Michaela Bayerlová1, Florian Klemm2, Frank Kramer1, Tobias Pukrop2,3, Tim Beißbarth1, Annalen Bleckmann1,2. 1. Department of Medical Statistics, University Medical Center Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany. 2. Department of Hematology and Medical Oncology, University Medical Center Göttingen, Göttingen, Germany. 3. Department of Internal Medicine III, University Hospital Regensburg, Regensburg, Germany.
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: WNT signaling is a complex process comprising multiple pathways: the canonical β-catenin-dependent pathway and several alternative non-canonical pathways that act in a β-catenin-independent manner. Representing these intricate signaling mechanisms through bioinformatic approaches is challenging. Nevertheless, a simplified but reliable bioinformatic WNT pathway model is needed, which can be further utilized to decipher specific WNT activation states within e.g. high-throughput data. RESULTS: In order to build such a model, we collected, parsed, and curated available WNT signaling knowledge from different pathway databases. The data were assembled to construct computationally suitable models of different WNT signaling cascades in the form of directed signaling graphs. This resulted in four networks representing canonical WNT signaling, non-canonical WNT signaling, the inhibition of canonical WNT signaling and the regulation of WNT signaling pathways, respectively. Furthermore, these networks were integrated with microarray and RNA sequencing data to gain deeper insight into the underlying biology of gene expression differences between MCF-7 and MDA-MB-231 breast cancer cell lines, representing weakly and highly invasive breast carcinomas, respectively. Differential genes up-regulated in the MDA-MB-231 compared to the MCF-7 cell line were found to display enrichment in the gene set originating from the non-canonical network. Moreover, we identified and validated differentially regulated modules representing canonical and non-canonical WNT pathway components specific for the aggressive basal-like breast cancer subtype. CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, we demonstrated that these newly constructed WNT networks reliably reflect distinct WNT signaling processes. Using transcriptomic data, we shaped these networks into comprehensive modules of the genes implicated in the aggressive basal-like breast cancer subtype and demonstrated that non-canonical WNT signaling is important in this context. The topology of these networks can be further refined in the future by integration with complementary data such as protein-protein interactions, in order to gain greater insight into signaling processes.
INTRODUCTION: WNT signaling is a complex process comprising multiple pathways: the canonical β-catenin-dependent pathway and several alternative non-canonical pathways that act in a β-catenin-independent manner. Representing these intricate signaling mechanisms through bioinformatic approaches is challenging. Nevertheless, a simplified but reliable bioinformatic WNT pathway model is needed, which can be further utilized to decipher specific WNT activation states within e.g. high-throughput data. RESULTS: In order to build such a model, we collected, parsed, and curated available WNT signaling knowledge from different pathway databases. The data were assembled to construct computationally suitable models of different WNT signaling cascades in the form of directed signaling graphs. This resulted in four networks representing canonical WNT signaling, non-canonical WNT signaling, the inhibition of canonical WNT signaling and the regulation of WNT signaling pathways, respectively. Furthermore, these networks were integrated with microarray and RNA sequencing data to gain deeper insight into the underlying biology of gene expression differences between MCF-7 and MDA-MB-231breast cancer cell lines, representing weakly and highly invasive breast carcinomas, respectively. Differential genes up-regulated in the MDA-MB-231 compared to the MCF-7 cell line were found to display enrichment in the gene set originating from the non-canonical network. Moreover, we identified and validated differentially regulated modules representing canonical and non-canonical WNT pathway components specific for the aggressive basal-like breast cancer subtype. CONCLUSIONS: In conclusion, we demonstrated that these newly constructed WNT networks reliably reflect distinct WNT signaling processes. Using transcriptomic data, we shaped these networks into comprehensive modules of the genes implicated in the aggressive basal-like breast cancer subtype and demonstrated that non-canonical WNT signaling is important in this context. The topology of these networks can be further refined in the future by integration with complementary data such as protein-protein interactions, in order to gain greater insight into signaling processes.
Authors: F Klemm; A Bleckmann; L Siam; H N Chuang; E Rietkötter; D Behme; M Schulz; M Schaffrinski; S Schindler; L Trümper; F Kramer; T Beissbarth; C Stadelmann; C Binder; T Pukrop Journal: Carcinogenesis Date: 2010-12-20 Impact factor: 4.944
Authors: David Croft; Gavin O'Kelly; Guanming Wu; Robin Haw; Marc Gillespie; Lisa Matthews; Michael Caudy; Phani Garapati; Gopal Gopinath; Bijay Jassal; Steven Jupe; Irina Kalatskaya; Shahana Mahajan; Bruce May; Nelson Ndegwa; Esther Schmidt; Veronica Shamovsky; Christina Yung; Ewan Birney; Henning Hermjakob; Peter D'Eustachio; Lincoln Stein Journal: Nucleic Acids Res Date: 2010-11-09 Impact factor: 16.971
Authors: Emek Demir; Michael P Cary; Suzanne Paley; Ken Fukuda; Christian Lemer; Imre Vastrik; Guanming Wu; Peter D'Eustachio; Carl Schaefer; Joanne Luciano; Frank Schacherer; Irma Martinez-Flores; Zhenjun Hu; Veronica Jimenez-Jacinto; Geeta Joshi-Tope; Kumaran Kandasamy; Alejandra C Lopez-Fuentes; Huaiyu Mi; Elgar Pichler; Igor Rodchenkov; Andrea Splendiani; Sasha Tkachev; Jeremy Zucker; Gopal Gopinath; Harsha Rajasimha; Ranjani Ramakrishnan; Imran Shah; Mustafa Syed; Nadia Anwar; Ozgün Babur; Michael Blinov; Erik Brauner; Dan Corwin; Sylva Donaldson; Frank Gibbons; Robert Goldberg; Peter Hornbeck; Augustin Luna; Peter Murray-Rust; Eric Neumann; Oliver Ruebenacker; Oliver Reubenacker; Matthias Samwald; Martijn van Iersel; Sarala Wimalaratne; Keith Allen; Burk Braun; Michelle Whirl-Carrillo; Kei-Hoi Cheung; Kam Dahlquist; Andrew Finney; Marc Gillespie; Elizabeth Glass; Li Gong; Robin Haw; Michael Honig; Olivier Hubaut; David Kane; Shiva Krupa; Martina Kutmon; Julie Leonard; Debbie Marks; David Merberg; Victoria Petri; Alex Pico; Dean Ravenscroft; Liya Ren; Nigam Shah; Margot Sunshine; Rebecca Tang; Ryan Whaley; Stan Letovksy; Kenneth H Buetow; Andrey Rzhetsky; Vincent Schachter; Bruno S Sobral; Ugur Dogrusoz; Shannon McWeeney; Mirit Aladjem; Ewan Birney; Julio Collado-Vides; Susumu Goto; Michael Hucka; Nicolas Le Novère; Natalia Maltsev; Akhilesh Pandey; Paul Thomas; Edgar Wingender; Peter D Karp; Chris Sander; Gary D Bader Journal: Nat Biotechnol Date: 2010-09-09 Impact factor: 54.908
Authors: Carl F Schaefer; Kira Anthony; Shiva Krupa; Jeffrey Buchoff; Matthew Day; Timo Hannay; Kenneth H Buetow Journal: Nucleic Acids Res Date: 2008-10-02 Impact factor: 16.971
Authors: Hyun Jung Park; Ping Ji; Soyeon Kim; Zheng Xia; Benjamin Rodriguez; Lei Li; Jianzhong Su; Kaifu Chen; Chioniso P Masamha; David Baillat; Camila R Fontes-Garfias; Ann-Bin Shyu; Joel R Neilson; Eric J Wagner; Wei Li Journal: Nat Genet Date: 2018-05-21 Impact factor: 38.330
Authors: Kerstin Menck; Darius Wlochowitz; Astrid Wachter; Lena-Christin Conradi; Alexander Wolff; Andreas H Scheel; Ulrike Korf; Stefan Wiemann; Hans-Ulrich Schildhaus; Hanibal Bohnenberger; Edgar Wingender; Tobias Pukrop; Kia Homayounfar; Tim Beißbarth; Annalen Bleckmann Journal: Cancers (Basel) Date: 2022-04-21 Impact factor: 6.575
Authors: Ryan Lusk; Evan Stene; Farnoush Banaei-Kashani; Boris Tabakoff; Katerina Kechris; Laura M Saba Journal: Nat Commun Date: 2021-03-12 Impact factor: 14.919
Authors: Claudia Binder; Annalen Bleckmann; Kerstin Menck; Saskia Heinrichs; Darius Wlochowitz; Maren Sitte; Helen Noeding; Andreas Janshoff; Hannes Treiber; Torben Ruhwedel; Bawarjan Schatlo; Christian von der Brelie; Stefan Wiemann; Tobias Pukrop; Tim Beißbarth Journal: J Exp Clin Cancer Res Date: 2021-12-15