Jeffrey D Robinson1, Alexandra Tate2, John Heritage2. 1. Portland State University, Department of Communication, University Center Building, 520 SW Harrison Street, Suite 440, Portland, OR 97201, USA. Electronic address: jeffreyr@pdx.edu. 2. University of California, Los Angeles, Department of Sociology, Los Angeles, CA, USA.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: Soliciting patients' complete agendas of concerns (aka. 'agenda setting') can improve patients' health outcomes and satisfaction, and physicians' time management. We assess the distribution, content, and effectiveness of physicians' post-chief-complaint, agenda-setting questions. METHODS: We coded videotapes/transcripts of 407 primary-, acute-care visits between adults and 85 general-practice physicians operating in 46 community-based clinics in two states representing urban and rural care. Measures are the incidence of physicians' questions, their linguistic format, position within visits, likelihood of being responded to, and the nature of such responses. RESULTS: Physicians' questions designed to solicit concerns additional to chief concerns occurred in only 32% of visits (p<.001). Compared to questions whose communication format explicitly solicited 'questions' (e.g., "Do you have any questions?"), those that were formatted so as to allow for 'concerns' (e.g., "Any other concerns?") were significantly more likely to generate some type of agenda item (Chi(2) (1, N=131)=11.96, p=.001), and to do so more frequently when positioned 'early' vs. 'late' during visits (Chi(2) (1, N=73)=4.99, p=.025). CONCLUSIONS: Agenda setting is comparatively infrequent. The communication format and position of physicians' questions affects patients' provision of additional concerns/questions. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Physicians should increase use of optimized forms of agenda setting.
OBJECTIVE: Soliciting patients' complete agendas of concerns (aka. 'agenda setting') can improve patients' health outcomes and satisfaction, and physicians' time management. We assess the distribution, content, and effectiveness of physicians' post-chief-complaint, agenda-setting questions. METHODS: We coded videotapes/transcripts of 407 primary-, acute-care visits between adults and 85 general-practice physicians operating in 46 community-based clinics in two states representing urban and rural care. Measures are the incidence of physicians' questions, their linguistic format, position within visits, likelihood of being responded to, and the nature of such responses. RESULTS: Physicians' questions designed to solicit concerns additional to chief concerns occurred in only 32% of visits (p<.001). Compared to questions whose communication format explicitly solicited 'questions' (e.g., "Do you have any questions?"), those that were formatted so as to allow for 'concerns' (e.g., "Any other concerns?") were significantly more likely to generate some type of agenda item (Chi(2) (1, N=131)=11.96, p=.001), and to do so more frequently when positioned 'early' vs. 'late' during visits (Chi(2) (1, N=73)=4.99, p=.025). CONCLUSIONS: Agenda setting is comparatively infrequent. The communication format and position of physicians' questions affects patients' provision of additional concerns/questions. PRACTICE IMPLICATIONS: Physicians should increase use of optimized forms of agenda setting.
Authors: Marsha N Wittink; Patrick Walsh; Sule Yilmaz; Michael Mendoza; Richard L Street; Benjamin P Chapman; Paul Duberstein Journal: Patient Educ Couns Date: 2017-08-08
Authors: Shahzad Ahmed; Christopher V Almario; William D Chey; Lori A Robbins; Bianca Chang; Joseph Ahn; Jeffrey Ko; Phillip Gu; Alvin Siu; Brennan M R Spiegel Journal: Inform Health Soc Care Date: 2018-03-06 Impact factor: 2.439
Authors: Stuart Ekberg; Ruth Parry; Victoria Land; Katie Ekberg; Marco Pino; Charles Antaki; Laura Jenkins; Becky Whittaker Journal: BMC Palliat Care Date: 2021-12-08 Impact factor: 3.234
Authors: Julien A M Vos; Laura A M Duineveld; Vera E van Miltenburg; Inge Henselmans; Henk C P M van Weert; Kristel M van Asselt Journal: Support Care Cancer Date: 2022-06-21 Impact factor: 3.359
Authors: Anne Elizabeth Clark White; Eve Angeline Hood-Medland; Richard L Kravitz; Stephen G Henry Journal: J Gen Intern Med Date: 2021-06-22 Impact factor: 5.128