Ying Jiao Zhao1, Ai Leng Khoo1, Liang Lin1, Monica Teng1, Calvin J Koh2, Seng Gee Lim2, Boon Peng Lim1, Yock Young Dan3,4. 1. Pharmacy and Therapeutics Office, Group Corporate Development, National Healthcare Group, Singapore. 2. Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, National University Hospital, National University Health System, Singapore. 3. Division of Gastroenterology and Hepatology, National University Hospital, National University Health System, Singapore. yock_young_dan@nuhs.edu.sg. 4. Department of Medicine, Yong Loo Lin School of Medicine, National University of Singapore, Singapore. yock_young_dan@nuhs.edu.sg.
Abstract
BACKGROUND AND AIM: The high cost of chronic hepatitis C (HCV) direct-acting antivirals (DAAs) poses significant financial challenges for health payers, especially in Asia. A personalized treatment strategy based on individualized probability of virological response using oral DAAs as second-line therapy would seem practical but has not been studied. METHODS: We performed a Markov model to project health outcomes and costs for patients with genotype 1 HCV through 10 treatment strategies over a lifetime period. The implication of retreatment was also incorporated to reflect real-life situation. RESULTS: Using boceprevir and peginterferon/ribavirin (BOC/PR, the least costly treatment) as a base case, the all-oral therapies such as ombitasvir/paritaprevir/ritonavir-dasabuvir are cost-effective with an incremental cost-effective ratio of $US50 828. However, the all-oral DAAs would no longer be cost-effective compared with conventional therapies if retreatment were taken into account. A road map strategy using rapid virological response to guide use of BOC/PR and sofosbuvir/PR had the most favorable incremental cost-effective ratio ($US27 782) relative to BOC/PR. Nevertheless, the trade-off with the cost-effectiveness of the road map strategy is an increased number of liver-related deaths compared with all-oral DAAs (52 vs 10-20 per 10 000 patients) by incorporating retreatment. CONCLUSIONS: The 12-week all-oral DAAs were cost-effective options using conventional drug-to-drug comparison. However, they cease to be cost-effective when treatment strategies incorporating DAA retreatment for interferon failures are incorporated. HCV management can be optimized by adopting individualized treatment algorithm providing a practical solution to health payers to make oral DAAs accessible to those who need them most.
BACKGROUND AND AIM: The high cost of chronic hepatitis C (HCV) direct-acting antivirals (DAAs) poses significant financial challenges for health payers, especially in Asia. A personalized treatment strategy based on individualized probability of virological response using oral DAAs as second-line therapy would seem practical but has not been studied. METHODS: We performed a Markov model to project health outcomes and costs for patients with genotype 1 HCV through 10 treatment strategies over a lifetime period. The implication of retreatment was also incorporated to reflect real-life situation. RESULTS: Using boceprevir and peginterferon/ribavirin (BOC/PR, the least costly treatment) as a base case, the all-oral therapies such as ombitasvir/paritaprevir/ritonavir-dasabuvir are cost-effective with an incremental cost-effective ratio of $US50 828. However, the all-oral DAAs would no longer be cost-effective compared with conventional therapies if retreatment were taken into account. A road map strategy using rapid virological response to guide use of BOC/PR and sofosbuvir/PR had the most favorable incremental cost-effective ratio ($US27 782) relative to BOC/PR. Nevertheless, the trade-off with the cost-effectiveness of the road map strategy is an increased number of liver-related deaths compared with all-oral DAAs (52 vs 10-20 per 10 000 patients) by incorporating retreatment. CONCLUSIONS: The 12-week all-oral DAAs were cost-effective options using conventional drug-to-drug comparison. However, they cease to be cost-effective when treatment strategies incorporating DAA retreatment for interferon failures are incorporated. HCV management can be optimized by adopting individualized treatment algorithm providing a practical solution to health payers to make oral DAAs accessible to those who need them most.
Authors: Emily E Dunn; Kathryn Vranek; Lauren M Hynicka; Janet Gripshover; Darryn Potosky; T Joseph Mattingly Journal: Qual Manag Health Care Date: 2017 Jul/Sep Impact factor: 0.926
Authors: Melanie Runge; Magdalene Krensel; Claudia Westermann; Dominik Bindl; Klaus Nagels; Matthias Augustin; Albert Nienhaus Journal: Int J Environ Res Public Health Date: 2020-01-09 Impact factor: 3.390