Effects of strain relaxation in Pr0.67Sr0.33MnO3 films probed by polarization dependent X-ray absorption near edge structure.

The Mn K edge X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) of Pr0.67Sr0.33MnO3 films with different thicknesses on (001) LaAlO3 substrate was measured, and the effects of strain relaxation on film properties were investigated. The films showed in-plane compressive and out-of-plane tensile strains. Strain relaxation occurred with increasing film thickness, affecting both lattice constant and MnO6 octahedral rotation. In polarization dependent XANES measurements using in-plane (parallel) and out-of-plane (perpendicular) geometries, the different values of absorption resonance energy Er confirmed the film anisotropy. The values of Er along these two directions shifted towards each other with increasing film thickness. Correlating with X-ray diffraction (XRD) results it is suggested that the strain relaxation decreased the local anisotropy and corresponding probability of electronic charge transfer between Mn 3d and O 2p orbitals along the in-plane and out-of-plane directions. The XANES results were used to explain the film-thickness dependent magnetic and transport properties.

The perovskite manganites (Re1-xAxMnO3), where Re is a trivalent rare earth, and A is a divalent metal exhibit a range of interesting properties12 such as high spin polarization and colossal magnetoresistance (CMR). Manganites are potential candidates for resistance random access memories (RRAM) in the next generation of non-volatile memories345. The electronic structure plays an important role4 in resistance switching of RRAM678. The electronic structure of manganite is correlated with the local environment9 that affects material properties10. For example, the intersite hopping of Mn 3d electrons through the bridging oxygen 2p orbital affects the double-exchange coupling strength11 and Curie temperature c. Crystal structure and electronic structure are correlated through strong electron-phonon coupling in manganites1. Thin films grown on single crystal substrates are normally strained due to lattice-mismatch between the film and substrate. The crystal structure and octahedral rotation of thin films may therefore differ from that of bulk12. Strain relaxation occurs gradually and continuously with increasing film thickness, leading to film-thickness dependent c1912. Polarization dependent X-ray absorption structure (XAS) may be used to probe the film-thickness dependent electronic structure. Correlating the electronic structure with the crystal structure, material properties such as magnetoresistance may be better understood.

X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) provides insight into the electronic structure of the absorbing atom13. For manganites, the absorbing ion of interest is Mn in the MnO6 octahedron. The Mn XAS may be collected either by total electron yield (TEY) mode or total fluorescence yield (TFY) mode14. Due to the low fluorescence signal intensity in the soft X-ray region15, the TFY mode cannot be used. Instead the total electron yield (TEY) mode may be employed to collect the Mn edge (~640 eV) XAS, however, the signal sampling depth is limited to only a few nanometers near the surface1014. The surface-sensitive information from TEY may not necessarily be representative for thick films. Additional information and discussion of Mn edge data are found in Supplementary Figure S1 online.

In the hard X-ray region, the quality of the TFY signal is enhanced, and therefore may be used to collect the Mn edge (~6.5 keV) signal16. The TFY signal is bulk sensitive17 and is suitable for investigating the effects of strain relaxation in films of the various thicknesses (12 to 100-nm) as used in our current study. The main absorption structure in the Mn edge XANES is due to the excitation of a Mn core 1s electron to empty 4p orbitals18, which is sensitive to the local environment around the absorbing atom. For example, due to hybridization between Mn 3d orbitals and O 2p orbitals, there exists a mixture of O 2p orbitals with Mn 3d orbitals. The electronic structure with n electrons in Mn 3d orbitals may be described as a mixture of two configurations19202122: 3dn and 3dn+1 refers to the O ligand surrounding the Mn ion, and indicates O ligand with one electron hole resulting from the electron transfer from O 2p to empty Mn 3d orbitals. After X-ray absorption, two electronic configurations exist for the final states: 3dn4p1 and 3dn+14p1. These final states may be revealed in the fine structure of XANES. The effects of strain relaxation on film properties may be investigated using the sensitivity of XANES to the crystal structure.

In this work we report the Mn edge X-ray absorption near edge structure (XANES) of Pr0.67Sr0.33MnO3 (PSMO) films of different thicknesses on (001) LaAlO3 (LAO) substrates. The narrow bandwidth manganite has high strain sensitivity23. Bulk PSMO has a smaller bandwidth than that of the La1-xSrxMnO3 system1. Thus, bulk PSMO may find potential application due to its high transition temperature, i.e. its ferromagnetic metal (FM)-to-paramagnetic insulator (PI) phase transition at ~ 300 K2425. Our results show that the PSMO films deposited on LAO substrate experienced in-plane compressive strain and out-of-plane tensile strain. In polarization dependent measurements, the in-plane (parallel) and out-of-plane (perpendicular) XANES showed anisotropic properties with different absorption energies r (peak point). With increasing film thickness, the difference of r between these two polarization dependent measurements decreased. Correlating with the XRD results, it is suggested that the strain relaxation weakened the local anisotropy and the corresponding probability of charge transfer between Mn 3d and O 2p along in-plane and out-of-plane directions. This is responsible for the change of r with increasing film thickness. The transport and magnetic properties also changed with strain relaxation, mediated by the change of electronic structure.

Results

The XRD results of PSMO films are shown in Fig. 1(a–c). For the 12-nm film, the in-plane lattice constant (3.790 Å) was the same as that of the LAO substrate (as shown in Fig. 1(b)), indicating that the PSMO film was fully strained by the LAO substrate. The calculated26 out-of-plane lattice constant (3.958 Å) from the (002) peak was larger than the bulk value (3.860 Å). The in-plane compressive strain (−1.8%) between the PSMO film and LAO substrate elongated the out-of-plane lattice27. In the 80-nm and the 100-nm films, the (00l) curves (Fig. 1a) indicate more than one peak. The results were fitted into two components (P1 and P2) as shown in Supplementary Figure S2 online. The reciprocal space mapping around the (−103) peak and L scan indicate that the in-plane and out-of-plane lattice constants are not uniform for the 100-nm film, as a result of strain relaxation in this thicker film (Fig. 1b,c). However, due to the volume-averaged XRD signal and the overlapping peaks, the differentiation of the value of for these two parts are difficult. To resolve this challenge, volume conservation was assumed. The in-plane lattice constants of P1 and P2 components were calculated based on the volume-conservation assumption28, as shown in Table 1. Previous work revealed that moving from the LAO substrate into the PSMO film, the value of the PSMO film changed gradually from 3.790 Å of substrate to that of PSMO (>3.950 Å) in ~15 unit cells27. This could cause a peak shift and broadening. As indicated in Table 1, the lower value in the 12-nm film compared to that in 30 nm film could be attributed to this non-uniform region. The effects of this region on film properties will be discussed later. With the increase of film thickness from 30 nm, the strain relaxed partially and the out-of-plane lattice parameter decreased gradually. Due to strain relaxation, the tetragonal ratio c/a (Table 1) of the PSMO film changed, and the corresponding change of the MnO6 octahedron is illustrated in Fig. 1(d). Previous work of epitaxial films on different substrates29303132 showed that the tetragonal c/a ratio had a direct influence on electronic structure and anisotropy in the electronic hopping integral.

Figure 1

(a) (00l) scan of PSMO films with different thicknesses on LAO substrate; reciprocal spacing mapping around (−103) for (b) 12-nm and (c) 100-nm film; (d) illustration of strain relaxation in tetragonal ratio of MnO6 octahedron.

Table 1

Summary of averaged lattice constant, tetragonal ratio, measured (Exp.) and calculated (Cal.) Curie temperature c of PSMO films with different thicknesses.

Thickness (nm)	a (Å)	c (Å)	c/a	MnO6 Tilt	Tc/Tc, 30 nm
					Exp.	Cal.
12	3.790	3.957	1.044	a0a0c−	—	—
30	3.790	3.959	1.045	a0a0c−	1	1
50	3.790	3.958	1.044	a−a−c−	1.013	1.006
80	3.792 (L)	3.956 (L)	1.043 (L)	a−a−c−	1.221	1.040
3.796 (R)	3.947(R)	1.040 (R)
100	3.792 (L)	3.954(L)	1.043 (L)	a−a−c−	1.275	1.102
3.807 (R)	3.924(R)	1.031 (R)

T c was normalized to that of the 30-nm film. For the lattice constants of the 80-nm and 100-nm films, the in-plane lattice constant was calculated based on volume-conservation. Refer to the text for more details.

The strain affects not only the lattice constant, but also the MnO6 rotation in the PSMO films. In Fig. 2(a–c), half-integer diffraction was measured to determine the octahedral rotation. According to Glazer’s notation33343536, the MnO6 rotation pattern in the 12-nm film is 00-. With increasing film thickness, one additional peak (0.5 0.5 1.5) gradually appeared and became obvious in the 50-nm film, as shown in Fig. 2(c). Note that the intensity of this peak (indicated by the purple arrow in Fig. 2(c) for films ≥ 50 nm) is weak. This suggests that the MnO6 rotation in the thick films (≥50 nm) became −−−. The effects of strain relaxation on the MnO6 rotation is illustrated in Fig. 2(d). The measured rotation of AlO6 in the LAO substrate was --- in our study, consistent with the reported results21. The in-plane compressive strain suppressed the octahedron tilt around the two in-plane (x and y) axes. The rotation around the two in-plane axes gradually occurred with partial relaxation of in-plane compressive strain in the thick films. This phenomenon is consistent with previous work21 that demonstrated the existence of in-plane rotation (−/−) in strain-free and in-plane tensile strain cases. Based on the integer and half-integer diffraction results, the crystal structure of PSMO films with different thicknesses changed drastically, affecting the corresponding electronic structure and other film properties.

Figure 2

Half-integer diffraction peak of (a) 100-nm and (b) 12-nm PSMO films; (c) the (0.5 0.5 l) peak of PSMO film with different thicknesses. The curve was normalized to the LAO (002) peak; (d) illustration of the effect of strain relaxation on MnO6 octahedral rotation pattern.

The properties of manganites are strongly coupled with the electronic structure. XANES is able to detect the local environment of the absorbing atom and electronic structure. Polarization dependent XANES was used to study the effects of strain on the electronic structure. The polarization dependent XANES is defined as follows: in parallel measurement (||), the polarization vector ( vector) of the X-rays was in the film plane; in perpendicular case (⊥), the polarization vector was perpendicular to the film plane. The polarization-dependent Mn edge XANES of the 12-nm PSMO film is shown in Fig. 3. In this study, we only focused on the main absorption edge at ~ 6555 eV, which is due to the electronic excitation from the Mn core 1s orbital to empty 4p orbitals18. The absorption intensity revealed the unoccupied states of the Mn 4p orbitals.

Figure 3

(a) Polarized Mn K edge XANES and (b) corresponding derivative curves for the 12-nm PSMO film.

As shown in Fig. 3, the resonance energy (peak point) was different between the two polarization dependent measurements (|| and ⊥). The PSMO film experienced in-plane compressive and out-of-plane tensile strains as shown from the XRD measurements. In the parallel measurement, the polarization direction was along the in-plane compressive strain direction giving a higher value (6555.8 eV). In the perpendicular measurement, the polarization direction was along the out-of-plane tensile strain direction with a lower (6554.9 eV). The derivative curves of Mn edge XANES are shown in Fig. 3(b). In the parallel measurement, the Mn edge XANES revealed two sub-peaks at 6552.4 eV (B1) and 6553.7 eV (B2), respectively. In the perpendicular case, the intensity of the lower energy peak (B1) increased, whereas the higher energy peak (B2) disappeared. There are several possible reasons for the origin of these two sub-peaks. (1) The coexistence of the Mn3+ and Mn4+ ions in the film3738. The ratio of B1/B2 should be similar in both parallel and perpendicular measurements if the ions with different chemical valences are the main factor, whereas our experimental results show different B1/B2 ratios for films with different thicknesses. (2) The energy splitting of Mn empty 4px, 4py, 4p levels due to the anisotropy of the local environment39. The strain relaxation in thick film changed its crystal structure, and the position of B1 and B2 should change accordingly if the strain-induced splitting of Mn 4p energy level was responsible. However, the positions of B1 and B2 peaks from the derivative curves did not change with different thicknesses. (3) The electronic charge transfer between the Mn 3d and O 2p orbitals40 (Fig. 4(a)). The anisotropic strain along in-plane and out-of-plane directions induces large anisotropy in the local environment in the two directions. The hybridization between Mn 3d orbitals and O 2p orbitals then becomes anisotropic due to the difference of orbital overlap along these two different directions41. During the X-ray absorption process (from Mn core 1s to Mn 4p), the charge transfer (from O 2p to Mn 3d) existed simultaneously. The final state may be viewed as a mixture of two electronic configurations192021: 3dn4p1, and 3dn+14p1. The refers to the O ligands, and indicates one hole in the O ligands, resulting from the electron transfer from O 2p to empty Mn 3d orbitals. In the 3dn+14p1 configuration, the Coulomb interaction between the Mn 1s core hole and the extra 3d electron lowers the total energy from electron transfer15. Hence, the lower energy B1 peak corresponded to the photon absorption leading to the final configuration 3dn+14p1 as shown in Fig. 4(b), and the higher energy B2 peak corresponds to the photon absorption leading to the final configuration 3dn4p1. This assignment was further supported by the density of states (DOS) calculated using the FEFF8.4 code. The 118 atomic cluster was built based on XRD results and the simulation details were expressed elsewhere4243. Fig. 4(c) shows the p, d-projected density of states (DOS) on the Mn site for a 12-nm PSMO film with the Fermi level set to zero. The peak A in Mn 3d orbitals is assigned to the pre-edge of Mn edge XANES, while the peak B1 and B2 in p orbitals is assigned to the main edge absorption19. The splitting of the DOS around B1 and B2 causes the multiple peaks in the X-ray absorption curve.

Figure 4

Illustration of (a) charge transfer (∆) between Mn 3d and O 2p orbitals, and (b) final electronic configuration after X-ray absorption. Refer to the text for details; (c) the calculated p and d-projected density of states (DOS) of the Mn atom for the 12-nm PSMO film.

Taking the perpendicular measurement as an example, the excited Mn 1s core electron will fill the empty 4pz orbital. In this situation, the dominant charge transfer is the in-plane process (Fig. 4(a)), filling the Mn 3dx2−y2 orbital through O 2px, 2py orbitals. Although the Mn 3d orbitals hybridized with 6 oxygen atoms in all x, y, z directions, the possibility of electron transfer from oxygen 2p to fill the Mn 3d3z2−r2 is limited due to the strong Coulomb interaction between the excited 1s core electron at 4pz and the electron at the 3d3z2−r2 orbital (in the event that the transferred electron occupied the 3d3z2−r2 orbital). In this case, the in-plane compressive strain enhances the hybridization between Mn 3d and O 2p orbitals, resulting in strong absorption corresponding to the 3dn+14p1 (B1 peak) configuration. Similarly, in the parallel measurement, the dominant charge transfer was the out-of-plane process, filling the Mn 3d3z2−r2 orbital through O 2pz orbitals. The out-of-plane tensile strain weakens the hybridization between Mn and O, limiting the absorption corresponding to the 3dn+14p1 (B1 peak) configuration.

The two B1 and B2 sub-peaks in the derivative curve (Fig. 3d) indicate that the shape of the Mn edge XANES has two contributions, and the relative ratio of the B1/ B2 peak intensity affects the maximum position of XANES (). Both the crystal structure and the charge transfer were affected by the strain relaxation, which is revealed by . The Mn edge XANES of PSMO films of different thicknesses is shown in Fig. 5(a). The difference of of two polarization dependent measurements, summarized in Fig. 5(b), showed a decrease with increasing film thickness. This phenomenon may be understood as follows: with the existence of strain relaxation, the anisotropy of the local environment along the in-plane and out-of-plane directions decreased as demonstrated in Fig. 1(d). Thus there is a decrease in the difference of probability of electronic charge transfer along the two directions (parallel direction from O 2px,y to Mn 3dx2−y2; and perpendicular direction from O 2pz to Mn 3d3z2−r2). The difference of relative ratio of B1/B2 peak in XANES is thus decreased, and the resonance energy along the two directions shifts towards each other with increasing film thickness.

Figure 5

(a) Polarized Mn K edge XANES for PSMO films with different thicknesses; (b) summary of r from the parallel and perpendicular measurements with varying film thickness. The dashed lines are viewing guides.

Discussion

The polarization dependent XANES is sensitive to the electronic structure due to the hybridization between Mn 3d and O 2p orbitals. In the 12-nm film, the in-plane charge transfer predominated over that in the out-of-plane direction. With increasing film thickness, both the in-plane and out-of-plane charge transfer became important. Figure 6(a–c) shows the magnetoresistance (MR = (ρH − ρ0)/ρ0) curves for the PSMO films. Large MR values existed near c in all films. At low temperature the MR value increased with decreasing film thickness. It has been identified that with decreasing film thickness the quantum interference effects (QIE) from electron-electron interactions and weak localization4445 become more important at low temperature. The dimensionality of the system, i.e. 3-dimensional (3D) and 2-dimensional (2D), influences the temperature dependent resistance. In the 2D system, the QIE has a logarithmic dependence (ln T) as follows4445:

Figure 6

(a) the magnetization-temperature (MT) curves of PSMO films with different thicknesses, measured with a field of 100 Oe; (b) resistance-temperature (RT) curves at 0T and (c) Magnetoresistance (MR) of PSMO film with a magnetic field of 4T; (d) The change of χ2 with film thickness. The red dot refers to equation (1) and the blue star refers to equation (2). Refer to the text for more information.

In the 3D system, the QIE changes as Tp/2. The fitting parameter p = 1 has been used to determine the change from 3D to 2D43, as shown below:

where, A, B, C, and n are free fitting parameters. In our work, the low temperature (<60 K) transport data were fitted according to the two above equations. The normalized characterizes how well the experimental data is fitted; a smaller value indicates a better fit. In this equation, N is the number of data points, and are measured and fitted resistivities, respectively. The fitting details are found in Supplementary Figure S3 online. It was observed that the ln T fitting was better with a smaller for the 12-nm film; for thicker films (80 nm), the T1/2 showed a better fit. For the 100-nm film, the absolute difference between the two values was very small, probably indicating the decreasing role played by the QIE correction terms in equations (1) and (2)44. In other words, the two equations using the QIE correction terms may no longer be applicable in thick films. The fitting data suggest that in the 12-nm film, the 2D QIE seemed to emerge. Figure 6(c) shows an increase of MR value with decreasing film thickness at low temperature (10–100 K). Weak electronic localization in thin film may produce large negative MR effects46 at low temperature. Details of the 3D-to-2D cross over as a function of film thickness warrant further study, which is beyond the current scope of investigation.

The double-exchange model suggests that the exchange interaction intensity is proportional to the averaged electron hopping possibility4748495051 between the two neighboring Mn sites () and c. In the case of weak strain, strain relaxation affects the crystal structure and c of manganite films may be calculated according to the following equation48:

where is the bulk strain, is the Jahn-Teller strain, and 25.

Calculated values of c using equation (3) increased with increasing film thickness, consistent with the experimental results as shown in Fig. 6(a) and in Table 1. Note that for calculations involving the 80-nm and 100-nm films, the averaged lattice constant was used (from the area ratio of volume-averaged XRD results, see Supplementary Figure S2 online). The discrepancy between experimental and calculated values may arise from ignoring the effects of inhomogeneous crystal structure through film thickness and orbital reconstruction29303132. In the 100-nm film, strain relaxation weakened the anisotropy in the local environment and enhanced the electronic hopping probability. For the 12-nm film with the lowest c, the effects of interface may be important and warrant further investigation.

In summary, the effects of thickness-dependent strain relaxation on Pr0.67Sr0.33MnO3 film properties were investigated. The films showed in-plane compressive strain and out-of-plane tensile strain. Strain relaxation occurred with increasing film thickness, affecting both the lattice constant and MnO6 octahedral rotation. These in turn influenced the corresponding electronic structures. In polarization dependent measurements, the in-plane and out-of-plane XANES were anisotropic with different absorption energy r. With increasing film thickness, the difference of r between the two polarization dependent measurements decreased. Based on the XRD results, the strain relaxation weakened the local anisotropy and probability of charge transfer (between Mn 3d and O 2p orbitals) along the in-plane and out-of-plane directions, giving rise to the change in r. The magnetoresistance effect and Curie temperature of PSMO films also showed variation with strain relaxation.

Methods

Film fabrication

Pr0.67Sr0.33MnO3 (PSMO) films with different thicknesses (12, 30, 50, 80 and 100 nm) were grown on (001) LaAlO3 (LAO) single crystal substrates using a 248 nm KrF pulsed laser at a substrate temperature of 780 °C and a pure oxygen pressure of 26 Pa. The energy of the laser beam was 90 mJ and the pulse frequency was 5 Hz. After deposition, the films were cooled to room temperature at 20 K/min.

Characterization

X-ray diffraction (XRD) was measured using four-circle diffractometer at the Singapore Synchrotron Light Source (SSLS) with CuKα1 radiation equivalent. The magnetic properties were measured by a superconducting quantum interference device (SQUID), and the transport properties were measured by Physical Property Measurement System (PPMS). The polarization dependent XANES measurements were performed using linear polarized X-rays at beamline 20-ID-B of the Advanced Photon Source (APS), Argonne National Laboratory, USA. Fluorescent X-rays were detected using a multi-element germanium detector, and the XANES normalization was done using Athena. Details on the beamline optics and instruments may be found elsewhere2526. A Mn metal foil was placed to intercept a scattered beam for monochromator energy calibration.

Additional Information

How to cite this article: Zhang, B. et al. Effects of strain relaxation in Pr0.67Sr0.33MnO3 films probed by polarization dependent X-ray absorption near edge structure. Sci. Rep. 6, 19886; doi: 10.1038/srep19886 (2016).