Literature DB >> 27141969

Hidden costs: The ethics of cost-effectiveness analyses for health interventions in resource-limited settings.

Sarah E Rutstein1,2, Joan T Price3, Nora E Rosenberg4,5, Stuart M Rennie6, Andrea K Biddle1, William C Miller2,5.   

Abstract

Cost-effectiveness analysis (CEA) is an increasingly appealing tool for evaluating and comparing health-related interventions in resource-limited settings. The goal is to inform decision-makers regarding the health benefits and associated costs of alternative interventions, helping guide allocation of limited resources by prioritising interventions that offer the most health for the least money. Although only one component of a more complex decision-making process, CEAs influence the distribution of health-care resources, directly influencing morbidity and mortality for the world's most vulnerable populations. However, CEA-associated measures are frequently setting-specific valuations, and CEA outcomes may violate ethical principles of equity and distributive justice. We examine the assumptions and analytical tools used in CEAs that may conflict with societal values. We then evaluate contextual features unique to resource-limited settings, including the source of health-state utilities and disability weights, implications of CEA thresholds in light of economic uncertainty, and the role of external donors. Finally, we explore opportunities to help align interpretation of CEA outcomes with values and budgetary constraints in resource-limited settings. The ethical implications of CEAs in resource-limited settings are vast. It is imperative that CEA outcome summary measures and implementation thresholds adequately reflect societal values and ethical priorities in resource-limited settings.

Entities:  

Keywords:  Cost-effectiveness analysis; equity; ethics; resource-limited settings

Mesh:

Year:  2016        PMID: 27141969      PMCID: PMC5303190          DOI: 10.1080/17441692.2016.1178319

Source DB:  PubMed          Journal:  Glob Public Health        ISSN: 1744-1692


  46 in total

1.  The global burden of disease disability weights.

Authors:  J Jelsma; V G Chivaura; K Mhundwa; W De Weerdt; P de Cock
Journal:  Lancet       Date:  2000-06-10       Impact factor: 79.321

2.  Allocating funds for HIV/AIDS: a descriptive study of KwaDukuza, South Africa.

Authors:  Arielle Lasry; Michael W Carter; Gregory S Zaric
Journal:  Health Policy Plan       Date:  2010-06-15       Impact factor: 3.344

3.  Cost-effectiveness analysis: is it ethical?

Authors:  A Williams
Journal:  J Med Ethics       Date:  1992-03       Impact factor: 2.903

4.  Cost-value analysis of health interventions: introduction and update on methods and preference data.

Authors:  Erik Nord
Journal:  Pharmacoeconomics       Date:  2015-02       Impact factor: 4.981

5.  Dollars may not buy as many QALYs as we think: a problem with defining quality-of-life adjustments.

Authors:  D G Fryback; W F Lawrence
Journal:  Med Decis Making       Date:  1997 Jul-Sep       Impact factor: 2.583

Review 6.  Cost-effectiveness of HIV/AIDS interventions in Africa: a systematic review of the evidence.

Authors:  Andrew Creese; Katherine Floyd; Anita Alban; Lorna Guinness
Journal:  Lancet       Date:  2002-05-11       Impact factor: 79.321

Review 7.  Defining equity in health.

Authors:  P Braveman; S Gruskin
Journal:  J Epidemiol Community Health       Date:  2003-04       Impact factor: 3.710

8.  Criteria for priority-setting in health care in Uganda: exploration of stakeholders' values.

Authors:  Lydia Kapiriri; Ole Frithjof Norheim
Journal:  Bull World Health Organ       Date:  2004-04-16       Impact factor: 9.408

9.  Is cost-effectiveness analysis preferred to severity of disease as the main guiding principle in priority setting in resource poor settings? The case of Uganda.

Authors:  Lydia Kapiriri; Trude Arnesen; Ole Frithjof Norheim
Journal:  Cost Eff Resour Alloc       Date:  2004-01-08

10.  Guidance on priority setting in health care (GPS-Health): the inclusion of equity criteria not captured by cost-effectiveness analysis.

Authors:  Ole F Norheim; Rob Baltussen; Mira Johri; Dan Chisholm; Erik Nord; DanW Brock; Per Carlsson; Richard Cookson; Norman Daniels; Marion Danis; Marc Fleurbaey; Kjell A Johansson; Lydia Kapiriri; Peter Littlejohns; Thomas Mbeeli; Krishna D Rao; Tessa Tan-Torres Edejer; Dan Wikler
Journal:  Cost Eff Resour Alloc       Date:  2014-08-29
View more
  8 in total

1.  Variation in the methodological approach to productivity cost valuation: the case of prostate cancer.

Authors:  Paul Hanly; Rebecca Maguire; Frances Drummond; Linda Sharp
Journal:  Eur J Health Econ       Date:  2019-08-23

2.  The validity of cost-effectiveness analyses of tight glycemic control. A systematic survey of economic evaluations of pharmacological interventions in patients with type 2 diabetes.

Authors:  Francisco J Barrera; Freddy Jk Toloza; Oscar J Ponce; Jorge A Zuñiga-Hernandez; Larry J Prokop; Nilay D Shah; Gordon Guyatt; Rene Rodriguez-Gutierrez; Victor M Montori
Journal:  Endocrine       Date:  2020-09-21       Impact factor: 3.633

3.  Informing road traffic intervention choices in South Africa: the role of economic evaluations.

Authors:  Hadley K H Wesson; Nkuli Boikhutso; Adnan A Hyder; Melanie Bertram; Karen J Hofman
Journal:  Glob Health Action       Date:  2016-07-06       Impact factor: 2.640

4.  Cost-Effectiveness of Pre-exposure HIV Prophylaxis During Pregnancy and Breastfeeding in Sub-Saharan Africa.

Authors:  Joan T Price; Stephanie B Wheeler; Lynda Stranix-Chibanda; Sybil G Hosek; D Heather Watts; George K Siberry; Hans M L Spiegel; Jeffrey S Stringer; Benjamin H Chi
Journal:  J Acquir Immune Defic Syndr       Date:  2016-08-01       Impact factor: 3.731

5.  Exploring the ethics of global health research priority-setting.

Authors:  Bridget Pratt; Mark Sheehan; Nicola Barsdorf; Adnan A Hyder
Journal:  BMC Med Ethics       Date:  2018-12-06       Impact factor: 2.652

6.  Utilitarianism and the ethical foundations of cost-effectiveness analysis in resource allocation for global health.

Authors:  Elliot Marseille; James G Kahn
Journal:  Philos Ethics Humanit Med       Date:  2019-04-03       Impact factor: 2.464

Review 7.  Economic value of protected areas via visitor mental health.

Authors:  Ralf Buckley; Paula Brough; Leah Hague; Alienor Chauvenet; Chris Fleming; Elisha Roche; Ernesta Sofija; Neil Harris
Journal:  Nat Commun       Date:  2019-11-12       Impact factor: 14.919

8.  Values are not enough: qualitative study identifying critical elements for prioritization of health equity in health systems.

Authors:  Thea van Roode; Bernadette M Pauly; Lenora Marcellus; Heather Wilson Strosher; Sana Shahram; Phuc Dang; Alex Kent; Marjorie MacDonald
Journal:  Int J Equity Health       Date:  2020-09-15
  8 in total

北京卡尤迪生物科技股份有限公司 © 2022-2023.