D Węziak-Białowolska1. 1. European Commission Joint Research Centre, Directorate Competences, Modelling, Indicators & Impact Evaluation Unit, Via E. Fermi 2749, 21027 Ispra, VA, Italy. Electronic address: dorota.bialowolska@gmail.com.
Abstract
OBJECTIVES: Although there is strong uptake of active or passive engagement with the cultural and creative activities as determinants of individual health, well-being and social participation, few population studies report any causal influence on self-reported and physical health or life satisfaction from voluntary engagement with the arts (playing an instrument or singing, painting, sculpture) or passive cultural participation (attending the cinema, theatre, opera and exhibitions). This study set out to investigate any potential derived benefits to the Swiss population. STUDY DESIGN: The 2010 and 2013 waves of the Swiss Household Panel study were used for analysis. The data are representative for the Swiss population aged 14 years and older with respect to major demographic variables. METHODS: Using longitudinal data, the strengths of the two approaches to evaluating causal inference were simultaneously applied: propensity score matching and difference-in-differences. Propensity score matching attempted to eliminate selection bias by conditioning on confounding variables. Difference-in-differences estimator was applied to remove unobserved fixed effects via intra-individual comparisons over time by comparing the trends in a matched treatment and control group. RESULTS: The study showed that voluntary cultural activity-of any type, passive or active-did not seem to have any causative influence on health and well-being. Results showed that long-term health and well-being did not improve significantly as a result of any specific activity in the cultural arena. CONCLUSIONS: The investigation provided little evidence to justify health promotion messages for involvement with the arts. Nevertheless, these findings do not contest that active or passive participation in cultural- and arts-related activities may be beneficial to health and well-being when guided by qualified therapists to treat specific health-related problems.
OBJECTIVES: Although there is strong uptake of active or passive engagement with the cultural and creative activities as determinants of individual health, well-being and social participation, few population studies report any causal influence on self-reported and physical health or life satisfaction from voluntary engagement with the arts (playing an instrument or singing, painting, sculpture) or passive cultural participation (attending the cinema, theatre, opera and exhibitions). This study set out to investigate any potential derived benefits to the Swiss population. STUDY DESIGN: The 2010 and 2013 waves of the Swiss Household Panel study were used for analysis. The data are representative for the Swiss population aged 14 years and older with respect to major demographic variables. METHODS: Using longitudinal data, the strengths of the two approaches to evaluating causal inference were simultaneously applied: propensity score matching and difference-in-differences. Propensity score matching attempted to eliminate selection bias by conditioning on confounding variables. Difference-in-differences estimator was applied to remove unobserved fixed effects via intra-individual comparisons over time by comparing the trends in a matched treatment and control group. RESULTS: The study showed that voluntary cultural activity-of any type, passive or active-did not seem to have any causative influence on health and well-being. Results showed that long-term health and well-being did not improve significantly as a result of any specific activity in the cultural arena. CONCLUSIONS: The investigation provided little evidence to justify health promotion messages for involvement with the arts. Nevertheless, these findings do not contest that active or passive participation in cultural- and arts-related activities may be beneficial to health and well-being when guided by qualified therapists to treat specific health-related problems.
Authors: Mihaela Ghența; Aniela Matei; Luise Mladen-Macovei; Elen-Silvana Bobârnat Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2022-05-20 Impact factor: 4.614
Authors: Andy Hau Yan Ho; Stephanie Hilary Xinyi Ma; Moon-Ho Ringo Ho; Joyce Shu Min Pang; Emily Ortega; Ram Bajpai Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2019-11-21 Impact factor: 2.692