| Literature DB >> 27785424 |
Phillip Marks1, Armin Soave1, Shahrokh F Shariat2, Harun Fajkovic2, Margit Fisch1, Michael Rink1.
Abstract
While men are at a considerable higher risk of developing urothelial carcinoma of the bladder (UCB), women present with more advanced disease stages and seem to experience unfavorable outcomes. Evaluating specific differences in the UCB incidence and outcomes between both genders in the non-muscle invasive, muscle-invasive or locally advanced and metastatic setting, as well as determining the underlying causes of disease, may allow optimizing treatment and improving the quality of urological care among both genders. In this review we summarize the best evidence and most recent findings on gender-specific differences in UCB incidence and outcomes. In addition, we present a comprehensive overview on established and potential reasons for differences in gender-specific UCB outcomes, including disparities in the pelvic anatomy, the diagnostic work-up, the modality and quality of treatment, the exposure to risk factors, the degradation of carcinogens as well as the sex-hormone signaling.Entities:
Keywords: Urothelial carcinoma of the bladder (UCB); chemotherapy; gender; outcome; sex; steroid hormones; surgery; survival; therapy; urinary bladder neoplasms
Year: 2016 PMID: 27785424 PMCID: PMC5071204 DOI: 10.21037/tau.2016.03.22
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Transl Androl Urol ISSN: 2223-4683
Selected studies on gender-specific outcomes of bladder cancer patients treated with bladder preserving therapy
| Study | Cohort [patients (%)] | Period of treatment | Pathologic tumor stage [patients (%)] | Treatment | Intravesical instillation therapy [patients (%)] | Follow up (months) | Disease recurrence | Disease progression | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fernandez-Gomez | n=1,062: 706 (66.5) with primary NMIBC, and 356 (33.5) with recurrent NMIBC; | 1990–1999 | pTa: 214 (20.2); | Primary TURB (all patients) | BCG induction (all patients) | 69 (median) | UVA (f | UVA (f | Negative impact of female gender on disease recurrence; no impact of gender on disease progression |
| Boorjian | n=1,021: with primary or recurrent NMIBC; | 1978–2006 | pTa: 612 (59.9) [f: 166 (62.6), m: 446 (59.0)]; | Re-TURB (all patients) | BCG induction (all patients) | ≥60 | MVA (m | MVA (m | No impact of female gender on disease recurrence and disease progression |
| Palou | n=146: with primary NMIBC; | 1985–1996 | pT1: 146 (100.0) plus concomitant; | TURB (all patients) | BCG induction (all patients) | 104 (median) | UVA (f | UVA (f | Negative impact of female gender on disease recurrence; no impact of female gender on disease progression |
| Chamie | n=7,410: with primary or recurrent NMIBC; | 1992–2002 | pTa: 2,398 (32.3); | NS | NS | ≥60 | MVA (f | MVA (f | Negative impact of female gender on disease progression; no impact of female gender on disease recurrence |
| Kluth | n=916: with primary NMIBC; | 1996–2007 | pT1: 916 (100.0) plus concomitant; | TURB | Single dose of MMC postoperatively: | 43 (median) | MVA (f | MVA (f | Negative impact of female gender on disease recurrence; no impact of female gender on disease progression |
| Gontero | n=2,451: 2,181 (89.0) with primary NMIBC and 270 (11.0) with recurrent NMIBC; | 1990–2011 | pT1: 2451 (100.0) plus concomitant; | TURB (all patients); | BCG induction (all patients) | 62 (median) | UVA (f | UVA (f | No impact of female gender on disease recurrence and disease progression |
NMIBC, non-muscle invasive bladder cancer; f, female; m, male; NS, not stated; BCG, Bacillus Calmette-Guérin; UVA, univariable analysis; HR, hazard ratio; MVA, multivariable analysis; Re-TURB: repeat transurethral resection of the bladder; TURB, transurethral resection of the bladder; MMC, mitomycin.
Selected studies on gender-specific outcomes of bladder cancer patients treated with radical cystectomy
| Study | Cohort [patients (%)] | Period of treatment | Pathologic tumor stage and nodal status [patients (%)] | Adjuvant treatment [patients (%)] | Follow-up (months) | Outcome | Conclusion |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Tilki | n=583 [f: 94 (16.1), m: 488 (83.7)] | 1979–2008 | pT4: 583 (100.0); pN+: 312 (53.5); | CT: 240 (41.2); | 55 (median) | MVA (f | Negative impact of female gender on cancer-specific mortality and disease recurrence |
| Tilki | n=243 [f: 50 (20.6), m: 193 (79.4%)] | 1979–2008 | pTis: 243 (100.0); pN+: 22 (5.8); | NS | 38 (median) | MVA (f | Negative impact of female gender on cancer-specific mortality; no impact of female gender on disease recurrence |
| May | n=521 [f: 133 (25.5), m: 388 (74.5)] | 1992–2007 | pT≤2: 216 (41.5) [f: 57 (42.9), m: 159 (41.0)]; | CT: 88 (16.9) [f: 19 (14.3), m: 69 (17.8)] | 59 (median) | MVA (f | Negative impact of female gender on cancer-specific mortality |
| Otto | n=2,483 [f: 507 (20.4), m: 1,976 (79.6)] | 1989–2008 | pT≤1: 708 (28.5) [f: 125 (24.7), m: 583 (29.5)]; | CT: 345 (13.9) [f: 65 (12.8), m: 280 (14.2)] | 42 (median) | MVA (f | Negative impact of female gender on cancer-specific mortality |
| Kluth | n=8,102 [f: 1,605 (20.0), m: 6,497 (80.0)] | 1971–2012 | pT0: 448 (5.5) [f: 85 (5.3), m: 363 (5.6)]; | CT: 1,654 (20.4) [f: 330 (21.0), m: 1,324 (20.0)] | 41 (median) | MVA (f | Negative impact of female gender on cancer-specific mortality; no independent impact of female gender on disease recurrence |
| Kaushik | n=128 [f: 37 (28.9), m: 91 (71.1)] | 1980–2005 | pT4: 128; pN+: 53 (42.4) [f: 9 (25.0), m: 44 (49.4)] | CT*: 37 (28.9) [f: 7 (18.9), m: 30 (33.0)] | 126 (median) | MVA (m | No impact of female gender on all-cause mortality and cancer-specific mortality |
| Soave | n=517 [f: 119 (23.0), m: 398 (77.0)] | 1996–2010 | pT0: 51 (9.9) [f: 12 (10.1), m: 39 (9.8)]; | CT: 91 (17.6) [f: 31 (26.1), m: 60 (15.1)] | 44 (median) | MVA (f | No impact of female gender on disease recurrence and cancer-specific mortality |
| Messer | n=4,216 [f: 890 (21.2), m: 3,326 (78.8)] | 1979–2008 | pT≤1: 1,321 (31.3) [f: 256 (28.9), m: 1,064 (32.1)]; | CT: 993 (23.6) [f: 194 (21.8), m: 799 (24.0)] | 32 (median) | MVA (f | Negative impact of female gender on disease recurrence and cancer-specific mortality |
| Mitra | n=828 [f: 414 (50.0), m: 414 (50.0)] | 1971–2009 | pT0,a,is: 172 (20.8) [f: 86 (20.8), m: 86 (20.8)]; | CT: 165 (19.9) [f: 82 (49.7), m: 83 (50.3)] | f: 146, m:103 (median) | MVA (f | No impact of female gender on disease recurrence and cancer-specific mortality |
*, neoadjuvant plus adjuvant chemotherapy. f, female; m, male; NS, not stated; CT, chemotherapy; RT, radiotherapy; MVA, multivariable analysis; HR, hazard ratio.