Cindy Wu1, C Scott Hultman2, Paul Diegidio2, Steven Hermiz2, Roja Garimella2, Trisha M Crutchfield2, Clara N Lee2. 1. Dr Wu is an Assistant Professor, Dr Hultman is the Ethel and James Valone Distinguished Professor of Surgery and Chief, Dr Diegidio is a Resident, and Dr Lee is an Associate Professor, Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, The University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC. Dr Hermiz is a General Surgery Resident, The University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC. Ms Garimella is an undergraduate student, Brown University, Providence, RI. Ms Crutchfield is a Research Associate, Center for Health Promotion and Disease Prevention, The University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC cindy_wu@med.unc.edu. 2. Dr Wu is an Assistant Professor, Dr Hultman is the Ethel and James Valone Distinguished Professor of Surgery and Chief, Dr Diegidio is a Resident, and Dr Lee is an Associate Professor, Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, The University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC. Dr Hermiz is a General Surgery Resident, The University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC. Ms Garimella is an undergraduate student, Brown University, Providence, RI. Ms Crutchfield is a Research Associate, Center for Health Promotion and Disease Prevention, The University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, NC.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: What do patients want when looking for an aesthetic surgeon? When faced with attributes like reputation, years in practice, testimonials, photos, and pricing, which is more valuable? Moreover, are attributes procedure-specific? Currently, inadequate evidence exists on which attributes are most important to patients, and to our knowledge, none on procedure-specific preferences. OBJECTIVES: First, to determine the most important attributes to breast augmentation, combined breast/abdominal surgery, and facelift patients using conjoint analysis. Second, to test the conjoint using an internet crowdsourcing service (Amazon Mechanical Turk [MTurk]). METHODS: Anonymous university members were asked, via mass electronic survey, to pick a surgeon for facelift surgery based on five attributes. Attribute importance and preference was calculated. Once pre-tested, the facelift, breast augmentation and combined breast/abdominal surgery surveys were administered worldwide to MTurk. RESULTS: The university facelift cohort valued testimonials (33.9%) as the most important, followed by photos (31.6%), reputation (18.2%), pricing (14.4%), and practice years (1.9%). MTurk breast augmentation participants valued photos (35.3%), then testimonials (33.9%), reputation (15.7%), pricing (12.2%), and practice years (3%). MTurk combined breast/abdominal surgery and facelift participants valued testimonials (38.3% and 38.1%, respectively), then photos (27.9%, 29.4%), reputation (17.5%, 15.8%), pricing (13.9%, 13.9%), practice years (2.4%, 2.8%). CONCLUSIONS: Breast augmentation patients placed higher importance on photos; combined breast/abdominal surgery and facelift patients valued testimonials. Conjoint analysis has had limited application in plastic surgery. To our knowledge, internet crowdsourcing is a novel participant recruitment method in plastic surgery. Its unique benefits include broad, diverse and anonymous participant pools, low-cost, rapid data collection, and high completion rate.
BACKGROUND: What do patients want when looking for an aesthetic surgeon? When faced with attributes like reputation, years in practice, testimonials, photos, and pricing, which is more valuable? Moreover, are attributes procedure-specific? Currently, inadequate evidence exists on which attributes are most important to patients, and to our knowledge, none on procedure-specific preferences. OBJECTIVES: First, to determine the most important attributes to breast augmentation, combined breast/abdominal surgery, and facelift patients using conjoint analysis. Second, to test the conjoint using an internet crowdsourcing service (Amazon Mechanical Turk [MTurk]). METHODS: Anonymous university members were asked, via mass electronic survey, to pick a surgeon for facelift surgery based on five attributes. Attribute importance and preference was calculated. Once pre-tested, the facelift, breast augmentation and combined breast/abdominal surgery surveys were administered worldwide to MTurk. RESULTS: The university facelift cohort valued testimonials (33.9%) as the most important, followed by photos (31.6%), reputation (18.2%), pricing (14.4%), and practice years (1.9%). MTurk breast augmentation participants valued photos (35.3%), then testimonials (33.9%), reputation (15.7%), pricing (12.2%), and practice years (3%). MTurk combined breast/abdominal surgery and facelift participants valued testimonials (38.3% and 38.1%, respectively), then photos (27.9%, 29.4%), reputation (17.5%, 15.8%), pricing (13.9%, 13.9%), practice years (2.4%, 2.8%). CONCLUSIONS: Breast augmentation patients placed higher importance on photos; combined breast/abdominal surgery and facelift patients valued testimonials. Conjoint analysis has had limited application in plastic surgery. To our knowledge, internet crowdsourcing is a novel participant recruitment method in plastic surgery. Its unique benefits include broad, diverse and anonymous participant pools, low-cost, rapid data collection, and high completion rate.
Authors: Giap H Vu; Anthony Azzolini; Laura S Humphries; Daniel M Mazzaferro; Christopher L Kalmar; Carrie E Zimmerman; Jordan W Swanson; Jesse A Taylor; Scott P Bartlett Journal: Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open Date: 2020-07-15
Authors: Jamie L Welshhans; Jeffrey J Harmon; Ira Papel; Richard Gentile; Devinder Mangat; Patrick Byrne; Ryan M Collar Journal: JAMA Facial Plast Surg Date: 2018-03-01 Impact factor: 4.611
Authors: Alexandra Bucknor; Joani Christensen; Parisa Kamali; Sabine Egeler; Charlotte van Veldhuisen; Hinne Rakhorst; Irene Mathijssen; Samuel J Lin; Heather Furnas Journal: Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open Date: 2018-04-16
Authors: Chantal R Valiquette; Christopher R Forrest; Leila Kasrai; Kyle R Wanzel; Glykeria Martou; Brett A Beber; John L Semple; Thomas Constantine; Emily S Ho; Ron B Somogyi Journal: Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open Date: 2021-07-16