Prevalence of Angiostrongylus vasorum in southern Belgium, a coprological and serological survey.

BACKGROUND: Canine angiostrongylosis, a gastropod-borne helminthic infection, is increasingly being described in North America and is now reported in many European countries. In dogs, Angiostrongylus vasorum may cause a wide spectrum of clinical signs. Respiratory distress such as coughing and dyspnoea are the most frequently described manifestations. The aim of the present study was to gain additional information on the distribution, prevalence and risk factors associated with A. vasorum infection in dog from southern Belgium through the combined used of a commercially available in-clinic assay for detection of circulating antigen (Angio Detect™, IDEXX, Westbrook, USA) and coprology in two different canine populations: dogs with clinical signs compatible with angiostrongylosis and asymptomatic dogs or dogs presented for unrelated conditions (control).
RESULTS: A total of 979 dogs were enrolled in the study from November 2014 until February 2016. Seven hundred fifty-seven dogs were included in the control group, whereas 222 dogs had clinical signs compatible with angiostrongylosis. Forty-six dogs out of 979 (4.7 %) had A. vasorum circulating antigen. There was a highly significant difference between the two populations (3.6 % (27/747) and 8.6 % (19/222) in control and symptomatic dogs, respectively) (P = 0.00379). First stage larvae (L1) of A. vasorum were found in seven out of 24 serologically positive control dogs and in six out of 17 serologically positive symptomatic dogs. Interestingly, L1 of Crenosoma vulpis were detected by Baermann technique in one control and nine symptomatic dogs, respectively. Out of 17 Angio Detect™ (IDEXX, Westbrook, USA) positive dogs with negative (14) or not performed Baermann test (three), one dog was positive in both in-house ELISAs (Ag and Ab) and one dog was positive for Ag. Statistical analysis was unable to detect any risk factors associated with the direct and/or indirect detection of A. vasorum.
CONCLUSIONS: This seroepidemiological study demonstrated for the first time a high seroprevalence in Southern Belgium for A. vasorum. The Angio Detect™ was found to be suitable in this context as the collection, preservation and examination of stools were difficult. Nevertheless, discrepancies were observed between the different available tests. Additional research is clearly needed. Also, coproscopy remains a very useful tool in dogs infected for less than nine weeks and for the identification of other canine lung nematodes such as C. vulpis. This study also demonstrates that asymptomatic dogs may shed A. vasorum L1 in their faeces and therefore contribute to the maintenance of A. vasorum life-cycle.

Background

Canine angiostrongylosis, a gastropod-borne helminthic infection caused by the so-called “French heartworm”, was first reported in France in the 1800s [1]. The disease is increasingly being described in North America [2] and is reported now in many European countries [3]. The red fox (Vulpes vulpes) is considered as the main reservoir of this nematode [4] and many species of slugs and snails may act as intermediate hosts [5].

In dogs, Angiostrongylus vasorum may cause a wide spectrum of clinical signs from mild to severe, which can lead to death. Respiratory distress such as coughing and dyspnoea are the most frequently described manifestations. The diagnosis of the disease is sometimes very challenging as infected animals may exhibit clinical signs overlapping those of other conditions [6], be atypical such as bleeding and neurological disorders or be absent [7-9].

Despite the fact that epidemiological models indicate that Belgium has a highly favourable climate for the completion of A. vasorum life-cycle [10], the parasite was not recorded in this country until 2013 when a fatal autochthonous case was described in a four and a half month puppy [11]. Very recently, nine additional cases were diagnosed through Baermann faecal examination and quantitative PCR on bronchoalveolar lavage fluid [12, 13], which suggests that the parasite could be well established in Belgium at least in the study area (Wallonia, southern Belgium). However, it is well known that A. vasorum has a patchy distribution [14, 15] and this might be a challenge for the collection of reliable epidemiological data.

A confirmatory diagnosis can be obtained using the Baermann method, based on the isolation and microscopic identification of A. vasorum first stage larvae (L1) from faeces, showing the characteristic notch feature on the tail [16]. Nevertheless, the availability of newly developed commercial tests targeting circulating A. vasorum antigens has made possible the in-clinic diagnosis of this infection [17], while the ELISAs used for mass-screening in different canine populations allowed the implementation of region- or even nation-wide surveys [18-20]. The aim of the present study was to gain additional information on the distribution, prevalence and risk factors associated with A. vasorum infection in the dog through the combined used of in-clinic detection of circulating antigen and of coprology in two different canine populations: dogs with clinical signs compatible with angiostrongylosis and asymptomatic dogs or dogs presented for unrelated conditions.

Methods

Collection of samples and data

The survey was conducted from November 2014 until February 2016. Seventeen small animal practices were selected on voluntary basis across Southern Belgium (Wallonia) (Fig. 1). In each practice samples were collected from dogs belonging to two populations: a first random dog population (called “control” thereafter) presented for unrelated conditions (such as vaccination, spaying, traumas, skin conditions and others) whereas the second population included dogs showing clinical signs compatible with angiostrongylosis such as coughing, exercise intolerance, dyspnoea, bleeding or neurological disorders. Dogs from any breeds, age and sex were included in this survey. These two populations were selected based on the exclusion criteria of absence of travel history outside Belgium during the three previous months.

Fig. 1

Selected veterinary clinics and their locations across southern Belgium

Simultaneously, a questionnaire was filled in by the owner: sex, age, breed, locality, life style and recent anti-parasitic treatments, if any, were recorded.

Sample analysis

Blood samples from these dogs were collected in dry or heparinised tubes and centrifuged in order to obtain serum or plasma. An in-clinic serological test detecting A. vasorum circulating Ag (Angio Detect™, IDEXX, Westbrook, USA) was used for initial screening of all dogs (979) following manufacturer’s instructions, with a sensitivity of 84.6 % and a specificity of 100 %, as previously described [17]; reading of the test was performed strictly at 15 min. Intensity of positive results was assessed as +, ++, +++ [17]. All practices have been trained and monitored by the first author in order to obtain comparable results.

Recently passed stools from dogs with a positive serological screening were collected on 3 consecutive days. In some cases, this was not possible, or stools were obtained only once or twice. Additionally, some serologically negative dogs with a high suspicion of lungworm infection (showing dyspnoea or coughing or living with another seropositive dog) were also screened through coproscopy by isolation of L1 through Baermann larval migration-technique. This examination was done at the Laboratory of Parasitology of the Faculty of Veterinary Medicine, University of Liège. Differentiation between A. vasorum and C. vulpis L1 was performed based on morphological criteria [21].

Sera presenting conflicting results between serology and coprology were sent to the Institute of Parasitology, Vetsuisse Faculty, University of Zurich, Switzerland, and were further analysed for the presence of circulating A. vasorum antigens using monoclonal and polyclonal antibodies in a sandwich-ELISA, with a sensitivity of 95.7 % and a specificity of 94.0 %, as previously described [22]. Additionally, a sandwich-ELISA (sensitivity 81.0 %, specificity 98.8 %) using A. vasorum adult somatic antigen purified by monoclonal antibodies (mAb Av 5/5) was used for specific antibody detection [23]. All test runs included a background control, a conjugate control, three positive control sera from three experimentally infected dogs and two negative control sera from uninfected dogs.

Statistical analysis

To identify possible risk factors associated with the seropositivity to A. vasorum, answers to the questionnaire were encoded and merged with the serological results (positive, negative) of each dog. The host variables were made available to the model, with sex as a binary variable (male or female), access to garden, terrace, urban park, forest, street and vegetable garden as binary variable (yes/no), housing as a binary variable (inside or access to the outside), clinical signs compatible with angiostrongylosis as a binary variable (yes/no), age as a categorical variable (< 1 year, between 1 and 3 years, between 3 and 8 years and over 8 years), post code of the owner’s domicile as a categorical variable and locality as a categorical variable (urban, rural or periurban).

An univariate analysis was conducted and odds ratio's (OR) with 95 % confidence intervals (CIs 95 %) were attributed to each variable. All variables with P < 0.20 in univariate analysis were then included in subsequent multivariate logistic regression analyses. A P value < 0.05 was used to define statistical significance.

Statistical analyses were performed using the R software/environment (R-3.1.2, R Foundation for Statistical Computing, http://www.r-project.org/) and SAS software, Version 9.3 TS level 1 M2 of the SAS System for Unix and SAS University Edition (SAS Institute, Cary, NC, USA).

Results

A total of 979 dogs were enrolled in the study. Seven hundred fifty-seven were included in the control group, whereas 222 dogs had clinical signs compatible with angiostrongylosis. The distribution of samples according to the different tests (serology versus coprology) is given in Table 1. Forty-six dogs out of 979 (4.7 %) had A. vasorum circulating antigen detected with the rapid in-clinic assay. There was a highly significant difference between the two populations (3.6 % (27/757) and 8.6 % (19/222) in control and symptomatic dogs respectively) (χ  = 8.4702, df = 1, P = 0.00361).

Table 1

Results of Angio Detect™ (IDEXX, Westbrook, USA) rapid assay test performed with sera of symptomatic and control dogs. Baermann coprological analysis was performed on dogs positive for Angio Detect™ test or suspected of angiostrongylosis

	Parasite	Control dogs n = 757 (%)	Symptomatic dogs n = 222 (%)	Total n = 979 (%)
Total Angio Detect™-positive		27/757 (3.6)	19/222 (8.6)	46/979 (4.7)
Angio Detect™-positive and Baermann not performed		3/27	2/19	5/46
Angio Detect™-positive and Baermann-positive	L1 A. vasorum	7/24 (29)	6/17 (35)	13/41 (32)
	L1 C. vulpis	0/24	1/17	1/41
	L1 A. vasorum and C. vulpis	0/24	2/17	2/41
Angio Detect™-positive and Baermann-negative		17/24	8/17	25/41
Angio Detect™-negative and Baermann-positive	L1 A. vasorum	0/1	0/5	0/6
	L1 C. vulpis	1/1	4/5	5/6
	L1 A. vasorum and C. vulpis	0/1	1/5	1/6

Stools were obtained from 41 seropositive dogs (24 and 17 in control and symptomatic dogs respectively) and 6 seronegative dogs with strong suspicion of angiostrongylosis (1 and 5 in control and symptomatic dogs respectively). Stools from 5 seropositive dogs were not available for testing. L1 of A. vasorum were found in 7 out of 24 (29 %) serologically positive (Angio Detect™) control dogs and in 6 out of 17 (35 %) serologically positive symptomatic dogs. Interestingly L1 of C. vulpis were detected by the larval migration Baermann technique in 1 control and 9 symptomatic dogs, respectively. In the latter group 1 dog was found seropositive for A. vasorum but only C. vulpis L1 were found, and 1 dog was found seronegative for A. vasorum but L1 of A. vasorum and C. vulpis were found via the Baermann technique (Fig. 2). A majority of seropositive (Angio Detect™) and symptomatic dogs exhibited cardio-pulmonary symptoms (cough, dyspnoea and exercise intolerance). Neurological signs and bleeding were recorded in one symptomatic dog (Table 2).

Fig. 2

First stage larvae of Crenosoma vulpis (left) and Angiostrongylus vasorum (right) found in faeces of a dog isolated by the Baermann method

Table 2

Number of dogs showing different clinical signs recorded by the veterinarians in the questionnaire

Clinical signs	Dogs	Angio Detect™-positive
Coughing	86	6
Dyspnoea	19	3
Exercise intolerance	39	3
Bleeding	11	1
Neurological disorders	13	1
Coughing + exercise intolerance	44	5
Coughing + bleeding	6	0
Bleeding + neurological disorders	1	0
No clear statement	3	0
Total	222	19

Eighteen sera of dogs with conflicting results between serology and coproscopy (or coproscopy not performed) were analysed by in-house ELISAs at the Institute of Parasitology of the University of Zurich, Switzerland. Out of 17 seropositive dogs with Angio Detect™ and with negative or not performed Baermann test, one dog was positive for both ELISAs (Ag and Ab) and one dog was positive for Ag ELISA only. The dog found seronegative for A. vasorum with Angio Detect™ but positive for L1 of A. vasorum and C. vulpis was found positive by Ab ELISA (Table 3).

Table 3

Results of in-house ELISAs (Ag and Ab) tested on 18 dogs with conflicting results between serology and coprology (negative) or with coprology not performed

	Angio Detect™-positive				Angio Detect™-negative
	ELISA Ag		ELISA Ab		ELISA Ag		ELISA Ab
	No. positive/ No. tested)	No. negative/ No. tested	No. positive/No. tested	No. negative/ No. tested	No. positive/ No. tested	No. negative/ No. tested	No. positive/ No. tested	No. negative/ No. tested
Symptomatic	1/4	3/4	1/4	3/4	0/1	1/1	1/1	0/1
Control	1/13	12/13	0/13	13/13	–	–	–	–
Total	2/17	15/17	1/17	16/17	0/1	1/1	1/1	0/1

Data obtained from the questionnaire provided the different localities where dogs were living (Fig. 3). In the univariate analysis access to the forest (Z = -1.673, P = 0.094) and clinical signs (Z = 2.895, P = 0.00379) were associated with seropositivity to A. vasorum. These two explanatory variables were included in the multivariate model. However, only the presence of clinical signs compatible with angiostrongylosis resulted as a risk factor for A. vasorum seropositivity (P = 0.0079; OR = 3.1; 95 % CI: 1.33–7.22).

Fig. 3

Locations (based on postal codes) of seropositive dogs for A. vasorum according to Angio Detect™ (IDEXX, Westbrook, USA) and C. vulpis according to Baermann examination in southern Belgium

Discussion

Originally, three practices were chosen for a pilot study because of previously diagnosed canine angiostrongylosis in the region. Additionally, 14 other practices in southern Belgian were enrolled in the study based on the interest they showed to test and deliver samples in order to explore whether more cases could be diagnosed. The implementation of this type of survey relies heavily on the willingness and rigour of the different participants, namely the veterinary practices. This may be considered as a potential bias. However, canine practices were selected in the five different provinces of southern Belgium (Wallonia) where a large number of both symptomatic and control dogs were sampled. Therefore, the present survey, the first large scale epidemiological study conducted in Belgium, should be considered as a pilot study aiming to give a fairly good estimation of the impact of angiostrongylosis in the canine population of southern Belgium.

For practical reasons (ease of use and rapidity) the 979 canine sera were screened using an in-clinic test (Angio Detect™) which is able to detect specific A. vasorum circulating antigen as early as nine weeks post-experimental inoculation. This test has a good sensitivity (84.6 %) for clinically affected dogs, and a very high specificity (100 %) regarding different lungworms [17]. In total 46 dogs (4.7 %) had specific circulating antigen which indicates that A. vasorum infections is well established in the canine southern Belgian population. This is in agreement with recently published data dealing with single case reports [11, 13] or small clinical series [12]. Large-scale seroepidemiological surveys were previously performed in Europe using ELISAs, showing antigen detection in 0.5 to 2.17 % of the study populations [18–20, 24–26]. Among Belgium’s neighbouring countries, in Germany, 4003 randomly selected canine sera were collected from western federal states and tested by Schnyder et al. [18] using Ab and Ag ELISAs, the latter test being able to detect A. vasorum specific antigen as early as seven weeks post-infection [27]. A total of 20 sera (0.5 %) were antigen positive in that study. The comparison of this seroprevalence with the results of the control group presented in our study (3.6 %) confirms that the investigated area, which has a border with North Rhine Westphal and Rhineland-Palatinate must be very suitable for the completion of A. vasorum life-cycle [10], particularly considering that the rapid in-clinic assay is recommended for testing clinically affected dogs and less sensitive than the ELISAs that have been used in the mentioned study from Germany. In symptomatic dogs the proportion of antigen positive dogs was even higher (8.6 %). The majority of these dogs had cardio-pulmonary symptoms (cough, dyspnoea, exercise intolerance) which are by far the most commonly observed clinical signs in dogs with canine angiostrongylosis [9]. Coagulopathies and neurological disorders, which were only reported in one seropositive dog during the present study, are reported in canine angiostrongylosis but represent a small proportion of the patients [7].

Other epidemiological studies based on coproscopy confirmed that asymptomatic dogs can excrete L1 and thus contribute to the dissemination of the parasite in the environment. For example, in UK, Morgan et al. [28] found A. vasorum L1 in the faeces of 15 % and 2 % of symptomatic and asymptomatic dogs, respectively. Barutzki & Schaper [29] in Germany isolated L1 in 6 % of symptomatic dogs (n = 810) versus 0.1 % in a survey conducted earlier by the same authors in asymptomatic individuals [30]. It is not known whether these asymptomatic carriers may or may not develop clinical signs later on, as the majority of these dogs may have been treated with an anthelmintic drug.

The larval migration-technique was difficult to implement during this study: a total of 47 stool samples were obtained and in some cases, samples from only one day of collection were provided by the owners, or the stools had dried up. This might explain at least partly the high level of discrepancy observed between the serological assay (positivity) and the Baermann technique (negativity). Additional explanations could be linked to the technical characteristics of the in-clinic test which requires reading after 15 min sharp (and resulting in false positive results if reading is performed later), and the potential of non-reported anti-parasitic treatment by the owner (resulting in negative coproscopy while serology may still be positive) [27]. Indeed, in experimentally infected dogs, patency started between 7–8 weeks after infection, approximately at the same time of antigen detection (while antibody detection may start as soon as three weeks after infection), with the difference that dogs, once diagnosed seropositive, remain positive unless treated [27], in opposition to Baermann examination, where intermittent larval shedding can be observed [31]. The potential role of the immune response that inhibits the production of L1 as described in canine dirofilariosis [32] could also be hypothesised. Nevertheless, some discrepancies were not explained by the above hypotheses and some dogs positive with Angio Detect™ were not confirmed by in house ELISAs (Ag and/or Ab).

Interestingly, L1 of C. vulpis were observed in nine and one symptomatic and control dogs, respectively confirming the presence of this nematode in Belgium, as recently reported [33]. Consequently, this parasitic infection must be included in the differential diagnosis of pulmonary conditions. It is noteworthy that in five of these C. vulpis infected dogs the Angio Detect™ assay resulted in a negative result, while a mixed infection in these dogs may have been missed. This confirmed the high specificity of the test as previously demonstrated by Schnyder at al. [20] towards C. vulpis and other canine nematodes. In one symptomatic Angio Detect™ negative dog, L1 of both A. vasorum and C. vulpis were observed, whereas the sample was found to be positive with Ab ELISA. A possible explanation could be the production of immune complexes, as shown for Dirofilaria immitis, which could block Ag detection on commercially available tests [34, 35].

Conclusions

In conclusion, this seroepidemiological study demonstrated a high seroprevalence in southern Belgium for A. vasorum and further investigation is necessary to check if this patchy distribution in the investigated area is also present in the northern part of Belgium. The Angio Detect™ was found to be suitable in this context as the collection, preservation and examination of stools were challenging. More research is needed in order to understand variability in the results obtained from different diagnostic tools. However, coproscopy remains a very useful tool in patent dogs infected for less than nine weeks and for the identification of other canine lung nematodes such as C. vulpis as mixed infections with different lungworm species may occur. This study also demonstrates that asymptomatic dogs or dogs presented for unrelated conditions may shed A. vasorum L1 in their faeces and therefore contribute to the maintenance of A. vasorum life-cycle. Consequently, practitioners in endemic areas should be sensitized and may suggest to screen for A. vasorum infection even in asymptomatic dogs. For dogs with eating behaviour at high-risk and potential ingestion of snails, regular testing or preventative monthly treatments are recommended [36].