Andrea B Troxel1, David A Asch2, Kevin G Volpp2. 1. Department of Biostatistics and Epidemiology, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA atroxel@mail.med.upenn.edu. 2. Department of Medicine, Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, USA US Department of Veterans Affairs, Philadelphia, PA, USA.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Randomized clinical trials provide gold-standard evidence for the efficacy of interventions, but have limitations, including highly selected populations that make inference on effectiveness difficult and a lack of ability to adapt and change midstream. METHODS: We propose two innovations for pragmatic trial design. RESULTS: Evidence-based evolutionary testing, a framework that allows adaptation of interventions and rapid-cycle innovation, preserves the power of randomization while acknowledging the need for adaptation and learning. An opt-out consent framework increases the fraction of the target population who participate in trials, but may lead to dampening of effect sizes. CONCLUSION: Pragmatic trials offer numerous advantages in the evaluation of behavioral interventions in health. Statistical innovations, including evidence-based evolutionary testing and opt-out framing of consent and enrollment processes, can enhance the power of pragmatic trials and lead to more rapid progress.
BACKGROUND: Randomized clinical trials provide gold-standard evidence for the efficacy of interventions, but have limitations, including highly selected populations that make inference on effectiveness difficult and a lack of ability to adapt and change midstream. METHODS: We propose two innovations for pragmatic trial design. RESULTS: Evidence-based evolutionary testing, a framework that allows adaptation of interventions and rapid-cycle innovation, preserves the power of randomization while acknowledging the need for adaptation and learning. An opt-out consent framework increases the fraction of the target population who participate in trials, but may lead to dampening of effect sizes. CONCLUSION: Pragmatic trials offer numerous advantages in the evaluation of behavioral interventions in health. Statistical innovations, including evidence-based evolutionary testing and opt-out framing of consent and enrollment processes, can enhance the power of pragmatic trials and lead to more rapid progress.
Authors: Niteesh K Choudhry; Jerry Avorn; Robert J Glynn; Elliott M Antman; Sebastian Schneeweiss; Michele Toscano; Lonny Reisman; Joaquim Fernandes; Claire Spettell; Joy L Lee; Raisa Levin; Troyen Brennan; William H Shrank Journal: N Engl J Med Date: 2011-11-14 Impact factor: 91.245
Authors: David F Blackburn; Roy T Dobson; James L Blackburn; Thomas W Wilson; Mary Rose Stang; William M Semchuk Journal: Can J Cardiol Date: 2005-05-01 Impact factor: 5.223
Authors: David A Asch; Andrea B Troxel; Walter F Stewart; Thomas D Sequist; James B Jones; AnneMarie G Hirsch; Karen Hoffer; Jingsan Zhu; Wenli Wang; Amanda Hodlofski; Antonette B Frasch; Mark G Weiner; Darra D Finnerty; Meredith B Rosenthal; Kelsey Gangemi; Kevin G Volpp Journal: JAMA Date: 2015-11-10 Impact factor: 56.272
Authors: Andrea B Troxel; David A Asch; Shivan J Mehta; Laurie Norton; Devon Taylor; Tirza A Calderon; Raymond Lim; Jingsan Zhu; Daniel M Kolansky; Brian M Drachman; Kevin G Volpp Journal: Am Heart J Date: 2016-07-08 Impact factor: 5.099
Authors: Rinad S Beidas; Emily M Becker-Haimes; Danielle R Adams; Laura Skriner; Rebecca E Stewart; Courtney Benjamin Wolk; Alison M Buttenheim; Nathaniel J Williams; Patricia Inacker; Elizabeth Richey; Steven C Marcus Journal: Implement Sci Date: 2017-12-15 Impact factor: 7.327
Authors: Aurélie Affret; Amandine Luc; Cédric Baumann; Pierre Bergman; Anne-Laurence Le Faou; Anne Pasquereau; Pierre Arwidson; François Alla; Linda Cambon Journal: BMJ Open Date: 2020-10-27 Impact factor: 2.692
Authors: Katharine Lawrence; Danissa V Rodriguez; Dawn M Feldthouse; Donna Shelley; Jonathan L Yu; Hayley M Belli; Javier Gonzalez; Sumaiya Tasneem; Jerlisa Fontaine; Lisa L Groom; Son Luu; Yinxiang Wu; Kathleen M McTigue; Bonny Rockette-Wagner; Devin M Mann Journal: JMIR Res Protoc Date: 2021-02-09