Julio Urrutia1, Tomas Zamora2, Mauricio Campos2, Ratko Yurac3, Joaquin Palma2, Sebastian Mobarec2, Carlos Prada2. 1. Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, School of Medicine, Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile, Marcoleta 352, Santiago, Chile. jurrutia@med.puc.cl. 2. Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, School of Medicine, Pontificia Universidad Catolica de Chile, Marcoleta 352, Santiago, Chile. 3. Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, Clinica Alemana de Santiago, Santiago, Chile.
Abstract
PURPOSE: We performed an agreement study using two subaxial cervical spine classification systems: the AOSpine and the Allen and Ferguson (A&F) classifications. We sought to determine which scheme allows better agreement by different evaluators and by the same evaluator on different occasions. METHODS: Complete imaging studies of 65 patients with subaxial cervical spine injuries were classified by six evaluators (three spine sub-specialists and three senior orthopaedic surgery residents) using the AOSpine subaxial cervical spine classification system and the A&F scheme. The cases were displayed in a random sequence after a 6-week interval for repeat evaluation. The Kappa coefficient (κ) was used to determine inter- and intra-observer agreement. RESULTS: Inter-observer: considering the main AO injury types, the agreement was substantial for the AOSpine classification [κ = 0.61 (0.57-0.64)]; using AO sub-types, the agreement was moderate [κ = 0.57 (0.54-0.60)]. For the A&F classification, the agreement [κ = 0.46 (0.42-0.49)] was significantly lower than using the AOSpine scheme. Intra-observer: the agreement was substantial considering injury types [κ = 0.68 (0.62-0.74)] and considering sub-types [κ = 0.62 (0.57-0.66)]. Using the A&F classification, the agreement was also substantial [κ = 0.66 (0.61-0.71)]. No significant differences were observed between spine surgeons and orthopaedic residents in the overall inter- and intra-observer agreement, or in the inter- and intra-observer agreement of specific type of injuries. CONCLUSION: The AOSpine classification (using the four main injury types or at the sub-types level) allows a significantly better agreement than the A&F classification. The A&F scheme does not allow reliable communication between medical professionals.
PURPOSE: We performed an agreement study using two subaxial cervical spine classification systems: the AOSpine and the Allen and Ferguson (A&F) classifications. We sought to determine which scheme allows better agreement by different evaluators and by the same evaluator on different occasions. METHODS: Complete imaging studies of 65 patients with subaxial cervical spine injuries were classified by six evaluators (three spine sub-specialists and three senior orthopaedic surgery residents) using the AOSpine subaxial cervical spine classification system and the A&F scheme. The cases were displayed in a random sequence after a 6-week interval for repeat evaluation. The Kappa coefficient (κ) was used to determine inter- and intra-observer agreement. RESULTS: Inter-observer: considering the main AO injury types, the agreement was substantial for the AOSpine classification [κ = 0.61 (0.57-0.64)]; using AO sub-types, the agreement was moderate [κ = 0.57 (0.54-0.60)]. For the A&F classification, the agreement [κ = 0.46 (0.42-0.49)] was significantly lower than using the AOSpine scheme. Intra-observer: the agreement was substantial considering injury types [κ = 0.68 (0.62-0.74)] and considering sub-types [κ = 0.62 (0.57-0.66)]. Using the A&F classification, the agreement was also substantial [κ = 0.66 (0.61-0.71)]. No significant differences were observed between spine surgeons and orthopaedic residents in the overall inter- and intra-observer agreement, or in the inter- and intra-observer agreement of specific type of injuries. CONCLUSION: The AOSpine classification (using the four main injury types or at the sub-types level) allows a significantly better agreement than the A&F classification. The A&F scheme does not allow reliable communication between medical professionals.
Authors: Julio Urrutia; Tomas Zamora; Ratko Yurac; Mauricio Campos; Joaquin Palma; Sebastian Mobarec; Carlos Prada Journal: Spine (Phila Pa 1976) Date: 2017-03 Impact factor: 3.468
Authors: Paul A Anderson; Timothy A Moore; Kirkland W Davis; Robert W Molinari; Daniel K Resnick; Alexander R Vaccaro; Christopher M Bono; John R Dimar; Bizhan Aarabi; Glen Leverson Journal: J Bone Joint Surg Am Date: 2007-05 Impact factor: 5.284
Authors: Alexander R Vaccaro; John D Koerner; Kris E Radcliff; F Cumhur Oner; Maximilian Reinhold; Klaus J Schnake; Frank Kandziora; Michael G Fehlings; Marcel F Dvorak; Bizhan Aarabi; Shanmuganathan Rajasekaran; Gregory D Schroeder; Christopher K Kepler; Luiz R Vialle Journal: Eur Spine J Date: 2015-02-26 Impact factor: 3.134
Authors: Joost J van Middendorp; Laurent Audigé; Ronald H Bartels; Ciaran Bolger; Hamish Deverall; Priyesh Dhoke; Carel H Diekerhof; Geertje A M Govaert; Vicente Guimerá; Heiko Koller; Stephen A C Morris; Tony Setiobudi; Allard J F Hosman Journal: Spine J Date: 2013-03-29 Impact factor: 4.166
Authors: Christopher K Kepler; Alexander R Vaccaro; John D Koerner; Marcel F Dvorak; Frank Kandziora; Shanmuganathan Rajasekaran; Bizhan Aarabi; Luiz R Vialle; Michael G Fehlings; Gregory D Schroeder; Maximilian Reinhold; Klaus John Schnake; Carlo Bellabarba; F Cumhur Öner Journal: Eur Spine J Date: 2015-01-20 Impact factor: 3.134
Authors: Addison T Stone; Richard J Bransford; Michael J Lee; Marcelo D Vilela; Carlo Bellabarba; Paul A Anderson; Julie Agel Journal: Evid Based Spine Care J Date: 2010-12
Authors: Juan P Cabrera; Ratko Yurac; Alfredo Guiroy; Andrei F Joaquim; Charles A Carazzo; Juan J Zamorano; Kevin P White; Marcelo Valacco Journal: Eur Spine J Date: 2021-04-11 Impact factor: 3.134
Authors: Julio Urrutia; Pablo Besa; Sergio Morales; Antonio Parlange; Sebastian Flores; Mauricio Campos; Sebastian Mobarec Journal: Eur Spine J Date: 2018-07-11 Impact factor: 3.134
Authors: Srikanth N Divi; Gregory D Schroeder; F Cumhur Oner; Frank Kandziora; Klaus J Schnake; Marcel F Dvorak; Lorin M Benneker; Jens R Chapman; Alexander R Vaccaro Journal: Global Spine J Date: 2019-05-08
Authors: Jose A Canseco; Gregory D Schroeder; Taylor M Paziuk; Brian A Karamian; Frank Kandziora; Emiliano N Vialle; F Cumhur Oner; Klaus J Schnake; Marcel F Dvorak; Jens R Chapman; Lorin M Benneker; Shanmuganathan Rajasekaran; Christopher K Kepler; Alexander R Vaccaro Journal: Global Spine J Date: 2020-12-11
Authors: Gregory D Schroeder; Jose A Canseco; Parthik D Patel; Srikanth N Divi; Brian A Karamian; Frank Kandziora; Emiliano N Vialle; F Cumhur Oner; Klaus J Schnake; Marcel F Dvorak; Jens R Chapman; Lorin M Benneker; Shanmuganathan Rajasekaran; Christopher K Kepler; Alexander R Vaccaro Journal: Spine (Phila Pa 1976) Date: 2021-05-15 Impact factor: 3.241