Fission fragment RBE for bone sarcoma induction.

Thirty beagles and 277 mice were injected with 249Cf, and 30 beagles and 274 mice were injected with 252Cf. The skeletal dose (in Gy) from 252Cf was about half from fission fragments and half from alpha particles, whereas 249Cf emits alpha particles in 100% of its transformations. Bone sarcomas (mostly osteosarcomas) were the main radiation-induced cancer. The relative biological effectiveness (RBE) of fission fragment dose relative to alpha-particle dose for bone sarcoma induction was calculated from the ratio of 249Cf/252Cf doses at equal times to bone sarcoma in (a) beagles and (b) mice, and (c) from the ratio 252Cf/249Cf risk coefficients in mice. The average RBE +/- standard deviation of the three evaluations was 0.1 +/- 0.1. The very low RBE for bone sarcomas is supported by the data of A. L. Batchelor, T. J. Jenner, and L. M. Cobb [Phys. Med. Biol. 28, 475-483 (1983)] for lung cancer induction in rats and by that of A. L. Brooks, J. A. Mewhinney, and R. O. McClellan [Health Phys. 22, 701-706 (1972)] for producing chromosome aberrations in the liver cells of Chinese hamsters. The low effectiveness of fission fragments relative to alpha particles, per gray of absorbed dose, is ascribed primarily to the much larger number of cells traversed by the alpha particles. Consideration might be given to decreasing the quality factor of fission fragments by an order of magnitude below that for alpha particles.