Bruce J Kimura1, Sean M Sliman2, Jill Waalen3, Stan A Amundson2, David J Shaw2. 1. Department of Graduate Medical Education, Scripps Mercy Hospital, San Diego, California. Electronic address: kimura.bruce@scrippshealth.org. 2. Department of Graduate Medical Education, Scripps Mercy Hospital, San Diego, California. 3. Scripps Translational Science Institute, San Diego, California.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Although the growth of point-of-care ultrasound has resulted in a proliferation of teaching programs, few data exist on the maintenance of proficiency. The aim of this study was to evaluate the retention of cardiac ultrasound skills and training in physicians up to 7 years after a formal focused curriculum in residency. METHODS: Thirty internal medicine physicians, deemed proficient at graduation and having passed a practical examination that confirms imaging skills and knowledge base when a score of ≥80% correct is attained, were retested. Twenty graduates (the NOPREP group) did not study any relevant material, and 10 graduates (the PREP group) were encouraged to study online videos. Scores were categorized by length of time (1-7 years) from graduates' last performance of ultrasound. RESULTS: The mean original test score of the physicians was 90 ± 6%. With retesting NOPREP (n = 20), seven physicians were within 1 year of their last use, and five (71%) repassed the examination, scoring 80 ± 15%. Among the remaining 13 NOPREP physicians who had >1 year of nonuse, none repassed, scoring 58 ± 17%. In retesting PREP (n = 10), one physician was within 1 year of last use and repassed, scoring 95%. Among the remaining nine PREP physicians with >1 year since last use, three (33%) repassed (P = .05), scoring 72 ± 21%. Diagnostic knowledge was significantly higher when good-quality images were obtained. CONCLUSIONS: Learned skills in cardiac ultrasound diminish notably within 2 years of nonuse.
BACKGROUND: Although the growth of point-of-care ultrasound has resulted in a proliferation of teaching programs, few data exist on the maintenance of proficiency. The aim of this study was to evaluate the retention of cardiac ultrasound skills and training in physicians up to 7 years after a formal focused curriculum in residency. METHODS: Thirty internal medicine physicians, deemed proficient at graduation and having passed a practical examination that confirms imaging skills and knowledge base when a score of ≥80% correct is attained, were retested. Twenty graduates (the NOPREP group) did not study any relevant material, and 10 graduates (the PREP group) were encouraged to study online videos. Scores were categorized by length of time (1-7 years) from graduates' last performance of ultrasound. RESULTS: The mean original test score of the physicians was 90 ± 6%. With retesting NOPREP (n = 20), seven physicians were within 1 year of their last use, and five (71%) repassed the examination, scoring 80 ± 15%. Among the remaining 13 NOPREP physicians who had >1 year of nonuse, none repassed, scoring 58 ± 17%. In retesting PREP (n = 10), one physician was within 1 year of last use and repassed, scoring 95%. Among the remaining nine PREP physicians with >1 year since last use, three (33%) repassed (P = .05), scoring 72 ± 21%. Diagnostic knowledge was significantly higher when good-quality images were obtained. CONCLUSIONS: Learned skills in cardiac ultrasound diminish notably within 2 years of nonuse.
Authors: Philippe Vignon; Benjamin Pegot; François Dalmay; Vanessa Jean-Michel; Simon Bocher; Erwan L'her; Jérôme Cros; Gwenaël Prat Journal: Intensive Care Med Date: 2018-06-21 Impact factor: 17.440
Authors: Andrew H Wu; Harshika Chowdhary; Matthew Fischer; Ali Salehi; Tristan Grogan; Louis Saddic; Jacques Neelankavil; Reed Harvey Journal: J Educ Perioper Med Date: 2022-04-01
Authors: Victor Galusko; Mohammed Yunus Khanji; Owen Bodger; Clive Weston; John Chambers; Adrian Ionescu Journal: J Cardiovasc Ultrasound Date: 2017-09-29