Simon Wilkinson1, Rebecca Waller2, Essi Viding3. 1. Department of Child and Adolescent Mental Health, Great Ormond Street & Royal London Higher Training Scheme, London, UK. 2. Department of Psychology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI, USA. 3. Division of Psychology and Language Sciences, University College London, London, UK.
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Children and adolescents with callous unemotional (CU) traits are at risk of severe and persistent antisocial behavior. It is commonly assumed that these children are difficult to treat but it has been proposed that they may benefit from being involved in interventions that go beyond typical parent training programs. This systematic review sought to answer two previously unanswered questions: do interventions involving young people reduce levels of CU traits? Do CU traits predict the effectiveness of interventions for antisocial behavior involving young people? METHOD: Studies were included that adopted an randomized controlled trial, controlled or open trial design and that had examined whether treatment was related to reductions in CU traits or whether CU traits predicted or moderated treatment effectiveness. RESULTS: Treatments used a range of approaches, including behavioral therapy, emotion recognition training, and multimodal interventions. 4/7 studies reported reductions in CU traits following treatment. There was a mixed pattern of findings in 15 studies that examined whether CU traits predicted treatment outcomes following interventions for antisocial behavior. In 7/15 studies, CU traits were associated with worse outcomes, although three of these studies did not provide data on baseline antisocial behavior, making it difficult to evaluate whether children with high CU traits had shown improvements relative to their own behavioral baseline, despite having the worst behavioral outcomes overall. CU traits did not predict outcomes in 7/15 studies. Finally, a single study reported that CU traits predicted an overall increased response to treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, the evidence supports the idea that children with CU traits do show reductions in both their CU traits and their antisocial behavior, but typically begin treatment with poorer premorbid functioning and can still end with higher levels of antisocial behavior. However, there is considerable scope to build on the current evidence base.
BACKGROUND:Children and adolescents with callous unemotional (CU) traits are at risk of severe and persistent antisocial behavior. It is commonly assumed that these children are difficult to treat but it has been proposed that they may benefit from being involved in interventions that go beyond typical parent training programs. This systematic review sought to answer two previously unanswered questions: do interventions involving young people reduce levels of CU traits? Do CU traits predict the effectiveness of interventions for antisocial behavior involving young people? METHOD: Studies were included that adopted an randomized controlled trial, controlled or open trial design and that had examined whether treatment was related to reductions in CU traits or whether CU traits predicted or moderated treatment effectiveness. RESULTS: Treatments used a range of approaches, including behavioral therapy, emotion recognition training, and multimodal interventions. 4/7 studies reported reductions in CU traits following treatment. There was a mixed pattern of findings in 15 studies that examined whether CU traits predicted treatment outcomes following interventions for antisocial behavior. In 7/15 studies, CU traits were associated with worse outcomes, although three of these studies did not provide data on baseline antisocial behavior, making it difficult to evaluate whether children with high CU traits had shown improvements relative to their own behavioral baseline, despite having the worst behavioral outcomes overall. CU traits did not predict outcomes in 7/15 studies. Finally, a single study reported that CU traits predicted an overall increased response to treatment. CONCLUSIONS: Overall, the evidence supports the idea that children with CU traits do show reductions in both their CU traits and their antisocial behavior, but typically begin treatment with poorer premorbid functioning and can still end with higher levels of antisocial behavior. However, there is considerable scope to build on the current evidence base.
Authors: Peter Fonagy; Stephen Butler; David Cottrell; Stephen Scott; Stephen Pilling; Ivan Eisler; Peter Fuggle; Abdullah Kraam; Sarah Byford; James Wason; Rachel Ellison; Elizabeth Simes; Poushali Ganguli; Elizabeth Allison; Ian M Goodyer Journal: Lancet Psychiatry Date: 2018-01-05 Impact factor: 27.083
Authors: Daniel A Waschbusch; Michael T Willoughby; Sarah M Haas; Ty Ridenour; Sarah Helseth; Kathleen I Crum; Amy R Altszuler; J Megan Ross; Erika K Coles; William E Pelham Journal: J Clin Child Adolesc Psychol Date: 2019-06-05
Authors: David A Schuberth; Yao Zheng; Dave S Pasalich; Robert J McMahon; Dimitra Kamboukos; Spring Dawson-McClure; Laurie Miller Brotman Journal: J Abnorm Child Psychol Date: 2019-04
Authors: Daniel A Waschbusch; Melissa D Bernstein; Jessica Robb Mazzant; Michael T Willoughby; Sarah Haas; Erica Coles; William E Pelham Journal: Evid Based Pract Child Adolesc Ment Health Date: 2016-08-30