| Literature DB >> 27123244 |
Eirini Manthou1, Kalliopi Georgakouli1, Ioannis G Fatouros2, Christina Gianoulakis3, Yannis Theodorakis4, Athanasios Z Jamurtas1.
Abstract
Excessive alcohol use can cause harmful effects on the human body, which are associated with serious health problems, and it can also lead to the development of alcohol use disorders (AUDs). There is certain evidence that physical exercise positively affects excessive alcohol use and the associated problems by leading to reduced alcohol intake. A literature search was conducted using the databases PubMed, Medline and Web of Science. The search terms used as keywords were: Addiction, abuse, alcohol use disorders, exercise training, β-endorphin, opioids, brain, ethanol and alcohol. The current study presents the studies that reported on the use of exercise in the treatment of AUDs between 1970 and 2015. The potential psychological and physiological mechanisms that contribute to the action of exercise were also reviewed, highlighting the role of β-endorphin and the hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis in AUDs and the possible association among physical activity, the endogenous opioid system and the desire for alcohol. Only 11 studies were identified that refer to the effect of exercise on alcohol consumption and/or the associated outcomes. Six of those studies concluded that exercise may have a positive impact towards alcohol consumption, abstinence rates or the urge to drink. One of those studies also indicated that a bout of exercise affects the endogenous opioids, which may be associated with the urge to drink. Another 3 studies indicated that responses to acute exercise in individuals with AUDs are different compared to those in healthy ones. Generally, despite limited research data and often contradictory results, there is certain early promising evidence for the role of exercise as an adjunctive tool in the treatment of AUDs. Physiological and biochemical parameters that would confirm that exercise is safe for individuals with AUDs should be examined in future studies.Entities:
Keywords: alcoholism; brain; ethanol; exercise training; opioids; β-endorphin
Year: 2016 PMID: 27123244 PMCID: PMC4840498 DOI: 10.3892/br.2016.626
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Biomed Rep ISSN: 2049-9434
Studies on the effects of exercise on heavy drinking and alcohol dependence.
| Study (year) | Subjects | Study design | CON | EX | Results | Comments | (Ref.) |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Gary and Guthrie (1972) | 20 alcohol-dependent patients (m) | – 4-week exercise intervention -Random assignment to EX or CON - Alcoholic treatment center | – Standard care - Group therapy, recreation programs | – 4 weeks, 5 times/week or until 20 miles has been reached -Incremental running program - Significantly reduced | – No effects with regard to drinking episodes -Significant gains in cardiovascular fitness and self-cathexis scale sleep disturbances | – Small number of subjects - No other alcohol-related outcomes reported - No follow-up data reported - Duration and type of control therapy not reported | ( |
| Sinyor | 58 alcoholic patients (m, f) | – 6-week exercise intervention - Multicenter inpatient treatment programs - Daily group therapy | -No exercise -Standard treatment followed | – 6 weeks, 5 times/week, 1 h each - Stretching, calisthenics, muscle-strengthening exercises, running or cross-country skiing | – At 3-month follow-up, significantly higher abstinence rates (self-report, validated by family members or colleagues) - Significant fitness gains | – Diagnoses and type of intervention not reported - Comparison of patients from different study centers receiving different treatments - No randomization | ( |
| Murphy | 48 students, heavy | – 8-week exercise intervention - Randomized to CON 1, 2 and EX | – CON 1: Standard intervention - CON 2: 3 times/week supervised meditation | – 8 weeks, 3 times/week, 30 min each - Running at individual intensity | – Significant reduction in alcohol consumption in treatment groups - Alcohol consumption on weekdays affected - Significant fitness gains | No clinical diagnosis of alcohol abuse or dependence | ( |
| Donaghy (1997) | 165 alcoholic patients (m, f) | Multicenter study: Inpatient and outpatient treatment programs of different types and durations | – 3 weeks of supervised gentle stretching and breathing exercises, followed by 12 weeks of home-based training - 3 times/week, 30 min each | – 3 weeks of supervised exercise, followed by 12 weeks of home-based exercise - 3 times/week, 30 min each - Aerobic and muscle- strengthening training | – No significant differences in abstinence rates - Significant improvements in power, fitness, body self-perception and self-esteem after 15 weeks - Power and fitness gains maintained at 5-month follow-up - No differences in body weight and resting pulse - Anxiety and depression equally reduced in the two groups | – Diagnoses and type of therapy not reported - Unexplained high number of dropouts at 5-month follow-up - Relapse rates did not differ between CON and EX | ( |
| Ussher | 20 alcohol-dependent patients following detoxification (m, f) | – Counterbalanced cross- over study, inpatient treatment program - Participation in the study following 10–14 days of alcohol detoxification - Randomized | 10 min of light intensity cycling at 5–20% HRR | 10 min of moderate intensity cycling at 40–60% of HRR | – Significantly lower scores for alcohol urges for EX vs. CON between baseline and during exercise - No significant changes in alcohol urge scores for EX vs. CON between baseline and immediately following exercise - No significant changes in any mood scores | – Small number of subjects - Ratings of alcohol urges tended to be higher at baseline for the moderate intensity in EX vs. CON - Maybe participants had expectations for the effects of different experimental (expectation bias) conditions on alcohol urges | ( |
| Vedamurthachar | 60 alcohol-dependent patients following detoxification (m) | – Random assignment to EX or CON for 2 weeks - Impatient treatment, 1 week after detoxification | None | – Sudarshana Kriya Yoga for 42–45 min - Yoga Nidra for 20 min | – Significantly lower cortisol - Significantly lower ACTH levels following intervention in the two groups, greater decrease in EG compared to CG - Non-significant increase in intervention in the two groups - Significantly lower BDI scores following intervention in the two groups, greater decrease in EG compared to CG | – Lack of placebo-controlled levels following EX in EG treatment of CON group - Medication for treating sleep symptoms - No other alcohol-related outcomes reported | ( |
| Coiro | 10 alcoholic patients (m); 10 age-matched healthy controls (m) | – Inpatient rehabilitation program - Trials of acute exercise | – One trial of exercise on a cycle ergometer - Samples at time points: 30 min before exercise, just before exercise, and 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 min after exercise - Initial load of 50 W, 50-W increase every 3 min until subjective exhaustion | – 3 trials of exercise on a cycle ergometer after 4, 6 and 8 weeks of abstinence - Samples at time points: 30 min before exercise, just before exercise, and 10, 20, 30, 40, 50 and 60 min after exercise - Initial load of 50 W, 50-W increase every 3 min until subjective exhaustion | – Similar baseline and in physiological variables in the two groups in all trials - Similar baseline levels of ACTH and cortisol in the two groups in all trials - Significant increase in ACTH and cortisol levels in CON following the trials - Significant increase in ACTH and cortisol levels in EX following the trial at week 6 of abstinence; however, these were significantly lower compared those in CON - Significant increase in ACTH and cortisol levels in EX after trial at week 8 of abstinence; these levels were not significantly different from those in CON | – Small number of subjects - No other alcohol-related outcomes reported | ( |
| Brown | 19 alcohol-dependent patients following detoxification (m, f) | Pilot study, outpatient alcohol program (no details reported) | None | – 12 weeks, 1/week supervised, 20–40 min each - Aerobic training (treadmill, ergometer) at 50–69% max HR - Including CBT-based exercise counseling, 2–3 times/week alone | – Significantly higher rate of abstinent days at end of treatment and 3-month follow-up - Significantly increased fitness and decreased BMI at the end of treatment | – Small number of subjects - Lack of CON group (effects not explained by EX alone) | ( |
| Brown | 49 alcohol-dependent patients (m, f) | Pilot study, outpatient alcohol program, aerobic exercise (AE) | Brief advice to exercise (BA) | – 12 weeks, 1/week supervised, 20–40 min each - Aerobic training (treadmill, ergometer) at 50–69% max HR exercise counseling, 2–3 times/week alone | -Significant decrease in drinking days and heavy drinking days in AE -Significantly lower alcohol and lower frequency of alcohol use compared to BA for those with sufficient attendance in AE (>8 exercise sessions) -Higher rate of abstinent days at 3-month follow-up in AE - Non-significant difference in VO2max between conditions | CON group (BA) reported similar increases in exercise participation as the ‘experimental’ group - Including CBT-based | ( |
| Jamurtas | 9 alcohol-dependent patients following detoxification (m, f); 9 healthy controls (m, f) | – Acute exercise - Participation in the study following 10–14 days of alcohol detoxification | 30 min of low intensity cycling at 55–60% MHR | 30 min of low intensity cycling at 55–60% MHR | – Significantly lower β-endorphin levels in EX vs. CON prior to exercise - Significantly increased β-endorphin levels only in EX following exercise - Non-significant decrease in alcohol urge scores for EX immediately following exercise (~17%) - No significant changes in CBC parameters between groups - Significant increases in RBCs, Hb and Hct in the two groups following exercise | – Small number of subjects - Low alcohol urge scores in EX at the baseline, perhaps due to medication | ( |
| Georgakouli | 17 heavy drinkers (m); 17 controls (not exceeding moderate alcohol consumption) | Acute exercise | – 30 min of moderate intensity cycling at 50–60% HRR | – 30 min of moderate intensity cycling at 50–60% HRR | – Significantly higher γ GT levels in EG vs. CG prior to exercise - Significantly increased γ GT levels only in EG following exercise - No significant differences in AST and ALT between groups prior to exercise - Significantly increased AST levels in the two groups following exercise - Significantly increased ALT levels only in EG following exercise | No alcohol-related outcomes reported | ( |
m, male; f, female; EX, experimental group; CON, control group; BDI, Beck depression inventory; CBT, cognitive-behavioral therapy; HR, heart rate; BMI, body mass index; HRR, heart rate reserve; MHR, maximum heart rate; CBC, complete blood count; RBCs, red blood cells; Hb, hemoglobin; Hct, hematocrit; γ GT, γ glutamyl transferase; AST, aspartate aminotransferase; ALT, alanine aminotransferase.