Alyson K Zalta1, James Gerhart2, Brian J Hall3,4, Kumar B Rajan5, Catalina Vechiu6, Daphna Canetti7, Stevan E Hobfoll2. 1. a Departments of Behavioral Sciences and Psychiatry , Rush University Medical Center , Chicago , IL , USA. 2. b Department of Behavioral Sciences , Rush University Medical Center , Chicago , IL , USA. 3. c Global and Community Mental Health Research Group, Department of Psychology , University of Macau (SAR) , Macau , People's Republic of China. 4. d Department of Health, Behavior and Society , Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health , Baltimore , MD , USA. 5. e Department of Internal Medicine , Rush University Medical Center , Chicago , IL , USA. 6. f Department of Psychology , University of Nevada , Reno , NV , USA. 7. g School of Political Science , University of Haifa , Haifa , Israel.
Abstract
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: This study tested three alternative explanations for research indicating a positive, but heterogeneous relationship between self-reported posttraumatic growth (PTG) and posttraumatic stress symptoms (PSS): (a) the third-variable hypothesis that the relationship between PTG and PSS is a spurious one driven by positive relationships with resource loss, (b) the growth over time hypothesis that the relationship between PTG and PSS is initially a positive one, but becomes negative over time, and (c) the moderator hypothesis that resource loss moderates the relationship between PTG and PSS such that PTG is associated with lower levels of PSS as loss increases. DESIGN AND METHOD: A nationally representative sample (N = 1622) of Israelis was assessed at three time points during a period of ongoing violence. PTG, resource loss, and the interaction between PTG and loss were examined as lagged predictors of PSS to test the proposed hypotheses. RESULTS: Results were inconsistent with all three hypotheses, showing that PTG positively predicted subsequent PSS when accounting for main and interactive effects of loss. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that self-reported PTG is a meaningful but counterintuitive predictor of poorer mental health following trauma.
BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE: This study tested three alternative explanations for research indicating a positive, but heterogeneous relationship between self-reported posttraumatic growth (PTG) and posttraumatic stress symptoms (PSS): (a) the third-variable hypothesis that the relationship between PTG and PSS is a spurious one driven by positive relationships with resource loss, (b) the growth over time hypothesis that the relationship between PTG and PSS is initially a positive one, but becomes negative over time, and (c) the moderator hypothesis that resource loss moderates the relationship between PTG and PSS such that PTG is associated with lower levels of PSS as loss increases. DESIGN AND METHOD: A nationally representative sample (N = 1622) of Israelis was assessed at three time points during a period of ongoing violence. PTG, resource loss, and the interaction between PTG and loss were examined as lagged predictors of PSS to test the proposed hypotheses. RESULTS: Results were inconsistent with all three hypotheses, showing that PTG positively predicted subsequent PSS when accounting for main and interactive effects of loss. CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggest that self-reported PTG is a meaningful but counterintuitive predictor of poorer mental health following trauma.
Entities:
Keywords:
Posttraumatic growth; political violence; posttraumatic stress; resource loss; terrorism
Authors: Stevan E Hobfoll; Anthony D Mancini; Brian J Hall; Daphna Canetti; George A Bonanno Journal: Soc Sci Med Date: 2011-03-08 Impact factor: 4.634
Authors: Stevan E Hobfoll; Patrick A Palmieri; Robert J Johnson; Daphna Canetti-Nisim; Brian J Hall; Sandro Galea Journal: J Consult Clin Psychol Date: 2009-02
Authors: Brian J Hall; Stevan E Hobfoll; Patrick A Palmieri; Daphna Canetti-Nisim; Oren Shapira; Robert J Johnson; Sandro Galea Journal: J Trauma Stress Date: 2008-02
Authors: Cristina D Pollari; Jennifer Brite; Robert M Brackbill; Lisa M Gargano; Shane W Adams; Pninit Russo-Netzer; Jonathan Davidov; Victoria Banyard; James E Cone Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2020-12-25 Impact factor: 3.390
Authors: Chengqi Cao; Li Wang; Jianhui Wu; Gen Li; Ruojiao Fang; Xing Cao; Ping Liu; Shu Luo; Brian J Hall; Jon D Elhai Journal: Front Psychol Date: 2018-08-28