R Scott Johnson1, Andrea G Stolar1, James F McGuire1, Krithika Mittakanti1, Sean Clark1, Loretta A Coonan1, David P Graham1. 1. When this work was done, Dr. Johnson was with the Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School and Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston (e-mail: rscottjohnson3@gmail.com ). Dr. Stolar and Dr. Mittakanti are with the Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Baylor College of Medicine, Houston. When this work was done, Dr. McGuire was with the Veterans Justice Program, Veterans Health Administration, Washington, D.C. Mr. Clark is with Veterans Justice Outreach, Lexington, Kentucky. Ms. Coonan and Dr. Graham are with the Mental Health Care Line, Michael E. DeBakey Veterans Affairs Medical Center, Houston.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Significant variability exists regarding the criteria and procedures used by different veterans' courts (VCs) across the country. Limited guidance is available regarding which VC model has the most successful outcomes. The purpose of this study was to examine factors associated with incarceration during VC participation. METHODS: This study used data for 1,224 veterans collected from the HOMES (Homeless Operations Management and Evaluation System) database of the Department of Veterans Affairs, as well as data from a national phone survey inventory of all U.S. VCs. To identify variables associated with incarceration during VC participation, four backward conditional logistic regressions were performed. RESULTS: The following variables were associated with higher rates of incarceration because of a veteran's noncompletion of the VC program: charges of probation or parole violations, longer stays in the VC program, end of VC participation because of incarceration for a new arrest or case transfer by the legal system, and requiring mental health follow-up but not undergoing treatment. The following variables were associated with lower rates of incarceration: stable housing and participating in a VC program that referred veterans for substance abuse treatment. CONCLUSIONS: This study offers VCs a thorough review of an extensive set of recidivism data. Further investigation is necessary to understand the impact of VCs.
OBJECTIVE: Significant variability exists regarding the criteria and procedures used by different veterans' courts (VCs) across the country. Limited guidance is available regarding which VC model has the most successful outcomes. The purpose of this study was to examine factors associated with incarceration during VC participation. METHODS: This study used data for 1,224 veterans collected from the HOMES (Homeless Operations Management and Evaluation System) database of the Department of Veterans Affairs, as well as data from a national phone survey inventory of all U.S. VCs. To identify variables associated with incarceration during VC participation, four backward conditional logistic regressions were performed. RESULTS: The following variables were associated with higher rates of incarceration because of a veteran's noncompletion of the VC program: charges of probation or parole violations, longer stays in the VC program, end of VC participation because of incarceration for a new arrest or case transfer by the legal system, and requiring mental health follow-up but not undergoing treatment. The following variables were associated with lower rates of incarceration: stable housing and participating in a VC program that referred veterans for substance abuse treatment. CONCLUSIONS: This study offers VCs a thorough review of an extensive set of recidivism data. Further investigation is necessary to understand the impact of VCs.
Authors: Andrea K Finlay; Sean Clark; Jessica Blue-Howells; Sherri Claudio; Matthew Stimmel; Jack Tsai; Alec Buchanan; Joel Rosenthal; Alex H S Harris; Susan Frayne Journal: Drug Court Rev Date: 2019