic data, aetiology, operative data and final outcome (anatomical and functional) were recorded. Fistulae were classified according to Goh's system and outcomes correlated with this classification. RESULTS: Successful closure at first repair was achieved in 90 % of type 1, 83 % of type 2, 100 % of type 3 and 100 % of type 4 fistulae. At second repair success was achieved in 100 % of all fistulae, irrespective of type. Continence post-anatomical closure was achieved in 100 % of type 1, 83 % of type 2, 83 % of type 3 and 75 % of type 4 fistulae. Fistula size and patient age were significant determinants of successful outcome. CONCLUSION: Anatomical closure was obtained in 90 % of VVF of the developed world at first attempt, 100 % overall, and was not affected by the Goh classification. Continence post-anatomical closure of VVF was 94 % overall and deteriorated with increasing Goh classification type. The Goh classification has no prognostic value regarding anatomical closure in VVF of the developed world, but may be useful in determining the risk of post-anatomical closure urinary incontinence. Smaller fistula size and younger patient age are significant determinants of success.
INTRODUCTION AND HYPOTHESIS: The Goh Vesico-Vaginal Fistula (VVF) classification has prognostic value in VVF in the developing world (predominantly obstetric), with chances of successful closure decreasing from type 1 to type 4. We evaluated the prognostic value of the Goh classification for VVF of the developed world (predominantly iatrogenic). METHODS: A retrospective review was performed of 63 consecutive patients with a mean age of 53 years (range 21-88) undergoing VVF repair under a single surgeon between 2006 and 2014. Demographic data, aetiology, operative data and final outcome (anatomical and functional) were recorded. Fistulae were classified according to Goh's system and outcomes correlated with this classification. RESULTS: Successful closure at first repair was achieved in 90 % of type 1, 83 % of type 2, 100 % of type 3 and 100 % of type 4 fistulae. At second repair success was achieved in 100 % of all fistulae, irrespective of type. Continence post-anatomical closure was achieved in 100 % of type 1, 83 % of type 2, 83 % of type 3 and 75 % of type 4 fistulae. Fistula size and patient age were significant determinants of successful outcome. CONCLUSION: Anatomical closure was obtained in 90 % of VVF of the developed world at first attempt, 100 % overall, and was not affected by the Goh classification. Continence post-anatomical closure of VVF was 94 % overall and deteriorated with increasing Goh classification type. The Goh classification has no prognostic value regarding anatomical closure in VVF of the developed world, but may be useful in determining the risk of post-anatomical closure urinary incontinence. Smaller fistula size and younger patient age are significant determinants of success.
Authors: Nadir I Osman; Christopher J Hillary; Aziz Gulamhusein; Alison Downey; Richard D Inman; Christopher R Chapple Journal: Eur Urol Open Sci Date: 2021-07-31