| Literature DB >> 27171398 |
M J Pont1, M W Honders1, A N Kremer1,2, C van Kooten3, C Out4, P S Hiemstra5, H C de Boer6, M J Jager7, E Schmelzer8, R G Vries9, A S Al Hinai10, W G Kroes11, R Monajemi12, J J Goeman12,13, S Böhringer12, W A F Marijt1, J H F Falkenburg1, M Griffioen1.
Abstract
Cellular immunotherapy has proven to be effective in the treatment of hematological cancers by donor lymphocyte infusion after allogeneic hematopoietic stem cell transplantation and more recently by targeted therapy with chimeric antigen or T-cell receptor-engineered T cells. However, dependent on the tissue distribution of the antigens that are targeted, anti-tumor responses can be accompanied by undesired side effects. Therefore, detailed tissue distribution analysis is essential to estimate potential efficacy and toxicity of candidate targets for immunotherapy of hematological malignancies. We performed microarray gene expression analysis of hematological malignancies of different origins, healthy hematopoietic cells and various non-hematopoietic cell types from organs that are often targeted in detrimental immune responses after allogeneic stem cell transplantation leading to graft-versus-host disease. Non-hematopoietic cells were also cultured in the presence of IFN-γ to analyze gene expression under inflammatory circumstances. Gene expression was investigated by Illumina HT12.0 microarrays and quality control analysis was performed to confirm the cell-type origin and exclude contamination of non-hematopoietic cell samples with peripheral blood cells. Microarray data were validated by quantitative RT-PCR showing strong correlations between both platforms. Detailed gene expression profiles were generated for various minor histocompatibility antigens and B-cell surface antigens to illustrate the value of the microarray dataset to estimate efficacy and toxicity of candidate targets for immunotherapy. In conclusion, our microarray database provides a relevant platform to analyze and select candidate antigens with hematopoietic (lineage)-restricted expression as potential targets for immunotherapy of hematological cancers.Entities:
Mesh:
Substances:
Year: 2016 PMID: 27171398 PMCID: PMC4865094 DOI: 10.1371/journal.pone.0155165
Source DB: PubMed Journal: PLoS One ISSN: 1932-6203 Impact factor: 3.240
Fig 1Validation of the cell type origin of (non-)hematopoietic samples.
Probe fluorescence as measured by microarray gene expression analysis is depicted on the x-axis in logarithmic scale. (A) Gene expression for various cell type-associated genes as determined by microarray gene expression analysis is shown. Hepatocyte-specific expression is shown for APOA2, ORM1, FGA and ALB and melanocyte-specific expression is shown for MLANA, SILV, TYRP1 and TYR. Fibroblasts-associated expression as defined by detectable expression in fibroblasts as well as a limited number of other non-hematopoietic cell types is shown for FBLN2, CD248, ITGA11 and THY1 and keratinocyte-associated expression is demonstrated for KRT14, LAMA3, KLK5 and DSG3. Fibroblasts, FB; keratinocytes, KC. (B) Gene expression for monocytes and dendritic cells (DC) is shown (left graph) as well as for immature and mature DC (right graph). Down-regulation of CD14 and up-regulation of CD86, CD209 and CCL22 is shown for DC (filled bars) cultured from monocytes (open bars) with GM-CSF and IL-4 (left graph). To validate maturation of DC, down-regulation of markers for immature DC (CCL13 and CD36) and up-regulation of markers for mature DC (LAMP3, HLA-DOB, FLT3, CD80, CD83 and HLA-DQA1) was checked (right graph). Immature DC (imDC) are depicted by squares and mature DC (matDC) are indicated by circles. Red symbols indicate samples which have been excluded from the dataset for incomplete maturation. (C) Various non-hematopoietic cell types (fibroblasts, keratinocytes, PTEC, melanocytes and HUVEC) were cultured in the presence of IFN-γ (100 IU/ml) for 4 days to mimic inflammation. Expression of various genes that are known to be induced by IFN-γ is shown (GBP2, IFITM1), including genes that are involved in HLA processing and presentation (TAP1, CD74, PSMB9 and HLA-DRA). Circles represent samples cultured without IFN-γ, while squares indicate samples after IFN-γ treatment. Red symbols indicate samples which have been excluded from the dataset for incomplete maturation.
Characteristics of leukemic cells selected for microarray gene expression analysis.
| AML 2467 (CD33/CD14) | PB | Acute myeloid leukemia with inv(16)(p13.1q22); | trisomy 8, trisomy 14, trisomy 21 | ||||||
| AML 1310 (CD33/CD14) | PB | Acute myeloid leukemia with inv(16)(p13.1q22); | - | ||||||
| AML 3097 (CD33) | BM | Acute promyelocytic leukemia with t(15;17)(q22;q12); | |||||||
| AML 2179 (CD33) | PB | Acute promyelocytic leukemia with t(15;17)(q22;q12); | - | ||||||
| AML 1591 (CD33) | PB | Acute promyelocytic leukemia with t(15;17)(q22;q12); | |||||||
| AML 1466 (CD33/CD14) | BM | Acute myeloid leukemia with t(9;11) (p22q23); | - | ||||||
| AML 4781 (CD33/CD14) | PB | Acute myeloid leukemia with inv(3)(q21q26.2); | |||||||
| AML 587 (CD33) | BM | Acute myeloid leukemia with mutated | |||||||
| AML 2536 (CD33) | BM | Acute myeloid leukemia with mutated | - | ||||||
| AML 4443 (CD33) | PB | Acute myeloid leukemia with mutated | |||||||
| AML 6395 (CD33) | PB | Acute myeloid leukemia with mutated | - | ||||||
| AML 3370 (CD33) | PB | Acute myeloid leukemia with mutated | - | ||||||
| AML 5205 (CD33/CD14) | PB | Acute myeloid leukemia with mutated | |||||||
| AML 3590 (CD33) | PB | t-AML | - | ||||||
| AML 3714 (CD33) | BM | AML-NOS, with minimal differentiation | complex | ||||||
| AML 5596 (CD33) | BM | AML-NOS, without maturation | - | ||||||
| AML 3778 (CD33) | PB | AML-NOS, without maturation | complex | ||||||
| AML 3870 (CD33) | BM | AML-NOS, with maturation | trisomy 8 | ||||||
| AML 6283 (CD33) | BM | AML-NOS, with maturation | |||||||
| AML 1143 (CD33) | PB | AML-NOS, acute monoblastic leukemia | - | ||||||
| AML 3009 (CD33) | BM | AML-NOS, acute monoblastic leukemia | |||||||
| AML 5074 (CD33/CD14) | PB | AML-NOS, acute monoblastic leukemia | complex | ||||||
| ALL 2391 (CD19) | BM | B Lymphoblastic leukemia NOS | trisomy 5 | ||||||
| ALL 2872 (CD19) | BM | B Lymphoblastic leukemia NOS | - | ||||||
| ALL 1299 (CD19) | BM | B Lymphoblastic leukemia NOS | del(6) (q21q23), del(Y) | ||||||
| ALL 3281 (CD19) | PB | B Lymphoblastic leukemia NOS | - | ||||||
| ALL 5903 (CD19) | BM | B Lymphoblastic leukemia with t(9;22)(q34;q11.2); | complex | ||||||
| ALL 3639 (CD19) | BM | B Lymphoblastic leukemia with t(9;22)(q34;q11.2); | trisomy 5, trisomy 8 | ||||||
| ALL 2375 (CD19) | BM | B Lymphoblastic leukemia with t(4;11) (q21;q23); | - | ||||||
| ALL 1833 (CD19) | PB | B Lymphoblastic leukemia with t(11;19) (q23;p13.3); | - | ||||||
| ALL 3655 (CD19) | BM | B Lymphoblastic leukemia with hyperdiploidy | complex | ||||||
| CML 3471 (CD34) | BM | Chronic myelogenous leukemia, | del (9q); complex | ||||||
| CML 5036 (CD34) | PB | Chronic myelogenous leukemia, | t(2;9;22) (p13;q34;q11) | ||||||
| CML 3087 (CD34) | BM | Chronic myelogenous leukemia, | del (Xp), del (17q); complex | ||||||
| CML 4779 (CD34) | BM | Chronic myelogenous leukemia, | - | ||||||
| CML 1303 (CD34) | BM | Chronic myelogenous leukemia, | - | ||||||
| CLL 1695 (CD19/CD5) | BM | Chronic lymphocytic leukemia | absent | del/del | del | normal | |||
| CLL 4725 (CD19/CD5) | BM | Chronic lymphocytic leukemia | absent | del | normal | del | |||
| CLL 5535 (CD19/CD5) | PB | Chronic lymphocytic leukemia | absent | del | normal | normal | |||
| CLL 6242 (CD19/CD5) | PB | Chronic lymphocytic leukemia | absent | normal | normal | del | |||
| CLL 2159 (CD19/CD5) | PB | Chronic lymphocytic leukemia | absent | del/del | normal | normal | |||
| MM 5987 (CD38) | BM | Plasma cell myeloma | hyperdiploid | +9, +15 | +1q | del | normal | t(4;14)(p16;q32) | absent |
| MM 5744 (CD38) | BM | Plasma cell myeloma | diploid | absent | +1q | del | normal | t(4;14)(p16;q32) | absent |
| MM 6622 (CD38) | BM | Plasma cell myeloma | diploid | absent | normal | normal | normal | normal | absent |
| MM 4298 (CD38) | BM | Plasma cell myeloma | diploid | -15 | normal | del | del | t(4;14)(p16;q32) | absent |
| MM 5019 (CD38) | BM | Plasma cell myeloma | diploid | absent | normal | del | normal | t(11;14)(q13;q32) | absent |
a Markers for flow cytometric isolation of malignant cells are indicated between brackets. AML cells have been isolated by expression of CD33 (CD33) or a combination of CD33 and CD14 (CD33/CD14) in which CD33 expressing AML cells positive or negative for monocyte lineage differentiation marker CD14 have been selected as two separate cell populations. CLL cells have been selected for co-expression of CD19 and CD5. ALL, CML and MM cells have been isolated by expression of CD19, CD34 and CD38, respectively.
b Origin of sample either peripheral blood (PB) or bone marrow (BM) mononuclear cells.
c WHO classification as described by Swerdlow et al, 2008.
d Other abnormalities include numerical abnormalities, CEBPA mutations, FLT3-ITD, or EVI1 overexpression.
e Partial del(6q?) in fraction of the cells.
f Complex karyotypes are depicted in S1 Table.
g CML in blast crisis.
h CML in chronic phase.
i Genetic abnormalities as detected by FISH for CLL or MM.
j del/del; homozygous deletion.
R2 values for regression analysis between microarray and q-PCR.
| Gene | Probe 1 | Probe 2 | Maximum expression in dataset | R2 | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Probe 1 | Probe 2 | Probe average | ||||
| ILMN_1689655 | ILMN_2157441 | 15.03 | 14.61 | 14.82 | ||
| ILMN_1751079 | 14.78 | |||||
| ILMN_1701308 | 14.75 | |||||
| ILMN_1740015 | ILMN_2396444 | 13.20 | 14.80 | 14.00 | ||
| ILMN_1706635 | 13.87 | |||||
| ILMN_1732799 | ILMN_2341229 | 13.59 | 13.54 | 13.57 | ||
| ILMN_1782704 | 13.49 | |||||
| ILMN_1753584 | 13.16 | |||||
| ILMN_1747622 | 11.66 | |||||
| ILMN_1753584 | 11.55 | |||||
| ILMN_1677793 | 11.09 | |||||
| ILMN_1721344 | 10.88 | 0.326 | ||||
| ILMN_1728199 | 10.76 | 0.409 | ||||
| ILMN_1759184 | ILMN_2383484 | 11.34 | 10.11 | 10.73 | 0.266 | |
| ILMN_1811392 | 10.11 | |||||
| ILMN_1663538 | 9.30 | 0.487 | ||||
| ILMN_1655904 | 9.20 | |||||
| ILMN_1688034 | 8.65 | -0.001 | ||||
| ILMN_1776939 | 8.62 | 0.320 | ||||
| ILMN_1755862 | 8.61 | 0.216 | ||||
| ILMN_2340217 | ILMN_1653652 | 8.07 | 8.78 | 8.43 | 0.347 | |
| ILMN_2219466 | 8.23 | 0.652 | ||||
| ILMN_1788166 | 8.09 | 0.545 | ||||
| ILMN_1802174 | 8.00 | |||||
a R2 values for individual genes were calculated from the regression model.
b Official gene symbols are depicted for genes as included in the q-PCR validation set.
c Illumina probe IDs as measured in the microarray database.
d Maximum probe fluorescence as measured by microarray gene expression analysis in the sample set for q-PCR validation.
e Average of maximum probe fluorescence is given for genes with more than 1 probe.
f R2 >0.667 are bold.
g MS4A1 is also known as CD20.
h PTPRC is also known as CD45.
Fig 2Effect of IFN-γ on gene expression in non-hematopoietic cell types.
Microarray gene expression analysis was performed on fibroblasts, keratinocytes, PTEC, melanocytes and HUVEC cultured in the presence of IFN-γ and probe fluorescence was compared with the same cell samples cultured in the absence of IFN-γ. All probes that were >10-fold up-regulated after IFN-γ treatment in one or more cell types are depicted. Probe fluorescence is shown on the y-axis in logarithmic scale. Circles show gene expression in the absence of IFN-γ, while squares indicate expression in the presence of IFN-γ. For each cell type, the number of probes that are >10-fold up-regulated by IFN-γ is shown.
Gene expression in skin fibroblasts as induced by IFN-γ and T-cell supernatant.
| Probe ID | Gene | Fibroblasts | Fibroblasts + IFN-γ | Fold Increase | Fibroblasts | Fibroblasts + T-sup | Fold Increase | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| AVG | SD | AVG | SD | AVG | SD | AVG | SD | ||||
| ILMN_1705247 | 71,48 | 18,18 | 915,69 | 4,61 | 57,07 | 5,64 | 410,79 | 21,92 | |||
| ILMN_1756862 | 127,45 | 50,12 | 1744,54 | 88,76 | 126,02 | 3,27 | 1215,58 | 198,99 | |||
| ILMN_1720048 | 405,52 | 320,65 | 566,98 | 379,69 | 1,40 | 146,88 | 58,76 | 3739,10 | 578,67 | ||
| ILMN_2098126 | 56,56 | 5,03 | 87,02 | 7,13 | 1,54 | 80,04 | 4,21 | 1448,07 | 17,78 | ||
| ILMN_1773352 | 55,04 | 4,49 | 70,60 | 14,72 | 1,28 | 52,54 | 0,90 | 564,89 | 13,32 | ||
| ILMN_1772964 | 79,79 | 26,74 | 654,98 | 396,22 | 76,86 | 23,08 | 1092,76 | 27,37 | |||
| ILMN_1736567 | 105,73 | 53,25 | 4540,97 | 791,32 | 59,62 | 4,58 | 6697,04 | 438,61 | |||
| ILMN_2379644 | 77,73 | 31,38 | 1627,96 | 282,95 | 46,04 | 4,27 | 3008,86 | 137,93 | |||
| ILMN_1761464 | 51,45 | 1,29 | 730,79 | 41,60 | 45,18 | 2,03 | 518,30 | 79,50 | |||
| ILMN_2047511 | 187,61 | 62,18 | 1916,52 | 1491,98 | 94,46 | 27,37 | 664,84 | 489,58 | |||
| ILMN_1791759 | 51,04 | 4,63 | 178,24 | 64,32 | 3,49 | 54,72 | 1,54 | 1600,24 | 844,80 | ||
| ILMN_1745356 | 48,55 | 4,44 | 303,32 | 131,99 | 41,91 | 1,69 | 5149,88 | 3359,40 | |||
| ILMN_2388547 | 124,13 | 41,46 | 1691,41 | 606,22 | 165,03 | 48,22 | 2084,78 | 643,31 | |||
| ILMN_1701114 | 183,62 | 52,59 | 2569,15 | 182,46 | 182,31 | 43,53 | 3793,63 | 414,77 | |||
| ILMN_2148785 | 143,83 | 37,33 | 1191,59 | 6,56 | 274,42 | 56,92 | 5802,20 | 1534,56 | |||
| ILMN_1774077 | 745,66 | 345,68 | 17626,86 | 2385,66 | 582,62 | 90,58 | 7100,17 | 300,24 | |||
| ILMN_1771385 | 48,49 | 2,67 | 903,78 | 21,36 | 57,47 | 0,85 | 1439,61 | 406,66 | |||
| ILMN_2114568 | 56,21 | 4,33 | 1124,80 | 148,70 | 48,52 | 1,19 | 1189,30 | 25,32 | |||
| ILMN_1803945 | 91,78 | 15,97 | 892,47 | 51,92 | 71,62 | 1,81 | 936,66 | 97,71 | |||
| ILMN_1778401 | 1305,90 | 484,58 | 9930,80 | 649,29 | 1354,92 | 495,95 | 15916,89 | 2069,86 | |||
| ILMN_1695311 | 542,10 | 87,50 | 7641,55 | 2580,39 | 355,31 | 31,05 | 3309,74 | 1393,47 | |||
| ILMN_1761733 | 89,92 | 32,72 | 2127,14 | 1065,96 | 66,70 | 10,93 | 930,50 | 471,41 | |||
| ILMN_1659075 | 51,01 | 4,51 | 897,08 | 186,07 | 51,14 | 1,29 | 312,10 | 118,38 | |||
| ILMN_1772218 | 160,29 | 7,45 | 3916,33 | 585,53 | 119,74 | 3,57 | 2708,72 | 724,98 | |||
| ILMN_1808405 | 59,19 | 9,86 | 887,82 | 661,25 | 41,27 | 0,96 | 870,79 | 606,77 | |||
| ILMN_1689655 | 176,76 | 126,36 | 12566,25 | 3920,68 | 93,09 | 0,69 | 4449,93 | 1823,37 | |||
| ILMN_2157441 | 138,34 | 86,70 | 5530,45 | 687,54 | 62,36 | 1,05 | 5817,44 | 2067,78 | |||
| ILMN_1715169 | 49,64 | 3,33 | 302,36 | 253,61 | 51,16 | 0,40 | 880,52 | 833,29 | |||
| ILMN_1752592 | 97,08 | 25,57 | 3135,67 | 1486,29 | 59,02 | 1,21 | 2467,91 | 384,34 | |||
| ILMN_1697499 | 73,82 | 26,82 | 826,23 | 777,15 | 48,12 | 0,54 | 1122,44 | 1073,92 | |||
| ILMN_2066060 | 56,77 | 0,82 | 317,56 | 109,15 | 60,67 | 1,64 | 812,22 | 438,83 | |||
| ILMN_2066066 | 52,33 | 1,69 | 192,74 | 48,32 | 3,68 | 48,40 | 2,49 | 988,46 | 215,83 | ||
| ILMN_1723912 | 63,42 | 5,51 | 1192,97 | 174,91 | 64,62 | 10,67 | 1230,95 | 168,61 | |||
| ILMN_2347798 | 212,00 | 45,36 | 2234,49 | 782,87 | 664,54 | 215,55 | 12733,61 | 8737,71 | |||
| ILMN_1739428 | 148,34 | 6,69 | 2190,73 | 666,22 | 333,39 | 47,93 | 2205,74 | 1097,87 | |||
| ILMN_1701789 | 309,27 | 24,42 | 5293,10 | 106,34 | 248,64 | 35,15 | 2465,82 | 954,09 | |||
| ILMN_1664543 | 61,94 | 6,84 | 500,90 | 52,90 | 111,53 | 4,69 | 1162,56 | 556,31 | |||
| ILMN_2334296 | 124,90 | 13,66 | 3132,98 | 608,04 | 68,50 | 2,03 | 2266,51 | 1379,17 | |||
| ILMN_2368530 | 54,42 | 6,19 | 149,61 | 4,61 | 2,75 | 109,67 | 4,68 | 1873,74 | 978,51 | ||
| ILMN_1656310 | 48,99 | 9,14 | 523,11 | 154,06 | 45,64 | 0,65 | 5685,52 | 4062,65 | |||
| ILMN_1708375 | 498,42 | 212,95 | 2664,97 | 295,19 | 277,69 | 29,54 | 4185,18 | 822,05 | |||
| ILMN_1662358 | 198,75 | 6,86 | 10822,34 | 4316,73 | 671,64 | 353,82 | 6055,89 | 2475,95 | |||
| ILMN_1701613 | 291,17 | 134,16 | 9431,88 | 2494,20 | 190,98 | 15,69 | 4008,61 | 1773,14 | |||
| ILMN_1751079 | 1184,40 | 16,21 | 13220,08 | 1203,62 | 824,61 | 168,64 | 6181,11 | 527,53 | |||
| ILMN_1678841 | 49,97 | 2,18 | 76,70 | 15,87 | 1,53 | 52,95 | 1,42 | 1077,09 | 664,73 | ||
| ILMN_1727271 | 1219,84 | 167,93 | 18566,63 | 8233,61 | 364,88 | 11,13 | 7669,97 | 593,84 | |||
| ILMN_2337655 | 1267,64 | 209,92 | 13887,52 | 4384,17 | 508,79 | 30,61 | 11333,68 | 2227,47 | |||
Illumina probe IDs as included in the microarray database.
b Official gene symbols are depicted for genes that are >10-fold up-regulated by IFN-γ, T-cell supernatant or both.
c AVG and SD are the average and standard deviation of probe fluorescence as measured in different fibroblast samples, respectively.
d Fold increase was calculated from the average probe fluorescence as measured in fibroblasts after pre-treatment with IFN-γ or T-cell supernatant divided by the average probe fluorescence in the corresponding fibroblast samples cultured without cytokines. Values in bold indicate >10-fold upregulated gene expression by IFN-γ, T-cell supernatant or both.
e T-sup; T-cell supernatant harvested from an activated CD4 T-cell clone containing high levels of inflammatory cytokines.
Fig 3Gene expression profiles for potential targets for immunotherapy of hematological malignancies.
Gene expression profiles were generated for hematopoiesis-restricted minor histocompatibility antigens and B-cell specific surface antigens as potential targets for immunotherapy of hematological malignancies. (A) Gene expression profiles for minor histocompatibility antigens HA-1 (HMHA1), LB-ARHGDIB-1R (ARHGDIB) and LB-ITGB2-1 (ITGB2). (B) Gene expression profiles for B-cell specific antigens CD19, CD79B and ROR1. Probe fluorescence intensity is shown on the x-axis in logarithmic scale. On the y-axis malignant and healthy (non-)hematopoietic cell types as included in the microarray dataset are shown. Each dot represents a different sample and the mean and standard deviation of gene expression is shown for each cell type.