Tommi L Gaines1, Daniel Werb1,2, Jaime Arredondo1, Victor M Alaniz3, Carlos Vilalta4, Leo Beletsky1,5. 1. a Division of Global Public Health , University of California at San Diego , San Diego , California , USA. 2. b International Centre for Science in Drug Policy, St. Michael's Hospital , Toronto , Canada. 3. c Tijuana Police Department , Tijuana , Mexico. 4. d Centro de Investigacion y Docencia Economica , Mexico City , Mexico. 5. e School of Law and Bouvé College of Health Sciences, Northeastern University , Boston , Massachusetts , USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: In 2009, Mexico enacted a drug policy reform (Narcomenudeo) designed to divert persons possessing small amounts of illicit drugs to treatment rather than incarceration. To assess reform impact, this study examines the spatial-temporal trends of drug-related policing in Tijuana, Mexico post-enactment. METHOD: Location of self-reported arrests (N = 1,160) among a prospective, community-recruited cohort of people who inject drugs (PWID) in Tijuana (N = 552) was mapped across city neighborhoods. Official police reports detailing drug-related arrests was triangulated with PWID self-reported arrests. Exploratory spatial data analysis examined the distribution of arrests and spatial association between both datasets across three successive years, 2011-2013. RESULTS: In 2011, over half of PWID reported being detained but not officially charged with a criminal offense; in 2013, 90% of arrests led to criminal charges. Official drug-related arrests increased by 67.8% (p <.01) from 2011 to 2013 despite overall arrest rates remaining stable throughout Tijuana. For each successive year, we identified a high degree of spatial association between the location of self-reported and official arrests (p <.05). CONCLUSION: Two independent data sources suggest that intensity of drug law enforcement had risen in Tijuana despite the promulgation of a public health-oriented drug policy reform. The highest concentrations of arrests were in areas traditionally characterized by higher rates of drug crime. High correlation between self-reported and official arrest data underscores opportunities for future research on the role of policing as a structural determinant of public health.
BACKGROUND: In 2009, Mexico enacted a drug policy reform (Narcomenudeo) designed to divert persons possessing small amounts of illicit drugs to treatment rather than incarceration. To assess reform impact, this study examines the spatial-temporal trends of drug-related policing in Tijuana, Mexico post-enactment. METHOD: Location of self-reported arrests (N = 1,160) among a prospective, community-recruited cohort of people who inject drugs (PWID) in Tijuana (N = 552) was mapped across city neighborhoods. Official police reports detailing drug-related arrests was triangulated with PWID self-reported arrests. Exploratory spatial data analysis examined the distribution of arrests and spatial association between both datasets across three successive years, 2011-2013. RESULTS: In 2011, over half of PWID reported being detained but not officially charged with a criminal offense; in 2013, 90% of arrests led to criminal charges. Official drug-related arrests increased by 67.8% (p <.01) from 2011 to 2013 despite overall arrest rates remaining stable throughout Tijuana. For each successive year, we identified a high degree of spatial association between the location of self-reported and official arrests (p <.05). CONCLUSION: Two independent data sources suggest that intensity of drug law enforcement had risen in Tijuana despite the promulgation of a public health-oriented drug policy reform. The highest concentrations of arrests were in areas traditionally characterized by higher rates of drug crime. High correlation between self-reported and official arrest data underscores opportunities for future research on the role of policing as a structural determinant of public health.
Entities:
Keywords:
Drug policy; Mexico; drug laws; police; spatial-temporal analysis
Authors: Dan Werb; Steffanie A Strathdee; Emilo Meza; Maria Gudelia Rangel Gomez; Lawrence Palinkas; Maria Elena Medina-Mora; Leo Beletsky Journal: Glob Public Health Date: 2015-12-13
Authors: Abby E Rudolph; Natalie D Crawford; Carl Latkin; Robert Heimer; Ebele O Benjamin; Kandice C Jones; Crystal M Fuller Journal: Ann Epidemiol Date: 2011-04 Impact factor: 3.797
Authors: Dan Werb; María Elena Medina Mora; Leo Beletsky; Claudia Rafful; Tim Mackey; Jaime Arredondo; Steffanie A Strathdee Journal: Int J Drug Policy Date: 2014-06-02
Authors: Tommi L Gaines; Leo Beletsky; Jaime Arredondo; Daniel Werb; Gudelia Rangel; Alicia Vera; Kimberly Brouwer Journal: J Urban Health Date: 2015-04 Impact factor: 3.671
Authors: Steffanie A Strathdee; Remedios Lozada; Gustavo Martinez; Alicia Vera; Melanie Rusch; Lucie Nguyen; Robin A Pollini; Felipe Uribe-Salas; Leo Beletsky; Thomas L Patterson Journal: PLoS One Date: 2011-04-25 Impact factor: 3.240
Authors: Theodore M Hammett; Son Phan; Julia Gaggin; Patricia Case; Nicholas Zaller; Alexandra Lutnick; Alex H Kral; Ekaterina V Fedorova; Robert Heimer; Will Small; Robin Pollini; Leo Beletsky; Carl Latkin; Don C Des Jarlais Journal: BMC Health Serv Res Date: 2014-06-17 Impact factor: 2.655
Authors: Steffanie A Strathdee; Jaime Arredondo; Teresita Rocha; Daniela Abramovitz; Maria Luisa Rolon; Efrain Patiño Mandujano; Maria Gudelia Rangel; Horcasitas Omar Olivarria; Tommi Gaines; Thomas L Patterson; Leo Beletsky Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2015-08-10 Impact factor: 2.692
Authors: David Goodman-Meza; Maria Elena Medina-Mora; Carlos Magis-Rodríguez; Raphael J Landovitz; Steve Shoptaw; Dan Werb Journal: Am J Public Health Date: 2018-11-29 Impact factor: 9.308
Authors: Javier A Cepeda; Steffanie A Strathdee; Jaime Arredondo; Maria L Mittal; Teresita Rocha; Mario Morales; Erika Clairgue; Eliane Bustamante; Daniela Abramovitz; Irina Artamonova; Arnulfo Bañuelos; Thomas Kerr; Carlos L Magis-Rodriguez; Leo Beletsky Journal: Int J Drug Policy Date: 2017-12
Authors: Mario Morales; Claudia Rafful; Tommi L Gaines; Javier A Cepeda; Daniela Abramovitz; Irina Artamonova; Pieter Baker; Erika Clairgue; Maria Luisa Mittal; Teresita Rocha-Jimenez; Jaime Arredondo; Thomas Kerr; Arnulfo Bañuelos; Steffanie A Strathdee; Leo Beletsky Journal: BMC Int Health Hum Rights Date: 2018-09-15
Authors: Mario Morales; Claudia Rafful; Pieter Baker; Jaime Arredondo; Sunyou Kang; Maria L Mittal; Teresita Rocha-Jiménez; Steffanie A Strathdee; Leo Beletsky Journal: Health Justice Date: 2020-04-29
Authors: Carlos D Rivera Saldana; Leo Beletsky; Annick Borquez; Susan M Kiene; Steffanie A Strathdee; María Luisa Zúñiga; Natasha K Martin; Javier Cepeda Journal: Addiction Date: 2021-03-03 Impact factor: 7.256