Michael H Livingston1, Sara Colozza1, Kelly N Vogt1, Neil Merritt1, Andreana Bütter1. 1. From the Division of General Surgery, Western University (Livingston, Vogt, Merritt, Bütter); the Schulich School of Medicine & Dentistry, Western University (Colozza); and the Division of Pediatric Surgery, Western University (Merritt, Bütter), London, Ont.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: There is ongoing variation in the use of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) and chest tube with fibrinolytics (CTWF) for empyema in children. Our objective was to report outcomes from a centre that recently made the transition from VATS to CTWF as the primary treatment modality. METHODS: We conducted a historical cohort study of children with empyema treated with either primary VATS (between 2005 and 2009) or CTWF (between 2009 and 2013). RESULTS: Sixty-seven children underwent pleural drainage for empyema during the study period: 28 (42%) were treated with primary VATS, and 39 (58%) underwent CTWF. There were no significant differences between the VATS and CTWF groups for length of stay (8 v. 9 d, p = 0.61) or need for additional procedures (4% v. 13%, p = 0.19). Length of stay varied widely for both VATS (4-53 d) and CTWF (5-46 d). Primary VATS failed in 1 (4%) patient, who required an additional chest tube, and CTWF failed in 5 (13%) patients. Additional procedures included 3 rescue VATS, 2 additional chest tubes and 1 thoracotomy. All patients recovered and were discharged home. CONCLUSION: Primary VATS and CTWF were associated with similar outcomes in children with empyema. There appears to be a subset of children at risk for treatment failure with CTWF. Further research is needed to determine if these patients would benefit from primary VATS.
BACKGROUND: There is ongoing variation in the use of video-assisted thoracoscopic surgery (VATS) and chest tube with fibrinolytics (CTWF) for empyema in children. Our objective was to report outcomes from a centre that recently made the transition from VATS to CTWF as the primary treatment modality. METHODS: We conducted a historical cohort study of children with empyema treated with either primary VATS (between 2005 and 2009) or CTWF (between 2009 and 2013). RESULTS: Sixty-seven children underwent pleural drainage for empyema during the study period: 28 (42%) were treated with primary VATS, and 39 (58%) underwent CTWF. There were no significant differences between the VATS and CTWF groups for length of stay (8 v. 9 d, p = 0.61) or need for additional procedures (4% v. 13%, p = 0.19). Length of stay varied widely for both VATS (4-53 d) and CTWF (5-46 d). Primary VATS failed in 1 (4%) patient, who required an additional chest tube, and CTWF failed in 5 (13%) patients. Additional procedures included 3 rescue VATS, 2 additional chest tubes and 1 thoracotomy. All patients recovered and were discharged home. CONCLUSION: Primary VATS and CTWF were associated with similar outcomes in children with empyema. There appears to be a subset of children at risk for treatment failure with CTWF. Further research is needed to determine if these patients would benefit from primary VATS.
Authors: Claudia Marhuenda; Concepció Barceló; Inmaculada Fuentes; Gabriela Guillén; Indalecio Cano; María López; Francisco Hernández; Eduardo G Pérez-Yarza; José A Matute; María A García-Casillas; Víctor Alvarez; Antonio Moreno-Galdó Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2014-11 Impact factor: 7.124
Authors: Saleem Islam; Casey M Calkins; Adam B Goldin; Catherine Chen; Cynthia D Downard; Eunice Y Huang; Laura Cassidy; Jacqueline Saito; Martin L Blakely; Shawn J Rangel; Marjorie J Arca; Fizan Abdullah; Shawn D St Peter Journal: J Pediatr Surg Date: 2012-11 Impact factor: 2.545
Authors: Beth A Kurt; Kimberly M Winterhalter; Robert H Connors; Bradford W Betz; John W Winters Journal: Pediatrics Date: 2006-08-14 Impact factor: 7.124
Authors: Samatha Sonnappa; Gordon Cohen; Catherine M Owens; Carin van Doorn; John Cairns; Sanja Stanojevic; Martin J Elliott; Adam Jaffé Journal: Am J Respir Crit Care Med Date: 2006-05-04 Impact factor: 21.405
Authors: Shawn D St Peter; Kuojen Tsao; Troy L Spilde; Scott J Keckler; Christopher Harrison; Mary Ann Jackson; Susan W Sharp; Walter S Andrews; Doug C Rivard; Frank P Morello; George W Holcomb; Daniel J Ostlie Journal: J Pediatr Surg Date: 2009-01 Impact factor: 2.545
Authors: Najib M Rahman; Brennan C Kahan; Robert F Miller; Fergus V Gleeson; Andrew J Nunn; Nicholas A Maskell Journal: Chest Date: 2014-04 Impact factor: 9.410