Benign follicular tumors comprise a large and heterogeneous group of neoplasms that share a common histogenesis and display morphological features resembling one or several portions of the normal hair follicle, or recapitulate part of its embryological development. Most cases present it as clinically nondescript single lesions and essentially of dermatological relevance. Occasionally, however, these lesions be multiple and represent a cutaneous marker of complex syndromes associated with an increased risk of visceral neoplasms. In this article, the authors present the microscopic structure of the normal hair follicle as a basis to understand the type and level of differentiation of the various follicular tumors. The main clinicopathological features and differential diagnosis of benign follicular tumors are then discussed, including dilated pore of Winer, pilar sheath acanthoma, trichoadenoma, trichilemmoma, infundibuloma, proliferating trichilemmal cyst/tumor, trichoblastoma and its variants, pilomatricoma, trichodiscoma/fibrofolliculoma, neurofollicular hamartoma and trichofolliculoma. In addition, the main syndromes presenting with multiple follicular tumors are also discussed, namely Cowden, Birt-Hogg-Dubé, Rombo and Bazex-Dupré-Christol syndromes, as well as multiple tumors of follicular infundibulum (infundibulomatosis) and multiple trichoepitheliomas. Although the diagnosis of follicular tumors relies on histological examination, we highlight the importance of their knowledge for the clinician, especially when in presence of patients with multiple lesions that may be the cutaneous marker of a cancer-prone syndrome. The dermatologist is therefore in a privileged position to recognize these lesions, which is extremely important to provide further propedeutic, appropriate referral and genetic counseling for these patients.
Benign follicular tumors comprise a large and heterogeneous group of neoplasms that share a common histogenesis and display morphological features resembling one or several portions of the normal hair follicle, or recapitulate part of its embryological development. Most cases present it as clinically nondescript single lesions and essentially of dermatological relevance. Occasionally, however, these lesions be multiple and represent a cutaneous marker of complex syndromes associated with an increased risk of visceral neoplasms. In this article, the authors present the microscopic structure of the normal hair follicle as a basis to understand the type and level of differentiation of the various follicular tumors. The main clinicopathological features and differential diagnosis of benign follicular tumors are then discussed, including dilated pore of Winer, pilar sheath acanthoma, trichoadenoma, trichilemmoma, infundibuloma, proliferating trichilemmal cyst/tumor, trichoblastoma and its variants, pilomatricoma, trichodiscoma/fibrofolliculoma, neurofollicular hamartoma and trichofolliculoma. In addition, the main syndromes presenting with multiple follicular tumors are also discussed, namely Cowden, Birt-Hogg-Dubé, Rombo and Bazex-Dupré-Christol syndromes, as well as multiple tumors of follicular infundibulum (infundibulomatosis) and multiple trichoepitheliomas. Although the diagnosis of follicular tumors relies on histological examination, we highlight the importance of their knowledge for the clinician, especially when in presence of patients with multiple lesions that may be the cutaneous marker of a cancer-prone syndrome. The dermatologist is therefore in a privileged position to recognize these lesions, which is extremely important to provide further propedeutic, appropriate referral and genetic counseling for these patients.
Benign hair follicle tumors (BHFT) encompass a large number of relatively rare neoplasms
defined by the type and degree of hair follicle differentiation as seen on their
histologic examination.They generally occur on the head and neck of adults as a nondescript slow-growing
solitary papule or nodule, and are mostly of exclusive dermatologic relevance. However
they can possess peculiar clinical features enabling the diagnosis and, most
importantly, they may be the first clinical manifestation of complex visceral
cancer-prone syndromes. In addition, some can mimic primary malignant skin neoplasms or
possess a malignant counterpart from which they should be distinguished. Occasionally
they can be misdiagnosed as benign or malignant sweat gland tumors.Diagnostic criteria for BHFT are well established and, from a practical point of view,
the main issue about these neoplasms concerns their differential diagnosis, i.e. the
distinction among different BHFT depicting some type of hair follicle differentiation
and the distinction between certain types of BHFT and basal cell carcinoma.[1,2]Their pathogenesis remains largely unknown. Loss of heterozygosity of mutated tumor
suppressor genes has been implicated in the genesis of some sporadic cases of BHFT in an
analogous manner to their respective hereditary counterparts.[3] Additionally, in some cases a relationship with viral
infection has been suggested.[4]As the precise diagnosis of these tumors, required by the reasons explained above,
depends on the similarity of their histologic phenotype to the microscopic features of
the normal hair follicle, a short review of the latter is provided emphasizing the
distinctive characteristics of the different anatomical regions of the adnexal.
MICROSCOPIC ASPECTS OF HAIR FOLLICLE DIFFERENTIATION
The mature anagen hair follicle can be divided in different segments: infundibulum,
isthmus, "stem" and bulb, distinguishable from each other by the organization and
morphology of the cells that compose them, as well as their relative disposition (Figure 1). Beyond these regions that correspond to a
vertical section of the hair follicle, two sheaths, resulting from a horizontal section
of the hair follicle, can be also defined: i) an outer hair sheath (ORS) extending from
the base of the bulb to the base of the infundibulum, which lays on a basement membrane
that in some areas is thickened and hyaline (vitreous membrane); and ii) an inner root
sheath (IRS) that is continuous along the bulb and the stem, disappearing at the
isthmus. ORS is composed of pale cells that are similar along the entire ORS. In
contrast, IRS is more complex as three concentric cell layers are identifiable: Henle
layer, Huxley layer and cuticle. The more peripheral, Henle layer is a single row column
that encloses the double row Huxley layer. These layers extend vertically from the bulb
to the stem and are composed of cells characterized by the presence of conspicuous
eosinophilic trichohyalin granules (the hair equivalent to keratohyalin). These cells
undergo cornification near the level where the stem initiates, resulting in compact
corneocytes characterized by their gray-blue hue. Cornification is seen earlier (before
the beginning of the stem) in Henle layer than in Huxley layer. Cuticle is the most
central layer of IRS and consists of axially oriented flat minute pale cells.
Figure 1:
Different segments of the hair follicle. A. Infundibulum.
Keratinization similar to the epidermis, including a granular layer and
basket-weave orthokeratosis. B. Isthmus. Trichilemmal keratinization,
characterized by absence of granular layer and abrupt compact orthokeratosis.
C. Stem. Pale outer root sheath cells surrounded by a hyaline
membrane. D. Bulb. Closely packed basophilic keratocytes and
interspersed pigmented melanocytes characteristic of the hair matrix
Different segments of the hair follicle. A. Infundibulum.
Keratinization similar to the epidermis, including a granular layer and
basket-weave orthokeratosis. B. Isthmus. Trichilemmal keratinization,
characterized by absence of granular layer and abrupt compact orthokeratosis.
C. Stem. Pale outer root sheath cells surrounded by a hyaline
membrane. D. Bulb. Closely packed basophilic keratocytes and
interspersed pigmented melanocytes characteristic of the hair matrix
Signs of infundibular differentiation
The infundibular epithelium is indistinguishable from that of the adjacent epidermis
(Figure 1A), consisting in:(i) a basal layer;(ii) a spinous layer with conspicuous intercellular bridges;(iii) a granular layer of granular cells with keratohyalin granules identical to
those of the epidermis; and(iv) a basket-weave stratum corneum. It should be noted that the infundibulum is not
a constituent of the outer root sheath (ORS).
Signs of Outer Root Sheath differentiation (isthmus; stem)
The ORS (trichilemma) consists of rows of keratinocytes with pale, abundant
PAS-positive cytoplasm, which cornify horizontally and abruptly without a granular
cell layer, originating the compact eosinophilic stratum corneum (Figures 1B and 1C). The thickness and hue of ORS changes along its length: thin and clear
at the bulb, thicker and more eosinophilic (pink) at the stem, and again thinner at
the isthmus. Although ORS cells are bound by desmosomes, inter-cellular bridges are
seldom conspicuous.Signs of ORS differentiation include:(i) pale/clear, PAS-positive cells with no conspicuous intercellular
bridges;(ii) absence of granular layer; and(iii) a compact eosinophilic stratum corneum.Some phenotypic differences between the upper (isthmus) and lower (stem) segments of
ORS exist (more striking nuclear palisading and pinker cytoplasm with higher content
of glycogen of ORS cells in the stem).Signs of Inner Root Sheath differentiation:(i) Cells with conspicuous bright eosinophilic trichohyalin (at the bulb);(ii) Compact blue-gray corneocytes (stem).(i) Inverted cup disposition of matrical cells involved by(ii) the lower (bulbar) segment of IRS, i.e. two to three columnar rows of
cells with conspicuous bright eosinophilic tricohyalin, that is, in turn,
surrounded by(iii) the most inferior portion of ORS (a thin layer of pale PAS positive
cells).Signs of hair matrix differentiation (Figure
1D)(i) Small cells with a scant basophilic cytoplasm and voluminous round nuclei
with prominent nucleolus, occurring in crowded aggregates;(ii) Mitotic figures;(iii) Necrosis of isolated cells (karyorrhexis and picnosis);(iv) Dendritic melanocytes (occasionally).(i) Ghost cells (anucleated polygonal eosinophilic cells centered by an empty
space replacing the nucleus);(ii) Refractile yellow-orange cornified cells;(iii) True hair shaft (rarely observable).(i) Loosely arranged, thin collagen fibers in a mucinous matrix;(ii) Scattered fibroblasts with round or oval nucleus;(iii) Numerous capillary blood vessels.
Signs of differentiation towards the follicular germ
Crescent-shaped, oval or round aggregates of cells with oval nucleus, and scant,
intensely basophilic cytoplasm (basaloid cells) with peripheral palisading,
recapitulating the follicular hair germ.
CLASSIFICATION
The classification of the benign follicular proliferations is histogenic and based on
the set of microscopic similarities between lesions and normal hair follicle structures
to which they can be contiguous and that are recapitulated at different degrees in the
tumor (Chart 1).
Chart 1
Classification of benign follicular tumors
Infundibular and/or isthmic differentiation
Dilated pore (Winer)
Pilar sheath acanthoma
Pilar sheath acanthoma
Trichilemmoma
Desmoplastic trichilemmoma
Infundibuloma (tumor of follicular infundibulum)
Pilar tumor (proliferating trichilemmal cyst)
Germinative cell differentiation
Trichoblastoma
Adamantinoid trichoblastoma
Trichoepithelioma
Trichogerminoma
Panfolliculoma
Matrical differentiation
Pilomatricoma
Mesenchimatous follicular differentiation
Trichodiscoma/Fibrofolliculoma
Neurofollicular hamartoma
Perifollicular fibroma
Trichofolliculoma
Folliculosebaceous cystic hamartoma
Classification of benign follicular tumors
Dilated pore (Winer)
It occurs as a small solitary papule centered by a follicular pore on the face, neck
or back, mimicking a giant comedo. It can be multiple and, exceptionally, it is
agminated with a linear distribution (dilated pore nevus).[5]Histologically it is a small vertically oriented infundibulocystic lesion, filled
with lamellar ortokeratosis.[6] The
wall recapitulates the infundibular epithelium and contains regularly spaced
elongated rete ridges, slightly thicker than those of the adjacent epidermis. These
infundibular radiary crests do not contain keratinous microcysts or sebaceous ducts,
as is the case of pilar sheath acanthoma (see below). In serial sections a subjacent
infundibular cyst may be occasionally found.Although it has been suggested that dilated pore of Winer merely corresponds to an
infundibular cyst opening to the skin surface with reactive wall hyperplasia
surrounded by fibrotic adventitial dermis, the identity of the lesion within the
follicular tumours has been reaffirmed. [7]Differential diagnosisPilar sheath acanthoma: See below.Comedo: It is an operculized dilated infundibular cavity filled with lamelar
ortokeratosis and limited by infundibular epithelium with no elongated rete
ridges.
Pilar sheath acanthoma
It is a rarely reported diagnosis presenting clinically as a solitary papule centered
by a keratotic plug on the upper lip or central area of the face.Microscopically, it is a well-circumscribed, vertically oriented epithelial cystic
proliferation of the dermis, opening on the skin surface and filled by lamellar
keratin.[8] Peripheral lobules
of infundibular or isthmic (pale, PAS+) cells irradiate from the acanthotic and
hyperplastic cyst wall (Figure 2). Within the
radiate lobules, where the cells of the most peripheral layer commonly display
nuclear palisading, small horn cysts and, less frequently, sebaceous ducts, sebocytes
or tiny squamous eddies may be seen.
Figure 2:
Pilar sheath acanthoma. A. This is a particularly large and solid example; note
the multilobular architecture. B. Predominantly isthmic differentiation with
abrupt compact keratinization
Pilar sheath acanthoma. A. This is a particularly large and solid example; note
the multilobular architecture. B. Predominantly isthmic differentiation with
abrupt compact keratinizationThus, the lesion is considered to be made of a more superficial infundibulocystic
portion and a deeper lobulated and radiary region with isthmic
differentiation.[1]Differential diagnosisDilated pore (Winer): The peripheral radial ridges of dilated pore
are regular, evenly spaced and made of infundibular rather than isthmic keratinocytes
and do not contain keratinous cysts. Distinction can be less straightforward in
oblique sections.Trichofoliculoma: As pilar sheath acanthoma, trichofolliculoma has a
vertically oriented well-circumscribed infundibulocystic silhouette. However, smaller
infundibula rather than pale cell lobules irradiate from the main wall, resulting in
minute dystrophic or more mature vellus hairs, features that contrast with the less
florid pattern of pilar sheath acanthoma.Due to the occasional extension to deep dermis/hypodermis and to the radiate
projections, the treatment of choice is surgical excision with a 2 mm margin from the
ostium.
Trichoadenoma (Nikolowski)
It is a rare lesion occurring in adults with no gender predilection, presenting as a
3-15 mm nondescript papule/nodule on the face, neck or trunk.Histologically it corresponds to a well-circumscribed, horizontally oriented, dermal
nodule, with no continuity with the overlying epidermis. The tumor is composed of
numerous, relatively large, round or oval, infundibulocystic structures, separated by
a poorly developed fibrous stroma (proportion epithelium/stroma: “10:1”). The
epithelial cysts are occasionally contiguous, and solid cords projecting from the
thin cystic wall, which may appear “isolated” in the stroma, can occur.
Calcifications are typically absent.[9,10]
Differential diagnosis:
Trichoepithelioma: As trichoadenoma, it is a horizontal
intradermal well-defined tumor composed of keratinous infundibulocysts depicting
granular layer. However, nests of germinative cells in nodular, trabecular and
cribriform arrays coexist in different proportions. Also, contrasting with
trichoadenoma, follicular germ, papillar or bulb differentiation and retraction
clefts within the stroma are characteristically seen in trichoepithelioma.Desmoplastic trichoepithelioma: It displays a general picture
similar to trichoadenoma but possesses a characteristic central depression and a
much more developed and denser stroma. In addition, most cells have features of
germ cells rather than infundibular differentiation, and calcification is often
seen, a feature characteristically absent in trichoadenoma.Trichilemmal cyst nevus: Although at low magnification
trichilemmal nevus may evoke the diagnosis of trichoadenoma,
the former consists of isthmic structures, with no granular layer ("agminated
trichilemmal cysts"), contrasting with the infundibular differentiation phenotype
of trichoadenoma.[11]Microcystic adnexal carcinoma: Can be distinguished from
trichoadenoma by its irregular, asymmetrical silhouette, deep extension, abundant
scirrhous stroma and characteristic perineural invasion.
Tricholemmoma
Two types of clinical presentation of trichilemomma are recognized.The more common type occurs as a solitary papule on the face of adults, generally
misdiagnosed as a verrucous papilloma, a viral wart or a basal cell carcinoma. Rarely
does it correspond to a cutaneous horn.[12]In exceptional cases the patient presents, typically after the second decade of life,
with multiple papules of the face (nasolabial folds, upper lip, front, ears). In this
variant, cutaneous lesions (trichilemommas) coexist with small papules on the oral
cavity (gums, tongue), which tend to coalesce in a cobblestone pattern corresponding
to fibromas. This "florid" clinical picture constitutes the classic mucocutaneous
presentation of Cowden's syndrome, which shows multiple extracutaneous neoplasms
(breast, kidney, intestine) and depends on germline mutations of the tumour
suppressor gene PTEN. It is generally admitted that the presence of 3 or more
histologically proven trichilemommas constitutes a major criteria for diagnosis of
Cowden's syndrome. [13] However, more
recently, in the new proposed diagnostic criteria, the presence of at least 3
trichilemmomas, one of which must be biopsy-proven, is considered enough to fulfil
one major criterion. [14]It is likely that other entities characterized by similar germline PTEN mutations
including: (i) Lhermitte-Duclos disease (hamartomatous cerebellar dysplastic
gangliocytoma); (ii) Bannayan Riley Ruvacalba syndrome (pediatric hamartomatous
syndrome displaying multiple subcutaneous lipomas, hemangiomas, intestinal polyps and
macrocefaly); and (iii) segmentar forms of a Proteus-like syndrome, constitute, with
the Cowden's syndrome, poles of a symptomatic spectrum depending of germline PTEN
mutations and generically designated as PTEN Hamartoma Tumor Syndrome
(PHTS).[15,16]Microscopically the aspect is identical in solitary and Cowden's associated variants:
a folliculocentric lobular proliferation of polygonal, clear, PAS-positive isthmic
cells with nuclear palisading of the peripheral cells that characteristically lay on
a thickened hyaline eosinophilic basement membrane (Figures 3A and 3B). Squamous eddies
are frequently seen, occasionally centered by foci of infundibular keratinization.
Pigmentation, necrosis or calcification may occur. Rarely the overlying epidermis is
hyperplastic.
Figure 3
Trichilemmoma. A. Typical lobular architecture in close relation with the
neighboring hair follicles. B. Detail of the pale cells with a hint of
peripheral palisading and surrounding hyaline membrane. C. Detail of a
desmoplastic trichilemmoma, with sclerotic stroma and apparently infiltrative
architecture. D. CD34 immunohistochemistry, demonstrating positivity in the
tumor cells
Trichilemmoma. A. Typical lobular architecture in close relation with the
neighboring hair follicles. B. Detail of the pale cells with a hint of
peripheral palisading and surrounding hyaline membrane. C. Detail of a
desmoplastic trichilemmoma, with sclerotic stroma and apparently infiltrative
architecture. D. CD34 immunohistochemistry, demonstrating positivity in the
tumor cellsSome cases of solitary trichilemmoma (as well as desmoplastic trichilemomma, see
below) could represent a reorganized viral papilloma, as testified by the occasional
presence in these cases of signs of cytopathogenic HPV effect. However this
interpretation, as well as the molecular finding of HPV in trichilemmomas, remains
controversial.[17,18]In Cowden's syndrome, beyond trichilemmomas, follicular inverted keratosis,
infundibular hyperplasia, or tumor of the follicular infundibulum (see below) have
been reported. In addition, acrokeratosis verruciformis-like lesions can occur. Oral
fibromas of Cowden's syndrome are indistinguishable microscopically from the common
oral fibroma.
Differential diagnosis
Infundibuloma: As trichilemmoma, it is made of infundibular
cells, larger and paler than the peripheral basaloid cells, displaying nuclear
palisading and laying at the dermal border of the lesion. However, in contrast to
trichilemmoma, infundibuloma has a subepidermal plaque-like general arrangement
and no peripheral hyaline membrane, but instead, a characteristic reinforcement of
the elastic tissue.Epidermal panfolliculoma: This acanthotic intraepidermal
follicular proliferation, although containing areas of trichilemmal
differentiation, recapitulates both upper and lower hair follicle segments
exhibiting, in addition, germinative, matrix, bulb, papilla, and inner root sheath
microscopic phenotypical features.Other intraepidermal clear cell neoplasms. Clear cell acanthoma:
lower limb localization, well circumscribed acanthotic lesion of pale and large
keratinocytes covered with a psoriasiform scale, distinct demarcation from
intraepidermal adnexal epithelium and surrounding keratinocytes. Clear
cell poroma: absence of both peripheral palisading and hyaline
peripheral membrane, sharp contrast with neighboring epidermis, dermal extension,
ductal differentiation. Clear cell squamous cell carcinoma in
situ: nuclear atypia, absence of basement membrane.[19]
Desmoplastic trichilemmoma (DT)
DT constitutes a type of solitary tricholemmoma characterized by a pseudo invasive
silhouette imparted by the disposition of the stroma that dissects the epithelial
tumor lobules (Figure 3C). Peripheral palisading
of nuclei may be absent.[20,21]Basal cell carcinoma: In DT no clefts between the epithelium and
stroma, nor cellular atypia or apoptosis, are found. In superficial biopsies the
distinction may be less obvious and in these cases the differential expression of
BerEP4 (present in CBC, absent in DT) and CD34 (absent in CBC, present in DT -
Figure 3D) may be helpful.Tumor of follicular infundibulum (infundibuloma)Two clinical variants occur.[22,23] More commonly the lesion is a
solitary keratotic papule of the face, neck or upper trunk in elderly patients,
judged as a seborrheic keratosis or basal cell carcinoma. Exceptionally, multiple
(<20 to >100) lenticular, hypopigmented or skin-colored, maculopapular or
slightly atrophic elements are seen on the face, neck and upper trunk of young
adults, simulating plane warts, pityriasis versicolor, guttate hypomelanosis or
vitiligo (Figure 4A).[24] Atrophic lesions may be confused
as acne scars and erythematous ones may resemble actinic porokeratosis. Although
the lesions are benign, the possibility of "transformation" into basal cell
carcinoma as well as its occurrence within the spectrum of the cutaneous lesions
of Cowden syndrome have been described, making follow-up of these patients
advisable. [25,26] It can also arise within nevus sebaceous.
Figure 4
Multiple tumors of follicular infundibulum (infundibulomatosis). A. Multiple
hypopigmented macular or slightly papular lesions in the submandibular
region. B. Plate-like proliferation of monomorphous pale keratinocytes,
well-demarcated from the adjacent epidermis. C. PAS stain is positive in the
cells. D. Condensation of elastic fibers around the base of the
proliferation (arrow)
Multiple tumors of follicular infundibulum (infundibulomatosis). A. Multiple
hypopigmented macular or slightly papular lesions in the submandibular
region. B. Plate-like proliferation of monomorphous pale keratinocytes,
well-demarcated from the adjacent epidermis. C. PAS stain is positive in the
cells. D. Condensation of elastic fibers around the base of the
proliferation (arrow)Histologically, the tumor consists of a well circumscribed, subepidermal,
horizontal, plate-like proliferation of pale-staining, PAS-positive keratinocytes
(Figures 4B and 4C). Cells are monomorphous with no atypia; peripheral
palisading of nuclei is a common feature. The peripheral cells may lie on a
thickened basement membrane, and small keratinous pseudocysts may occur. A unique
feature, peculiar to the tumor of follicular infundibulum, is the presence of a
network of elastic fibers surrounding the lower margin of the tumor (Figure 4D).Immunohistochemically the lesion stains for MNF-116 and CK5/6, and is negative for
Ber-EP4, Bcl2, CK7 and CK20.
Differential diagnosis:
Superficial basal cell carcinoma: Pale cells are seldom
prominent; the pattern is "multicentric" in nests, rather than in plaque;
clefts are obvious between the epithelium and the underlying stroma; tumor
cells are frequently atypical, and show BerEP4 and Bcl2 immunoreactivity,
features that sharply contrast with the findings in infundibuloma.[24,27]Trichilemmoma: Infundibuloma lacks the lobular folliculocentric pattern, and
peripheral hyaline basement membrane typical of trichilemomma, depicting a
subepidermal anastomosing plaque-like pattern and reinforcement of the
peripheral elastic tissue, features not found in trichilemmoma.Epidermal panfolliculoma: infundibular plate like areas made
of pale cells may occur, but only focally, the lesion being characterized by a
recapitulation of the entire spectrum of hair follicle.It should be noted that cases described as "Multiple infundibular
tumors of the head and neck" bear no resemblance with
infundibulomatosis and exhibit histological features akin to those of prurigo
nodularis.[28]The putative relationship between infundibuloma and basal cell carcinoma (BCC)
as well as the eventuality of "transformation" of infundibuloma into BCC,
although controversial, may justify the removal of solitary lesions.[29] In infundibulomatosis,
cryotherapy, CO2 laser, topical retinoids, or keratolytics may be
attempted.
Pilar tumor (proliferating trichilemmal cyst)
Typically pilar tumor (PT) is a large (2-25 cm), exophytic nodule/tumor with a
smooth, often ulcerated surface, present for years on the scalp of elderly women,
and clinically interpreted as a squamous cell carcinoma.[30] It may occur de novo or arise on
a pre-existing trichilemmal cyst, and it may have an extra-cephalic localization.
Recurrence is rare and metastases occur exceptionally.[31]The diagnosis requires the identification, at least focally, of a trichilemmal
cyst and the presence of significant cytological atypia. It resides on the dermis
and/or hypodermis and may be contiguous with the hair follicle. It corresponds to
a well-circumscribed, large, rounded solid/cystic tumor with a smooth border
surrounded by a dense pseudocapsule that is separated by clefts from the adjacent
tissue. Irregular anastomosing strands of keratinocytes irradiate centripetally
from the tumor wall. These strands are successively composed of: i) basal layer;
ii) cells with abundant eosinophilic cytoplasm similar to the outer root sheath at
the isthmus; and iii) a horny layer in direct contact with the isthmic cells,
without interposition of a granular layer (Figure
5). These cornified foci occur frequently as scattered islands
surrounded by the isthmic cells. Mitotic figures as well as dyskeratotic
keratinocytes may be observed and cytological atypia is characteristically
prominent. Calcification is common. The epithelial strands may lie on a peripheral
hyaline thickened basement membrane.
Figure 5
Proliferating trichilemmal cyst/tumor. Partially cystic and solid lesion
with keratinocytes increasing in size from the basal layer to the lumen,
displaying abrupt keratinization without granular layer
Proliferating trichilemmal cyst/tumor. Partially cystic and solid lesion
with keratinocytes increasing in size from the basal layer to the lumen,
displaying abrupt keratinization without granular layerThe intensity of cytologic atypia and the presence of mitotic figures and
dysketatosis in an epithelial tumor of eosinophilic cells that is only
partially cystic may arise the suspicion of squamous cell carcinoma. However,
the asymmetric, irregular and invasive border, focal contiguity/ replacement of
the epidermis of the latter contrast with the low and higher magnification
features of PT that additionally exhibits "trichilemmal" rather than epidermal
cornification.Despite the intensity of the atypical cytological features, PT behaves most
often in a benign fashion. The rarities of regional lymph node metastases as
well as the local symptoms warrant a complete surgical excision.
Trichoblastoma
It is a benign neoplasm made of germinative hair follicle cells with a
differentiation generally restricted towards the hair germ and papilla. It is
relatively infrequent except in the setting of organoid nevus. Clinically it
presents as a dermal or dermo-hypodermal nodule of the head or neck. When it
occurs within an organoid nevus it may be clinically felt to be a BCC.Several forms of trichoblastoma have been reported including giant, subcutaneous,
pigmented and clear cell variants. "Cutaneous lymphadenoma" is generally
considered an adamantinoid variant of trichoblastoma (see below). Also,
trichoepithelioma is thought to correspond to a trichoblastoma with advanced
differentiation (see below).Typically it corresponds to a dermal and/or hypodermal, well circumscribed,
symmetrical tumor with no contiguity with the surface epithelium, composed of
irregular nests of small basophil cells, resembling a BCC. Within the tumor the
cellular aggregates exhibit different patterns: nodular, adenoid, cystic, and
trabecular. The latter can be cribriform, racemous, reticulated or "schwannoid"
("rippled").[1]Two cell types constitute the cell aggregates of trichoblastoma: i) basaloid
cells, with inconspicuous cytoplasm and appearing to contain solely a basophil
nucleus (similar to follicular germinative cells); ii) cells with larger, pink
cytoplasm alike hair stem cells.In most instances there is a strong predominance of the germinative (basaloid)
cells. However the relative proportion of the 2 cell types is somewhat related to
the architectural pattern of the cell aggregates (e.g.: essentially germinative
cells in the nodular pattern; equivalence of germinative and stem cells in the
reticulated pattern). Hair papilla and hair germ formation ("limited hair follicle
differentiation") is typically found in trichoblastoma.Surrounding the epithelial aggregates a conspicuous, cellular or dense stroma is
found, which characteristically contains clefts present between the stroma and the
surrounding dermis, but usually not between the stroma and the epithelial
aggregates (Figure 6).
Figure 6
Trichoblastoma. A. Basaloid proliferation with dense stroma separated by
clefts from the adjacent dermis. B. Detail of the cellular stroma forming
condensations near the basaloid islands (papillary mesenchymal bodies)
Trichoblastoma. A. Basaloid proliferation with dense stroma separated by
clefts from the adjacent dermis. B. Detail of the cellular stroma forming
condensations near the basaloid islands (papillary mesenchymal bodies)Melanin in the cell nests is not rare, namely in trichoblastomas associated with
organoid nevi. Despite some cellular pleomorphism, no cytologic atypia or mitoses
are found. Similarly, pronounced tumoral necrosis is absent, but individual
apoptotic bodies with occasional confluence may be observed.Frequently, continuity with the follicular infundibulum is seen, and
infundibulocystic differentiation may occur within the nests of eosinophilic
cells. When the latter is prominent and the lesion is superficial, the histologic
picture is indistinguishable from that of trichoepithelioma (see below).The most common difficulty in the differential diagnosis is to distinguish
trichoblastoma from BCC. In most instances the asymmetric silhouette, cytologic
atypia, occasional mitoses, presence of clefts between the cellular nests and
the stroma with its mucinous character, allow the diagnosis of the latter. In
partial or superficial biopsies, and occasionally in particular cases, the
distinction may be more difficult. When the whole lesion is not available for
microscopic examination and if immunohistochemistry is performed in these
cases, CK15 immunoreactivity of the cellular aggregates as well as the presence
of scattered CK20-positive cells would favour the diagnosis of trichoblastoma.
In the same way, the differential expression of CD10 and Bcl2 (CD10 positive on
the stroma of trichoblastoma, but not on BCC cells; and Bcl2 immunoreactivity
positive in BCC cells, but negative in trichoblastoma cells) may be helpful in
the distinction.[32,33]Trichoepithelioma would correspond to a superficial variant of trichoblastoma
with prominent infundibulocystic differentiation (see below).Trichoblastoma is a benign tumor and the complete surgical excision (often
necessary for a correct histologic diagnosis) is the preferable treatment
modality. Rarely it can have malignant evolution secondary to the sarcomatous
transformation of the stroma or coexist with other malignant adnexal
neoplasm(s) within an organoid nevus.[34]
It is an uncommon neoplasm with differentiation towards the hair germ
characterized by the permeation of the tumoral tissue by a conspicuous lymphocytic
infiltrate, a feature reflected on the initial designations of "lymphoepitelial
cutaneous tumour" and "cutaneous lymphadenoma". Currently the tumor is considered
a variant of trichoblastoma.Clinically, it corresponds to a slowly growing solitary non-descript nodule on the
face or lower limb of adults. Pediatric cases are exceptional.Microscopic examination generally discloses a well-circumscribed dermal tumor made
of epithelial nests and strands, variable in size and shape, in which two cell
types are readily identifiable: (i) basophilic, germinative cells with a tendency
for nuclear palisading at the periphery of the epithelial aggregations; and (ii)
loosely arranged cells with more prominent and paler cytoplasm occupying the
centre of the tumor nests. Typically, small mature lymphocytes conspicuously
infiltrate the tumor epithelium. As a rule the epithelial aggregations are
embedded in a dense stroma (Figure
7).[35,36]
Figure 7
Trichoblastoma. A. Trichoblastoma. A. Basaloid proliferation with dense
stroma separated by clefts from the adjacent dermis. B. Detail of the
cellular stroma forming condensations near the basaloid islands (papillary
mesenchymal bodies)
Trichoblastoma. A. Trichoblastoma. A. Basaloid proliferation with dense
stroma separated by clefts from the adjacent dermis. B. Detail of the
cellular stroma forming condensations near the basaloid islands (papillary
mesenchymal bodies)The (i) cytoarchitectural compartmentalization of the tumor nests, with basaloid
peripheral cells and loosely arranged pale, glycogen-rich central cells,
observable from low magnification; (ii) the lymphoid cell infiltration; and (iii)
the presence of scattered S100 and CD1a-positive dendritic cells, are highly
characteristic and distinctive of adamantinoid trichoblastoma, which seldom poses
problems in terms of differential diagnosis.Distinction from trichogerminoma, another hair germ tumor considered by some as
another variant of trichoblastoma (see below), is based on the typical concentric
arrangement of the cells ("cell balls") on the centre of the tumor nests in
trichogerminoma, which, in addition, lacks the characteristic lymphocytic cell
permeation of adamantinoid trichoblastoma.
Trichoepithelioma
Tricoepithelioma is thought to correspond to a superficial (intradermal)
trichoblastoma with prominent infundibulocystic differentiation.Besides the more common solitary, clinically nondescript, sporadic type occurring
in adults, lesions may be multiple, presenting in childhood or adolescence with
autosomal dominant inheritance (epithelioma adenoides cysticum - OMIM 601606). In
the latter type the patient presents with multiple 2-10 mm papules occasionally
coalescing on the face (nasolabial folds) or scalp and neck. Linear blaschkoid
distribution may occur. Coexistence with cylindromas or less frequently
spiradenoma has been reported, in the context of CYLD gene mutations.[37] Multiple trichoepitheliomas are,
in addition, characteristic of Rombo syndrome and Bazex-Dupré-Christol syndrome
(BDCS). In both of these syndromes trichoepitheliomas coexist with atrophoderma
vermiculatum, milia, hypotrichosis and basal cell carcinoma. Distinction between
them depends on i): localization of the atrophodermic changes: malar regions and
elbows in Rombo syndrome versus dorsal hands in BDCS; ii) cyanotic erythema in
Rombo syndrome present from infancy, not reported in BDCS, and: iii) X-linked
transmission in BDCS contrasting to the autosomal dominant pattern of inheritance
of Rombo syndrome.[38]Occasionally giant solitary trichoepitheliomas of the thigh, buttock and perianal
regions have been reported. More frequently the solitary forms are clinically
misdiagnosed as a melanocytic nevus or a non-ulcerated BCC.Histologically, trichopithelioma is a well-demarcated intradermal tumor with a
horizontal long axis separated from the neighbouring dermis by retraction clefts.
The tumor is composed of nests of basaloid (hair germ) cells in a nodular or
trabecular array coexisting with infundibulocystic structures (Figure 8A). In the latter, calcification may be
seen. In the basaloid nests, hair germ/papilla and bulbar differentiation are
present. Although peripheral nuclear palisading and individual cell necrosis may
occur, no significant atypia, massive necrosis or atypical mitoses are seen. The
stroma is loosely collagenous and contains elongated fibroblasts occasionally
organized in small aggregates at the vicinity of the basaloid cell nests
(papillary mesenchymal bodies, traducing hair papilla differentiation). With the
exception of foreign body granulomatous reaction to ruptured keratocysts,
inflammation is characteristically absent.
Figure 8
A. Trichoepithelioma. Basaloid proliferation with abundant infundibular
keratinization; note the dense stroma separated by clefts from the adjacent
dermis. B. Desmoplastic trichoepithelioma. Thin basaloid strands in a dense
stroma, and a few A B keratocysts
A. Trichoepithelioma. Basaloid proliferation with abundant infundibular
keratinization; note the dense stroma separated by clefts from the adjacent
dermis. B. Desmoplastic trichoepithelioma. Thin basaloid strands in a dense
stroma, and a few A B keratocystsBasal cell carcinoma (infundibulocystic). The cellular,
fibrocytic nature of the stroma, the presence of clefts within the stroma and
between the stroma and surrounding dermis, as well as the larger follicular
differentiation spectrum (infundibular and germinative, papillary or bulb), all
argue for the diagnosis of trichoepithelioma.Trichoadenoma: as opposed to tricoepithelioma, trichoadenoma
(i) is an strictly infundibular (and not germinative) hair tumor, (ii) displays
dilated contiguous infundibular structures, and (iii) a scanty stroma
(epithelium to stroma ratio of "10/1") (iv) that is devoid of clefts.Trichoblastoma: For some authorities trichoepithelioma is a
superficial trichoblastoma with more advanced (infundibular) differentiation
(see above).
Desmoplastic trichopithelioma
Described by Brownstein and Shapiro, desmoplastic trichopithelioma is a variant of
solitary trichoepitelioma, recognizable for its clinicopathologic
singularities.[39]Clinically it is a small annular plaque with a characteristic depressed centre and
raised border occasionally presenting scattered tiny milia grains. It can mimic
the clinical image of granuloma annulare. In most cases it occurs on the malar
region or forehead of adult women. Exceptionally lesions are multiple, familial or
non-familial, occurring as typical annular plaques on the face and neck.Histologically it corresponds to a well-circumscribed, symmetrical, discoid lesion
on the superficial and mid dermis with a characteristic central depression that
can evoke the diagnosis at low magnification. The tumor is made of branching or
more linear cords of basaloid cells and keratinous infundibulocystic structures
(Figure 8B). The cords are irregular,
giving rise to bizarre patterns, occasionally one cell thick. The keratinous cysts
are frequently calcified and can exhibit centrifugal "tadpole" projections of
their wall. The epithelial aggregations are embedded in a conspicuous compact and
hypocellular, desmoplastic stroma. No cytologic atypia or atypical mitoses occur.
Focal foreign body granulomatous inflammatory infiltrate can occur surrounding
ruptured keratinous cysts.
Differential diagnosis
Basal cell carcinoma: in superficial (shave) biopsies
histological distinction between trichoepithelioma and BCC may be vexing; the
localization of clefting within the stroma, or between stroma and neighbouring
dermis, rather than between stroma and epithelial aggregates; the more
extensive infundibulocystic differentiation; the more superficial and symmetric
silhouette; as well as the absence of necrosis, mitosis and of inflammatory
infiltrate, argue in favour of DT. Additionally, in contrast with morpheaform
BCC, CK20/Cam 5.2-positive cells are often seen within the epithelial
aggregates of DT.[2]Syringoma: Syringoma may show keratinous cysts with wall
rupture and foreign body reaction, and be misdiagnosed as DT and vice
versa. However, syringoma is more superficially located than DT,
exhibits ductal differentiation, and does not show germinative cells or
clefting within the stroma. One cell thick strands or cords are not a feature
of syringoma. EMA and CEA regularly decorate the luminal border and more
occasionally the luminal cells of syringoma, but are not expressed in DT.Microcystic adnexal carcinoma (MAC): the characteristic
features of MAC that allow its distinction from DT (deep extension,
infiltrative pattern, asymmetry and perineural invasion) are not always present
in small/superficial/shave biopsies, in which the distinction between these two
neoplasms may not be possible. Immunohistochemical data described in MAC that
can assist the differential diagnosis include expression of
CααSMA) of the peripheral cells of ductal structures, and
absence of BerEP4 and CK20/Cam5.2 immunoreactivity in tumor strands.
Trichogerminoma
Trichogerminoma is an insufficiently known benign follicular neoplasm described by
Sau et al in 1992.[40]It is a germinative hair follicle tumor with an intermediate differentiation
between trichoblastoma and panfolliculoma (Table 1). From a clinical standpoint it
is a nondescript papule or nodule of the head or neck.Microscopic examination discloses an intradermal symmetrical nodule composed by
basophilic lobules within a fibrotic stroma well demarcated from the surrounding
dermis by clefts (Figure 9A). Within the
tumor lobules, rounded cell nests ("cell balls") made of concentrically arranged
pale cells, are characteristically seen (Figure
9B). The pale cell nests are surrounded by one or more layers of small
basaloid, germinative cells displaying nuclear palisading at the periphery of the
lobules. Hair germ and bulb structures are routinely found. Infundibulocystic,
isthmic structures, sebaceous ducts and sebocytes often coexist.
Immunohistochemically a "zonal" pattern produced by expression of CK5/6, CK 5/8 e
CAM 5.2 on the peripheral germinative cells contrasting with the absence of
staining at the cell balls is typical and may be helpful in distinguishing
trichogerminoma from the more classic nodular types of trichoblastoma. [41,42]
Figure 9
Trichogerminoma. A. Well-circumscribed intradermal multinodular lesion
separated from the adjacent dermis by clefts. B. Detail of the “cell balls”
composed of concentrically arranged pale cells surrounded by an outer layer
of darker cells
Trichogerminoma. A. Well-circumscribed intradermal multinodular lesion
separated from the adjacent dermis by clefts. B. Detail of the “cell balls”
composed of concentrically arranged pale cells surrounded by an outer layer
of darker cellsIn contrast with adamantinoid trichoblastoma (that also shows cytoarchitectural
compartmentalization of the cell aggregates in a peripheral germinative cell and a
central pale cell area), no lymphocytes or S100/CD1a-positive dendritic cells are
found in trichogerminoma.Trichogerminoma is thought to be a variant of trichoblastoma with specific
histological ("cell balls") and immunohistochemical features.
Panfolliculoma
In 1993 Ackerman et al.[1] described 6 cases of a benign hair follicle neoplasm akin to
trichoblastoma with a nodular/cystic pattern but characterized by phenotypic
microscopic features of bulbar, matrical, stem, isthmic and infundibular
differentiation. As the tumor recapitulated all the epithelial components of the
mature hair follicle the term panfolliculoma was coined. Panfolliculoma would
represent a trichoblastoma depicting the most wide differentiation spectrum.
Cystic and intraepidermal variants may occur ("epidermal
panfolliculoma").[43,44] In the latter, histologic
examination discloses an epidermal acanthoma where features of differentiation for
upper and lower hair follicle, including germinative cells, matrical cells, outer
root sheath cells, trichohyalin granules indicative of inner root sheath
differentiation, ghost cells and laminated basket wave cornification, coexist.
Pilomatricoma
Not infrequent in pediatric ages, where it constitutes the most common adnexal
skin tumor, it presents clinically as a dermohypodermal progressively growing
nodule of the head, neck, upper limbs and, less frequently, trunk or lower limbs
(Figure 10A). Characteristically firm to
hard on palpation, its consistency depends on the presence and extent of
calcification. It may grow abruptly attaining large size mimicking a malignant
lesion. In rare occasions it may be multiple, occurring in the setting of myotonic
muscular dystrophy or of Gardner syndrome (familiar adenomatous polyposis)
associated with high incidence of colorectal malignancy. More rarely, it can be
the cutaneous marker of Rubinstein-Taybi syndrome or of chromossome 9 trisomy.
[45,46] Occasionally the solitary lesions involute with
anetodermic changes of overlying skin, suffer transepidermal elimination or are
spontaneously painful.
Figure 10
Pilomatrixoma. A. Nodule on the upper arm of a young patient; lesions are
typically hard upon palpation, and a bluish color, as seen in this example,
is not a rare feature. B. Well circumscribed dermal nodule with a biphasic
appearance (basaloid and eosinophilic areas). C. Sharp transition between
basaloid cells and keratinized strands. D. Detail of ghost cells, in which
only the outline of the nuclei and cytoplasmic borders are discernible
Pilomatrixoma. A. Nodule on the upper arm of a young patient; lesions are
typically hard upon palpation, and a bluish color, as seen in this example,
is not a rare feature. B. Well circumscribed dermal nodule with a biphasic
appearance (basaloid and eosinophilic areas). C. Sharp transition between
basaloid cells and keratinized strands. D. Detail of ghost cells, in which
only the outline of the nuclei and cytoplasmic borders are discernibleβ-catenin gene mutations have been described in most cases studied,
implicating the WNT/β-catenin pathway in the pathogenesis of
pilomatricoma, a feature in agreement with the association with Gardner´s
syndrome, as this is characterized by germline mutations of a suppressor allele of
this tumor suppressor pathway.[47]
More recently, chromosome 18 trisomy has been identified in pilomatricoma cells, a
genetic anomaly that could additionally be pathogenically relevant via the
hyperfunction of the anti-apoptotic gene Bcl-2, that resides in this
chromosome.[48]The histological picture varies with the age of lesions. Typically, it is a
well-circumscribed dermohypodermal rounded nodule, with smooth borders surrounded
by a pseudocapsule and constituted by epithelial aggregates (Figure 10B and 10C). In
these aggregates two cellular types are regularly found: i) peripherally, cells
are small with scant cytoplasm and a deeply basophilic elongated nucleus (matrical
cells); they occur in multiple layers with no nuclear palisading; ii) in the
centre of the epithelial aggregates, cells display an abundant eosinophilic
cytoplasm whereas the nucleus disappears and is replaced by an empty space. These
are known as ghost cells, they are characteristic of pilomatricoma and correspond
to terminal differentiation of the basophilic peripheral cells (matrical cells)
(Figure 10D). The transition between
matrical cells and ghost cells may be abrupt or gradual, through a variable number
of cells whose cytoplasm acquires progressive eosinophilia whereas the nucleus
suffers pycnosis and is finally lost (Figure
10C).In early lesions the architectural pattern is cystic and there is predominance of
basophilic matrical cell aggregates. Progressively ghost cells replace the
basophilic cells, and calcification ("calcified epithelioma") or, less often,
hemosiderin deposition or even ossification, may occur. Simultaneously, a
granulomatous foreign body inflammatory infiltrate is trigged, progressively
replacing the epithelial proliferation. This aspect may dominate the histological
picture in late lesions. Melanin granules and dendritic melanocytes may occur
within the epithelial aggregates, reinforcing the phenotypic similitude between
pilomatricoma and hair matrix. In some instances, particularly in older patients,
the predominance of basophilic cells may persist in late lesions, a feature that
frequently coexists with conspicuous mitosis ("proliferative pilomatricoma"). The
histological picture is so characteristic that differentiation from other tumors
is rarely put forward. When the basophilic cells are prominent the lesion can be
misinterpreted as a "proliferative pilomatricoma" or even a malignant
pilomatricoma. "Proliferative pilomatricoma" exhibits brisk mitotic activity, and
predominance of matrical basophilic cells over ghost cells, but conserves the well
circumscribed smooth border seen in ordinary pilomatricoma and should not be
confused with the malignant pilomatricoma that, besides cytological atypia,
variable mitotic rate and predominance of matrical cells, displays an asymmetrical
silhouette, with poor circumscribed infiltrative jagged borders, central necrosis
of the epithelial aggregates, and a lymphohistiocytic inflammatory infiltrate on a
desmoplastic stroma.[49] In
partial superficial biopsies confusion with basal cell carcinoma may occur, but
nuclear peripheral palisading and clefting between an altered stroma and the
epithelial aggregates do not occur in pilomatricoma.Pilomatricoma is a benign tumor. Nevertheless, locally aggressive and even
metastatic examples have been rarely reported. Accordingly, surgical excision is
advisable.
Trichodiscoma and Fibrofolliculoma
These two follicular neoplasms, characterized by extensive perifollicular
mesenchymatous differentiation, although exhibiting distinct histologic features,
generally coexist in the same patient, occasionally in identical nearby clinical
lesions or in the same lesion (where both pictures can be seen in the same section
or in serial sections) and are thought to correspond to different designations of
the same entity with different development and topographic orientation of their
constituents.Multiple fibrofolliculomas and trichodiscomas are the main cutaneous
manifestations of the rare Birt-Hogg-Dubé syndrome (BHDS) (Figure 11A). In this syndrome, with autosomal dominant
inheritance, there is an increased incidence of kidney neoplasms (oncocytomas,
chromophobe carcinoma, papillary carcinoma, clear cell carcinoma), and lung
disease (spontaneous pneumothorax, pulmonary cysts, bullous emphysema). Less
often, patient may present multiple lipomas and angiolipomas, as well as neural
tumors (neurothekeoma, meningeoma), connective tissue nevi, facial angiofibromas
and parathyroid adenoma. The relationship with colorectal cancer is controversial.
The initially reported association with medullary cancer of thyroid has not been
confirmed and was instead associated with the presence of coexistent dominant
hereditary multiple endocrine neoplasia type 2.[50]
Figure 11
A. Birt-Hogg-Dubé syndrome. Multiple papules distributed on the face and a
larger nodular lesion on the right nasal ala. B. Trichodiscoma. Papule
containing a centrally located dense stroma that pushes the epithelial
component to the periphery; note the small sebaceous lobules (arrows). C.
Fibrofolliculoma. Vertically oriented distorted follicular structure with
thin anastomosing strands surrounded by a dense stroma
A. Birt-Hogg-Dubé syndrome. Multiple papules distributed on the face and a
larger nodular lesion on the right nasal ala. B. Trichodiscoma. Papule
containing a centrally located dense stroma that pushes the epithelial
component to the periphery; note the small sebaceous lobules (arrows). C.
Fibrofolliculoma. Vertically oriented distorted follicular structure with
thin anastomosing strands surrounded by a dense stromaThe susceptibility gene for SBHD has been localized in 17p11.2 and 17p12-q11.2,
and subsequently identified as a "new" supressor tumor gene designated as
folliculin (FLCN). It is present in 60% to 80% of the patientsExceptional cases of multiple trichodiscomas without any other cutaneous or
extracutaneous manifestation as well as observations of localized/circumscribed
SBHD have been reported.[51,52] Fibrofolliculoma/trichodiscoma can
also occur in exceptional occasions as a sporadic solitary lesion of exclusive
dermatologic relevance.Fibrofolliculoma: Histologic examination discloses a vertically
oriented dermal papule centred by a follicular infundibulum from which
anastomosing thin cellular cords, that may contain sebocytes or sebaceous lobules,
irradiate into the surrounding abundant stroma (Figure 11B). Cystic dilatation of the centrally located infundibulum
may occur. Stroma is readily conspicuous at low magnification, with a striking
mucinous character, containing parallel fibres of fibrillary collagen, fibroblasts
and occasional dendritic cells.Trichodiscoma: The classic histologic picture of trichodiscoma
differs from that of fibrofolliculoma by the relative proportions and disposition
of the stromal and epithelial components, as well as the horizontal rather than
vertical general orientation of the lesion. In trichodiscoma there is a greater
development of the stroma and tendency to a more peripheral disposition of the
epithelial component, which keeps its radiary disposition and tends to exhibit a
more pronounced mature sebaceous content, recapitulating mantle hair
differentiation (Figure 11C). The stroma,
peripherally limited by the infundibulo-sebaceous cords, dominates the picture.
Its nature is similar to that of fibrofolliculoma and is characteristically devoid
of elastic fibres.As seen, the distinction between fibrofolliculoma and trichodiscoma is not always
possible and, due to the presence of mantle hair differentiation, the lesions are
also known under the term "mantleoma".Fibrofilliculoma/trichodiscoma has a distinctive, easily recognisable
histological picture (Chart 2).
Trichofoliculomas (see below) with a well-developed stroma may be confounded
with fibrofolliculoma. However, in the former no radiate cords containing
sebocytes emanate from the main infundibular wall, and in turn,
fibrofolliculoma does not depict secondary infundibula from which vellus hair
emanate.
Chart 2
Differential diagnosis between trichodiscoma and fibrofolliculoma
Trichodiscoma
Fibrofolliculoma
Horizontally oriented
Vertically oriented
Epithelial +
Epithelial +++
Peripheral location
Central location
Stroma +++
Stroma +++
Cystic pattern - to +
Cystic pattern ++
Differential diagnosis between trichodiscoma and fibrofolliculomaNeurofollicular hamartoma, described by Barr et al, is thought
to represent a variant of fibrofilliculoma/trichodiscoma with a prominent
spindle cell stroma. [53-55] It should be noted that
neurofollicular hamartoma is a solitary papule of the nose of strict
dermatologic relevance whereas fibrofolliculoma/trichodiscoma are in general
multiple and a major sign of BHDS.
Perifollicular fibroma
Perifollicular fibroma presents as single or multiple papules most commonly
located on the head and neck. Some authors have regarded it as a hamartomatous
lesion and a possible variant of angiofibroma/fibrous papule, whereas others have
affirmed its relation to the spectrum of fibrofolliculoma/trichodiscoma. In fact,
the association of multiple perifollicular fibromas and colonic polyps is called
the Hornstein-Knickenberg syndrome, which is closely related to or even part of
the spectrum of Birt-Hogg-Dubé syndrome.[56,57] In addition,
lesions with overlapping features between fibrofolliculoma and perifollicular
fibroma have been documented in the setting of Birt-Hogg-Dubé syndrome.[58]Histologically, it consists of cellular fibrous tissue arranged concentrically
around one or several normal hair follicles with an "onion-skin" appearance.
Frequently, a cleft separates the fibrous tissue from the adjacent dermis.Fibrofolliculoma: the fibrous tissue surrounds and is closely
intermingled with a distorted hair follicle that displays thin anastomosing
projections that frequently contain sebocytes or small sebaceous lobules; in
contrast, in perifollicular fibroma, the fibrous tissue surrounds normal
follicular structures.Angiofibroma/fibrous papule: perifollicular fibrosis tends to
be less prominent, an angiomatous component is evident, and the presence of
spindle-shaped or stellate fibroblasts is usually easy to identify.
Trichofolliculoma
The diagnosis may be clinically elicited in the presence of a smooth hemispheric
papule with a central depression from which multiple thin hair emerge, located on
the centrofacial area in adults.Histologically it corresponds to single or multiple vertically oriented
infundibulocystic keratinous structure(s) draining to the skin surface by an
ostium and resulting from one or multiple dilated infundibula. From their wall
smaller infundibula emanate centrifugally that, in turn, give rise to mature or
dystrophic vellus hair follicles (Figure
12). The follicular elements are embedded in a connective tissue, which may
be poorly developed or, in contrast, abundant and fibrous, separated from the
surrounding dermis by retraction clefts.[59]
Figure 12
Trichofolliculoma. Cystic cavity from which numerous vellus hair follicles
radiate
Trichofolliculoma. Cystic cavity from which numerous vellus hair follicles
radiateThe distinction from pilar sheath acanthoma, dilated pore and tricoepithelioma
is generally straightforward. Neither perifollicular fibroma nor
fibrofolliculoma/trichodiscoma, which share a stroma similar to that of
tricofolliculoma, show vellus hairs irradiating from dilated infundibulocystic
structures that are characteristic of the latter.The difference between trichofolliculoma and folliculosebaceous cystic
hamartoma (HQFS) would rely on the operculized
indundibulocystic silhouette with irradiating vellus hair follicles in the
former, and the sebaceous differentiation and development of the stroma with
obligatory mesenchymal changes (adipocytes) in the latter. However, the fact
that both can share the same architectural pattern, the possibility of
sebaceous differentiation in trichofolliculoma ("sebaceous tricofoliculoma")
and the report of cases where distinction between these tumors is virtually
impossible, may indicate a close relationship between these lesions and/or a
common pathogenic basis.[60]
Folliculosebaceous cystic hamartoma
Clinically it is a slow growing solitary nodule of the head and neck, as a rule
first noticed in the 5th or 6th decades. Congenital forms are not exceptional.
Lesion can attain a large size and be cerebriform.The histological characterization of the folliculosebaceous cystic hamartoma has
been thoroughly precised in the initial description: a dermal infundibulocystic
structure into which merge sebaceous ducts attached to sebaceous lobules,
surrounded by a fibroplasic lamellar stroma that incorporates mesenchymal
elements, including adipocytes, separated from the surrounding dermis by clefting.
[61] The individualization
of folliculosebaceous cystic hamartoma as an entity distinct from
trichofolliculoma is controversial. The prominence and character of the stroma as
well as the non-operculized general disposition and magnitude of the sebaceous
differentiation would assist the diagnosis of folliculosebaceous cystic hamartoma
rather than sebaceous trichofolliculoma (see above)It should be noted that folliculosebaceous cystic hamartoma bears no relationship
with Torre-Muir syndrome.
Answer key
Coccidioidomycosis and the skin: a comprehensive review.
2015;90(5):610-21.
Authors: Iga Płachta; Marcin Kleibert; Anna M Czarnecka; Mateusz Spałek; Anna Szumera-Ciećkiewicz; Piotr Rutkowski Journal: Int J Mol Sci Date: 2021-04-30 Impact factor: 5.923
Authors: Roberto Estrada-Castañón; María Elisa Vega-Memije; Juan Carlos Cuevas-González; María de Guadalupe Chávez-López Journal: Int J Trichology Date: 2017 Oct-Dec