| Literature DB >> 27729784 |
Makedonka Gulcev1, Cavan Reilly2, Timothy J Griffin3, Corey D Broeckling4, Brian J Sandri1, Bruce A Witthuhn3, Shane W Hodgson1, Prescott G Woodruff5, Chris H Wendt6.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: Exacerbations are a leading cause of morbidity in COPD. The objective of this study was to identify metabolomic biomarkers of acute exacerbations of COPD (AECOPD).Entities:
Keywords: Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease; metabolomics; tryptophan
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2016 PMID: 27729784 PMCID: PMC5047709 DOI: 10.2147/COPD.S107844
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Chron Obstruct Pulmon Dis ISSN: 1176-9106
Characteristics of case and control subjects
| Characteristics | Cases day 0 (N=33) | Cases day 30 (N=33) | Controls (N=65) | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Age, years | 62.03 (51–78) | – | 62.57 (50–81) | 0.1 |
| Sex: male | 18 (57%) | – | 38 (58%) | 1 |
| FEV1 percent predicted | 31.18 (14.9–75.2) | – | 34.49 (14.3–72.5) | 0.07 |
| Pack years | 47.92 (11–150) | – | 44.90 (14–144) | 0.23 |
| Beta agonist | 22 (0.67) | 23 (0.7) | 51 (0.78) | 0.42 |
| Methacholine antagonist | 15 (0.45) | 7 (0.21) | 21 (0.32) | 0.11 |
| LABA | 22 (0.67) | 24 (0.73) | 48 (0.74) | 0.77 |
| LAMA | 21 (0.64) | 18 (0.55) | 46 (0.71) | 0.28 |
| ICS | 23 (0.7) | 24 (0.73) | 48 (0.74) | 0.94 |
| Steroids | 13 (0.39) | 3 (0.09) | 0 (0) | <0.01 |
| Antibiotic | 17 (0.52) | 6 (0.18) | 0 (0) | <0.01 |
Notes: For continuous variables, the mean and the range are presented (the latter in parentheses) and for binary variables the count and the percent are provided (the latter in parentheses). The P-value tests the null hypothesis of no difference among the three groups and is obtained from a linear mixed-effects model for continuous variables and from a generalized linear mixed-effects model with logistic link for binary variables.
Abbreviations: LABA, long-acting beta-agonist; LAMA, long-acting methacholine antagonist; ICS, inhaled corticosteroid; FEV1, forced expiratory volume in 1 second.
Figure 1Venn diagram that depicts the number of analytes overlapping between the two comparison groups.
Figure 2Analyte expression.
Notes: 25/34 of the analytes identified at 5% FDR that were differentially expressed comparing day 0 and day 30. Top number is retention time and bottom number is m/z. X-axis: C = control, d0 = day 0, d30 = day 30. Y-axis: peak intensity.
Abbreviations: FDR, false discovery rate; m/z, mass/charge.
Figure 3Tryptophan and kynurenine expression.
Notes: No statistically significant differences in tryptophan levels. Kynurenine levels were significantly lower at day 0 compared to day 30 (P=0.00292).
Figure 4IDO activity as depicted by Kyn/Trp ratio.
Notes: Tryptophan and kynurenine levels were measured in plasma by SRM. Kyn/Trp values were significantly higher at day 0 compared to day 30 (P=0.0352) and higher at day 0 than in controls (P=0.0338).
Abbreviations: IDO, indoleamine 2,3-dioxygenase; SRM, selective reaction monitoring; Kyn/Trp, kynurenine/tryptophan.
Transitions for tryptophan and kynurenine
| Metabolite | Q1 | Q2 |
|---|---|---|
| Tryptophan | 204.892 | 188 |
| Tryptophan | 204.892 | 169.9 |
| Tryptophan | 204.892 | 158.96 |
| Tryptophan | 204.892 | 117.908 |
| Kynurenine | 208.92 | 191.904 |
| Kynurenine | 208.92 | 145.943 |
| Kynurenine | 208.92 | 135.957 |
| Kynurenine | 208.92 | 94.049 |
| Tryptophan 13C11 | 216 | 199 |
| Tryptophan 13C11 | 216 | 169 |
| Tryptophan 13C11 | 216 | 154 |
| Tryptophan 13C11 | 216 | 140.9 |
| Kynurenine D6 | 215 | 198 |
| Kynurenine D6 | 215 | 150.9 |
| Kynurenine D6 | 215 | 142 |
| Kynurenine D6 | 215 | 98.2 |
Note: Q1 and Q2, first and second mass analyzers.
Abbreviation: m/z, mass/charge.
Analytes differentially expressed comparing day 0 to day 30
| RT | Putative identification | |
|---|---|---|
| 0.4092 | 192.0339 | |
| 0.3653 | 227.1242 | |
| 1.5818 | 229.1532 | Peptide |
| 0.6904 | 229.1537 | Peptide |
| 0.6979 | 251.1345 | Peptide |
| 3.5796 | 285.6607 | |
| 1.0920 | 293.0517 | |
| 0.6929 | 319.1215 | |
| 1.0963 | 343.0335 | |
| 1.0904 | 395.0595 | |
| 1.0927 | 401.0747 | |
| 1.0978 | 411.0227 | |
| 2.2749 | 416.2397 | |
| 2.2383 | 436.2067 | Peptide |
| 2.2804 | 438.2229 | |
| 1.9731 | 440.2379 | |
| 0.3585 | 448.668 | |
| 1.6195 | 456.2284 | Peptide |
| 2.2801 | 479.2485 | Peptide |
| 6.5000 | 480.3403 | Lipid |
| 6.4761 | 482.3572 | Lipid |
| 6.5022 | 502.3207 | Peptide |
| 6.4766 | 504.3396 | |
| 5.2860 | 509.3309 | |
| 1.0933 | 531.0327 | |
| 13.1409 | 531.4049 | |
| 2.2757 | 541.2188 | Peptide |
| 13.1434 | 594.4145 | Lipid |
| 6.4827 | 606.3066 | Peptide |
| 1.6767 | 709.0683 | |
| 13.1658 | 940.523 |
Abbreviations: RT, retention time; m/z, mass/charge.
Analytes differentially expressed comparing day 0 to controls
| RT | Putative identification | |
|---|---|---|
| 1.8662 | 163.1318 | |
| 1.6614 | 171.0983 | |
| 1.86 | 185.1138 | |
| 1.5791 | 191.1498 | |
| 0.4092 | 192.0339 | |
| 0.3588 | 193.1538 | |
| 0.4057 | 198.0943 | |
| 3.0522 | 199.1797 | |
| 0.3585 | 203.0523 | |
| 0.5741 | 204.1223 | |
| 9.8983 | 208.0385 | |
| 1.6615 | 212.1249 | |
| 2.5382 | 213.1435 | |
| 0.3442 | 219.026 | |
| 3.0513 | 221.1605 | |
| 3.4716 | 223.0953 | |
| 1.8588 | 226.1407 | |
| 1.1927 | 229.1528 | |
| 1.5818 | 229.1532 | Peptide |
| 0.6904 | 229.1537 | Peptide |
| 1.0901 | 230.0336 | |
| 1.5848 | 240.1584 | |
| 13.7318 | 243.968 | |
| 0.3551 | 244.0788 | |
| 3.0993 | 244.1537 | |
| 3.4708 | 245.078 | |
| 1.0961 | 246.0052 | |
| 0.7777 | 246.0236 | |
| 1.6071 | 246.1656 | |
| 8.6263 | 247.1305 | Peptide |
| 3.0976 | 249.1076 | |
| 0.6979 | 251.1345 | Peptide |
| 1.5881 | 251.1353 | |
| 13.7623 | 251.3842 | |
| 1.0976 | 253.0267 | |
| 2.5361 | 254.1701 | |
| 1.6966 | 255.1202 | |
| 0.4398 | 256.0572 | |
| 1.6824 | 257.0866 | |
| 8.8146 | 259.6639 | |
| 0.3524 | 263.0841 | |
| 0.8497 | 267.0591 | |
| 3.8807 | 269.1376 | |
| 0.3485 | 271.0384 | |
| 1.6376 | 274.0912 | |
| 1.0971 | 276.0376 | |
| 0.3572 | 276.9842 | |
| 3.2302 | 281.1351 | |
| 5.1828 | 283.152 | |
| 6.6211 | 283.2227 | |
| 3.475 | 286.1041 | |
| 0.3485 | 287.0129 | |
| 1.0906 | 287.0312 | |
| 2.2739 | 289.1319 | |
| 3.0952 | 290.1338 | Peptide |
| 1.7269 | 292.0288 | |
| 1.6814 | 292.0944 | |
| 1.092 | 293.0517 | |
| 2.0077 | 295.1871 | |
| 1.6749 | 297.0732 | |
| 5.7355 | 300.1562 | Peptide |
| 6.6352 | 305.2672 | |
| 1.0892 | 309.0231 | |
| 2.2719 | 309.6462 | |
| 1.0864 | 315.036 | |
| 4.693 | 316.1872 | Peptide |
| 1.6716 | 319.0568 | |
| 0.6929 | 319.1215 | |
| 1.6643 | 319.2067 | |
| 3.2243 | 322.1631 | |
| 6.6409 | 322.2928 | |
| 7.4187 | 322.6846 | |
| 6.6068 | 324.2496 | |
| 6.6439 | 327.2493 | |
| 0.3577 | 330.7515 | |
| 7.4216 | 331.6843 | |
| 0.3551 | 332.7515 | |
| 1.0892 | 337.0185 | |
| 4.1134 | 338.2654 | Sphingosine |
| 0.6137 | 339.0849 | |
| 1.0963 | 343.0335 | |
| 3.5422 | 343.2918 | |
| 0.3486 | 344.9705 | |
| 7.4247 | 345.688 | |
| 1.6143 | 346.0417 | |
| 5.1858 | 346.1605 | Peptide |
| 1.1105 | 346.9641 | |
| 0.3591 | 349.1201 | Peptide |
| 6.6633 | 349.2919 | |
| 13.0941 | 352.2866 | |
| 3.8858 | 354.127 | Peptide |
| 0.3356 | 355.0009 | |
| 7.9032 | 355.2823 | |
| 2.269 | 357.2031 | Lipid |
| 8.8104 | 357.2973 | |
| 1.5944 | 363.05 | |
| 3.5481 | 365.2758 | |
| 6.6604 | 366.3192 | |
| 1.72 | 367.9704 | |
| 0.3604 | 371.1011 | |
| 6.6651 | 371.2745 | |
| 4.726 | 371.3242 | |
| 13.1143 | 372.7997 | |
| 1.0931 | 373.074 | |
| 7.4528 | 376.3162 | |
| 7.901 | 377.2642 | |
| 8.8109 | 379.2798 | |
| 1.6829 | 381.0287 | |
| 0.3593 | 383.114 | |
| 1.6636 | 387.1926 | |
| 2.1815 | 389.1957 | |
| 0.3536 | 390.7096 | |
| 4.7366 | 393.3058 | |
| 1.0904 | 395.0595 | |
| 1.6779 | 395.0655 | |
| 0.3563 | 399.0878 | |
| 6.2208 | 400.34 | |
| 1.0927 | 401.0747 | |
| 1.9865 | 402.2247 | |
| 0.3465 | 402.9335 | |
| 2.0137 | 404.2393 | |
| 1.09 | 405 | |
| 0.3504 | 405.096 | |
| 1.6048 | 410.0573 | |
| 6.6635 | 410.3434 | |
| 1.0978 | 411.0227 | |
| 0.9505 | 411.1445 | |
| 10.2998 | 411.2636 | Peptide |
| 2.2901 | 413.1735 | Peptide |
| 6.6685 | 415.2991 | |
| 2.2749 | 416.2397 | |
| 1.9486 | 418.2552 | Peptide |
| 1.0939 | 420.9697 | Myo-inositol |
| 0.4032 | 421.0134 | |
| 13.056 | 422.1534 | Peptide |
| 1.986 | 424.2069 | Peptide |
| 2.0219 | 426.2226 | Peptide |
| 3.3009 | 430.3147 | |
| 3.8793 | 435.1404 | Peptide |
| 2.2383 | 436.2067 | Peptide |
| 1.9411 | 438.2215 | |
| 2.2804 | 438.2229 | |
| 7.9047 | 439.2336 | Peptide |
| 1.9731 | 440.2379 | Peptide |
| 0.3602 | 441.0728 | |
| 8.8391 | 441.2505 | |
| 0.361 | 443.07 | Peptide |
| 1.6293 | 443.2068 | Peptide |
| 7.9101 | 445.253 | Peptide |
| 1.6022 | 446.0764 | |
| 0.3583 | 446.6695 | |
| 0.4907 | 447.1107 | |
| 0.3585 | 448.668 | |
| 1.6604 | 450.0504 | |
| 0.352 | 451.1009 | |
| 13.1007 | 451.3301 | |
| 2.1912 | 454.2176 | |
| 6.6619 | 454.3717 | |
| 6.6553 | 455.4541 | |
| 0.571 | 456.0049 | |
| 1.6195 | 456.2284 | Peptide |
| 6.67 | 459.3263 | Peptide |
| 1.7063 | 459.9791 | |
| 0.4394 | 463.0131 | |
| 0.7459 | 463.0142 | |
| 1.6884 | 463.0538 | |
| 1.5937 | 464.0727 | Peptide |
| 0.3345 | 464.9774 | |
| 1.9822 | 465.2359 | Peptide |
| 12.737 | 467.0998 | |
| 3.473 | 467.1661 | Peptide |
| 10.3003 | 467.3253 | |
| 4.9923 | 468.3055 | |
| 0.987 | 469.0545 | |
| 13.1096 | 469.3385 | |
| 1.7225 | 470.9654 | |
| 1.6195 | 472.0268 | |
| 1.0919 | 479.012 | |
| 1.6744 | 479.1225 | Peptide |
| 2.2801 | 479.2485 | Peptide |
| 8.8117 | 482.2728 | Peptide |
| 5.5895 | 482.3202 | |
| 7.9175 | 485.1119 | |
| 4.993 | 490.2884 | Peptide |
| 6.1727 | 496.3386 | Lipid |
| 6.6598 | 498.3931 | |
| 0.3607 | 499.0317 | |
| 0.3661 | 501.0279 | |
| 5.5152 | 502.2903 | Peptide |
| 6.5022 | 502.3207 | Peptide |
| 6.6618 | 503.3524 | |
| 5.588 | 504.3023 | Peptide |
| 9.342 | 505.1728 | Peptide |
| 7.906 | 507.2218 | Peptide |
| 0.3502 | 509.0611 | |
| 8.8148 | 509.2378 | Peptide |
| 6.6027 | 510.3528 | Lipid |
| 0.4088 | 511.1077 | |
| 10.3056 | 512.3832 | |
| 1.6796 | 514.1279 | Peptide |
| 4.3737 | 514.3133 | Peptide |
| 0.3597 | 515.0057 | |
| 0.374 | 517.1219 | |
| 6.1755 | 518.3203 | Lipid |
| 0.3419 | 518.8442 | |
| 5.7313 | 520.3393 | |
| 10.2989 | 521.3353 | Peptide |
| 6.4842 | 522.3544 | Lipid |
| 6.6752 | 522.355 | |
| 7.4224 | 524.37 | Lipid |
| 1.9592 | 527.2105 | Peptide |
| 10.3044 | 528.3798 | Peptide |
| 5.902 | 530.3202 | |
| 10.3126 | 530.3374 | Peptide |
| 0.3349 | 530.8702 | |
| 1.0933 | 531.0327 | |
| 0.3529 | 532.9185 | |
| 13.773 | 536.1627 | |
| 10.7768 | 537.3705 | |
| 0.3335 | 538.905 | |
| 0.3693 | 539.1055 | |
| 5.7297 | 539.3104 | |
| 13.7723 | 541.1272 | Peptide |
| 2.2757 | 541.2188 | Peptide |
| 5.7333 | 542.3218 | |
| 6.6533 | 542.4236 | |
| 1.952 | 543.2365 | Peptide |
| 2.2779 | 546.1989 | Peptide |
| 7.4211 | 546.3526 | Lipid |
| 6.6677 | 547.3805 | |
| 0.4231 | 548.0531 | |
| 9.2218 | 554.1747 | Peptide |
| 0.3499 | 554.8997 | |
| 1.6083 | 555.0536 | |
| 0.37 | 555.0773 | |
| 2.2743 | 557.1907 | |
| 9.2188 | 559.1309 | |
| 0.3603 | 560.9874 | |
| 7.4221 | 562.328 | Peptide |
| 13.6 | 563.393 | |
| 2.2754 | 568.1795 | Peptide |
| 5.5875 | 572.2921 | Peptide |
| 1.5933 | 572.3243 | |
| 5.7311 | 573.3019 | Peptide |
| 1.6231 | 574.0328 | |
| 1.6091 | 577.0354 | |
| 7.4223 | 577.3347 | Peptide |
| 13.1318 | 577.4431 | |
| 1.6266 | 585.0671 | |
| 2.606 | 585.2705 | Peptide |
| 6.6434 | 586.4511 | |
| 10.3024 | 590.4088 | |
| 6.932 | 590.4251 | |
| 6.6434 | 591.4084 | |
| 6.4549 | 592.2653 | Peptide |
| 1.6239 | 598.3267 | |
| 6.8086 | 600.3238 | Peptide |
| 1.6056 | 601.1917 | |
| 1.7112 | 603.939 | |
| 5.7322 | 604.2916 | |
| 6.4827 | 606.3066 | Peptide |
| 0.3469 | 607.0939 | |
| 7.415 | 608.3224 | Peptide |
| 5.392 | 611.2865 | Peptide |
| 6.6809 | 612.3241 | Peptide |
| 7.4196 | 614.3404 | |
| 0.3622 | 619.0479 | |
| 4.3825 | 620.3067 | Peptide |
| 0.3506 | 626.9787 | |
| 13.6773 | 627.453 | |
| 2.2746 | 630.1508 | |
| 6.6362 | 630.4782 | |
| 0.5446 | 633.0673 | |
| 10.5995 | 633.1485 | |
| 3.4554 | 633.2536 | Peptide |
| 0.3616 | 635.0202 | |
| 13.6383 | 635.3657 | |
| 6.6358 | 635.4317 | |
| 10.725 | 637.4437 | |
| 1.6034 | 639.0026 | |
| 0.359 | 644.7984 | |
| 7.4254 | 646.2822 | |
| 1.6088 | 649.9961 | |
| 0.3528 | 655.0219 | |
| 5.7638 | 665.2701 | Peptide |
| 0.3547 | 670.9943 | |
| 1.7155 | 673.9541 | |
| 6.6237 | 674.5011 | |
| 7.4111 | 676.3079 | |
| 0.3492 | 676.9997 | |
| 12.0071 | 677.554 | |
| 0.3161 | 678.6746 | |
| 6.6254 | 679.4573 | Lipid |
| 1.7114 | 679.9699 | |
| 0.3429 | 688.7822 | |
| 1.7173 | 689.9271 | |
| 0.3507 | 692.97 | |
| 0.3477 | 694.9721 | |
| 13.6232 | 703.4517 | Lipid |
| 13.1358 | 703.5737 | |
| 1.6767 | 709.0683 | |
| 11.7477 | 712.5443 | |
| 7.4314 | 713.3025 | |
| 9.9864 | 717.632 | Lipid |
| 6.6167 | 718.5284 | |
| 13.4943 | 722.551 | Ceramide |
| 6.6094 | 723.4853 | |
| 5.7355 | 725.4297 | Lipid |
| 13.1381 | 725.5549 | |
| 7.4214 | 729.4603 | |
| 13.5057 | 729.5885 | |
| 0.3477 | 734.953 | |
| 1.6269 | 735.4944 | Lipid |
| 11.4089 | 739.5345 | |
| 13.8137 | 740.5197 | Lipid |
| 10.8899 | 741.5508 | |
| 1.9897 | 743.3704 | |
| 7.4197 | 744.2956 | |
| 13.493 | 751.567 | Lipid |
| 13.1615 | 754.0566 | |
| 10.4529 | 758.5868 | |
| 0.5736 | 759.0603 | |
| 7.7516 | 760.5809 | Lipid |
| 13.0793 | 764.0389 | |
| 13.1581 | 765.0463 | |
| 6.5956 | 767.509 | |
| 2.2768 | 771.4027 | |
| 13.132 | 771.5631 | |
| 0.3524 | 772.9186 | |
| 12.8808 | 774.5722 | |
| 12.293 | 778.5329 | Lipid |
| 13.1639 | 782.5684 | Lipid |
| 13.1358 | 793.5442 | |
| 10.3346 | 794.5649 | Lipid |
| 13.7571 | 796.561 | |
| 7.4286 | 797.4589 | |
| 1.599 | 798.3899 | |
| 5.7361 | 798.9721 | |
| 5.7311 | 801.9803 | |
| 13.1657 | 804.5514 | Lipid |
| 14.361 | 806.5633 | Lipid |
| 12.9319 | 806.5706 | Lipid/ceramide |
| 13.2426 | 810.6704 | |
| 0.3509 | 810.8878 | |
| 2.2829 | 812.4288 | |
| 8.6836 | 820.4116 | |
| 12.6246 | 820.5522 | Lipid |
| 13.0707 | 827.5999 | |
| 12.9375 | 828.5527 | Lipid |
| 13.9946 | 830.568 | Lipid |
| 6.1864 | 830.961 | |
| 5.7348 | 835.9755 | |
| 0.3123 | 836.6608 | |
| 6.4852 | 839.497 | |
| 1.7063 | 841.9379 | |
| 7.4234 | 842.023 | |
| 10.3171 | 847.4601 | |
| 11.7131 | 856.5728 | |
| 5.7373 | 866.9606 | |
| 5.7347 | 869.9697 | |
| 13.1642 | 872.5377 | Lipid |
| 8.8102 | 876.5694 | |
| 11.9 | 882.5886 | |
| 13.0421 | 884.6029 | |
| 12.9953 | 893.0155 | |
| 12.9321 | 896.5377 | |
| 5.7506 | 900.2364 | |
| 5.7392 | 900.9573 | |
| 7.4281 | 910.0114 | |
| 13.1352 | 929.5189 | Lipid |
| 11.7452 | 939.4679 | |
| 13.1658 | 940.523 | |
| 1.6171 | 954.6025 | |
| 11.4692 | 955.5848 | |
| 13.0992 | 963.574 | |
| 3.5652 | 979.9296 |
Abbreviations: m/z, mass/charge; RT, retention time.