| Literature DB >> 26771647 |
Vanessa D Arriola1, Jeffrey W Rozelle2.
Abstract
Traumatic brain injury (TBI) is commonly defined by Menon et al. as an "alteration of the brain function, or other evidence of brain pathology, caused by an external force." TBI can be caused by penetrating trauma to the head in which the magnitude of the injury is dependent on the magnitude of the forces that are applied to the head. The consequences of TBI can range from minimal to severe disability and even death. The major objectives of this systematic review are to survey the current literature on Operation Enduring Freedom (OEF) and Operation Iraqi Freedom (OIF) Hispanic veterans with TBI. To complete this analysis, the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and MetaAnalysis (PRISMA) identified 875 articles in common and retrieved a total of 34 articles that met the inclusion criteria, consisted of OEF/OIF Hispanic veterans, reported quantitative data, and were conducted with adult U.S. veterans living in the United States. Since TBI diagnosis was unclear in most articles, only five articles that used the VATBIST instrument were analyzed. The results suggested that there is a lack of research on OEF/OIF Hispanic veterans and Hispanic subgroups. Future studies need to be conducted to consider minority groups while analyzing data involving TBI.Entities:
Keywords: Hispanic; TBI; traumatic brain injury; veteran
Year: 2016 PMID: 26771647 PMCID: PMC4810037 DOI: 10.3390/bs6010003
Source DB: PubMed Journal: Behav Sci (Basel) ISSN: 2076-328X
Severity of traumatic brain injury (TBI).
| Severity | Glasgow Coma Scale Rating (GCS) | Loss of Consciousness (LOC) | Alteration of Consciousness (AOC) | Posttraumatic Amnesia (PTA) | Structural Brain Imaging |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Mild | 13–15 | Up to 30 min | Up to 24 h | Up to 24 h | Normal |
| Moderate | 9–12 | 30 min to 24 h | > 24 h | 24 h to 7 days | Normal or abnormal |
| Severe | 9–8 | > 24 h | > 24 h | > 7 days | Normal or abnormal |
Notes: Adapted from: [26].
Figure 1PRISMA flow diagram.
Review on traumatic brain injury in United States Operation Enduring Freedom/Operation Iraqi Freedom (OEF/OIF) Hispanic veteran.
| Study | Study Design, Population Sample | Sample Size (% Hispanic) | TBI Definition | Assessment | Outcomes | Critique |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Patil | Retrospective cohort study | 246 (19%) | VA’s TBI screening. | Self-reported head pain occurring 30 days prior to initial MTBI screening. Headache severity: Neurobehavioral Symptoms Inventory (0 = none; 4 = almost always) | 45% diagnosed with migraine headaches. 20% diagnosed with chronic daily headaches. 92% reported some level of sleep disturbances. | Small sample size. Self-report data (not a valid instrument) for headaches. Low follow up (missing chart information) |
| Ettenhofer | Retrospective, cross-sectional design. | 57 (21.4%) | VA’s TBI screening. TBI’s definition. | Medical chart review. Clinical interview. | Post concussive symptoms = 34% of veterans self-reported (severe to very severe). | Small sample size. Generability: Only one Polytrauma Network. 89.5% individuals were diagnosed with PTSD. Other co-morbidities could affect the functional status ( |
| Norman | Retrospective, cross-sectional design | 303,716 (~12%) | VA’s TBI screening. DoD TBI’s definition Severe: Normal or abnormal imaging, LOC > 24 h; AOC > 24, PTA > 7 days. | ICD-9-CM code for communications disorders (aphasia, voice disorders and, fluency) | Voice disorders (3.5 per 1000). Aphasia (1.9 per 1000). Fluency disorder (0.7 per 1000). TBI with aphasia (OR = 11.09–252.75, | Diagnostic bias: some veterans were only diagnosed once with communication disorders. Diagnostic categories too broad. No clear mechanism of injury, could be associated with speech-language problems |
| Rodgers | Retrospective, cross-sectional design Veterans Affairs Outpatient Level 3 Polytrauma clinic | 310 (1.3%) | DoD TBI’s definition. VA’s TBI screening. Self-report TBI | Self-report of Beck Depression Inventory II (BDI-II) Score: 0 = no symptoms to 3 = severe symptoms. | Mean BDI-II total score = 21.20 (SD = 11.76; range = 0–51) CFA’s models: three-factor TBI, two factor psychiatric, three-factor substance abuse, and two-factor neurorehabilitation samples. Chi-square for all models were significant ( | Instrument (BDI-II) was demonstrated to have a good reliability and validity in previous studies.3. Generalizability (only veterans referred to outpatient level 3polytrauma clinic. Small sample size to use CFA’s models. |
| Sozda | Cross-sectional study design | 103 (14%) | DoD TBI’s definition | Wechsler Adult Intelligence Scale (WAIS-III) Digit Span subset. Delis-Kaplan Executive Functioning System. Hopskins Verbal Learning Test. Brief Visuospatial Memory Test. Beck Depression Inventory. PTSD Checklist-Military Version | Non-normality of neuropsychological (Wilsoxon’s sign ranked tests to compare median z scores of interest, and Cohen’s r effect sizes; small = 0.1, medium= 0.3, large = 0.5). Visual learning and memory abilities = intact compared to verbal learning and memory performance = reduced. Verbal learning (SD = 1.1 below the mean) and verbal memory (SD = 1.4 below the mean) | All MTBI’s were self- reported during soldier’s active duty status. Lack of methodology while identification of included/excluded patients. Controlled environment setting, Causal relationship between psychiatric symptoms, MTBI, and neuropsychological performance. |