PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to compare C11 choline and F18 FDG PET/CT, gadoxeticenhanced 3T MRI and contrastenhanced CT for diagnosis of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twelve chronic hepatitis B patients suspected of having HCC by abdominal ultrasonography received all diagnostic modalities performed within a oneweek timeslot. PET/CT results were analyzed visually by two independent nuclear medicine physicians and quantitatively by tumor to background ratio (T/B). Nine patients then had histopathological confirmation. RESULTS: Six patients had well differentiated HCC, while two and one patient(s) were noted with moderately and poorly differentiated HCC, respectively. All were detected by both CT and MRI with an average tumor size of 5.7±3.8 cm. Five patients had positive C11 choline and F18 FDG uptake. Of the remaining four patients, three with well differentiated HCC showed negative FFDG uptake (one of which showed negative results by both tracers) and one patient with moderately differentiated HCC demonstrated no C11 choline uptake despite intense F18 FDG avidity. The overall HCC detection rates with C11 choline and F18 FDG were 78% and 67%, respectively, while the sensitivity of F18 FDG for nonwell differentiated HCC was 100%, compared with 83% of C11 choline. The average T/B of C11 choline in welldifferentiated HCC patients was higher than in moderately and poorly differentiated cases (p=0.5) and vice versa with statistical significance for T/B of F18 FDG (p = 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggested better detection rate in C11 choline for well differentiated HCC than F18 FDG PET. However, the overall detection rate of PET/CT with both tracers could not compare with contrastenhanced CT and MRI.
PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to compare C11choline and F18 FDG PET/CT, gadoxeticenhanced 3T MRI and contrastenhanced CT for diagnosis of hepatocellular carcinoma (HCC). MATERIALS AND METHODS: Twelve chronic hepatitis Bpatients suspected of having HCC by abdominal ultrasonography received all diagnostic modalities performed within a oneweek timeslot. PET/CT results were analyzed visually by two independent nuclear medicine physicians and quantitatively by tumor to background ratio (T/B). Nine patients then had histopathological confirmation. RESULTS: Six patients had well differentiated HCC, while two and one patient(s) were noted with moderately and poorly differentiated HCC, respectively. All were detected by both CT and MRI with an average tumor size of 5.7±3.8 cm. Five patients had positive C11choline and F18 FDG uptake. Of the remaining four patients, three with well differentiated HCC showed negative FFDG uptake (one of which showed negative results by both tracers) and one patient with moderately differentiated HCC demonstrated no C11choline uptake despite intense F18 FDG avidity. The overall HCC detection rates with C11choline and F18 FDG were 78% and 67%, respectively, while the sensitivity of F18 FDG for nonwell differentiated HCC was 100%, compared with 83% of C11choline. The average T/B of C11choline in welldifferentiated HCC patients was higher than in moderately and poorly differentiated cases (p=0.5) and vice versa with statistical significance for T/B of F18 FDG (p = 0.02). CONCLUSIONS: Our results suggested better detection rate in C11choline for well differentiated HCC than F18 FDG PET. However, the overall detection rate of PET/CT with both tracers could not compare with contrastenhanced CT and MRI.
Authors: Saleh A Alqahtani; Faisal M Sanai; Ashwaq Alolayan; Faisal Abaalkhail; Hamad Alsuhaibani; Mazen Hassanain; Waleed Alhazzani; Abdullah Alsuhaibani; Abdullah Algarni; Alejandro Forner; Richard S Finn; Waleed K Al-Hamoudi Journal: Saudi J Gastroenterol Date: 2020-10 Impact factor: 2.485