Helen O'Leary1, Keith M Smart2, Niamh A Moloney3, Catherine M Doody1. 1. School of Public Health, Physiotherapy and Sports Science, University College Dublin, Dublin, Ireland. 2. Physiotherapy Department, St. Vincent's University Hospital, Dublin, Ireland. 3. Faculty of Medicine and Health Sciences, Macquarie University, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Research suggests that peripheral and central nervous system sensitization can contribute to the overall pain experience in peripheral musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions. It is unclear, however, whether sensitization of the nervous system results in poorer outcomes following the treatment. This systematic review investigated whether nervous system sensitization in peripheral MSK conditions predicts poorer clinical outcomes in response to a surgical or conservative intervention. METHODS: Four electronic databases were searched to identify the relevant studies. Eligible studies had a prospective design, with a follow-up assessing the outcome in terms of pain or disability. Studies that used baseline indices of nervous system sensitization were included, such as quantitative sensory testing (QST) or questionnaires that measured centrally mediated symptoms. RESULTS: Thirteen studies met the inclusion criteria, of which six were at a high risk of bias. The peripheral MSK conditions investigated were knee and hip osteoarthritis, shoulder pain, and elbow tendinopathy. QST parameters indicative of sensitization (lower electrical pain thresholds, cold hyperalgesia, enhanced temporal summation, lower punctate sharpness thresholds) were associated with negative outcome (more pain or disability) in 5 small exploratory studies. Larger studies that accounted for multiple confounders in design and analysis did not support a predictive relationship between QST parameters and outcome. Two studies used self-report measures to capture comorbid centrally mediated symptoms, and found higher questionnaire scores were independently predictive of more persistent pain following a total joint arthroplasty. CONCLUSION: This systematic review found insufficient evidence to support an independent predictive relationship between QST measures of nervous system sensitization and treatment outcome. Self-report measures demonstrated better predictive ability. Further high-quality prognostic research is warranted.
BACKGROUND: Research suggests that peripheral and central nervous system sensitization can contribute to the overall pain experience in peripheral musculoskeletal (MSK) conditions. It is unclear, however, whether sensitization of the nervous system results in poorer outcomes following the treatment. This systematic review investigated whether nervous system sensitization in peripheral MSK conditions predicts poorer clinical outcomes in response to a surgical or conservative intervention. METHODS: Four electronic databases were searched to identify the relevant studies. Eligible studies had a prospective design, with a follow-up assessing the outcome in terms of pain or disability. Studies that used baseline indices of nervous system sensitization were included, such as quantitative sensory testing (QST) or questionnaires that measured centrally mediated symptoms. RESULTS: Thirteen studies met the inclusion criteria, of which six were at a high risk of bias. The peripheral MSK conditions investigated were knee and hip osteoarthritis, shoulder pain, and elbow tendinopathy. QST parameters indicative of sensitization (lower electrical pain thresholds, cold hyperalgesia, enhanced temporal summation, lower punctate sharpness thresholds) were associated with negative outcome (more pain or disability) in 5 small exploratory studies. Larger studies that accounted for multiple confounders in design and analysis did not support a predictive relationship between QST parameters and outcome. Two studies used self-report measures to capture comorbid centrally mediated symptoms, and found higher questionnaire scores were independently predictive of more persistent pain following a total joint arthroplasty. CONCLUSION: This systematic review found insufficient evidence to support an independent predictive relationship between QST measures of nervous system sensitization and treatment outcome. Self-report measures demonstrated better predictive ability. Further high-quality prognostic research is warranted.
Authors: Matthew C Morris; Stephen Bruehl; Amanda L Stone; Judy Garber; Craig Smith; Tonya M Palermo; Lynn S Walker Journal: J Pediatr Psychol Date: 2022-04-08
Authors: Young Hak Roh; Young Do Koh; Jong Oh Kim; Kyu Ho Lee; Hyun Sik Gong; Goo Hyun Baek Journal: Clin Orthop Relat Res Date: 2018-04 Impact factor: 4.176
Authors: Vasileios Georgopoulos; Kehinde Akin-Akinyosoye; Weiya Zhang; Daniel F McWilliams; Paul Hendrick; David A Walsh Journal: Pain Date: 2019-09 Impact factor: 7.926
Authors: Matthew C Morris; Stephen Bruehl; Amanda L Stone; Judy Garber; Craig Smith; Tonya M Palermo; Lynn S Walker Journal: Clin J Pain Date: 2021-09-01 Impact factor: 3.423
Authors: Miguel Angel Galan-Martin; Federico Montero-Cuadrado; Enrique Lluch-Girbes; María Carmen Coca-López; Agustín Mayo-Iscar; Antonio Cuesta-Vargas Journal: J Clin Med Date: 2020-04-22 Impact factor: 4.241