| Literature DB >> 26824220 |
Jenelle L Pederson1, Lindsey M Warkentin2, Sumit R Majumdar1,3, Finlay A McAlister1,4.
Abstract
Depressive symptoms during a medical hospitalization may be an overlooked prognostic factor for adverse events postdischarge. Our aim was to evaluate whether depressive symptoms predict 30-day readmission or death after medical hospitalization. We conducted a systematic review of studies that compared postdischarge outcomes by in-hospital depressive status. We assessed study quality and pooled published and unpublished data using random effects models. Overall, one-third of 6104 patients discharged from medical wards were depressed (interquartile range, 27%-40%). Compared to inpatients without depression, those discharged with depressive symptoms were more likely to be readmitted (20.4% vs 13.7%, risk ratio [RR]: 1.73, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 1.16-2.58) or die (2.8% vs 1.5%, RR: 2.13, 95% CI: 1.31-3.44) within 30 days. Depressive symptoms were common in medical inpatients and are associated with an increased risk of adverse events postdischarge. Journal of Hospital Medicine 2016;11:373-380.Entities:
Mesh:
Year: 2016 PMID: 26824220 PMCID: PMC5066695 DOI: 10.1002/jhm.2547
Source DB: PubMed Journal: J Hosp Med ISSN: 1553-5592 Impact factor: 2.960
Summary of 18 Longitudinal Studies on Postdischarge Outcomes Among Depressed and Not Depressed Hospitalized Patients
| Author, Date of Publication, Enrollment Period | Setting Country/Region, No. of Hospitals | No. of Inpatients, Clinical Features | Major Exclusion Criteria | Follow‐up, mo | Depression Measure (Cutoff) and Screening Method | Mean Age (SD), y | % Female | Positive Screen, No. (%) | Primary Outcome, Secondary Outcomes |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Studies that use a scale based on DSM‐III criteria or a diagnostic interview according to DSM‐III criteria | |||||||||
| Frasure‐Smith et al., | Canada/Quebec, 1 urban teaching | 218, AMI | Terminal noncardiac illness, unstable, not cognitive | 6 | BDI (≥10); mod DIS by interviewer, after transfer to medicine | 60 (range, 24–88) | 22 | 68 (31), 35 (16) | All‐cause mortality |
| Frasure‐Smith et al., | Canada/Quebec, 1 urban teaching, 10 urban area | 218; 78, AMI | Terminal noncardiac illness, unstable, not cognitive | 12 | BDI (≥10) by interviewer, after transfer to medicine | 60 (11) | 32 | 290 (32) | Cardiac mortality |
| Freedland et al., | USA/MO, 1 urban teaching | 58, CHF ≥75 years | Dementia, medically unstable | 3 | Mod DIS by psychiatric residents and interviewer | 78 (6) | 57 | 10 (17) | All‐cause readmission, all‐cause mortality |
| Fulop et al., | USA/NY, 1 urban teaching | 203, CHF ≥65 years | — | 1, 6 | GDS (≥10); SCID‐NP by interviewer, at discharge | 77 (8) | 53 | 73 (36), 44 (22) | Depression, composite PCP, ED, care visits, and readmission |
| Lespérance et al., | Canada/Quebec, 1 urban teaching | 430, unstable angina | Terminal noncardiac illness, not cognitive, recent CABG | 12 | BDI (≥10); mod DIS by interviewer, 5 days after admission | 62 (11) | 29 | 178 (41), 120 (28) | Cardiac death and MI, any death, angina readmission |
| Rumsfeld et al., | CA, USA, UK, multiple | 634, AMI with CHF | Valvular or congenital heart failure | Up to 32 | MOS‐D (≥0.06) by interviewer, before discharge | 65 (11) | 28 | 143 (23) | All‐cause death, CVD death and readmission |
| Song et al., | South Korea, 2 urban teaching | 165, HF | If minor criteria for HF attributable to other medical condition | 6 | BDI (≥10) self‐administer or interviewer, 3–4 days of admin | 62 (13) | 49 | 131 (79) | HF readmission and all‐cause mortality, HF readmit |
| Papaioannou et al., | Greece/Athens, 1 urban | 230, AECOPD | Other respiratory illness, known depressed | Monthly up to 12 | BDI‐I (≥19) self‐administer, first day | 71 (9) | 12 | 91 (40) | All‐cause mortality, AECOPD readmission |
| Studies that use a scale based on or validated against DSM‐IV criteria or a diagnostic interview according to DSM‐IV criteria | |||||||||
| Almagro et al., | Spain, 1 urban teaching | 130, AECOPD | Other pulmonary disease | July 1999 | GDS‐SF (≥6) by interviewer, day before discharge | 72 (9) | 8 | 43 (33) | All‐cause mortality |
| Almagro et al., | Spain, 1 urban teaching | 134, AECOPD | Other pulmonary disease | 1,‡ 36§ | GDS‐SF (≥6) by interviewer | 72 (10) | 5 | 55 (41) | All‐cause mortality,§ lung function,‡ frailty‡ |
| Büla et al., | Switzerland, 1 urban teaching | 401, medical ≥ 75 years | Stay <24 hours, elective/facility transfer, unstable, not cognitive | 6 | GDS‐SF (≥6) by interviewer, within 2 days of admission | 82 (75–99) | 61 | 90 (22) | All‐cause readmission, all‐cause mortality |
| Cancino et al., | USA/MA, 1 urban tertiary | 680; 738, medical | Nursing home or hospital transfer, isolated, suicidal | 1 | PHQ‐9 (≥5 or severity) by interviewer, on admin | 50 (14) | 51 | 561 (40) | All‐cause readmission, ED visits, PCP visits |
| Mitchell et al., | USA/MA, 1 urban tertiary | 738, medical | Nursing home or hospital transfer, isolated, suicidal | 1, 2, 3 | PHQ‐9 (≥5) by interviewer, on admin | 50 (15) | 50 | 238 (32) | ED visits and all‐cause readmission |
| Covinsky et al., | USA/OH, 1 urban teaching | 573, medical | ICU, oncology, telemetry, nursing home admissions | 36 | GDS‐SF (≥6) by interviewer, within 2 days of admission | 80 | 68 | 197 (34) | All‐cause mortality |
| Jiang et al., | USA/NC, 1 urban teaching | 357 (331 DIS only), CHF | Suicidal, planned surgery, pregnant | 3, 12 | BDI (≥10) self‐admin; mod DIS (+BDI only) by interviewer | 63 (13) | 33 | 126 (35), 46 (14) | All‐cause mortality, all‐cause readmission |
| Kartha et al., | USA/MA, 1 urban safety net | 144, medical recently hospitalized | Planned readmission, unable to keep PCP appointments | 3 | PHQ‐9 (algorithm) by interviewer | 55 (16) | 56 | 39 (27) | All‐cause readmission |
| Koenig and Kuchbhatla, | USA/NC, 1 urban teaching | 331, medical ≥60 years | Stay <3 or >7 days, ICU/CCU, severe illness, nursing home transfers | 3, 6, 9, 12 | CES‐D (≥16) or HAM‐D (≥11) or DIS by psychiatrist, on or after third day | 70 (7) | 51 | 160 (48) | Depression, composite physical disability, health visits, and all‐cause readmission |
| Rollman et al., | USA/PA, 4 urban teaching | 471, CHF, suspected depressed | Antidepressants users (excluded from PHQ‐2 group only) | Up to 12 | PHQ‐2; PHQ‐9 (≥5 in +PHQ‐2), by interviewer, ∼4 days | 66 (13) | 35 | 371 (79), 351 (74) | All‐cause mortality |
NOTE: Abbreviations: AECOPD, acute exacerbation of chronic obstructive pulmonary disease; AMI, acute myocardial infarction; BDI, Beck Depression Inventory; CABG, coronary artery bypass graft surgery; CES‐D, Center for Epidemiologic Studies‐Depression Scale; CHF, congestive heart failure; CVD, cardiovascular disease; DIS, Diagnostic Interview Schedule; DSM, Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders; ED, emergency department; GDS, Geriatric Depression Scale; GDS‐SF, Geriatric Depression Scale‐Short Form; HADS, Hospital Anxiety and Depression Scale; HAM‐D, Hamilton Depression Rating Scale; HF, heart failure; ICU/CCU, intensive care unit/coronary care unit; MI, myocardial infarction; mod DIS, Diagnostic Interview Schedule modified for research interviewers; MOS‐D, Medical Outcomes Study‐Depression Questionnaire; PCP, primary care physician; PHQ‐9, Patient Health Questionnaire‐9; PHQ‐2, Patient Health Questionnaire‐Short Screen; SCID‐NP, Structured Clinical Interview–Nonpsychiatric Patient Version; SD, standard deviation. *Subgroup of same cohort for those with identical enrollment periods. †Enrolment period not available. Period based on year of submission if specified or year previous to publication. ‡Follow‐up for other specified outcomes. §Follow‐up for mortality.
Figure 1Risk ratios for 30‐day readmission for depressed compared to not depressed patients.
Forest plot presents results of the meta‐analysis in which the size of each data marker indicates the weight assigned to individuals studies. Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; IV, independent variable.
Figure 2Risk ratios for 30‐day mortality for depressed compared to not depressed patients. Forest plot presents results of the meta‐analysis in which the size of each data marker indicates the weight assigned to individuals studies. Abbreviations: CI, confidence interval; IV, independent variable.