We describe the epidemiology, clinical features, and molecular characterization of enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli (EHEC) infections caused by the singular hybrid pathotype O80:H2, and we examine the influence of antibiotics on Shiga toxin production. In France, during 2005-2014, a total of 54 patients were infected with EHEC O80:H2; 91% had hemolytic uremic syndrome. Two patients had invasive infections, and 2 died. All strains carried stx2 (variants stx2a, 2c, or 2d); the rare intimin gene (eae-ξ); and at least 4 genes characteristic of pS88, a plasmid associated with extraintestinal virulence. Similar strains were found in Spain. All isolates belonged to the same clonal group. At subinhibitory concentrations, azithromycin decreased Shiga toxin production significantly, ciprofloxacin increased it substantially, and ceftriaxone had no major effect. Antibiotic combinations that included azithromycin also were tested. EHEC O80:H2, which can induce hemolytic uremic syndrome complicated by bacteremia, is emerging in France. However, azithromycin might effectively combat these infections.
We describe the epidemiology, clinical features, and molecular characterization of enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli (EHEC) infections caused by the singular hybrid pathotype O80:H2, and we examine the influence of antibiotics on Shiga toxin production. In France, during 2005-2014, a total of 54 patients were infected with EHEC O80:H2; 91% had hemolytic uremic syndrome. Two patients had invasive infections, and 2 died. All strains carried stx2 (variants stx2a, 2c, or 2d); the rare intimin gene (eae-ξ); and at least 4 genes characteristic of pS88, a plasmid associated with extraintestinal virulence. Similar strains were found in Spain. All isolates belonged to the same clonal group. At subinhibitory concentrations, azithromycin decreased Shiga toxin production significantly, ciprofloxacin increased it substantially, and ceftriaxone had no major effect. Antibiotic combinations that included azithromycin also were tested. EHEC O80:H2, which can induce hemolytic uremic syndrome complicated by bacteremia, is emerging in France. However, azithromycin might effectively combat these infections.
Enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli (EHEC) are a subset of Shiga
toxin–producing E. coli (STEC) that cause diarrhea and hemorrhagic
colitis; illness can progress to hemolytic uremic syndrome (HUS) in 5%–10% of cases
(,). HUS is the most frequent etiology of pediatric acute
renal failure, and its lethality is 3%–5% worldwide (,)
and 1% in France (). Long-term
renal injuries occur in 20%–30% of HUSpatients (,,).EHEC serotype O157:H7 accounts for ≈60% of HUS cases worldwide (,). Other well-known serogroups associated with HUS include
O26, O111, O145, O55, O103, O121, and O91. EHEC O80:H2 strains are rarely reported in the
literature but have been detected in France. In 2013, an EHEC O80:H2 strain was responsible
for a severe case of HUS with relapse associated with bacteremia (). We identified several genetic traits in this
isolate, such as a rare variant of the intimin gene (eae-ξ) and
genetic determinants related to the pS88 plasmid associated with extraintestinal-virulence
pathogenic E. coli (ExPEC) (). This plasmid, mainly found in avian pathogenic
E. coli and E. coli strains that cause neonatal
meningitis, may partly explain the bacteremia observed, which has been reported in patients
with HUS.The occurrence of bacteremia during EHEC infections warrants antibiotic treatment for those
infections. However, antibiotics usually are not recommended for EHEC infection because of
the risk for worsening HUS, notably by induction of synthesis or secretion of Shiga toxin
(Stx) (,–). Therefore, bacteremia during EHEC infection represents
a new therapeutic challenge. However, a 2011 outbreak in Germany linked to EHEC O104:H4
() underscored the potential
benefit of certain antibiotics when HUS occurs (,). Thus, the use of antibiotics during EHEC infections
remains a source of debate (,).Our study aimed to determine the incidence rate of HUS cases associated with the singular
EHEC O80:H2, describe their clinical features, and examine the molecular characteristics of
the strains. In addition, we assessed the effects of different antibiotics on Stx
production in representative strains.
Materials and Methods
Clinical Data
For this study, we considered all E. coli O80:H2 isolates received
during January 2005–October 2014 by the Centre National de
Référence Associé Escherichia coli (Paris,
France). We then collected demographic and clinical data from patients’
medical records (e.g., age, sex, location); presence of diarrhea (with or without
blood); possible source of infection; presence of neurologic or other complications
(including pancreatitis, hepatitis, myocarditis, and bacteremia); whether the patient
had HUS; and outcome at time of follow-up (e.g., relapse, residual renal injuries
[including proteinuria and renal failure], arterial hypertension, or death). HUS was
defined as anemia (hemoglobin <10 g/dL), thrombopenia (platelets
<150,000/mm3), and renal failure (creatinine above reference for
age, weight, and sex, or >0.2 protein/creatinine ratio).
Bacteria Strains
We recovered isolates 35344 and 35431 from stool and blood cultures, respectively, of
a HUSpatient who was the subject of a recent case report (). These strains belonged to sequence type 301
and harbored 4 intestinal virulence genes (stx2c,
stx2d, hlyA, and eae-ξ)
and most of the extraintestinal virulence genes carried by plasmid pS88 (). The Laboratoire National de
Réference pour les Escherichia coli (Marcy l’Etoile,
France) and reference laboratories from Spain, Italy, and Germany were associated
with this study and provided us with their EHEC O80 strains when available. The
reference strain EDL933 (O157:H7, stx1a, stx2a, and
eae-γ) served as the control in the study of Stx
production (). We stored
all EHEC strains at −80°C in 5% glycerol.
Serotyping
The Centre National de Référence des Escherichia coli,
Shigella, et Salmonella at the Institute Pasteur
(Paris, France) initially determined the O80 serogroup by using a method based on the
analysis of the O antigen genes cluster rfb restriction fragments
length polymorphism ();
this result was recently confirmed by O80-specific PCR with primers targeting O80
polymerase gene wzy (GenBank accession no. AB812032). This new PCR
was included in our previously described O-serogroup multiplex PCR (). We assessed specificity of
the new multiplex PCR on template DNA extracted from 130 O reference strains as
previously described ().
Primers used for the EHEC O-serogrouping multiplex PCR are provided (Technical Appendix Tables 1, 2). We
determined the H serogroup by using PCR targeting the fliC genes
().
Molecular Characterization
Among EHEC O80 strains, we screened several genetic determinants by multiplex PCR as
previously described (),
including intestinal virulence genes (stx1,
stx2, eae, and hlyA)
and extraintestinal virulence genes associated with plasmid pS88
(sitA, eitB, cia, iss,
iucC, iroN, hlyF,
etsC, cvaA, and
ompT) (,). We also determined the variants of stx2
(stx2a, stx2b, stx2c, and
stx2d) and the variant of eae by using PCR-based
methods (,).To investigate the genetic diversity of the O80:H2 strains studied, we used the
DiversiLab genotyping method (bioMérieux, Marcy-l’Étoile,
France), which is based on PCR amplification of repeat sequences of DNA (rep-PCR) as
previously described (). We
then compared these genotypes with representative strains of serogroups (O157, O104,
O121, and O111) previously typed and recorded in our DiversiLab database (S.
Bonacorsi, unpub. data).
Effect of Various Antibiotics on Stx Production
We prepared inocula to assess Stx production in the presence or absence of
antibiotics as previously described (). We obtained log-phase growth of strains in
brain–heart infusion broth by using overnight incubation at 37°C and
then diluted the result with Luria-Bertani broth for an inoculum of 106
CFU/mL. We added 3 antimicrobial agents (azithromycin, ciprofloxacin, and
ceftriaxone) at final MICs of 0.5 and 0.25 for a single assay. We also tested
combinations of antibiotics at a MIC of 0.5. For each strain, we also performed an
antibiotic-free assay. We collected the bacterial cultures after 18 h of incubation
at 37°C and centrifuged at 4°C at 2,000 rpm for 10 min. We filtered
supernatants through a 0.22-µm pore-size filter (Millipore, Bedford, MA, USA)
and stored at −20°C until needed.We quantified Stx1 and Stx2 by using a chemiluminescent immunoassay for EHEC toxins
(Liaison, DiaSorin, Spain). We expressed the results in relative light units, and
converted each result to a concentration of Stx (ng/mL) by using a standard curve
obtained by serial dilution of a highly positive sample and the manufacturer-provided
positive control (70 ng/mL Stx concentration). We performed each measure 3 times.
Statistical Analysis
We calculated means, medians, and SDs in Excel (Microsoft Corp., Redmond, WA, USA).
Student paired t-test was used to compare means of Stx
concentrations; p values <0.05 were considered statistically significant.
Quantitative variables are presented as median and range or quartile range.
Results
During January 2005–October 2014, the Centre National de Référence
Associé Escherichia coli collected 57 strains of EHEC O80:H2 in
France. These strains were isolated, mostly from stool specimens, from 54 patients; 2
and 3 isolates each were recovered from 2 patients. Clinical data were available for all
but 1 patient.The spatiotemporal distribution of the O80:H2 infections clearly indicates an increased
number of infections during the past 5 years (Figure
1). In 2014, the EHEC O80 serogroup was the second-leading cause of pediatric
HUS in France (). Most of the
cases occurred during summer and the beginning of autumn. Geographic distribution of
O80:H2 EHEC infections in France revealed high 10-year cumulative incidences
(>1/100,000) in Franche-Comté (2.83/100,000 children) and in
Rhône-Alpes (1.19/100,000 children), contrasting with the distribution of O157
infections, which are rarely detected in these areas (Figure 2).
Figure 1
Number of enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli O80:H2 strains
detected annually, France, January 2005–October 2014.
Figure 2
Regional 10-year cumulative incidence rates of hemolytic uremic syndrome cases
caused by enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli serotypes O157:H7
and O80:H2, France, January 2005–October 2014. A) Serotype O157:H7. B)
Serotype O80:H2. White, <0.5 cases/100,000 children; light gray shading,
0.5–0.7 cases/100,000 children; medium gray shading, 0.8–0.9
cases/100,000 children; dark gray shading, 1–2 cases/100,000 children;
black, >2 cases/100,000 children.
Number of enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli O80:H2 strains
detected annually, France, January 2005–October 2014.Regional 10-year cumulative incidence rates of hemolytic uremic syndrome cases
caused by enterohemorrhagic Escherichia coli serotypes O157:H7
and O80:H2, France, January 2005–October 2014. A) Serotype O157:H7. B)
Serotype O80:H2. White, <0.5 cases/100,000 children; light gray shading,
0.5–0.7 cases/100,000 children; medium gray shading, 0.8–0.9
cases/100,000 children; dark gray shading, 1–2 cases/100,000 children;
black, >2 cases/100,000 children.Among the 53 patients for whom clinical data were available, 48 (91%) had HUS; 27 (51%)
were male. Median age for these 48 patients was 1.2 years (range 0.2–39 years,
interquartile range [IQR] 0.7–1.6 years). Only 1 adult HUSpatient (a
39-year-old) was reported. The 5 (9%) non-HUSpatients were largely older (1, 2, 6, 21,
and 40 years old). Among HUSpatients, fever was present in 45%; median leukocyte count
was 13,000 cells/mm3 (data were not available for 14 patients), and 56% had
leukocytosis (>11,500 leukocytes/mm3) (Technical Appendix Table 3). Diarrheal illness was reported for 83%
of HUSpatients (bloody diarrhea for 30%); median time from onset of diarrhea to
diagnosis of HUS was 6 days (data available for 37 patients). Diarrheal illness in
family members was recorded in only 2 HUS cases. One patient had a relapse complicated
by bacteremia (), 1 patient died
after myocardial complication with pancreatic abscess from which an O80:H2 EHEC strain
was isolated, and 1 patient died from septic shock with intestinal necrosis and
peritonitis. Eight (17%) cases of neurologic complication (17%) were reported. All the
neurologic complications were seizures (documented in 6 cases by imaging) with ischemic
strokes. Among the 8 patients with neurologic complications, 2 died, and 1 has
difficulty concentrating (19 months after HUS); for 1 patient, the neurologic state
could not be assessed, and for 4 others, the neurologic outcome was favorable.Of the 48 patientsHUS, 27% needed acute dialysis support (median duration 10 days,
range 3–21 days, IQR 7.4–13.5 days), and 28% had long-term renal sequelae,
including proteinuria for all cases, hypertension in 3 cases, and chronic renal failure
in 1 case (median follow-up duration 8 months, range 1–108 months, IQR
2–41 months). Finally, only 21% of medical records mentioned the possible source
of infection, and no hypothesis could be formulated.Genetic characterization showed that all O80:H2 strains of human origin collected in
France carried the stx2 genes and no stx1 genes (Technical Appendix Table 3). The
stx2 subtype could not be determined for the 2 strains (isolated in
2006 and in 2010) because they had lost their stx2 gene despite
preservation at −80°C. Among the remaining strains, 69% had a combination
of stx2 variants, stx2c/2d (62%) and
stx2a/2d (7%); 31% harbored unique variants, stx2a
(22%) and stx2d (9%). All strains had the intimin encoding gene
eae and its variant eae-ξ, and 87% carried
the enterohemolysin ehxA gene. All 57 strains shared
>4 characteristic genes of the pS88 plasmid,
sitA, cia, hlyF, and
ompT; 98% had the iss and
iroN genes; 96% had the cvaA gene; and 61% had the
iucC and etsC genes (Technical Appendix Table 3).Antimicrobial drug susceptibility testing revealed that most strains were multidrug
resistant; rates of resistance were 91% for amoxicillin, 89% for nalidixic acid, 82% for
cotrimoxazole, and 71% for kanamycin (Technical
Appendix Table 3). Overall, 52% of the strains were resistant to all 4
antibiotics.To examine whether an animal could be the potential source of EHEC O80:H2, we solicited
the Laboratoire National de Réference pour les Escherichia coli.
Only 1 strain from an animal source (LNR-511-4, isolated from raw cow milk cheese) was
available. This strain carried eae-ξ, ehxA, and
stx2a genes and 7 genes associated with the pS88 plasmid related to
ExPEC (sitA, cia, iss, iroN, hlyF, cvaA, and
ompT). This strain also was resistant to amoxicillin,
kanamycin, and nalidixic acid.To investigate the distribution in Europe of this emerging EHEC serogroup, several
national reference laboratories in Europe were associated with this study and were asked
to send us their available EHEC O80 strains. We obtained 5 strains from Spain, whereas
Italy and Germany had no such strain in their collections. Among the 5 strains from
Spain, 3 were of human origin (IH42632/03a, IH33264/ 07a, and IH102878/12a) and 2 were
of animal origin (VTB-262 from a cow and FV4476 from a pig [the pig-origin strain was
actually isolated in Slovakia]) (). All 5 strains shared eae-ξ, but
stx2 (stx2a) was found in only 2 strains (both of
human origin), and none had ehxA. Only the 3 human strains harbored
most of the investigated genes associated with pS88. The contrast between animal strains
and human strains from the national reference laboratory in Spain was also evident in
their antibiotic-resistance profiles; only the human strains were multidrug resistant
(Technical Appendix Table 3).To analyze the genetic diversity and genetic relatedness with other EHEC serogroups, all
the O80:H2 strains were analyzed by using rep-PCR and compared with some other
serogroups (O157, O104, O111, and O121) (Figure 3).
All EHEC O80:H2 strains shared 95% similarity except strain IH102878/12a from Spain (90%
similarity). These data suggest that almost all EHEC O80 strains belong to a unique
clonal group, regardless of their geographic origin and source (human or animal). EHEC
O80:H2 strains were genetically distant to representative strains of serogroups O157,
O104, O111, and O121.
Figure 3
Dendrogram obtained after DiversiLab genotyping analysis (based on PCR
amplification of repeat sequences of DNA) of 56 enterohemorrhagic
Escherichia coli (EHEC) O80 strains from humans in France
compared with other isolates detected in France, Germany, and Spain, January
2005–October 2014. Other isolates include 1 animal-origin strain from
France (LNR511-4, bovine, 2012); 5 animal- and human-origin isolates from Spain
(FV4476, porcine; VTB-262, bovine; IH43632/03a, IH33264/07a, and IH 102878/12a,
human); and 6 comparison strains from other serogroups (EDL933 and 32031, O157;
32527 and 32573, O104, isolated during a 2011 outbreak in Germany; 36061, O121;
and 34593, O111). ID, identification.
Dendrogram obtained after DiversiLab genotyping analysis (based on PCR
amplification of repeat sequences of DNA) of 56 enterohemorrhagic
Escherichia coli (EHEC) O80 strains from humans in France
compared with other isolates detected in France, Germany, and Spain, January
2005–October 2014. Other isolates include 1 animal-origin strain from
France (LNR511-4, bovine, 2012); 5 animal- and human-origin isolates from Spain
(FV4476, porcine; VTB-262, bovine; IH43632/03a, IH33264/07a, and IH 102878/12a,
human); and 6 comparison strains from other serogroups (EDL933 and 32031, O157;
32527 and 32573, O104, isolated during a 2011 outbreak in Germany; 36061, O121;
and 34593, O111). ID, identification.To study the effect of antibiotics on Stx production in O80:H2 EHEC strains, we selected
4 representative strains (33115, 35344, 35431, and 36047) based on their genotypic and
clinical characteristics (Technical Appendix
Table 3). Strain EDL933 (O157:H7) served concomitantly as the control. We
examined susceptibility to the 3 antibiotics (Table). First, we estimated the basal production of Stx in different strains
after 18 h of growth without antibiotics (Figure
4). The basal production among the different O80:H2 strains were comparable but
significantly lower compared with that of strain EDL933, which produces ≈100-fold
more Stx than certain O80:H2 strains (35344 and 36047). We could not separately estimate
the respective rates of Stx1 and Stx2.
Table
Antibiotic susceptibility of enterohemorrhagic Escherichia
coli O80:H2 and O157:H7 isolates used in an antibiotics assay, France,
January 2005–October 2014
Isolate
(source)
Serotype
MIC,
µg/mL
Azithromycin
Ciprofloxacin
Ceftriaxone
35344 (stool)
O80:H2
1
0.5
0.25
35431 (blood)
O80:H2
16
0.5
0.06
33115 (pancreas)
O80:H2
16
0.25
0.06
36047 (stool)
O80:H2
16
0.06
0.06
EDL933 (ground beef)
O157:H7
32
0.12
0.12
Figure 4
Mean concentrations (logarithmic scale) of Shiga toxin produced in the absence of
antibiotics by selected strains of enterohemorrhagic Escherichia
coli serotypes O80, France, January 2005–October 2014. O157
reference strain (EDL933) was used as control. Error bars indicate SDs.
Mean concentrations (logarithmic scale) of Shiga toxin produced in the absence of
antibiotics by selected strains of enterohemorrhagic Escherichia
coli serotypes O80, France, January 2005–October 2014. O157
reference strain (EDL933) was used as control. Error bars indicate SDs.For each strain, we examined the influence of the 3 antibiotics at concentrations below
the MICs expressed as relative secretion of Stx compared with basal secretion (without
antibiotics) after 18 hours’ incubation period (Figure 5, panels A–E). Overall, azithromycin was responsible for
>5-fold decreases of Stx production in all O80:H2 strains
at a MIC of 0.5. As expected, the same effect was observed with the EDL933 strain. At
all concentrations tested, ciprofloxacin significantly induced a major increase of Stx
secretion for all strains except strain 35344. The increase was particularly marked for
O80:H2 strains compared with O157 strains; a 100-fold increase was observed for 33115
and 35431 (Figure 5, panels B and C), compared with
a 6-fold increase for EDL933 (Figure 5, panel E).
Ceftriaxone, in contrast with other antibiotics, did not significantly alter Stx
production except for 1 O80:H2 strain (Figure 5,
panel C).
Figure 5
Relative production rate of Shiga toxin produced in 5 strains of enterohemorrhagic
Escherichia coli (4 O80 strains and 1 O157 strain) at
subinhibitory concentrations of azithromycin, ciprofloxacin, and ceftriaxone,
compared with basal production rate (no antibiotics), France, January
2005–October 2014. A) Isolate 35344. B) Isolate 33115. C) Isolate 35431. D)
Isolate 36047. E) Isolate EDL933. Error bars indicate SDs.
Relative production rate of Shiga toxin produced in 5 strains of enterohemorrhagic
Escherichia coli (4 O80 strains and 1 O157 strain) at
subinhibitory concentrations of azithromycin, ciprofloxacin, and ceftriaxone,
compared with basal production rate (no antibiotics), France, January
2005–October 2014. A) Isolate 35344. B) Isolate 33115. C) Isolate 35431. D)
Isolate 36047. E) Isolate EDL933. Error bars indicate SDs.Finally, we wanted to determine whether the beneficial effect of azithromycin on Stx
production would persist in the presence of 2 other antibiotics, a combination which
might be used in cases of bacteremia. The combinations of antibiotics were tested on 2
O80:H2 strains (Figure 6). Azithromycin paired with
ciprofloxacin significantly reduces Stx production compared with ciprofloxacin alone.
However, this production was higher than that observed with azithromycin alone, and for
both strains, Stx levels were higher for azithromycin/ciprofloxacin compared with no
antibiotic. These data indicate that the macrolide might only partially inhibit the
noxious effect of ciprofloxacin. The effect of azithromycin in combination with
ceftriaxone depended on the strain tested. For strain 35344, the association slightly
increased Stx production compared with ceftriaxone, whereas for strain 33115, the
opposite was observed. However, in this experiment, the observed Stx rate was lower in
ceftriaxone and azithromycin/ceftriaxone assays compared with basal secretion.
Figure 6
Relative production rate of Shiga toxin produced in 2 strains of enterohemorrhagic
Escherichia coli O80 (isolates 35344 and 33115) at
subinhibitory concentrations of azithromycin, ciprofloxacin, ceftriaxone (alone
and in combination), compared to basal production rate (no antibiotics), France,
January 2005–October 2014. AZM, azithromycin; AZM/CIF,
azithromycin/ciprofloxacin; AZM/CRO, azithromycin/ceftriaxone; CIF, ciprofloxacin;
CRO, ceftriaxone. Error bars indicate SDs.
Relative production rate of Shiga toxin produced in 2 strains of enterohemorrhagic
Escherichia coli O80 (isolates 35344 and 33115) at
subinhibitory concentrations of azithromycin, ciprofloxacin, ceftriaxone (alone
and in combination), compared to basal production rate (no antibiotics), France,
January 2005–October 2014. AZM, azithromycin; AZM/CIF,
azithromycin/ciprofloxacin; AZM/CRO, azithromycin/ceftriaxone; CIF, ciprofloxacin;
CRO, ceftriaxone. Error bars indicate SDs.
Discussion
In this study, we described the emergence in France of a new virulent EHEC serotype,
O80:H2, that harbors singular genetic characteristics of a hybrid STEC/ExPEC pathotype.
Several important conclusions can be drawn.First, the EHEC O80:H2 strain appears to be at least as virulent as the EHEC O157:H7
strains present in France. Indeed, the rate of HUS-associated complications, such as
renal injuries (28%) and death (4%), of the O80:H2 strain were comparable with that of
O157:H7 (,). Moreover, EHEC O80:H2 isolates have the
particular properties to induce invasive infections; >2 of the
53 patients affected had bacteremia or deep abscess. Extraintestinal infections very
rarely are associated with EHEC; to our knowledge, only 6 cases of bacteremia have been
previously described in the context of HUS (). None of these 6 reports extensively searched for
extraintestinal virulence factors. Whether the extraintestinal virulence of EHEC O80:H2
is related to the presence of genetic traits characteristic of an extraintestinal
virulence–associated plasmid remains to be determined. Identification of the
salmochelin-encoding genes (iroN) in 98% of the EHEC O80:H2 from France
is of particular interest. This gene is clearly involved in the pathophysiology of
E. coli bacteremia and meningitis (,).Because the surveillance system for STEC is voluntary in France and because
stx-specific PCR is performed only in cases involving diarrhea with
HUS suspicion, accurate data are not available on the rates of diarrhea without HUS or
of bloodstream infections caused by this serotype and others. Only cases of diarrhea
occurring among HUSpatient contacts are systematically investigated. Therefore, many
cases of O80:H2-related diarrhea are probably undiagnosed, and we cannot draw any
conclusion concerning the risk for HUS in cases of diarrhea associated with STEC O80:H2.
Moreover, non-HUS cases of bacteremia caused by O80:H2 strains will escape
detection.We were not able to identify the potential source of this emerging EHEC pathotype. All
reported cases have been sporadic, and the possibility of foodborne infection remains
speculative, even though O80:H2 strains were isolated from few animals. The highest
incidence of O80:H2infection was observed in regions of France where EHEC O157
infections are not predominant, suggesting a possible atypical route or source of
infection. Although Spain does not share borders with the high-incidence regions of
France, it was the only country where a significant number of EHEC O80:H2 strains were
found. Two O80:H2 EHEC strains from Spain (IH102878/12a and IH33264/07a) were very
similar to French strains belonging to the same clonal group with a similar virulence
genotype, suggesting a direct lineage between the isolates in Spain and France. As is
usually observed for other serotypes, most of the infections with these strains occurred
during summer and the beginning of autumn (,).The molecular characterization of the EHEC O80:H2 strains was of particular interest.
The presence in all strains from Spain and France of the very rare
eae-ξ gene combined with results of the genetic diversity study
using rep-PCR strongly indicate that these strains, whatever their origin, have a common
ancestor combining the O80:H2 serotype and an eae-ξ gene
containing LEE. On this unique genetic background, several genetic events occurred: the
acquisition of >1 prophage encoding Stx, the presence of a
plasmid similar to that found in ExPEC, and the presence of a plasmid encoding
enterohemolysin. The chronology of these events remains speculative. However,
acquisition of Stx2-encoding genes seems to remain particularly active because 3
different variants in >4 different modes (in combination or
alone) were observed. The diversity of the extraintestinal virulence plasmidic genes
combination suggests the interplay of certain plasmidic determinants and intestinal
pathogenic traits. The minimal combination of plasmidic genes common to all strains was
the association of ompT and hlyF, which
might represent a beneficial influence on the intestinal pathogenic virulence of
E. coli O80:H2. Chromosomal ompT
and hlyF are involved in the secretion of outer membrane vesicles,
which might serve as transporters of toxins and thus might boost the virulence of
Stx-producing E. coli (,). Whether ompT has a similar
role remains to be further investigated.Finally, clinical features and molecular characterization indicating the potential
invasive pathogenicity of EHEC O80:H2 raise the question of which antibiotic should be
used in such infections. Several clinical studies have suggested a deleterious effect of
antibiotics during EHEC infection, leading to recommendations to not use such treatment
(). The major explanation of
such an adverse effect is the induction of Stx secretion through the SOS response, which
is stimulated by antibiotics such as fluoroquinolones in vitro and in experimental
models (,). Several studies demonstrated that the effect
of antibiotics on HUS depends on their class (,–). Ciprofloxacin raises the production and release of
Stx in vitro and is associated with a higher mortality rate in pigs (). Other studies have shown that
some antibiotics such as azithromycin might be associated with a decrease of the
production and release of Stx in vitro () and with favorable outcomes in in vivo studies in
piglets and mice (,). Finally, during a 2011
outbreak of EHEC O104 infection in Germany, a patient treated by ciprofloxacin plus
imipenem unexpectedly had a better prognosis than all others (). This result suggests that response to
antibiotics might also differ depending of the strain involved ().Our analysis of Stx production in the presence of antibiotics has clearly indicated that
ciprofloxacin should not be used in cases of EHEC O80 infection. In contrast,
azithromycin provided a beneficial in vitro effect and might be useful in cases of EHEC
O80–associated diarrhea. These results are consistent with the systematic review
by Agger et al. (), who
concluded that a protein synthesis inhibitor can be considered during EHEC infections
when specific criteria are met. To our knowledge, only a few studies have tested the
effect of antibiotics in combination (,). Our combination assay results would suggest that
azithromycin plus ceftriaxone might be a reasonable choice in cases of systemic
infection.These findings should be regarded as preliminary and require confirmation. However,
despite these promising in vitro results and because our assays were performed without
measuring cytotoxicity, we cannot yet advocate the use of these antibiotics for
treatment of patients infected with EHEC O80:H2. However, a planned national clinical
trial in France (NCT02336516) to test the efficacy of azithromycin in children with
postdiarrheal HUS might soon provide some answers.In conclusion, a clonal group of EHEC O80:H2 strains of unknown origin and with the
ability to induce invasive infections and lethality is emerging in France and represents
a new therapeutic challenge. The interplay between intestinal and extraintestinal
virulence factors in this new hybrid STEC/ExPEC pathotype remains to be elucidated.
Azithromycin might be a possible option to prevent invasive infections caused by EHEC
O80:H2, whereas azithromycin/ceftriaxone might be useful in treating such
infections.
Technical Appendix
Primers used and process applied for the enterohemorrhagic Escherichia
coli serogroup O multiplex PCR, clinical features of enterohemorrhagic
E. coli O80:H2 infections in France, and phenotypic and
genetic characterization of O80:H2 isolates from France and Spain, January
2005–October 2014.
Authors: Elias A Rahal; Natalie Kazzi; Ahmad Sabra; Alexander M Abdelnoor; Ghassan M Matar Journal: Ann Clin Microbiol Antimicrob Date: 2011-09-12 Impact factor: 3.944
Authors: Lisa Fierz; Nicole Cernela; Elisabeth Hauser; Magdalena Nüesch-Inderbinen; Roger Stephan Journal: Front Microbiol Date: 2017-08-03 Impact factor: 5.640
Authors: Kioa L Wijnsma; Anne M Schijvens; John W A Rossen; A M D Mirjam Kooistra-Smid; Michiel F Schreuder; Nicole C A J van de Kar Journal: Pediatr Nephrol Date: 2017-03-25 Impact factor: 3.714