| Literature DB >> 27703387 |
Unchalee Permsuwan1, Piyameth Dilokthornsakul2, Surasak Saokaew3, Kednapa Thavorn4, Nathorn Chaiyakunapruk5.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The management of type 2 diabetes mellitus (T2DM) in elderly population poses many challenges. Dipeptidyl peptidase-4 (DPP-4) inhibitors show particular promise due to excellent tolerability profiles, low risk of hypoglycemia, and little effect on body weight. This study evaluated, from the health care system's perspective, the long-term cost-effectiveness of DPP-4 inhibitor monotherapy vs metformin and sulfonylurea (SFU) monotherapy in Thai elderly T2DM patients.Entities:
Keywords: DPP-4 inhibitor; Thailand; cost-effectiveness analysis; elderly; type 2 diabetes
Year: 2016 PMID: 27703387 PMCID: PMC5036830 DOI: 10.2147/CEOR.S113559
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Clinicoecon Outcomes Res ISSN: 1178-6981
Baseline characteristics of the cohort population
| Variables | Mean ±SD | Data sources |
|---|---|---|
| Patient demographics | ||
| Mean age (years) | 72.8±5.6 | BCRH database |
| Duration of diabetes (years) | 10.5±7.6 | TDR2006 |
| Proportion male | 34.3% | BCRH database |
| Risk factors | ||
| HbA1c level (%) | 7.9±6.6 | BCRH database |
| Systolic blood pressure (mmHg) | 143.6±22.4 | TDR2006 |
| Total cholesterol (mg/dL) | 187.4±45.4 | BCRH database |
| High-density lipoprotein cholesterol (mg/dL) | 49.8±15.1 | BCRH database |
| Low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (mg/dL) | 108.3±39.5 | BCRH database |
| Triglycerides (mg/dL) | 169.8±95.6 | BCRH database |
| Body mass index (kg/m2) | 24.6±4.1 | Trongsakul |
| eGFR (mL/min/1.73 m2) | 66.6±28.5 | BCRH database |
| Proportion of smokers | 8.10% | Trongsakul |
| Number of cigarettes smoked per day | 6.0 | Porapakkham and Plattara-Archachai |
| Alcohol consumption (mL/wk) | 136.5 | Center of Alcohol Studies |
| Cardiovascular disease complications | ||
| Myocardial infarction | 2.4% | BCRH database |
| Angina pectoris | 1.3% | BCRH database |
| Peripheral vascular disease | 0.2% | BCRH database |
| Stroke | 2.5% | BCRH database |
| Congestive heart failure | 4.7% | BCRH database |
| Atrial fibrillation | 2.5% | BCRH database |
| Left ventricular hypertrophy | 0.3% | BCRH database |
| Cataract | 42.8% | TDR2006 |
| Depression | 19.4% | Thaneerat and Tangwongchai |
| Foot ulcer complications | ||
| Uninfected ulcer | 5.9% | TDR2003 |
| Infected ulcer | 1.2% | Nitiyanant et al |
| Healed ulcer | 6.9% | Nitiyanant et al |
| History of amputation | 1.5% | TDR2006 |
| Macular edema | 2.5% | Supapluksakul et al |
| Neuropathy | 2.1% | BCRH database |
| Renal complications | ||
| Microalbuminuria | 18.0% | TDR2006 |
| Gross proteinuria | 26.1% | TDR2006 |
| End-stage renal disease | 0.1% | Nitiyanant et al |
| Retinopathy complications | ||
| Background retinopathy | 22.0% | TDR2006 |
| Proliferative retinopathy | 9.4% | TDR2006 |
| Severe vision loss | 1.5% | TDR2006 |
Abbreviations: BCRH, Buddhachinaraj Regional Hospital; SD, standard deviation; TDR, Thailand diabetes registry.
Cost parameters used in the CDM
| Variables | Mean (THB) | SD | Reference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Management costs | |||
| Aspirin | 185 | 119.58 | BCRH database |
| Statin | 2,042 | 4,956.59 | BCRH database |
| ACEI | 1,319 | 3,037.85 | BCRH database |
| Antidepressant | 2,323 | 6,107.65 | BCRH database |
| Screening for microalbuminuria | 320 | – | Maharaj Nakorn Chiang Mai hospital |
| Screening for gross proteinuria | 60 | – | Maharaj Nakorn Chiang Mai hospital |
| Eye screening | 129 | – | Pornpinatepong |
| Foot screening program | 70 | – | Standard cost list |
| Costs of acute events | |||
| Major hypoglycemia | 27,856 | 70,785.76 | BCRH database |
| Ketoacidosis event | 13,284 | 36,398.48 | BCRH database |
| Lactic acidosis event | 64,724 | 97,511.56 | BCRH database |
| Major hypoglycemia | 27,856 | 70,785.76 | BCRH database |
| Costs of eye diseases | |||
| Laser treatment | 1,920 | – | Pornpinatepong |
| Cataract operation | 7,000 | – | National Health Security Office |
| Blindness, first year | 30,902 | 17,675.91 | BCRH database |
| Blindness, subsequent years | 18,766 | 32,900.26 | BCRH database |
| Costs of cardiovascular complications | |||
| MI, first year | 106,323 | 129,552.60 | BCRH database |
| MI, subsequent years | 26,629 | 41,451.42 | BCRH database |
| Angina first year | 60,235 | 83,594.51 | BCRH database |
| Angina, subsequent years | 19,578 | 28,308.46 | BCRH database |
| CHF, first year | 58,875 | 79,235.18 | BCRH database |
| CHF, subsequent years | 25,452 | 39,122.61 | BCRH database |
| Stroke, first year | 71,362 | – | BCRH database |
| Stroke, subsequent years | 23,884 | 32,123.49 | BCRH database |
| Stroke death within 30 days | 38,189 | 41,778 | BCRH database |
| PVD, first year | 156,394 | 276,600.00 | BCRH database |
| PVD, subsequent years | 50,374 | 50,253.25 | BCRH database |
| Costs of neuropathy and foot complications | |||
| Neuropathy, first year | 24,410 | 37,763.1 | BCRH database |
| Neuropathy, subsequent years | 18,797 | 28,631.95 | BCRH database |
| Amputation | 48,365 | – | BCRH database |
| Gangrene treatment (yearly) | 76,950 | 95,163.4 | BCRH database |
| Infected ulcer | 0 | – | Assumption |
| Uninfected ulcer (yearly) | 53,076 | 74,776.36 | BCRH database |
| Costs of renal complications | |||
| HD, first year | 452,120 | – | Teerawattananon et al |
| HD, subsequent years | 428,141 | – | Teerawattananon et al |
| PD, first year | 460,129 | – | Teerawattananon et al |
| PD, subsequent years | 408,080 | – | Teerawattananon et al |
| RT, first year | 928,000 | – | King Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital |
| RT, subsequent years | 429,240 | – | King Chulalongkorn Memorial Hospital |
Note: The dash indicates no data available.
Abbreviations: ACEI, angiotensin-converting-enzyme inhibitor; BCRH, Buddhachinaraj Regional Hospital; CDM, IMS CORE Diabetes Model, Version 8.5; CHF, congestive heart failure; HD, hemodialysis; MI, myocardial infarction; PD, peritoneal dialysis; PVD, peripheral vascular disease; RT, renal transplant; SD, standard deviation; THB, Thai Baht.
Efficacy and adverse effects of DPP-4 inhibitors, metformin, and SFU
| Variables | Mean (95% CI) | Data sources |
|---|---|---|
| Efficacy | ||
| HbA1c reduction (%) | ||
| DPP-4 inhibitors vs placebo | −0.92 (−0.8, −1.03) | Calculation |
| Metformin vs placebo | −1.20 (−0.81, −1.59) | Pooled analysis |
| SFU vs placebo | −0.83 (−0.98, 0) | Calculation |
| Weighted mean difference (%) (DPP-4 inhibitors vs metformin), favor metformin | 0.28 (0.17, 0.40) | Wu et al |
| Weighted mean difference (%) (DPP-4 inhibitors vs SFU), favor DPP-4 inhibitors | −0.09 (–∞, 0.06) | Rosenstock et al |
| Adverse effects | ||
| Risk of severe hypoglycemia (%) | ||
| SFU | 2.44 | BCRH database |
| DPP-4 inhibitors | 0.55 (0.32, 4.87) | Calculation |
| Metformin | 0.55 (0.32, 4.87) | Assumption |
| Risk of symptomatic hypoglycemia (%) | ||
| SFU | 19.36 | RECAP-DM study |
| DPP-4 inhibitors | 4.14 (2.15, 7.99) | Calculation |
| Metformin | 9.41 (5.75, 15.33) | Calculation |
| Risk ratio of severe hypoglycemia (DPP-4 inhibitors vs SFU) | 0.225 (0.03, 1.99) | Rosenstock et al |
| Risk ratio of severe hypoglycemia (DPP-4 inhibitors vs metformin) | 0.25 (0.03, 2.19) | Pooled analysis |
| Risk ratio of symptomatic hypoglycemia (DPP-4 inhibitors vs SFU) | 0.214 (0.11, 0.41) | Rosenstock et al |
| Risk ratio of symptomatic hypoglycemia (DPP-4 inhibitors vs metformin) | 0.44 (0.27, 0.72) | Wu et al |
Notes:
HbA1c reduction from baseline of DPP-4 inhibitors =−0.92 (−1.20+0.28). Upper 95% CI =−1.03 (−1.2+0.17) and lower 95% CI =−0.8 (−1.2+0.4).
Estimate the efficacy of metformin from the pooled analysis of seven studies40,44–49 included in the meta-analysis by Wu et al.51
HbA1c reduction from baseline of SFU =−0.83 (−0.92+0.09). Upper 95% CI assumed to be =0 (−0.92+∞), lower 95% CI =−0.98 (−0.92−0.06).
Risk of severe hypoglycemia of DPP-4 inhibitors =0.55% (2.44%×0.225).
Risk of severe hypoglycemia of DPP-4 inhibitors was assumed to be equal to that of metformin.
Risk of symptomatic hypoglycemia of DPP-4 inhibitors =4.14% (19.36%×0.214),
Risk of symptomatic hypoglycemia of metformin =9.41% (4.14%/0.44).
Estimate risk ratio of severe hypoglycemia from the pooled analysis of two studies52,55 included in the meta-analysis by Wu et al.51
Abbreviations: BCRH, Buddhachinaraj Regional Hospital; DPP-4, dipeptidyl peptidase-4; SFU, sulfonylurea.
Results of DPP-4 inhibitor monotherapy versus metformin monotherapy or SFU monotherapy in base-case analysis
| Treatment | Total cost, THB (US$) | Quality-adjusted life year | Incremental costs, THB (US$) | Incremental effectiveness (QALYs gained) | Incremental cost-effectiveness ratio, THB/QALY (US$/QALY) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| DPP-4 inhibitor vs metformin | |||||
| Saxagliptin vs metformin | |||||
| Saxagliptin | 406,876 (12,344.54) | 5.965 | Higher cost | Lower QALY | Dominated |
| Metformin | 283,222 (8,592.90) | 5.986 | |||
| Sitagliptin vs metformin | |||||
| Sitagliptin | 434,982 (13,197.27) | 5.965 | Higher cost | Lower QALY | Dominated |
| Metformin | 283,222 (8,592.90) | 5.986 | |||
| Vildagliptin vs metformin | |||||
| Vildagliptin | 428,869 (13,011.80) | 5.965 | Higher cost | Lower QALY | Dominated |
| Metformin | 283,222 (8,592.90) | 5.986 | |||
| DPP-4 inhibitor vs SFU | |||||
| Saxagliptin vs SFU | |||||
| Saxagliptin | 406,876 (12,344.54) | 5.965 | 113,701 (3,449.67) | 0.031 | 3,632,604 (110,212.50) |
| SFU | 293,175 (8,894.87) | 5.933 | |||
| Sitagliptin vs SFU | |||||
| Sitagliptin | 434,982 (13,197.27) | 5.965 | 141,806 (4,302.37) | 0.031 | 4,530,556 (137,456.19) |
| SFU | 293,175 (8,894.87) | 5.933 | |||
| Vildagliptin vs SFU | |||||
| Vildagliptin | 428,869 (13,011.80) | 5.965 | 135,694 (4,116.93) | 0.031 | 4,335,273 (131,531.34) |
| SFU | 293,175 (8,894.87) | 5.933 | |||
Abbreviations: DPP-4, dipeptidyl peptidase-4; QALY, quality-adjusted life year; SFU, sulfonylurea; THB, Thai Baht.
Figure 1Tornado diagram of saxagliptin vs sulfonylurea in elderly T2DM patients.
Abbreviations: DPP-4, dipeptidyl peptidase-4; QALY, quality-adjusted life year; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; THB, Thai Baht.
Figure 2Cost-effectiveness acceptability curve of DPP-4 inhibitors vs sulfonylurea in elderly T2DM patients.
Abbreviations: DPP-4, dipeptidyl peptidase-4; QALY, quality-adjusted life year; T2DM, type 2 diabetes mellitus; THB, Thai Baht.