Donald Skinner1, Carla Sharp2, Lochner Marais3, Motsaathebe Serekoane4, Molefi Lenka3. 1. Research on Health and Society, Faculty of Health Sciences, Stellenbosch University, Tygerberg, Cape Town, South Africa. 2. Department of Psychology, University of Houston. 3. Centre for Development Support, University of the Free State, South Africa. 4. Department of Anthropology, University of the Free State.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) is a robust, powerful and internationally recognised diagnostic screening tool for emotional and behaviour problems among children, with the particular advantage that it can be used by non-health professionals. This makes it useful in a South African context characterized by shortages of professional mental health carers. However the cultural and contextual acceptability and potential uses of the SDQ have not yet been examined in the South African context. METHODS: The aim of the current study was to evaluate the acceptability of the SDQ in a Sesotho speaking area of South Africa. As part of a larger study to standardise the SDQ for use among Sotho speakers, teachers were asked to use the tool to assess learners in their class. Ten teachers were then asked to write a report on their experience of the SDQ and how useful and applicable they found it for their school setting. These findings were discussed at two later meetings with larger groupings of teachers. Reports were analysed using a modified contextualised interpretative content analysis method. RESULTS: Teachers found the SDQ very useful in the classroom and easy to administer and understand. They found it contextually relevant and particularly useful in gaining an understanding of the learners and the challenges that learners were facing. It further allowed them to differentiate between scholastic and emotional problems, assisting them in developing relationships with the pupils and facilitating accurate referrals. There were very few concerns raised, with the major problem being that it was difficult to assess items concerning contexts outside of the school setting. The teachers expressed interest in obtaining further training in the interpretation of the SDQ and a greater understanding of diagnostic labels so as to assist their learners. CONCLUSION: The SDQ was found to be acceptable and useful in the context of this very disadvantaged community. The teachers felt it assisted them in their role as teachers by providing a greater understanding of emotional and behaviour problems among learners. However, lack of places for referral and their own lack of appropriate skills and time did generate frustration.
BACKGROUND: The Strengths and Difficulties Questionnaire (SDQ) is a robust, powerful and internationally recognised diagnostic screening tool for emotional and behaviour problems among children, with the particular advantage that it can be used by non-health professionals. This makes it useful in a South African context characterized by shortages of professional mental health carers. However the cultural and contextual acceptability and potential uses of the SDQ have not yet been examined in the South African context. METHODS: The aim of the current study was to evaluate the acceptability of the SDQ in a Sesotho speaking area of South Africa. As part of a larger study to standardise the SDQ for use among Sotho speakers, teachers were asked to use the tool to assess learners in their class. Ten teachers were then asked to write a report on their experience of the SDQ and how useful and applicable they found it for their school setting. These findings were discussed at two later meetings with larger groupings of teachers. Reports were analysed using a modified contextualised interpretative content analysis method. RESULTS: Teachers found the SDQ very useful in the classroom and easy to administer and understand. They found it contextually relevant and particularly useful in gaining an understanding of the learners and the challenges that learners were facing. It further allowed them to differentiate between scholastic and emotional problems, assisting them in developing relationships with the pupils and facilitating accurate referrals. There were very few concerns raised, with the major problem being that it was difficult to assess items concerning contexts outside of the school setting. The teachers expressed interest in obtaining further training in the interpretation of the SDQ and a greater understanding of diagnostic labels so as to assist their learners. CONCLUSION: The SDQ was found to be acceptable and useful in the context of this very disadvantaged community. The teachers felt it assisted them in their role as teachers by providing a greater understanding of emotional and behaviour problems among learners. However, lack of places for referral and their own lack of appropriate skills and time did generate frustration.
Entities:
Keywords:
AIDS; Assessment; Children; HIV; South Africa; assessment; culture; mental health
Authors: Donald Skinner; N Tsheko; S Mtero-Munyati; M Segwabe; P Chibatamoto; S Mfecane; B Chandiwana; N Nkomo; S Tlou; G Chitiyo Journal: AIDS Behav Date: 2006-11
Authors: Gian Marco Marzocchi; Christiane Capron; Mario Di Pietro; Enric Duran Tauleria; Michel Duyme; Alessandra Frigerio; Maria Filomena Gaspar; Helena Hamilton; Gérard Pithon; Alexandra Simões; Carine Thérond Journal: Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry Date: 2004 Impact factor: 4.785
Authors: Christina A Laurenzi; Sarah Skeen; Phillip Sundin; Xanthe Hunt; Robert E Weiss; Mary Jane Rotheram-Borus; Mark Tomlinson Journal: Glob Public Health Date: 2019-08-19
Authors: Nikhat Hoosen; Eugene Lee Davids; Petrus J de Vries; Maylene Shung-King Journal: Child Adolesc Psychiatry Ment Health Date: 2018-01-11 Impact factor: 3.033