Dipak Dutta1, N Nagapradeep2, Haijin Zhu3, Maria Forsyth3, Sandeep Verma2,4,5, Aninda J Bhattacharyya1. 1. Solid State and Structural Chemistry Unit, Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore-560012 (Karnataka), India. 2. Department of Chemistry, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, Kanpur-208016 (UP), India. 3. Institute for Frontier Materials, Deakin University, Waurn Ponds, VIC3216, Australia. 4. Centre for Nanosciences, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, Kanpur-208016 (UP), India. 5. Centre for Environmental Science and Technology, Indian Institute of Technology, Kanpur, Kanpur-208016 (UP), India.
Abstract
Electrochemical device with components having direct significance to biological life processes is a potent futuristic strategy for the realization of all-round green and sustainable development. We present here synthesis design, structural analysis and ion transport of a novel solid organic electrolyte (G7Li), a compound reminiscent of ion channels, derived from regioisomeric N7-guanine-carboxylate conjugate and Li-ions. G7Li, with it's in-built supply of Li(+)-ions, exhibited remarkably high lithium-ion transference number (= 0.75) and tunable room temperature ionic conductivity spanning three decades (≈10(-7) to 10(-3) Ω(-1) cm(-1)) as a function of moisture content. The ionic conductivity show a distinct reversible transition around 80-100 °C, from a dual Li(+) and H(+) (<100 °C) to a pure Li(+) conductor (>100 °C). Systematic studies reveal a transition from water-assisted Li-ion transport to Li hopping-like mechanism involving guanine-Li coordination. While as-synthesized G7Li has potential in humidity sensors, the anhydrous G7Li is attractive for rechargeable batteries.
Electrochemical device with components having direct significance to biological life processes is a potent futuristic strategy for the realization of all-round green and sustainable development. We present here synthesis design, structural analysis and ion transport of a novel solid organic electrolyte (G7Li), a compound reminiscent of ion channels, derived from regioisomeric N7-guanine-carboxylate conjugate and Li-ions. G7Li, with it's in-built supply of Li(+)-ions, exhibited remarkably high lithium-ion transference number (= 0.75) and tunable room temperature ionic conductivity spanning three decades (≈10(-7) to 10(-3) Ω(-1) cm(-1)) as a function of moisture content. The ionic conductivity show a distinct reversible transition around 80-100 °C, from a dual Li(+) and H(+) (<100 °C) to a pure Li(+) conductor (>100 °C). Systematic studies reveal a transition from water-assisted Li-ion transport to Li hopping-like mechanism involving guanine-Li coordination. While as-synthesized G7Li has potential in humidity sensors, the anhydrous G7Li is attractive for rechargeable batteries.
The severe safety hazards and environmental concerns associated with the usage of liquid
electrolytes in electrochemical devices have been the focus of attention in research and
development for several decades123. For rechargeable batteries based
on lithium, the major issues with liquid electrolytes are high volatility and
flammability combined with high rates of the reactivity with the electrodes4. One school of thought to tackle the severities associated with molecular
liquids and enhance the safety has been to replace them by solid electrolytes56. In this context, several glassy, inorganic and organic polymer solid
electrolytes have been demonstrated as potential candidates for all-solid state
electrochemical devices such as batteries, fuel cells, etc7891011. However, an overwhelming majority of them have not been able to successfully
transcend beyond the precincts of laboratory-scale demonstrations12131415161718 which led to the predominant usage of liquid
electrolytes19. The other important issue of sustainability, so far
has not been vigorously explored. Many of the commercial liquid electrolytes including
room temperature ionic liquids are derived from materials with limited abundance and
their purest form is hard to achieve20. This is of paramount importance
for large scale electrochemical applications as they are not only going to increase
device cost, but also going to cause larger irrecoverable damage to Earth’s
ecology and environment.Similarities in the chemical composition and structural motifs has triggered an urge for
expanding the horizon of organic biomaterials to non-biological applications212223. Recently, the effective use of organic biomolecules like DNA
and peptides as structural templates for synthesis of energy storage materials has been
demonstrated2425. Unlike conventional inorganic materials, organic
biomaterials can be obtained from renewable sources and offer higher flexibility in
terms of ease of processability and tunability of chemical compositions, which
eventually will tremendously aid in improving the efficiency of the device. Guanine, a
natural heterocyclic nucleic acid constituent, is a known electronic conductor
(conductivity ≈ 10−15 Ω−1 cm−1
at 400 K and under vacuum of 10−6 mm
of Hg)26 due to the hole-hopping mechanism in oligonucleotides272829. Further, addition of metal complexes to nucleic acids is known
to aid hole migration, a vital feature in long-range charge transport in such
systems30. This approach is expected to offer new avenues to
construct DNA-based electronic devices and related technologies313233. Additionally, guanine supports formation of extended supramolecular architectures,
at times in the presence of small cations3435. These supramolecular
architectures may sustain long-range ion transport and may be used to design
bio-conductive materials36 and also hold promise as electrolytes in
electrochemical applications. Herein, we report for the first time a guanine based solid
organic crystalline electrolyte G7Li, which has crystalline structure reminiscent of ion
channels and having direct significance to biological life processes. G7Li is
synthesized from N7-(carboxymethyl)guanine with Li ions and its ion transport properties
are correlated to its crystal structure via extensive studies involving ionic
conductivity and static 7Li solid-state NMR spectroscopy
(7Li line-shapes and motional narrowing). Notably, G7Li exhibited
tunable room temperature ionic conductivity spanning over three orders in magnitude as a
function of humidity, thus providing a novel readily-accessible bio-friendly electrolyte
from guanine (an essential purine nucleobase).
Results and Discussion
Complexation of N7-(carboxymethyl)guanine (1) with
LiOH·H2O, followed by slow evaporation resulted in
colorless crystals of G7Li (c/f Tables S1 and
S2 in the Supplementary Information, ESI). Single crystal X-ray analysis
reveals that G7Li crystallized in monoclinic space group P21/c and
the asymmetric unit composed of an anionic guanine derivative (1), one Li-ion
and three water molecules in which 1 and the water molecules are directly
bound to the lithium ion revealing a distorted tetrahedral geometry
(Li1O1 = 1.933 Å). Notably, modified
guanine moieties interacted through the Watson−Crick face and the
extended sugar edge, due to the availability of free N9 acceptor site. These
interactions are supported by six hydrogen bonds
(N2−H2B…N9 = 1.992 Å;
N2−H2A…O6 = 2.185 Å;
N1−H1…N3 = 2.011 Å)
(Fig. 1), resulting in the formation of infinite guanine
ribbons, when viewed along the c-axis37. This
DDA…AAD triple hydrogen bonding sequence between guanine moieties is
scarce in the literature (where D = donor,
A = acceptor)3839. These guanine
ribbons are further stabilized by π-π interactions involving
parallel offset rings and exhibited a ladder-like structure, when viewed along the
b-axis (c/f Figure S1 in the ESI). Infinite array of lithium ions are
observed in the lattice when viewed along the c-axis. The lithium ions are
equispaced
(dLi1−Li1 = 6.991 Å,
Fig. 2) and the distance between them is longer than the
sum of the van der Waals radii (3.64 Å) and is obviously
longer than the sum of ionic radii (1.86 Å)40
as well. The alignment of lithium ions and the distances between them in the crystal
lattice (when viewed along different crystallographic directions) is further
depicted in Figure S2. Surprisingly, the carbonyl oxygen O6 of
guanine did not show any direct interaction with lithium ions instead interacted
with lithium bound water molecules which in turn connected through carboxylateoxygens (c/f Figures S3 and S4). Thus the G7Li on one hand strongly resembles a
ceramic Li-ion conductor to a great extent in terms of physical appearance (in the
form of powder with a lower melting temperature). On the other hand, the G7Li also
resembles an ionomer due to the built-in Li+-ions in the intrinsic
structure. These Li-ions are expected to sustain Li+-ion transport
and no extra addition of Li-salt is required. This is an added advantage over
polymer electrolytes where additional Li-salt has to be added to sustain
conductivity.
Figure 1
Synthesis of G7Li from 1. (right) guanine-guanine hydrogen bond interactions
in G7Li.
Inset: distorted tetrahedral geometry of Li ion in G7Li.
Figure 2
Alignment of Li ions in G7Li, when viewed along the c-axis; inset:
observed Li−Li distance in G7Li.
Thermal behaviour of G7Li is studied by thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) which is
depicted in Fig. 3a. The initial weight loss of 6.2% (at
80.5 °C) corresponds to the loss of two water molecules from
the complex. On further heating, a cusp is observed at around
100 °C, followed by rapid decomposition after
300 °C (stable up to
~375 °C). The thermal (decomposition) properties
of G7Li are better than many of the reported promising soft-matter (polymer)
electrolytes414243. The thermal stability of G7Li up to
~375 °C, which is sufficient for majority of the
electrochemical applications, however, is appreciably lower than any typical ceramic
conductor. We envisage that this lower thermal stability range of G7Li is not going
to be a major disadvantage as this will be easily offset by its’ higher
degree of biocompatibility and sustainability compared to majority of the prevalent
electrolytes. Room temperature (RT) powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) patterns of
as-synthesized G7Li and sample pre-heated to 300 °C are in
good agreement with the simulated diffraction patterns (c/f Figure S5 in the ESI).
Subsequent SEM analysis revealed a rod-like morphology for the as-synthesized G7Li
sample which is completely destroyed on heating the sample at
300 °C (c/f Fig. 3b,c). However, the
destruction of the rod-like morphology does not imply the loss of crystallinity of
the sample. This is confirmed by the PXRD pattern (Figure S5), DSC and ionic
conductivity results (vide infra).
Figure 3
(a) TGA profile of G7Li
(33–800 °C; heating rate
5 °C/min, N2 atmosphere) (inset: DSC
profile of G7Li (heating rate 5 °C/min,
N2 atmosphere)). SEM images of (b) as-synthesized G7Li
and (c) after heating the sample to 300 °C
(Scale: 2 μm).
The ionic conductivity of G7Li is estimated by ac-impedance spectroscopy (c/f ESI).
Figure 4 shows the Arrhenius plot of ionic conductivity
versus temperature (relative humidity, RH = 39%). The
impedance data typically in the low conductivity regime comprised of a single
semicircle. This data could be approximately fitted by a resistance (R1) and
CPE1 (=RC)
in parallel5678. In the high conductivity regime (i.e.
(200–300) °C and around room temperature) the
impedance data comprised of a depressed semicircle and a
“spike-like” region at high and low frequency region
respectively. The impedance data in the high conductivity regimes are fitted to a
series combination in R1, 1 should be in normal mode and not suffix. It is written
as R1 (R) and constant phase element, CPE1 in parallel and
CPE2 using ZViewTM software (Scribner Associates Inc.). The impedance
data, in general could be fitted well with n = 0.8
resulting in bulk capacitance values ∼10−11
F. Assuming the “spike-like” region to be another depressed
semicircle, reminiscent of ceramic conductors, fitting of the
“spike-like” region is also attempted using a resistance
(R2) in parallel to CPE2. In this case, the value of n which
fitted the data is found to be low (=0.5) which resulted in capacitance values
∼10−6 F. As G7Li is not a ceramic
conductor and hence does not possess well defined grain boundaries, it is strongly
felt that this model here may not be appropriate. The impedance response of G7Li is
very similar to a soft-matter electrolyte such as polymer electrolyte with the
additional advantage of in-built lithium ions without the requirement of addition of
any external salts. As the aim here is to solely estimate the bulk contribution, the
ionic conductivities are estimated from resistance values as per the equivalent
circuit depicted in Fig. 4. The room temperature conductivity
is found to be
∼1.0 × 10−7 Ω−1 cm−1,
which reduces to
3.9 × 10−11 Ω−1 cm−1
at 100 °C (Fig. 4). Interestingly, the
conductivity increased sharply with further increase in temperature and reached a
value of
0.2 × 10−5 Ω−1 cm−1
at 300 °C. Upon cooling, the conductivity retraces its path
in both the temperature regimes i.e. 100–300 °C
and 25–100 °C about the point of minimum (c/f
Figure S6). The conductivity (σ) in the
100–300 °C temperature regime can be fitted to
the Arrhenius equation,
σ = Aexp(−E/kT)
where A is the pre-exponential factor, k the Boltzmann constant,
T the absolute temperature and E being the
activation energy. The activation energy is estimated to be
~0.8 eV in the temperature range
100–300 °C (c/f Fig.
4).
Figure 4
Arrhenius plot of the conductivity versus temperature
(25–300 °C) of G7Li at 39% relative humidity
(RH) (ambient condition).
Inset: Nyquist plots for G7Li at
25–300 °C temperatures. The equivalent
circuit for fitting the ac-impedance data is also shown.
The room temperature ionic conductivity is accounted by the water assisted lithium
ion motion in G7Li. The observed decrease in ionic conductivity up to
100 °C can be attributed to the loss of water molecules, as
evident from the TGA profile (c/f Fig. 3a). Following the
evaporation of water molecules at
T > 100 °C, the
lithium ions primarily interact via guanine ligand. It is highly probable that
lithium ion transport takes place through a hopping-like mechanism involving
coordination to various sites in the guanine ligand leading to an Arrhenius-type
behavior of conductivity versus temperature44. This is also supported
by the estimated activation energy (=0.8 eV;
T = (100–300) °C;
anhydrous phase) which is similar to that of some of the known class of inorganiclithium ionic conductors in the same temperature range45 (as the
conductivity decreases from room temperature to 100 °C,
activation energy is not estimated as it will be unphysical). To further support the
results of ionic conductivity of G7Li, differential scanning calorimetry (DSC)
analysis is also performed (inset of Fig. 3a). To understand
the non-monotonic behaviour of ionic conductivity of G7Li, DSC for two cycles of
heating and cooling in the same temperature range
(25–300 °C) as that of the conductivity
experiments are performed. In the first heating scan, G7Li (inside a hermetically
sealed DSC aluminium can) shows a broad and strong endotherm centering at
101.7 °C
(∆Htransition = −167.9 J
g−1), along with two more major endotherms at
162 °C
(∆Htransition = −74.4 J
g−1) and 281.6 °C
(∆Htransition = −67.5 J
g−1). While the endotherm at
101.7 °C corresponds to phase transition following the loss
of water, the two other endotherms at 162 °C and
281.6 °C may correspond to the transitions from the rod-like
morphology to the poorly ordered (irregular shape) phase of the compound which is
clearly evident from SEM images (c/f Fig. 3b,c). This is
additionally supported by the TGA profile which shows no appreciable loss (weight
loss in the dehydrated phase in 80–300 °C: 0.8%)
at these transition temperatures. The PXRD pattern of the sample pre-heated to
300 °C (c/f Figure S5) also broadened as compared to the
as-synthesized sample. Upon cooling the sample in the reverse cycle
(300 → 25 °C) no DSC
exotherms are observed indicating that the initial (rod-like morphology) phases are
not recovered. Following the 1st heat and cool cycles, a small hole
is made in the lid of the aluminium can and the sample is kept in air (≈
RH 39%) for two days. This sample is again taken for the 2nd set of
heating and cooling DSC experiments (c/f Figure S7). The regeneration of the
endotherms in the second heating cycle and no appearance of exotherms again in the
subsequent cooling cycle strongly suggest that the conductivity behaviour below the
point of minimum (c/f Fig. 4) is water assisted lithium
transport. Interestingly, when the 2nd heating cycle from room
temperature to 300 °C using the same heating rate is done
under inert conditions (i.e. samples inside hermetically sealed DSC aluminium can
similar to 1st heat and cool cycle), no endothermic peaks are
observed (inset: Fig. 3a) which are clearly visible in the
first heating cycle and the second heating cycle of the air-exposed sample. Upon
cooling, similar to the first cycle no exotherms are observed. The observations from
DSC and TGA suggest that while heating G7Li dehydrates till
100 °C. This accounts well the decrease in ionic
conductivity with temperature till 100 °C. On cooling in
air, the sample rehydrates to the same limit at around
100 °C and this again leads to increase in ionic
conductivity. This strongly supports our conductivity versus temperature results
where the conductivity is observed to retract the same path on cooling. To elucidate
the structure of the dehydrated phase of G7Li, the sample is heated to a temperature
of 150 °C and immediately encapsulated inside wax. The PXRD
pattern of the dehydrated phase encapsulated inside wax (Figure S8) is identical to
that of the as-synthesized sample (Figure S8a,c). This suggests that elimination of
water molecules coordinated to Li+ ions in G7Li does not lead to any
recognizable change in it’s crystal structure. This is probably due to
the fact that the structure of G7Li is stabilized by infinite guanine ribbons in
which each guanine moiety holds six hydrogen bonds
(DDA···AAD type,
D = donor and A = acceptor) with two
adjacent guanine moieties (Fig. 1) and the
π-π interactions between the guanine ribbons (Figure S1b).
Thus the ionic conductivity at
T > 100 °C is due to
the hopping transport taking place because of lithium coordination to the
carboxylate and carbonyl oxygens of guanine moiety in G7Li.The lithium ion transference number (t+) in G7Li is estimated using
the dc-polarization technique4647 with non-blocking electrodes in a
cell configuration of the type Li(metal)|G7Li|Li(metal)
(ESI). The observed value of t+ = 0.75
suggest that 25% of the total ionic conductivity is sustained by other species viz.
proton in G7Li. It is noteworthy to mention here that this value of
t+ is very high as compared to conventional polymer
electrolytes (≈0.3)48 and also higher than some of the
rare reports on polycarbonate electrolytes with high Li+ ion
transference number4950. To investigate this issue, preliminary
ionic conductivity of G7Li is performed under various relative humidity (RH)
conditions of 52%, 75% and 98% in the temperature range of
(21–35) °C. The sample pellets are exposed for
sufficient time so as to reach equilibrium before recording the temperature
dependent impedance measurements. The results of the ionic conductivity measurements
as a function of relative humidity are shown in Figure S9 (Figure S10 shows the
stability of G7Li pellet under humid condition). The ionic conductivity at
25 °C at RH equal to 52%, 75% and 98% are respectively
1.5 × 10−7,
1.5 × 10−5, and
1.0 × 10−4 Ω−1 cm−1.
Thus, the value of conductivity at 98% RH is nearly three orders higher than the
room temperature conductivity measured at 39% (c/f Fig. 4). At
a nominal temperature of 35 °C, the ionic conductivities at
relative humidity 52%, 75% and 98% are observed to be
2.5 × 10−7,
1.7 × 10−5 and
3.0 × 10−4
Ω−1 cm−1
respectively. The activation energies at different humidity levels are estimated to
be 0.8 eV (52%), 0.7 (75%) and 0.6 (98%). Thus, the ion transport under
higher RH conditions appears to be more facile with reduced activation energy as
compared to ion transport under dryer conditions (c/f Fig. 4).
The higher ionic conductivity may be due to either of the two reasons. Firstly, as
the sample absorbs additional water under higher RH conditions, these results in
higher dissociation of lithium ions and substantial enhancement in the water
assisted Li-ion transport. Secondly, under higher humid conditions the proton
transport may also be enhanced. Both these factors are non-trivial to probe using
the transference number method employed in this study. Since under humid conditions
the lithium metal electrodes will be unstable due to vigorous reaction with water,
the deconvolution of individual contributions cannot be achieved using this
method.The pulsed field gradient nuclear magnetic resonance (PFG-NMR) spectroscopy, an
alternative tool to measure transference numbers of various ionic entities in a
sample, also could not successfully deconvolute the individual diffusion
coefficients for Li+ and H+ present in the sample due
to their short T2 relaxation times as well as the slow diffusion.
However, the Li+ ion mobility in G7Li is clearly recognized by
monitoring the change in line-width (full width at half maximum, FWHM) as a function
of temperature of the solid-state NMR spectra of 7Li in G7Li obtained
from the stationary powder sample (c/f Fig. 5a). The
7Li being a quadrupolar nucleus
(I = 3/2), the magnetic dipolar and electric quadrupolar
interactions usually influence the 7Li NMR spectra (chemical shift
interactions are normally small for 7Li). When a nucleus is fixed,
the quadrupolar or internuclear dipole-dipole interactions are accentuated resulting
in a broad line-width (usually known as rigid lattice line-width). The line-widths
for G7Li (Fig. 5b) are obtained by fitting the spectra using a
two components model consisting of the broad Gaussian peak (rigid lattice
line-width) and the sharper Lorenzian peak corresponding to the central transition.
The Li+ ion when it resides in a tetrahedral symmetry site, the
quadrupolar contributions are expected to be negligible and so the
7Li line-width is in fact dominated by the dipolar interactions. In
the range of temperature under investigation (−20 to
75 °C) no distinct quadrupolar satellite transitions
(+3/2 ↔ +1/2 and
−1/2 ↔ −3/2) are
observed in the 7Li spectra of G7Li indicating that the
Li+ ions are located at sites with tetrahedral symmetry
(T) and that there are no impurity ions51. This observation exactly supports the single crystal X-ray data.
This concurrence also encouraged us to investigate the Li+ ion
mobility by measuring the 7Li line-widths only of the central
transition (+1/2 ↔ −1/2) as a
function of temperature. At lower temperature (263 K) the spectrum is
dominated by broad lattice line-width indicating that vast majority of the
Li+ ions are relatively rigid, but still noticeable amount of
mobile ones can be identified from the little narrow peak on top. The not so broad
line-width of 4.3 kHz (Fig. 5b) of the central
transition suggests that the Li+ ions may be mobile even at such a
low temperature. As temperature increases, the line-widths gradually become
narrower, (Figs 5 and S11). The line-widths steadily decrease to 2.4 kHz
at 293 K (≈ambient temperature) after which it shows a
slight increase to 2.7 kHz at 323 K. The steady decrease in
line-width is due to higher mobility of Li+ ion at high temperature.
Since broadening of line-width usually originates from the increased quadrupolar or
internuclear dipole-dipole interactions52 the increase in
7Li line-width from 293 K to 323 K may be
accounted on the basis of weak 1H-7Li dipolar
interactions. This is also supported by the fact that the onset of motional
narrowing of proton is also around 318 K (c/f Figure S11). This explains
that the Li+ ion mobility below 373 K is water assisted
as mentioned earlier and the decrease in ionic conductivity is also partially due to
decrease in Li+ ion mobility in this temperature regime. The
additional evidence of the water assisted movement of Li+ ion arises
from the fact that Li+ ion hopping between the
T sites, which are 6.991 Å and
4.261 Å (=d) apart (c/f Figures S2 and S4), is
difficult. The jump period (τ) (ESI) at a particular temperature
is related to the local diffusion coefficient (D) by the equation
D = d2/4τ,
and the obtained values are
1.22 × 10−13 and
0.74 × 10−13 m2/s
for d = 4.261 and 6.991 Å
respectively. Once water starts exiting from the system
(T = 333 K) the
1H-7Li dipolar interactions weakens and this
effect together with the increase in Li+ ion mobility reinitiate the
7Li motional line-width narrowing. The line-width data shows a
sudden and sharp decrease between 333 K (2.6 kHz) to
343 K (1.4 kHz). The sudden increase in motional narrowing
may be due to the loss of large number of water molecules during this stage. A
further decrease of line-width is expected at and above 373 K, i.e. in
the new dehydrated phase when water molecules have fully exited from the system. In
the dehydrated phase within the temperature regime
(373–573) K (c/f Fig. 4), there will
also be an expected motional narrowing and it will purely be due to the fast
Li+ hopping between the carboxylate and carbonyl oxygens of the
guanine moieties in the G7Li. The activation energy calculated for the G7Li phase
(≈21–40 °C) from the line-width
measurements (c/f ESI) is 0.15 eV. Such low activation energies strongly
support the water assisted diffusion of Li+ ions in G7Li at room and
in proximity to the room temperature. Estimation of a lower activation energy
barrier (compared to the ionic conductivity in the similar temperature range, Figure
S9) can be anticipated primarily due to the differences in the probing methods and
time scale of measurement between the ac-impedance and NMR techniques. The NMR
detects specific ion motions on a much more local scale whereas the ionic
conductivity data represents net number of mobile charges on a larger length
scale5354.
Figure 5
(a) Static 7Li-NMR spectra and (b)
7Li line-width (FWHM: full width at half maximum) as a
function of temperature for G7Li solid powder.
To investigate whether protons in G7Li also contribute to the overall ionic
conductivity as evident from the transference number measurements, the
1H solid state MAS NMR experiments are performed as a function of
temperature. The 1H MAS NMR chemical shift spectra (c/f Figure S12a)
shows two broad peaks centering at 1.04 ppm and 4.96 ppm
corresponding probably to the free mobile water proton
(Li → OH2) and the static proton
covalently bonded to the nitrogen atoms of the guanine respectively. The broadening
of the peaks partially might be a result of the hydrogen bonding in the system. The
solid-state 1H MAS NMR spectra of G7Li (c/f Fig.
6a) are deconvoluted into a narrow component (mobile protons) and a broad
component (rigid protons) using the mixed Gaussian and Lorentzian function (c/f
example in Figure S12b) in order to obtain the line-width and integration for both
the components. At 293 K the spectrum is dominated by the rigid lattice
component (Fig. 6a), with recognizable contributions from the
mobile protons. As the temperature increases the population of the mobile protons
increases (Fig. 6d), suggesting the breach of the hydrogen
bonding at elevated temperatures and thus more protons become mobile. This will
negatively affect the conductivity as in ‘dry’ state the
proton transport is achieved via breach and formation of hydrogen bonding (Grotthuss
mechanism). The line-width that is observed to be 2.53 kHz at
293 K gradually decreases to 1.21 kHz at 343 K
indicating an enhancement of proton mobility with temperature in the mobile region.
However, an increase in line-width to 1.3 kHz with further increase in
temperature to 348 K may be due to the onset of water molecules exiting
from the system. The line-width of the rigid component is quite constant in the
studied temperature range as shown in Fig. 6(c) indicating a
quite stable structure and molecular dynamics in the lattice molecules. For proton
to hop between different sites, the ideal distance between the sites normally is
within 2.5 Å5556. In G7Li the
H···O distance between water molecules attached
to two adjacent Li-tetrahedra (c/f Figure S4) is around 2 Å
(<2.5 Å) suggesting that the facile proton conducting
pathways is through these water molecules coordinately bonded to Li+
ions.
Figure 6
(a) Static 1H-NMR spectra, (b) 1H
line width (FWHM: full width at half maximum) of the narrow component,
(c) 1H line width of the broad component, and
(d) the integration percentage of the narrow component as a
function of temperature for G7Li solid powder.
Despite the fact that G7Li shows Li+ and H+ ion
conductivity under ambient conditions, it should however, be emphasized that the
proton transport here is mainly due to the presence of water channels formed by
water molecules tetrahedrally co-ordinated to the Li+ ions. This is
further supported by NMR that out of the two types of protons (Figure S12a), the
protons covalently bonded to the nitrogen atoms of a guanine moiety in an infinite
guanine ribbons of G7Li (Fig. 1) are further held by the
hydrogen bonds from neighboring two guanine moieties making them immobile. Further,
as mentioned earlier, once the water is eliminated from G7Li by heating to above
100 °C it shows improved conductivity (even higher than the
room temperature conductivity) purely due to the mobile Li+ ions.
This also implies that eliminating water molecules under an inert condition will
make the G7Li a purely Li+ ion conductor under ambient temperature.
The enhanced Li+ ion conductivity at temperatures
>100 °C is proposed here to be due to
self-optimization of the ion hopping path lengths in a beneficial potential corridor
formed by the carboxylate and carbonyl oxygens of the guanine moiety. The structural
investigations of the single crystal of G7Li in the dehydrated phase using both
single crystal X-ray diffraction and NMR are nearly impossible (as it quickly
re-adsorbs atmospheric moisture to return to the room temperature phase) and this
prohibits determination of the exact positions of Li+ ions in the
dehydrated phase. However, as mentioned earlier powder X-ray diffraction studies by
encapsulating the dehydrated sample in wax shows no appreciable change in crystal
structure compared to the as-synthesized sample. This indicates that the positions
of the Li+ ions are expected to remain the same both in the
dehydrated phase and as-synthesized sample. This provides further proof of the fact
that Li+ ions transport in the dehydrated phase of G7Li takes place
through a beneficial potential corridor formed by the carboxylate and carbonyl
oxygens of the guanine moieties in the infinite ribbons of guanine.Cyclic voltammetry (CV) measurements at room temperature
(=25 °C) are attempted to ascertain the stability window of
G7Li. For the CV measurements (working electrode: stainless steel; counter and
reference electrodes: lithium foil; scan rates: (0.25–1.0)
mVs−1), a pellet of thickness 0.8 mm
(diameter: 1.2 cm) measurements are taken. Thinner pellets could not be
used as they tend to break and no attempt was made to cast thin films as they are
beyond the scope of the paper. Under these measurement conditions, no
electrochemical signatures including that of lithium deposition and stripping were
observed due to high resistance of G7Li (not shown here). Further, as the
conductivities are not so high at higher temperatures, performing the CV at elevated
temperatures will also not be useful in precisely detecting the electrochemical
stability. We do not discuss the electrochemical stability of G7Li any further in
the absence of a scientifically sound CV data. In order to find out the Li-G7Li
aerial specific resistance, the impedance spectrum of G7Li in a cell of the type
Li|G7Li|Li is recorded. After fitting the corresponding
Nyquist plot (Figure S13) with Maxwell equivalent circuit the Li-G7Li aerial
specific resistance is found to be
~1.0 × 106 Ω.
Conclusions
In conclusion, we have demonstrated for the first time a novel bio-friendly solid
electrolyte viz. G7Li obtained from a DNA base, guanine. G7Li, with it’s
intrinsic supply of Li+-ions, exhibits a tunable room temperature
ionic conductivity spanning over three orders in magnitude
(10−7–0.3 × 10−3 Ω−1 cm−1)
as a function of humidity. Two types of transport mediated by Li+ and
H+ that contributes to the total conductivity in G7Li at ambient
conditions are thoroughly deconvoluted using the transference number measurement and
NMR line-width experiments. The transport above 100 °C is
purely due to the Li+-ion. Considering the observations on
temperature dependent ionic conductivity and structural analysis we strongly believe
that G7Li may be beneficial as an electrolyte in conventional electrochemical
devices and additionally for sensing applications especially humidity sensing. The
novel approach demonstrated here may pave the way for the development of more
biocompatible solid organic electrolytes and eventually lead to the replacement of
liquid electrolytes that face severe problem of potential leakage of corrosive
liquids and the volatility and flammability of the electrolyte solvents.
Additional Information
Data availability: The CCDC contains the supplementary crystallographic data for this paper with the following deposition number
of CCDC: 962004 (G7Li).How to cite this article: Dutta, D. et al.
N7-(carboxymethyl)guanine-Lithium Crystalline Complex: A Bioinspired Solid
Electrolyte. Sci. Rep.
6, 24499; doi: 10.1038/srep24499 (2016).
Authors: Prabeer Barpanda; Jean-Noël Chotard; Charles Delacourt; Marine Reynaud; Yaroslav Filinchuk; Michel Armand; Michael Deschamps; Jean-Marie Tarascon Journal: Angew Chem Int Ed Engl Date: 2011-01-18 Impact factor: 15.336