Jason Silvestre1, Ines C Lin2, Joseph M Serletti2, Benjamin Chang2. 1. The Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. Electronic address: jasonsilvestremd@gmail.com. 2. The Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: The integrated plastic surgery match is among the most competitive residency matches in recent years. Although previous studies have correlated applicant characteristics with successful match outcomes, none have comprehensively investigated the role of geography in the match. This study elucidates regional biases in the match. METHODS: Plastic surgery residents who matched during 2011-2015 were eligible for study inclusion. Names of residents were obtained from official residency program websites and cross-referenced with data obtained from the Student Doctor Network. For each resident, region of residency program and medical school were compared. RESULTS: From 67 programs, 622 residents were identified. Most graduated from US medical schools (97.9%). A total of 94 residents matched at a home institution (15.1%). Half of the residents matched in the same region as their medical school (48.9%). Programs in the South matched the greatest number of residents from the same region (60.8%), whereas West programs matched the least (30.8%, p < 0.001). No regional differences existed regarding residents matching at their home institution (p = 0.268). More women matched at West programs (43.1%) versus East programs (30.6%, p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: A significant number of residents matched at their home institution. Roughly, half matched at a program in the same region as their medical school. Whether this regional phenomenon stems from applicant or program factors remains unknown. Yet, given the limited number of interviews and the high costs of interviewing, applicants and programs can use these data to help optimize the match process.
BACKGROUND: The integrated plastic surgery match is among the most competitive residency matches in recent years. Although previous studies have correlated applicant characteristics with successful match outcomes, none have comprehensively investigated the role of geography in the match. This study elucidates regional biases in the match. METHODS: Plastic surgery residents who matched during 2011-2015 were eligible for study inclusion. Names of residents were obtained from official residency program websites and cross-referenced with data obtained from the Student Doctor Network. For each resident, region of residency program and medical school were compared. RESULTS: From 67 programs, 622 residents were identified. Most graduated from US medical schools (97.9%). A total of 94 residents matched at a home institution (15.1%). Half of the residents matched in the same region as their medical school (48.9%). Programs in the South matched the greatest number of residents from the same region (60.8%), whereas West programs matched the least (30.8%, p < 0.001). No regional differences existed regarding residents matching at their home institution (p = 0.268). More women matched at West programs (43.1%) versus East programs (30.6%, p < 0.05). CONCLUSIONS: A significant number of residents matched at their home institution. Roughly, half matched at a program in the same region as their medical school. Whether this regional phenomenon stems from applicant or program factors remains unknown. Yet, given the limited number of interviews and the high costs of interviewing, applicants and programs can use these data to help optimize the match process.
Keywords:
Interpersonal and Communication Skills; Medical Knowledge; Professionalism; application; education; medical student; residency; resident; women
Authors: Lauren M Sinik; Katie G Egan; Alexis K Bagwell; Allison C Nauta; James A Butterworth Journal: J Surg Educ Date: 2022-07-11 Impact factor: 3.524
Authors: Laura R Hopson; Mary A Edens; Margaret Goodrich; Michael Kiemeney; Elizabeth B Werley; Adam Kellogg; Douglas Franzen Journal: West J Emerg Med Date: 2020-12-14
Authors: Adam D Glener; Michael Lebhar; J Andres Hernandez; Amanda R Sergesketter; Ronnie L Shammas; Roger W Cason; Sonali Biswas; Brett T Phillips Journal: Plast Reconstr Surg Glob Open Date: 2021-04-20