| Literature DB >> 27338427 |
Luís Pereira-da-Silva1,2, Carla Rêgo3,4,5, Angelo Pietrobelli6,7.
Abstract
This systematic review discusses data on the dietary intake of preschool children living in the Mediterranean countries of the European Union, including the comparison with a Mediterranean-like diet and the association with nutritional status. Specifically, data from the multinational European Identification and Prevention on Dietary and life style induced health effects in children and infants (IDEFICS) study and national studies, such as the Estudo do Padrão Alimentar e de Crescimento Infantil (EPACI) study and Geração XXI cohort in Portugal, ALimentando la SAlud del MAñana (ALSALMA) study in Spain, Étude des Déterminants pré-et postnatals précoces du développement et de la santé de l'ENfant (EDEN) cohort in France, Nutrintake 636 study in Italy, and Growth, Exercise and Nutrition Epidemiological Study in preSchoolers (GENESIS) cohort in Greece, were analyzed. In the majority of countries, young children consumed fruit and vegetables quite frequently, but also consumed sugared beverages and snacks. High energy and high protein intakes mainly from dairy products were found in the majority of countries. The majority of children also consumed excessive sodium intake. Early high prevalence of overweight and obesity was found, and both early consumption of energy-dense foods and overweight seemed to track across toddler and preschool ages. Most children living in the analyzed countries showed low adherence to a Mediterranean-like diet, which in turn was associated with being overweight/obese. Unhealthier diets were associated with lower maternal educational level and parental unemployment. Programs promoting adherence of young children to the traditional Mediterranean diet should be part of a multi-intervention strategy for the prevention and treatment of pediatric overweight and obesity.Entities:
Keywords: European Union; Mediterranean countries; Mediterranean dietary pattern; dietary intake; overweight and obesity; preschool children
Mesh:
Year: 2016 PMID: 27338427 PMCID: PMC4924029 DOI: 10.3390/ijerph13060572
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health ISSN: 1660-4601 Impact factor: 3.390
Multi-national European cohort studies investigating dietary habits, in comparison to the Mediterranean diet-like pattern, and weight status of preschool children, including those living in Mediterranean countries of the European Union.
| Author, Year (Reference) | Study Design/Name of the Study | Countries | Age | Sample Size | Outcome | Instruments | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| De Lauzon-Guillain | Multi-national European birth cohort study | Four European countries, including the Mediterranean countries France, Portugal, and Greece | 2–4 years | British ALSPAC cohort | Influence of early feeding practices on later fruit and vegetable intake in preschool children | FFQ | Breastfeeding for a longer period after birth was related to higher fruit and vegetable intake. In the Mediterranean cohorts, the mean fruit and vegetable intakes (servings/day) at 2-year old were respectively: 1.3 and 1.1 in the French cohort, and 1.1 and 0.7 in Greek cohort; and at 4 years old, 1.7 and 3.3 in the Portuguese cohort. |
| Hebestreit | Multi-national European cohort study “IDEFICS” | Eight countries, including the Mediterranean countries Italy, Cyprus, and Spain | Subsample 2–5 years | Mediterranean subgroup, | Associations between proxy-reported energy intake, daily food intake, and EDF with BMI z-score | fMDS Anthropometry | Proxy-reporters are subject to misreporting, in particular for children in the higher BMI levels. Energy intake is a more important predictor of unhealthy weight development in children than the daily food intake. |
| Hebestreit | Multi-national European cohort study “IDEFICS” | Eight countries, including the Mediterranean countries Italy, Cyprus, and Spain | Subsample 2–5 years | Mediterranean subgroup, | Description of energy density of dietary intake | 24-h dietary recalls plus school meal assessments | In the pre-school Mediterranean children subgroup, the mean food density was 1.81 Kcal/g from exclusively solid foods, and 1.27 Kcal/g from solid foods The daily intake from beverages was 284 Kcal. |
| Tognon | Multi-national European cohort study “IDEFICS” | Eight countries, including the Mediterranean countries Italy, Cyprus, and Spain | 2–9 years | Mediterranean subgroup recalls, | Adherence to a Mediterranean-like diet | 24-h dietary recalls on frequency of consumption of 43 foods fMDS | High adherence to a Mediterranean-like diet in children aged 2–5 years: Italy: girls 55.0%, boys 55.9% Spain: girls 37.1%, boys 32.3% Cyprus: girls 29.5%, boys 33.9% |
| Tognon | Multi-national European cohort study “IDEFICS” | Eight countries, including the Mediterranean countries Italy, Cyprus, and Spain | 2–9 years | Association between Mediterranean-like diet and overweight/obesity | fMDS Anthropometry | High fMDS levels at baseline protected against increases in BMI, waist circumference, and waist-to-height ratio, with a similar trend for percent fat mass. Parental education and high parental income were determinants of high fMDS levels. | |
| Ahrens | Multi-national European cohort study “IDEFICS” | Eight countries, including the Mediterranean countries Italy, Cyprus, and Spain | 2–10 years | Mediterranean subgroup, | Assessment of prevalence of overweight and obesity in European children | International Obesity Task Force (2012) weight categories | Higher prevalence of overweight and obesity was found in the Mediterranean countries, respectively: 25.0% and 17.4% in Italy, 15.5% and 7.2% in Cyprus, and 14.3% and 10.0% in Spain 17. Overall, population groups with low income and/or lower education levels showed the highest prevalence of obesity. |
Legend: BMI body mass index, EDF energy-dense foods, FFQ food-frequency questionnaire, fMDS frequency-based Mediterranean Diet Score.
National data on dietary habits and weight status of preschool children living in Mediterranean countries of the European Union.
| Country | Author, Year (Reference) | Study Design/Name of the Study | Age/Sample Size | Outcome | Tools | Results |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Cyprus | Hebestreit | Multi-national European cohort study “IDEFICS” | Subgroup 2–5 years Cypriot subsample | Associations between proxy-reported energy intake, daily food intake and EDF | fMDS | Consumption of mean energy densities: 1.87 Kcal/g exclusively from solid foods. 1.44 Kcal/g from solid foods |
| France | Fantino | National cross-sectional survey | 1–3 years | Assessment of energy and nutrient intake and adequacy of diet | 3-day weighed food records Conversion into intakes of energy and nutrients according to food composition databases | In relation to EAR, the mean daily energy intake was slightly higher up to 7 months of age, and lower after 1-year of age. Globally, the diet was adequate for a large proportion of children and satisfied most of their nutritional requirements. Mean daily intake of energy, protein, fat, and carbohydrate were adequate. Mean daily intake of sodium, calcium, magnesium, phosphorus and B group vitamins were above the DRI. Intake of alpha-linolenic acid, vitamin E, vitamin C, iron, and zinc was inadequate in some of children over 1-year of age. |
| Lioret | Mother–child cohort “EDEN” cross-sectional study at 2, 3, and 5 years of age | 2-years → 5-years | Assessment of dietary patterns at 2, 3, and 5 years of age. | FFQ | Dietary patterns identified at 2-years old: “Processed and fast foods”, positively correlated with French fries, processed meat, carbonated soft drinks, chocolate, chips, cookies, pizza, fruit juice, meat, dairy desserts, and ice cream; “Guidelines”, characterized by frequent consumption of cooked vegetables, rice, fresh fruit, raw vegetables, low-fat fish, potatoes, ham, stewed fruit, and meat; and “Baby foods”, positively correlated with baby foods, breakfast cereals, and stewed fruit. Moderate correlation coefficients were found between similar patterns across the 3 assessed ages. The “Processed and fast foods” at the 3 ages was inversely associated with maternal education and age, and positively associated with the presence of older siblings. The “Guidelines” at 2, 3, and 5-years was predicted by maternal education. | |
| Greece | Manios | Cross-sectional study on a sample of GENESIS cohort | 1–5 years | Assessments of nutrient adequacy of the diets and the nutritional status | 2-day weighed food records FFQ Anthropometry | In the pooled sample the prevalence of “at risk of overweight” and “overweight” was 16.7% and 16.4%, respectively; and the mean usual energy intake was 117% of the mean estimated energy requirement. The “at risk of being overweight” and “overweight” children had significantly higher mean daily energy intakes than their normal-weight counterparts. “Overweight” children consumed more energy from total fat and saturated fat and less from carbohydrate. The usual protein intake was within the AMDR, but 21.0% of children had lower intakes for carbohydrate and 59.5% higher intakes for fat. The estimated prevalence of inadequacy was between 10% and 25% for niacin, vitamin E and folate, and usual intakes exceeding the tolerable upper intake levels were recorded for Zn and Cu. |
| Manios | Cross-sectional study on a sample of GENESIS cohort | 2–5 years | Assessments of diet quality and socio-demographic factors related to it. Development of the “Healthy Eating Index “ | Weighed food records 24-h recalls Food diaries | About 80% of children had a poor diet (low Healthy Eating Index score), associated with low fruit, vegetable, and grains intake and high saturated fat intake. Poor diet was associated with lower levels of physical activity, lower maternal educational level, and unemployment status. | |
| Manios | Cross-sectional study on a sample of GENESIS cohort | 2–5 years | Development of a diet–lifestyle quality index for young children and its relation to obesity (Preschoolers Diet-Lifestyle Index—PDL-Index) | Weighed food records 24-h recalls Food diaries | Eleven components were scored 0 to 4, the total PDL-Index ranging from 0 to 44. Children following healthier diet-lifestyle patterns (third tertile of the PDL-Index) were less likely to be obese/overweight than those following unhealthy diet-lifestyle patterns (first tertile of the PDL-Index). | |
| Italy | Verduci | Single-center birth cohort | 1-year → 10-years | Assessment of dietary energy and macronutrient intakes and comparison with recommended dietary allowances | FFQ | At preschool ages At 1-year old: the mean total daily energy intake was 94 Kcal/Kg; the mean %TEV were 48.3% from carbohydrate, 33.6% from lipids, and 20.4% from protein. At 5-years old: the mean total daily energy intake was 119 Kcal/Kg; the mean %TEV were 57% from carbohydrate, 32% from lipids, and 15% from protein. Compared with the Italian recommended dietary allowances, the protein intake was high at any age analyzed and the energy intake was high at 5-years. In the longitudinal pattern, boys had significantly higher energy intake and glycemic load. |
| Hebestreit | Multi-national European cohort study “IDEFICS” | Subgroup 2–5 years Italian subsample | Associations between proxy-reported energy intake, daily food intake and EDF | fMDS | Consumption of mean energy densities: 2.24 Kcal/g exclusively from solid foods. 1.61 Kcal/g from solid foods | |
| Zuccotti | Cross-sectional study “NUTRINTAKE” | 6 Months–3 years | Comparison of the dietary intake between children living in North and South Italy | 7-day weighed food records Anthropometry | In the pooled sample: normal anthropometry and energy intake were found, despite high intake of proteins, simple carbohydrates, saturated fats, and sodium, and low intake of iron and fiber. Anthropometry, energy, and macronutrient intakes were similar in North and South Italy; in North, iron intake was 27% lower and fiber intake 16% higher than in South. | |
| Malta | Buttigieg | Cross-sectional study | 3-years | Associations between: Parenteral and childhood obesity Maternal awareness of public health promotion on healthy eating and parenteral and childhood obesity | Face-to-face interviews Anthropometry | Significant association was found between childhood obesity and obesity in either of the parents. Full maternal awareness of healthy eating promotion appeared to have a protective effect against the development of childhood obesity/overweight. |
| Portugal | Rêgo | Cross-sectional national study “EPACI” | Evaluation of feeding pattern and weight status | FFQ 3-days food diary Anthropometry | Daily intakes were: fresh fruit 93%, vegetables 99%, sugared beverages 17%, and sugared desserts 10%. Mean daily energy intake was 1200 Kcal; %TEV from carbohydrates 49.9%, from fat 28.5%, and from protein 18.2%. The foods mostly contributing to total energy intake were dairy products (28%), cereals (15%), and meat (13%). Mean daily protein intake was 4.5 g/Kg. The foods mostly contributing to total protein intake were dairy products (36%), meat (28%), and fish (13%). Mean daily sodium intake was 1843 mg; 87.3% of children exceeded the upper recommended limit. Absence of inadequacy except for vitamin E (all sample), and folate and B1 at 12–23 months Prevalence of overweight 31.4% with 6.5% of obesity | |
| Lopes | Cross-sectional regional study, on a sample of Geração XXI birth cohort | Evaluation of feeding pattern and weight status | FFQ and food diaries Anthropometry | Daily consumption was: fruits 86%, vegetables 92%, cakes and candies 65%, and sugared beverages 52%; 73% consumed salty snacks 1–4 times/week. Main sources of saturated fatty acids were dairy products 33.4%, meat 20.7%, and savory pastries and sugared desserts 14.7%. Excessive sodium intake was found in 99%. Insufficient intakes were found for vitamin D in 100%, vitamin E in 98.6%, folate in 21.5%, and calcium in 7.0%. Prevalence of overweight was 13.8%, and obesity 6.2%. | ||
| Vilela | Cross-sectional regional study, on a sample of Geração XXI birth cohort | Association between socioeconomic characteristics and family structure and consumption of EDF | FFQ EDF groups: soft drinks; sweets; cakes; and salty snacks | Lower EDF consumption was associated with: High socioeconomic characteristics. Influence from parents’ background and from the preceding generations. Absence of older siblings. | ||
| Vilela | Longitudinal regional study, using a sample of Geração XXI birth cohort | Association between the consumption of EDF at 2 years old and the consumption of foods and diet quality at 4 years old | FFQ EDF groups: soft drinks; sweets; cakes; and salty snacks Healthy eating index for 4 years old children | The consumption of EDF at 2-years old was negatively associated with the diet quality at 4-years old. Higher intakes of soft drinks, salty snacks, and sweets at 2-years old were associated with lower consumption of fruit and vegetables at 4 years old. | ||
| Durão | Longitudinal regional study, on a sample of Geração XXI birth cohort | Association between consumption of EDF at 2 years old and BMI at 4 years old | FFQ Anthropometry Cross-lagged panel design | No association was found between consumption of EDF at 2-years old and BMI at 4-years old. Both the consumption of EDF and BMI z-scores tracked across toddler and preschool ages. | ||
| Durão | Cross-sectional regional study on a sample of Geração XXI birth cohort | Association between maternal perceived responsibility and child feeding practices and dietary inadequacy | Mothers self-completed: The Child Feeding Questionnaire A scale on covert and overt control | Children whose mothers had higher levels of covert control, monitoring, and restriction were less likely to consume fruits and vegetables below recommendations and EDF above tolerable limits. Higher pressure to eat was associated with higher possibility of children consuming dairy above recommendations. | ||
| Spain | Dalmau | Cross-sectional study “ALSALMA” | Comparison of the nutritional patterns with the recommendations | Dietary diary on food intake on 4 non-consecutive days | Mean energy intake was 123%–124% higher than the DRI for 13–36 months of age. Mean percentage of protein intake increased with age, being 370% and 441% higher than the adequate intake for 13–24 months and 25–36 months of age, respectively. Higher percentages in daily intake of proteins and carbohydrates and lower percentage of total lipids were significantly related to a greater BMI, regardless of energy intake. Proportions of children with deficient micronutrient intakes for 13–24 months and 25–36 months of age were respectively: 81.7% and 92.1% for vitamin D; 39.3% and 53.4% for vitamin E; 12.5% and 14.8% for folic acid; 10.1% and 5.5% for calcium; and 27.1% and 31% for iodine. | |
| Hebestreit | Multi-national European cohort study “IDEFICS” | Spanish subsample | Associations between proxy-reported energy intake, daily food intake and EDF | fMDS | Consumption of mean energy densities: 1.67 Kcal/g exclusively from solid foods 1.16 Kcal/g from solid foods |
Legend: %TEV percentage of total energy value; AMDR acceptable macronutrient distribution ranges; BMI body mass index; DRI daily recommended intakes; EAR estimated average requirement; EDF energy-dense foods; FFQ food-frequency questionnaire; FFQ food-frequency questionnaire; fMDS frequency-based Mediterranean Diet Score; PDL-Index Preschoolers Diet-Lifestyle Index.