| Literature DB >> 27453625 |
Muhammad Kashif Mughal1, Carla S Ginn1, Robert L Perry2, Karen M Benzies1.
Abstract
We explored longitudinal effects of a two-generation preschool programme on receptive language scores in children (n = 78) at age 10 years, living with low income. Scores at four time-points, programme intake, exit, age 7, and age 10 years were measured using the Peabody picture vocabulary test (3rd ed.). Effects of culture (Aboriginal, other Canadian-born, and recent immigrant), and gender of the children were explored. Between programme intake and age 10, scores improved significantly, F(3, 75) = 21.11, p < .0005. There were significant differences among cultural groups at all time-points except age 10. Scores differed significantly for girls, but not boys, at age 10, F = 5.11, p = .01. Recent immigrant boys reached the Canadian average, while girls were two-thirds of the standard deviation below average. Early intervention programmes must include a focus on the unique circumstances of recent immigrant girls; supportive transition workers in schools are one recommendation.Entities:
Keywords: Preschool children; cross-cultural comparison; family; poverty
Year: 2015 PMID: 27453625 PMCID: PMC4940896 DOI: 10.1080/03004430.2015.1092141
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Early Child Dev Care ISSN: 0300-4430
Socio-demographic characteristics and percentages of PPVT III scores in clinical range.
| Aboriginal | Other Canadian-born | Recent immigrant | All | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Variables | Frequency (%) | Frequency (%) | Frequency (%) | Frequency (%) | ||||
| Gender (% male) | 21 | 11(52) | 29 | 15(52) | 28 | 14(50) | 78 | 40(51) |
| Child age (months) | 21 | 129(21.7) | 29 | 121.7(4.7) | 28 | 120.5(3.6) | 78 | 123.2(12.1) |
| PPVT III % in clinical range at intake | 21 | 6(29) | 29 | 6(21) | 28 | 14(50) | 78 | 26(33) |
| PPVT III % in clinical range at exit | 21 | 4(19) | 29 | 2(7) | 28 | 8(29) | 78 | 14(18) |
| PPVT III % in clinical range at age 7 | 21 | 4(19) | 29 | 4(14) | 28 | 9(32) | 78 | 17(22) |
| PPVT III % in clinical range at age 10 | 21 | 2(10) | 29 | 2(7) | 28 | 7(25) | 78 | 11(14) |
| Caregiver age (years) | 15 | 39.9(7.2) | 22 | 40.7(6.5) | 18 | 41.4(6.2) | 55 | 40.7(6.5) |
| Partnered | 11 | 7(64) | 17 | 11(65) | 16 | 10(63) | 44 | 28(64) |
| Completed high school | 11 | 6(55) | 20 | 17(85) | 18 | 15(83) | 49 | 38 (78) |
| File opened with child welfare as a child | 15 | 10(67) | 22 | 6(27) | 18 | 0(0) | 55 | 16(29) |
Note: PPVT III = Peabody picture vocabulary test (3rd ed.).
aSample size varied due to missing; 78 children with 56 caregivers.
PPVT III mean scores by cultural groups at four time-points.
| Aboriginal | Other Canadian-born | Recent Immigrant | All | |||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PPVT III scores | ||||||||
| Intake | 21 | 86.90(16.97) | 29 | 95.48(14.38)a | 28 | 80.39(17.38)a | 78 | 87.76(17.27)* |
| Exit | 21 | 98.38(13.26) | 29 | 102.14(10.53)a | 28 | 93.32(11.44)a | 78 | 97.96(12.09) |
| Seven years | 21 | 97.10(11.41) | 29 | 100.76(13.22)a | 28 | 91.93(13.74)a | 78 | 96.60(13.35) |
| Ten years | 21 | 97.90(9.18) | 29 | 100.62(11.25) | 28 | 95.25(12.43) | 78 | 97.96(11.29)* |
Note: PPVT III = Peabody picture vocabulary test (3rd ed.).
a Post hoc analyses showed significant differences between groups.
*p < .001.
PPVT III mean scores by gender at four time-points.
| Aboriginal boys | Other Canadian-born boys | Recent immigrant boys | Aboriginal girls | Other Canadian-born girls | Recent immigrant girls | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| PPVT III scores | ||||||
| Intake | 84.64(19.06) | 96.13(14.73) | 86.14(17.28) | 89.40(14.93) | 94.79(14.52)a | 74.64(16.04)a,* |
| Exit | 97.00(12.82) | 103.93(11.38) | 96.43(12.50) | 99.90(14.25) | 100.21(9.57) | 90.21(9.72)* |
| Seven years | 100.82(11.06) | 101.60(14.81) | 97.86(13.20) | 93.00(10.86) | 99.86(11.77)a | 86.00(11.93)a,* |
| Ten years | 97.73(9.42) | 98.20(9.52) | 100.29(13.19) | 98.10(9.42) | 103.21(12.69)a | 90.21(9.60)a,* |
Note: PPVT III = Peabody picture vocabulary test (3rd ed.).
a Post hoc analyses showed significant differences between groups.
*p < .05.